I don't understand why people can't just respect other's experience and style. Every style is different and even within each style the movements and kata can vary hugely depending on the lineage. We all try our best to perfect the art we love. Can we not have more honour and respect instead of trying to outdo each other? Everybody is learning and there are pros and cons to every martial art, style and dojo. Peace. Great video.
I know this master is great for his life in martial art and for his training, but like many others masters, he does basic karate, in this bunkai, the hikite do nothing, in first move in Pinann 1, the ''age uke'' above the head do nothing, why he rises his arm if he does nothing?? you understand? very basic, and unfortunately, the japanese do almost always that as bunkai
Very clever principles and very effective...shinzato's karate is so full of life and energy and he has developed a truly defensive art form. Have experienced this first hand in his dojo and he is simply incredible...
he wants to make believe he knows martial arts but it's all bullshit. he's a troll that has plagued many many videos i can prove this, mark him as spam or thumb him down
This is called the Kishaba Juku of Matsubayashi-Shorin-ryu. They do the Matsubayashi-ryu kata of Nagamine Shosin but have extensively reworked the way they develop power.
you know?you can hit the reply word everytime you want to answer to someone you awful jackass that's that little word on the right of every comment but i think your parents must've had down syndrom so you didnt have many chances to begin with so...no worries..and as far as this gay moving guy beating me up well...one word..muay thai for 15 years..fuck off you stupid bitch i'll say whatever the fuck i want
My sensei's sensei taught her to begin the first few blocks by crossing our arms in front so our hands aren't whipping out of no where. its also closer to typical fighting stance than your hands just at your side. so that's how I learned it.
Figured I'd post here. I study in this style that "that bald guy" uses. My sensei has had the priviledge of training with Shinzato Sensei in Okinawa. (The sensei in the video.)
His student wasn't the focus, the Sensei was though. He is explaining the very essense of what our Kata are about. Grace, strength and speed. There are similarities between Shotokan and Shorin Ryu, that is simply because Shotokan was developed from Shorin Ryu.
although, there is an element of its roots present that is\as demonstrated in chinese kung fu. silk reeling motion is important for remaining fluid whilst drawing the ki\chi from the ground ( i can hear how he pivots and its magnificient ) and through breath and hips. wouldnt you agree? in fact this is the best representation of chinese kung fu that i have ever seen lol.
to someone that don't understand the discipline and the reason behind why his doing all that exagerated hip moves you can say that, that is a terrible display of technique. I understand were you're coming from i was once like you...but believe me for you to state that comment i can tell you that, that guy on the video is years and years way ahead of you...
realy i'v leaned a lot of kata even if y quit for about 4 years but realy my sensei never used koshi the mous important thing is to know the kata perfectly and univac is right
it goes without saying that you should know your kata perfectly. however, its also basic knowledge that all your power for your punches and your kicks comes from your koshi.
I used to do Shitoryu (shuri-te) and this kata before switching to Goju-ryu (naha-te) 15 years ago, and I was never happy with the way Shitoryu was taught to me. I thought it was too stiff. This snapping of the hips is actually quite good because it demonstrates the special features of Shuri-te karate which is whip-like striking and blocking movements.
hip movement should happen naturally, the young karate-ka's kata shows the problem with exagerating the hip movement, but the sensei is great,i watched his foot work and his pre-loading action several times.
power, speed, and snap. they become smaller and less noticable as you progress. it's one of those things that needs to be both taught, and felt to be appreciated.
I don't get why the fight! I don't speak Japanese, so I can not judge the hip movements of the young lad: I thought that the "exaggerated" hip movements were intended as demonstration, so people understand concepts easily. If any of you speak Japanese, am I wrong? (Gee, I have to start studying nihongo :-)
I think this Okinawan sensei highlights some good elements worth emphasizing, such as simultaneous execution of techniques to really convey what the kata is trying to teach. However, I think there is a lot more to be learned in the opening move for this kata than what they have shown in this video.
The style is Kishaba Juku, the gentleman is Shinzato Katsuhiki Sensei. Google him and learn something. If you can be that fluid and have anywhere near HIS level of knowledge at his age, then you can comment. Funny how the negative comments come from people under the age of 25....
I looked ath several Kishiba Juku sites. There are so many problems with the hip motion that I am not sure where to start. Shigiru Egami experimented with a similar type of hi rotation and later abandoned it because of ineffectiveness
Shotokan guy, free your mind and the rest will follow- it works for the Okinawans, so do not knock it until you try it. Learn something of your roots before you criticize, please. Jee-zus!
