who cares what band comes first or second or anything, or what genre Evanescence are and what Nightwish played before or plays now...The actual truth lies in your musical taste.I don't like spinach I like potatoes, so what? Should I judge people who like spinach?huh?State your opinion, it's respectful, but don't judge before you actually learn to listen.
Tarja is fuckin amazing... Nightwish pretty much went downhill after her in my opinion but there are better singers than her... Sarah Brightman for example is INSANE... she has a vocal range of over 3 octaves and incredible control... I love Tarja but there are better
3 octives...not so much a big deal, both me, my cousi, and my opera teacher all have three and a half ocvtives. It's those with four octives who are the freaks of nature...O.o
Ahhh Floor. Evanescence reminds me of Lacuna Coil, After Forever, The gathering, Within temptation, Nightwish. That's the way it is; one can not look like ones son, it's always the other way around.
I have to agree. Though once the song keeps going it becomes less and less like that.
I wish I had known about this band a long time ago. I would have loved to see them in concert. I got the 'After Forever' cd a few days ago and I am loving it. ^_^ 'Empty Memories' is one of my favorite tracks.
true- however, its a genre not popular in America. its very popular in other countries - look at some of Afterforevers live concerts, or within temptations.
thousands present.
I stopped listening to a lot of american music due to lack of talent. every now and then there's something that catches my ear, but for the most part its just alternative crap. it is sad - the radio here plays the same 10 bands over and over again until a new band comes out.
Why everyone thinks that Evanescence begun in 2003 with Fallen...sorry but Evanescence started in 1997... with that name...but 2 years ago they were Childish Intentions..so Evanescence started in 1995...before that Nightwish
@adr14ntr jajajajaja but any with good taste on music knows that evanecescenceee sukcs there are alot of bands with female vocalist but that dosent mean that they are the same quality, some punk bands start with female vocalist, at 70' and even before with the rockabilly so a band with female vocalist is not of the 90'
@adr14ntr you can hear what you fucking taste want, but dont come here to make comparisons about a shitty band, even with his "years" they didnt make any change in music cuz they dont have quality they dont make any for the history of music" the wannabe goth shit". Are you trying to say that evashit have more years?are they the pioneers?
Nightwish start as a power metal band, the first SYMPHONIC METAL band was therion. just cuz some bands have female vocalist dosent mean that they are the same
@musikmood God! you are bored...You can check my channel and you'll see Im fan of Therion and Nightwish, so, I already knew all what yu said before... I just commented that Evanescence didnt start in 2003 as a lot of people believes and now you are here bitching about them...dont you have a better thing to do?
@adr14ntr you are trying to defend evaneshit with more shit, you said" they started in 1997, before than nw"
NW stared in 1996 even before, but that dosent matter, the years dont say nothing except the music, who caress if evashit started after of before? evashit didn't make any change, Nightwish and evashit are genres completely differents, dont try to make stupid comparations between this bands, the evashit's fans always make this kind of comments in videos of good bands, are idiots or WTF?
@musikmood As I said before, Evanescence didnt start in 1997 they started in 1995 before Nightwish, Nightwish started in 1996... Now, Im trying to defend Evanescence of what? I just commented that because I read comments saying that Evanescence is a new band when they are not... I didnt start that comparation, if I wrote it is because I read a comment about it... Im fan of Evanescence but Im fan of Nightwish too...
@musikmood And do you know something? Evanescence did made a change in music, because is a famous group of rock with a gothic/symphonic style that doesnt have a lot of famous bands, so, when Evanescence appeared in America got a lot of fans who didnt know European Metal bands like Nightwish, Therion, After Forever...but when some people heared Evanescence in the radio and they liked the mix of a female singer in a rock band with some classical instruments they wanted more, so they discovered
@musikmood amazing bands like After Forever, Nightwish, Epica, etc, ...that happenned to me , Im mexican, in Mexico you'll never hear anything in the tv or radio about After Forever, so how will people know them? But we can hear Evanescence on the radio because is mainstream music, but an excellent music, so we hear Evanescence, we search it on Internet and we realize that in Europe there are a lot of amazing bands...so I dont know why there are some idiot people who doesnt understand it
@adr14ntr FUCK! you are deaf! I have mexican friends and they heard NW since 98' and they had a tour in mexico 2000..so? is your fucking problem if you only hear the radio and the TV, if you want underground music you must to search it.
and now evashit started in 95' with other name jajaja, in that case NW started 93' with the black metal band jaja XD
anyway the YEARS DOSENT MATTER, EXCEPT THE MUSIC, you only hear music for the female vocalist, for that reason you think that they are the same
@musikmood You only hear female vocalist, you dont hear music, you only want a woman as vocalsit, for that reason you can't hear the BIG differences between them.
