I really don´t understand why they chose that song for the "sacrifice" of Faramir. Okay, with the melody it sounds like some kind of lament. But actually it´s a walking song! -.-
@9Nienor When humans communicate vocally, the way we say something matters much more than the words we're actually saying. Scientifically confirmed and all. When speaking face to face, the words themselves are only about 10% of what we're actually communicating.
The melody sets the context for the words. With a cheery, rhythmic melody, it's a walking song. With this one, it's a lament of worldly impermanence.
That may be true. Nevertheless Tolkien, who created the original song, intented it to be a walking song and thats why it should have stayed one. I mean, The Lord of the Rings is his creation, so why do they have to change everything?
@9Nienor How do you know it was intended to be a walking song? Why can't it just be a song they were singing while walking? Why can't it be an innocent shire song that Pippin, when pressed, chose because the lyrics seemed fitting to him in relation to the looming battle and his loss of innocence?
And if we're talking about Tolkein, it would be absolute lunacy to suggest that he didn't intend the lyrics to tie into the world and the story.
@9Nienor I also just pulled out my copy of Fellowship, and read the relevant passage. It's not a walking song, and not intended as such. It's a supper song or a bed song (both of which I would think as tending to more contemplative music), but hummed out of context by the group as a walking song.
A few pages into chapter 3, if you want to read it for yourself.
I´ve read the book often enough to know where it is and what it is. But as my mother tongue is not English I didn´t know any better word for it than "walking song", especially as the Hobbits sang it as one. But then it is, as you say, a bed song and therefore still unrelated to the events and as I guess, Tolkien intended a merrier rhythm for it,
No, you in reading the book interpreted the song as having a merrier rhythm.
And in terms of rhythm, how do you know that Pippin wasn't keeping the tune, but slowing it down because that pace felt more appropriate for the situation? I can certainly think of various traditional songs that can be sped up or slowed down depending on what you want to emphasize in it.
You're making assumptions based on your reading of the book and taking those assumptions as gospel.
@9Nienor what do you mean "change everything"? I'm so tired of those book fans taking a dig at the movie every chance they've got. You can't deny that the lyrics fit much much better with the melancholic scene of Faramir charging to his death. I say props to Peter Jackson for finding the connection here. Taking a song from as early as FotR and connecting it to something in RotK requires much more understanding and complexity than keeping the song as a merry walking song that it mite not even be
@9Nienor Because it's saying that they're on a sort of hopeless walk through darkness. And that's what Faramir's doing, he knows it's going to fail, but he keeps going anyways. And the "all shall fade" part is basically about Faramir dying.
Billy's voice is soooo magical in soooo many ways.. mysterious yet magical.. and when i found out that Billy just made up a tune for this poem which was originally made by Tolkien, hands down to Billy.. such talented lads they got for the movie, which will always be one of my very favs.. :)
The song in the movie is an adaptation, by Billy , called "The Edge of Night", of "The Walking Song" poem from the first book in the LoTR series written by Tolken.
one thing- i don't know how it's Billy's composition if it's a song by Bilbo in The Lord Of The Rings books, meaning it would technically be by Tolkien. Maybe Billy made the notation for it? Either way, amazing job!!
@xAizaOnigirix ...... The song in the movie is an adaptation, by Billy , called "The Edge of Night", of "The Walking Song" poem from the first book in the LoTR series written by Tolken.
This is an absolutely brilliant version, your voice is so beautiful. I don't want to sound like I'm on a begging mission or anything, but I make videos and I'd love to be able to use your cover of this song for one in the near future with your permission?
you're an amazing singer. i'm learnign this song for my next singing exam. is there anyone who can tell me where to find the full song with music added to it? x
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com.
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com
Billy Boyd (the actor who plays Pippin) wrote the words and music to this song himself- Howard Shore the film score composer for LOTR just added some background instrumentation
@QueenBeatlesWings Actually, Billy Boyd only wrote a few of the words to Edge of Night. It is from the original books. He did write the melody to it however.
I usually avoid covers but something made me click on yours and am I glad. Your voice and rendition of this song were touchingly lovely. Thanks for sharing this.
@Mithrandir1776 i can't find this song in the book......okay, I'm german, but there must be a translation......is it before or after they met Tom Bombadil?....do you know the name of the chapter?
Excellent job. You have real talent. I'm a big fan of the movies and loved this song and now I wouldn't be able to tell you which version I like more....... yours or the official soundtrack. If you live in Saint Louis, I'd love to buy you a drink!!!!!!
i love this song!! when i saw that part of the movie i was like a wow!!!!! he has a nice voice! i love!! pippin!! he´s cute!!! i love him!! and...his voice...