Mr. Yasaguri. What are your qualifications? As for spelling. Oh Well!!! I have without sounding like an like I am quoting my resume, 30 years in the Martial Arts I have studied Shotokan in the past. I have also studied Shorin-Ryu, Goju-Ryu, Pangai Noon, and several systems of jujitsu. First of all if you know anything about hip rotation. The rotation doesn't generate much power. It is the rear foot pushing against the floor that is a by product of the rotation. .
Spoken like a true Shotokan guy... my qualifications, you ask? Which means you never bothered to review "my" resume. We have equal time on the floor. I have also studied Goju (Meibukan) as well as Motobu Ryu, Motobu Udun ti, Okinawan kobudo, Aikikai Aikido and (though I think little of it) WTF TKD. I am not easily impressed by North American 'experts'. Cite a published article, maybe I will be.
After I read your last post, I went and read your profile. I see now that you are one of those elitists that believes what they do is the best. And everyone else is wrong. I should not even waste my time with you. This will be my last post. First I no longer study Shotokan and do not practice anything Shotokan. My Published Article of the American Sports Medicine Journal July, 2001. Title is Train proper body dynamics for Martial Arts.
No, I am not an elitist. I am a purist- there is a difference. There is a saying in Japanese: koshi o ireru; I guess the J have had it wrong in oh-so many activities for so long. You would appear to be one of those gaijin for whom a little knowledge is dangerous.
The specific sub heading in the article would be hip rotation or planting the foot. It also talks about the injuries that can occur from doing exactly what you Kishiba Juku guy there is doing.
Oh Yeah one other thing. The Bunkai is completly amature that they sort of showed there. And distancing the Bald guy steps in to the punch and it is still too far away to hit him.
You obviously do not speak nihongo, so the demonstration is lost on you. Bunkai or explanation of technique does not have to be demonstrated at point range to make your ideas clear. Learn to spell, and I will take you seriously. Your lack of accuracy in one simple area (for one who has a PhD and an MD is concerning for the quality of education down south; I wonder if you take your karate as seriously- perfection in all areas of life.
Oh did I forget to mention that I am a PhD, an actual MD. Oh I am a specialist in sports medicine and I have several papers published about body mechanics in relation to Martial Arts
This young guy s kata is not good for sure.. His hip movement is in proper. But, the Sensei is very good. I agree with yasaguri, this is Kishbajuku.. About Egami.. I have watched some clips of Egami, and it really made me vommit. Sorry, I dnt like to crisitize any senior teacher. I had a good image on Egami before I saw any of his videos or about Shotokai.. :)
The young guy, not sure if it is a physical thing or just nerves about being in front of a camera. Foot is arched too high in neko, focus is off as he advances with shuto uke, just not kosher.
However, I will not write him off entirely. He IS young and still salvageable. :)
Dear Yasaguri, What I think is certain ppl have difficulties in this rotational movement of hip. I have stud, same like him. Their body different. I think same prob with this young boy. But, when it is clear he has prob, I dnt knw why this sensei put him to video.. Better if he put another one. We practice Kyudokan, and hv similar rotational hip movement, but nt the same. Go and see my videos.. Even they may not b very well performed, haha :)
This guy has no power. His uses his hips but incorrectly. His whole body girates instead locking the hip at the end of the movement and his stances are sloppy. Ugly kata.
this is a freakin cooling looking kata. I learnt Pinan-sandan during a black belt training/grading camp, but I havn't seen a Pinan kata done so nicely. Flow throughout the body, really enjoyed watching this.
I don't understand why people can't just respect other's experience and style. Every style is different and even within each style the movements and kata can vary hugely depending on the lineage. We all try our best to perfect the art we love. Can we not have more honour and respect instead of trying to outdo each other? Everybody is learning and there are pros and cons to every martial art, style and dojo. Peace. Great video.
hellothereitsjustme 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
I know this master is great for his life in martial art and for his training, but like many others masters, he does basic karate, in this bunkai, the hikite do nothing, in first move in Pinann 1, the ''age uke'' above the head do nothing, why he rises his arm if he does nothing?? you understand? very basic, and unfortunately, the japanese do almost always that as bunkai
karatekid68 1 month ago
Very clever principles and very effective...shinzato's karate is so full of life and energy and he has developed a truly defensive art form. Have experienced this first hand in his dojo and he is simply incredible...
daverokudan 5 months ago
Even though i cant understand japanese the kata that the sensei does is just plain awesome!!!!!!!
malabarwarriors 10 months ago
Comment removed
malabarwarriors 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol, for a 7th dan his belt is very black and new lookin?!?!?!