"evshit is a famous group of rock with a gothic/symphonic style" what the fuck? goth? symphonic? ja XD
goth rock: Theatre of Hate, bauhaus
symphonic metal: therion, haggard
a fucking violin in the back of a song is NOT SYMPHONIC.
symphonic is a BIG composition THERION-VIA NOCTURNA
@musikmood hear what you want, but try to make any comparation, and dont say evashit, is goth, evashit is symphonic, evashit is excellent, cuz is ridiculous, si very stupid.
if they are excellents why DON'T they play in wacken fest, female vocalist fest ,goth fst, wave gothic treffen?
is easy, they are not good, they are fake.
if you want to defend evashit SHUT UP, and make comparations with band of this "style" like the nu metal shit, is much better.
Great song; I think it's about two people who have a relationship that suddenly comes to an end, and the speaker is saying that all of what was is now empty memories. Pretty cool.
Ne haragudj, ez már vicc. Ilyen hang a zongorán sincs :D:D:D LOL. It is funny. It can't be that note. This note isnt even on the piano. But you can sing it , wao very... impressive. And funny.
Dutch , nuff said .
pcrvg0808 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for After Forever
I love this band ~
VampireHorrorFreak 1 year ago
Spinach and Evanescence suck.
Potatoes and After Forever rule :D
alin1975 1 year ago 6
@alin1975 Evanescence are completely different to Spinach! >:(
Equinoctic 1 year ago
@alin1975 jajajajjajaja big difference
musikmood 9 months ago
ssooooo fucking great and beautiful...
keylllogdark 1 year ago 4
I Love This Song And This Band, Her Voice Is So Pure!
jamoukhadesana 1 year ago
This is my favorite of theirs that I've heard so far.
datlilnerdigrl 2 years ago
This song is wonderful, most certainly once she gets to the We know only sorrow
There's no future in tomorrow
All our hopes have buried too young
For the years that should have followed
We know only hatred
There's no future in our anguish
For our hope was buried with life
And reprisal will be ours
That is just gold.
DarkAngelAzreil 2 years ago
totally agree with equalvectorkeys comment below.
I think this song is great, floors voice is wonderful.
missheavymetal1 2 years ago
who cares what band comes first or second or anything, or what genre Evanescence are and what Nightwish played before or plays now...The actual truth lies in your musical taste.I don't like spinach I like potatoes, so what? Should I judge people who like spinach?huh?State your opinion, it's respectful, but don't judge before you actually learn to listen.
equalvectorkeys 2 years ago 38
@equalvectorkeys Bingo, you said it beautifully. As long as the music is good, who gives a shit about the rest of it?
darkseaofempathy 1 year ago
no woman can ever be compared to tarja. EVER :P even if u dont like the sound of her voice she is a also an insanely great singer that u cant deny.
Jaocob 2 years ago
Tarja is fuckin amazing... Nightwish pretty much went downhill after her in my opinion but there are better singers than her... Sarah Brightman for example is INSANE... she has a vocal range of over 3 octaves and incredible control... I love Tarja but there are better
fireflower114 2 years ago 2
3 octives...not so much a big deal, both me, my cousi, and my opera teacher all have three and a half ocvtives. It's those with four octives who are the freaks of nature...O.o
DarkAngelAzreil 2 years ago
Cyndi Lauper and Johnny Mathis both have 5 octaves.
datlilnerdigrl 2 years ago
Ahhh Floor. Evanescence reminds me of Lacuna Coil, After Forever, The gathering, Within temptation, Nightwish. That's the way it is; one can not look like ones son, it's always the other way around.