gianttrials 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Very badly. A shame!
senseichief 2 years ago
pay no mind to the troll named: wannabeebee;
he wants to make believe he knows martial arts but it's all bullshit. he's a troll that has plagued many many videos i can prove this, mark him as spam or thumb him down
mazdaplz 3 years ago
would any1 let me no what style of karate this is??
astralkarate 3 years ago
This is called the Kishaba Juku of Matsubayashi-Shorin-ryu. They do the Matsubayashi-ryu kata of Nagamine Shosin but have extensively reworked the way they develop power.
hankprohm 2 years ago 4
@astralkarate It's Shorin-Ryu...
hellothereitsjustme 1 month ago
腰をプリプリさせてセクシーな空手だのう
sexy dance
uchikata 3 years ago
this has to be one of the most idiotic things i've ever seen...ROFL
dpapaioannow 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dpapaionnow
this has to be one of the most idiotic things i've ever seen...ROFL
Answer.
You must be used to looking at idiotic things.
You will see one everytime you look at your reflection.
I would bet that if you and the guy teaching were to ever to get in to a full sparring session you would sh#te yourself from word go.
You wouldnt last 5 seconds.
wannabeebee 3 years ago
you know?you can hit the reply word everytime you want to answer to someone you awful jackass that's that little word on the right of every comment but i think your parents must've had down syndrom so you didnt have many chances to begin with so...no worries..and as far as this gay moving guy beating me up well...one word..muay thai for 15 years..fuck off you stupid bitch i'll say whatever the fuck i want
dpapaioannow 3 years ago
You know what.
I dont believe one single word you are saying.
Post a video Mr super star.
Lets see how good you are after your 15 years of training.
Otherwise crawl back in to your hole.
wannabeebee 3 years ago
Wheres your video you f#ckin waster?
wannabeebee 3 years ago
up your asshole ;)
dpapaioannow 3 years ago
I wouldnt allow a low life like you to wipe my sh#t so yet again you are wrong.
Either put up your video or f#ck off.
Just so you know numb nuts if you and the guy teaching in the video would ever get it on with a full no holds sparr.
He could if he wanted to break every bone in your stupid feeble body.
You are one stupid mother. You dont know jack sh#t.
wannabeebee 3 years ago
yeah ok whatever man..now go play with your barbie dolls...hush hush now little fairy...ROFL
dpapaioannow 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So wheres your fantastic video?
You havent got one have you?
Let me guess.
You are overweight, cant run and talk sh#t?
wannabeebee 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
18-F-Florida - MSG me on MSN. ID is in my profile. 2
capolopolis 3 years ago
My sensei's sensei taught her to begin the first few blocks by crossing our arms in front so our hands aren't whipping out of no where. its also closer to typical fighting stance than your hands just at your side. so that's how I learned it.
SakuraGoetsuke 3 years ago
:18-:19 was taht a fart???
XBoSnIaNxX 3 years ago
The Prof is yet another teacher who understands body dynamics and how to get the most with the least - the technical essence of our art.
NYCBeatnik 3 years ago 2
Wigle-wigle-wigle
neostardust 3 years ago
Figured I'd post here. I study in this style that "that bald guy" uses. My sensei has had the priviledge of training with Shinzato Sensei in Okinawa. (The sensei in the video.)
His student wasn't the focus, the Sensei was though. He is explaining the very essense of what our Kata are about. Grace, strength and speed. There are similarities between Shotokan and Shorin Ryu, that is simply because Shotokan was developed from Shorin Ryu.
PhZion3334 3 years ago
although, there is an element of its roots present that is\as demonstrated in chinese kung fu. silk reeling motion is important for remaining fluid whilst drawing the ki\chi from the ground ( i can hear how he pivots and its magnificient ) and through breath and hips. wouldnt you agree? in fact this is the best representation of chinese kung fu that i have ever seen lol.
opticannon 3 years ago
SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHO THIS GREAT, TRUE KARATEKA IS!!! WHAT IS HIS LINEAGE AND HIS ORGANIZATION???
This reminds me of Shinjinbukan! Marvelous!
Koryuhoka 3 years ago
his name is Katsuhiko Shinzato Sensei...
ShorinWaza 3 years ago
what a beautiful moves of karate
what karate is this? could someone tell me plz?
beibpxo 3 years ago
in karate if you did'nt learn koshi you learned nothing but garbage, sorry to say that but that is the cold hard truth..
ShorinWaza 3 years ago
i do ishinru karate and in a 2nd degre blue belt and other great kata are wansu sesoun nuhunchi seiuchin and Qwanchin that on is a bow aka staff kata
hobomagie 3 years ago
Wow... that was a terrible display of Pin Ann...
CassyCorp 3 years ago
to someone that don't understand the discipline and the reason behind why his doing all that exagerated hip moves you can say that, that is a terrible display of technique. I understand were you're coming from i was once like you...but believe me for you to state that comment i can tell you that, that guy on the video is years and years way ahead of you...
ShorinWaza 3 years ago
Actually, that was a proper execution of kata. It's not what you are used to because of the "do" mindset. This is "jutsu".
Koryuhoka 3 years ago
I practice Karate-Do... which is prolly the reason I saw it wrong...
CassyCorp 3 years ago
cool
christwarrior56 3 years ago
realy i'v leaned a lot of kata even if y quit for about 4 years but realy my sensei never used koshi the mous important thing is to know the kata perfectly and univac is right
killersdww 3 years ago
it goes without saying that you should know your kata perfectly. however, its also basic knowledge that all your power for your punches and your kicks comes from your koshi.
RKGOLF 3 years ago
Agreed. Also if you look at the guys hands they are maki wari conditioned.
Add that to his method of power generation and the forward momentum of the opponent he would be one powerfull guy.
wannabeebee 3 years ago
Comment removed
mazdaplz 3 years ago
wtf r u going on about, just read what youve written and explain yourself you muppet.
singhakabuttar 2 years ago
omg i see ur sensei and he alway moving he ass Lmao
porntime123 3 years ago
Here's how it works in Okinawa most of the time: First, learn 'koshi' - that circular, explosive, inner power. Then, perfect form of kata.
Here's how it works in the Americas most of the time: First, perfect form of kata. Then NEVER learn koshi.
univac500 4 years ago 2
good one
perspolisforever 3 years ago
that's aboslutely right.
RKGOLF 3 years ago
I used to do Shitoryu (shuri-te) and this kata before switching to Goju-ryu (naha-te) 15 years ago, and I was never happy with the way Shitoryu was taught to me. I thought it was too stiff. This snapping of the hips is actually quite good because it demonstrates the special features of Shuri-te karate which is whip-like striking and blocking movements.
Pecherin72 4 years ago
hip movement should happen naturally, the young karate-ka's kata shows the problem with exagerating the hip movement, but the sensei is great,i watched his foot work and his pre-loading action several times.
perspolisforever 4 years ago
I'm not a fan of those hip movements at all, what is their purpose?
Odacon 4 years ago
power, speed, and snap. they become smaller and less noticable as you progress. it's one of those things that needs to be both taught, and felt to be appreciated.
kempobrad 4 years ago
I don't get why the fight! I don't speak Japanese, so I can not judge the hip movements of the young lad: I thought that the "exaggerated" hip movements were intended as demonstration, so people understand concepts easily. If any of you speak Japanese, am I wrong? (Gee, I have to start studying nihongo :-)
malasangre 4 years ago
I think this Okinawan sensei highlights some good elements worth emphasizing, such as simultaneous execution of techniques to really convey what the kata is trying to teach. However, I think there is a lot more to be learned in the opening move for this kata than what they have shown in this video.
emotionumist 4 years ago
The style is Kishaba Juku, the gentleman is Shinzato Katsuhiki Sensei. Google him and learn something. If you can be that fluid and have anywhere near HIS level of knowledge at his age, then you can comment. Funny how the negative comments come from people under the age of 25....
Yasaguri 4 years ago
I looked ath several Kishiba Juku sites. There are so many problems with the hip motion that I am not sure where to start. Shigiru Egami experimented with a similar type of hi rotation and later abandoned it because of ineffectiveness
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
Shotokan guy, free your mind and the rest will follow- it works for the Okinawans, so do not knock it until you try it. Learn something of your roots before you criticize, please. Jee-zus!
Yasaguri 4 years ago
By the way, his name was Shigeru Egami- it helps to be able to cite sources properly. :(
Yasaguri 4 years ago
Mr. Yasaguri. What are your qualifications? As for spelling. Oh Well!!! I have without sounding like an like I am quoting my resume, 30 years in the Martial Arts I have studied Shotokan in the past. I have also studied Shorin-Ryu, Goju-Ryu, Pangai Noon, and several systems of jujitsu. First of all if you know anything about hip rotation. The rotation doesn't generate much power. It is the rear foot pushing against the floor that is a by product of the rotation. .