Gharkhan 2 years ago 2
rolling stone once askd lacuna coil how they feel about evanescence being an american rip off in an interview.
every one of those bands you mentioned was around long before evan...
dickr4chicks 2 years ago
Fuck off. I'm only stating my opinion.
OldNightwishRules 2 years ago
you can't compare evanescence with AF or nightwish. Evanescence is trendy american, AF and NT are metal - they are goth, not emo
That's like saying Epica sounds like madonna
dreamzwalker 2 years ago
lovin this band <3
yaoiluvRproductions 2 years ago 6
Very Beautiful...her voice => o_O
Withinscars 2 years ago 4
wow the first part really reminds me of Evanescence
OldNightwishRules 2 years ago
I have to agree. Though once the song keeps going it becomes less and less like that.
I wish I had known about this band a long time ago. I would have loved to see them in concert. I got the 'After Forever' cd a few days ago and I am loving it. ^_^ 'Empty Memories' is one of my favorite tracks.
ravenclaw2010 2 years ago
Yea i want to get the CD myself, no luck finding it in stores though.
OldNightwishRules 2 years ago
Oh that 's exactly what i thought whren i first heard it!
IOIcyprusgirlIOI 2 years ago
As much as I find it unfitting to compare AF to Evanescence, I have to agree with you on that...
moneymail002 2 years ago
shame on you.
this band was around before that shitty evanescence was piss in the wind.
evanescence sucks
dickr4chicks 2 years ago
Everyone's got to start somewhere. At least commend them for trying the genre in an area where it's not looked very highly upon or immensely popular.
kumiho92 2 years ago
true- however, its a genre not popular in America. its very popular in other countries - look at some of Afterforevers live concerts, or within temptations.
thousands present.
I stopped listening to a lot of american music due to lack of talent. every now and then there's something that catches my ear, but for the most part its just alternative crap. it is sad - the radio here plays the same 10 bands over and over again until a new band comes out.
1000s of songs, but only a couple played.
dickr4chicks 2 years ago 5
@dickr4chicks I couldn't agree more!
roly260 2 years ago
@dickr4chicks couldnt have said it better myself.
Flash2910 1 year ago
Why everyone thinks that Evanescence begun in 2003 with Fallen...sorry but Evanescence started in 1997... with that name...but 2 years ago they were Childish Intentions..so Evanescence started in 1995...before that Nightwish
adr14ntr 2 years ago
@adr14ntr jajajajaja but any with good taste on music knows that evanecescenceee sukcs there are alot of bands with female vocalist but that dosent mean that they are the same quality, some punk bands start with female vocalist, at 70' and even before with the rockabilly so a band with female vocalist is not of the 90'
musikmood 9 months ago
@musikmood you should read what equalvectorkeys said before comment
adr14ntr 9 months ago
@adr14ntr you can hear what you fucking taste want, but dont come here to make comparisons about a shitty band, even with his "years" they didnt make any change in music cuz they dont have quality they dont make any for the history of music" the wannabe goth shit". Are you trying to say that evashit have more years?are they the pioneers?
Nightwish start as a power metal band, the first SYMPHONIC METAL band was therion. just cuz some bands have female vocalist dosent mean that they are the same
musikmood 9 months ago 3
@musikmood God! you are bored...You can check my channel and you'll see Im fan of Therion and Nightwish, so, I already knew all what yu said before... I just commented that Evanescence didnt start in 2003 as a lot of people believes and now you are here bitching about them...dont you have a better thing to do?
adr14ntr 9 months ago
@adr14ntr you are trying to defend evaneshit with more shit, you said" they started in 1997, before than nw"
NW stared in 1996 even before, but that dosent matter, the years dont say nothing except the music, who caress if evashit started after of before? evashit didn't make any change, Nightwish and evashit are genres completely differents, dont try to make stupid comparations between this bands, the evashit's fans always make this kind of comments in videos of good bands, are idiots or WTF?
musikmood 9 months ago
@musikmood As I said before, Evanescence didnt start in 1997 they started in 1995 before Nightwish, Nightwish started in 1996... Now, Im trying to defend Evanescence of what? I just commented that because I read comments saying that Evanescence is a new band when they are not... I didnt start that comparation, if I wrote it is because I read a comment about it... Im fan of Evanescence but Im fan of Nightwish too...