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
Spoken like a true Shotokan guy... my qualifications, you ask? Which means you never bothered to review "my" resume. We have equal time on the floor. I have also studied Goju (Meibukan) as well as Motobu Ryu, Motobu Udun ti, Okinawan kobudo, Aikikai Aikido and (though I think little of it) WTF TKD. I am not easily impressed by North American 'experts'. Cite a published article, maybe I will be.
Yasaguri 4 years ago
After I read your last post, I went and read your profile. I see now that you are one of those elitists that believes what they do is the best. And everyone else is wrong. I should not even waste my time with you. This will be my last post. First I no longer study Shotokan and do not practice anything Shotokan. My Published Article of the American Sports Medicine Journal July, 2001. Title is Train proper body dynamics for Martial Arts.
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
No, I am not an elitist. I am a purist- there is a difference. There is a saying in Japanese: koshi o ireru; I guess the J have had it wrong in oh-so many activities for so long. You would appear to be one of those gaijin for whom a little knowledge is dangerous.
Yasaguri 4 years ago
The specific sub heading in the article would be hip rotation or planting the foot. It also talks about the injuries that can occur from doing exactly what you Kishiba Juku guy there is doing.
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
It will be a pleasure not talking with you... :)
Yasaguri 4 years ago
Oh Yeah one other thing. The Bunkai is completly amature that they sort of showed there. And distancing the Bald guy steps in to the punch and it is still too far away to hit him.
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
You obviously do not speak nihongo, so the demonstration is lost on you. Bunkai or explanation of technique does not have to be demonstrated at point range to make your ideas clear. Learn to spell, and I will take you seriously. Your lack of accuracy in one simple area (for one who has a PhD and an MD is concerning for the quality of education down south; I wonder if you take your karate as seriously- perfection in all areas of life.
Yasaguri 4 years ago
Oh did I forget to mention that I am a PhD, an actual MD. Oh I am a specialist in sports medicine and I have several papers published about body mechanics in relation to Martial Arts
kamikaiguy 4 years ago
Good for you. I hope if you quoted any of Egami's "research" that you at least had the presence of mind to spell his name correctly.
I am sure I should be impressed, but... I fail to be.
Yasaguri 4 years ago
"I am a PhD, an actual MD"....? hmmm....
yankee19050 4 years ago
This young guy s kata is not good for sure.. His hip movement is in proper. But, the Sensei is very good. I agree with yasaguri, this is Kishbajuku.. About Egami.. I have watched some clips of Egami, and it really made me vommit. Sorry, I dnt like to crisitize any senior teacher. I had a good image on Egami before I saw any of his videos or about Shotokai.. :)
aiko4321 4 years ago
ha, so desu! :)
The young guy, not sure if it is a physical thing or just nerves about being in front of a camera. Foot is arched too high in neko, focus is off as he advances with shuto uke, just not kosher.
However, I will not write him off entirely. He IS young and still salvageable. :)
Yasaguri 4 years ago
Dear Yasaguri, What I think is certain ppl have difficulties in this rotational movement of hip. I have stud, same like him. Their body different. I think same prob with this young boy. But, when it is clear he has prob, I dnt knw why this sensei put him to video.. Better if he put another one. We practice Kyudokan, and hv similar rotational hip movement, but nt the same. Go and see my videos.. Even they may not b very well performed, haha :)
aiko4321 4 years ago
im glad to see im not the only that thought it was weird.
nateman12345 4 years ago
This guy has no power. His uses his hips but incorrectly. His whole body girates instead locking the hip at the end of the movement and his stances are sloppy. Ugly kata.
chemolina 4 years ago
all hip motion. Power comes from the earth then through your hips they accelarate the power through your hands and release the power onto your enemy
Nhia89 4 years ago
this stile is interesting.
albanloucher 4 years ago
His hip movement is extremely exagerated.
kirvin2 4 years ago
this young guy moves like he's gay. it's exagerate.
jdeklaas 4 years ago
hahaha i thought no one else noticed. he exaggerated his hip movements; they look rather comical.
jessevoidable 4 years ago
it's not just his hip...his shoulders too:P lol
shot87 4 years ago
this is a freakin cooling looking kata. I learnt Pinan-sandan during a black belt training/grading camp, but I havn't seen a Pinan kata done so nicely. Flow throughout the body, really enjoyed watching this.
Is there a Pinan-sandan video also availible?
hirruken 5 years ago
Interesting version of my Tang Soo Do Pyung ahn edan
garridoe 5 years ago
well this is the original Pinan Shodan, maybe your TSD form is a intersting version of this one.
nijuken 5 years ago
that was nice
Macdu 5 years ago