adr14ntr 9 months ago
@musikmood And do you know something? Evanescence did made a change in music, because is a famous group of rock with a gothic/symphonic style that doesnt have a lot of famous bands, so, when Evanescence appeared in America got a lot of fans who didnt know European Metal bands like Nightwish, Therion, After Forever...but when some people heared Evanescence in the radio and they liked the mix of a female singer in a rock band with some classical instruments they wanted more, so they discovered
adr14ntr 9 months ago
@musikmood amazing bands like After Forever, Nightwish, Epica, etc, ...that happenned to me , Im mexican, in Mexico you'll never hear anything in the tv or radio about After Forever, so how will people know them? But we can hear Evanescence on the radio because is mainstream music, but an excellent music, so we hear Evanescence, we search it on Internet and we realize that in Europe there are a lot of amazing bands...so I dont know why there are some idiot people who doesnt understand it
adr14ntr 9 months ago
@adr14ntr FUCK! you are deaf! I have mexican friends and they heard NW since 98' and they had a tour in mexico 2000..so? is your fucking problem if you only hear the radio and the TV, if you want underground music you must to search it.
and now evashit started in 95' with other name jajaja, in that case NW started 93' with the black metal band jaja XD
anyway the YEARS DOSENT MATTER, EXCEPT THE MUSIC, you only hear music for the female vocalist, for that reason you think that they are the same
musikmood 9 months ago
@musikmood You only hear female vocalist, you dont hear music, you only want a woman as vocalsit, for that reason you can't hear the BIG differences between them.
"evshit is a famous group of rock with a gothic/symphonic style" what the fuck? goth? symphonic? ja XD
goth rock: Theatre of Hate, bauhaus
symphonic metal: therion, haggard
a fucking violin in the back of a song is NOT SYMPHONIC.
symphonic is a BIG composition THERION-VIA NOCTURNA
as you see you dont know nothing.
musikmood 9 months ago
@musikmood hear what you want, but try to make any comparation, and dont say evashit, is goth, evashit is symphonic, evashit is excellent, cuz is ridiculous, si very stupid.
if they are excellents why DON'T they play in wacken fest, female vocalist fest ,goth fst, wave gothic treffen?
is easy, they are not good, they are fake.
if you want to defend evashit SHUT UP, and make comparations with band of this "style" like the nu metal shit, is much better.
power symphonic metal vs nu shit, dont try
musikmood 9 months ago
@musikmood boring
adr14ntr 8 months ago
SO SAD, I wish they were still together sucks that i couldn't have seen them where i live
TearisShatteredMoon 2 years ago
Great song; I think it's about two people who have a relationship that suddenly comes to an end, and the speaker is saying that all of what was is now empty memories. Pretty cool.
darkseaofempathy 2 years ago 4
Ne haragudj, ez már vicc. Ilyen hang a zongorán sincs :D:D:D LOL. It is funny. It can't be that note. This note isnt even on the piano. But you can sing it , wao very... impressive. And funny.
Titti0913 3 years ago
En verdad que esta es la cancion de despedida T_T After FOREVER!!!
maryofjesus 3 years ago
I am the 9,000th HIT!! It's over 9,000!!!!!
KinStrategy 3 years ago 4
And now it's over 10,500 =D
No wonder... After Forever should have much more cred and fame than they have
Crowstale 3 years ago 6
my favourite.
Despica 3 years ago
basta basta io li sposo gli after forever!!!le loro canzoni sono fantasticheeee <3
ilmondotuttotondo 3 years ago
awesome band love them especially the god of war symbol
richie2259 3 years ago
nope...they won't make an album till 2009or2010!!!^^unfortunately!!!!=(
hallelujjaa 3 years ago
Does anyone know if they are working on a next albums?
megapotheosis 3 years ago
Sadly, they took a break as a band...
00Rotem00 3 years ago
Permanent break *cough, cough*
Jophelerx 3 years ago 3
Este tema es la raja, realmente increible!!!! viva After Forever
IMPERATROX 3 years ago
great song!
rajachango 3 years ago 6
Sooo fucking beautiful!
Areoz 4 years ago 17