Well actually I watched a cast interview on it. They had gone out to Karaoke and Billy Boyd(pippin's actor) was a really good singer. The movie playwright was tone deaf and really wanted a song to go with it.
She asked him and he had about a day and a half to do it. He read up a little on the Stories and wrote it so it would be like the Hobbit's and how they came to the Shire for the first time on a long journey. He said he thought it fit it.
it is indeed his own compossision, if u watch the special extended edition, it says they wanted 2 do his song in the book, but thers no actual song in the book(i think) so they c about him singing, and apparenlty som of the cast went 2 a kareoke thing and he sang, and they asked him 2 write a song,(im pretty sure) u would need 2 watch the special extended edition behind the scenes 4 the whole story...
Billy wrote the melody and sang it, yes, But the lyrics were already written and givien to him. I love this song though! It´s so beautiful and he is such a talented singer. LUV IT
@Sandra2Jonsson What i heard was he made it all, including lyrics. he had two days to do it, and no one had heard it before. he thought about what place and situation he was in and how it had to be something pipin's ancestors must have sung and wrote the whole song. it was entirely original. i agree he has and awesone voice. this is a great song. i wish i could write like that.
Billy Boyd did the singing for the movie. He has a light voice, but it's still distinctly male. The singer here is obviously female. So no, not the same. Still a great song though.
WOW! i thought I was listening to a professional recording for a few seconds. Your voice is gorgeous and perfect for celtic music. Great breath control, and I can really hear the emotion.
wow!!! that was awsome! i thought it was the original but them i heard you miss some notes in world. but anyhoo that was beautiful. gave me goose flesh. and trust me i'm not easy to impress :)
Happy Birthday Tolkien, thanks for helping to make Fantasy a realty. To, The Professer!
Gustoff27 1 month ago
Wow. Nice voice.
LordHienrich 3 months ago
Where did you get those wings, you, Angel? You have a beautiful voice. You should pursue a career with your talent!
BabyCovenant22 3 months ago
fucking gorgeous!
11BobbySweet11 4 months ago
Beautiful voice
musicaltheatre303 4 months ago
You have a beautiful singing voice!
Rimmonin 4 months ago
beautiful voice!!!! i love you voice!!
TheArahera 4 months ago
The Audio sucks !!!!
KristelDusk 4 months ago
I love it! Good job!
AndrewAshfordHungary 5 months ago
I really don´t understand why they chose that song for the "sacrifice" of Faramir. Okay, with the melody it sounds like some kind of lament. But actually it´s a walking song! -.-
9Nienor 5 months ago 5
@9Nienor When humans communicate vocally, the way we say something matters much more than the words we're actually saying. Scientifically confirmed and all. When speaking face to face, the words themselves are only about 10% of what we're actually communicating.
The melody sets the context for the words. With a cheery, rhythmic melody, it's a walking song. With this one, it's a lament of worldly impermanence.
Honestly, I think it's a great fit for the scene.
cptjeff 5 months ago
@cptjeff
That may be true. Nevertheless Tolkien, who created the original song, intented it to be a walking song and thats why it should have stayed one. I mean, The Lord of the Rings is his creation, so why do they have to change everything?
9Nienor 5 months ago
@9Nienor How do you know it was intended to be a walking song? Why can't it just be a song they were singing while walking? Why can't it be an innocent shire song that Pippin, when pressed, chose because the lyrics seemed fitting to him in relation to the looming battle and his loss of innocence?
And if we're talking about Tolkein, it would be absolute lunacy to suggest that he didn't intend the lyrics to tie into the world and the story.
cptjeff 5 months ago
@9Nienor I also just pulled out my copy of Fellowship, and read the relevant passage. It's not a walking song, and not intended as such. It's a supper song or a bed song (both of which I would think as tending to more contemplative music), but hummed out of context by the group as a walking song.
A few pages into chapter 3, if you want to read it for yourself.
cptjeff 5 months ago
@cptjeff
I´ve read the book often enough to know where it is and what it is. But as my mother tongue is not English I didn´t know any better word for it than "walking song", especially as the Hobbits sang it as one. But then it is, as you say, a bed song and therefore still unrelated to the events and as I guess, Tolkien intended a merrier rhythm for it,
9Nienor 5 months ago
No, you in reading the book interpreted the song as having a merrier rhythm.
And in terms of rhythm, how do you know that Pippin wasn't keeping the tune, but slowing it down because that pace felt more appropriate for the situation? I can certainly think of various traditional songs that can be sped up or slowed down depending on what you want to emphasize in it.
You're making assumptions based on your reading of the book and taking those assumptions as gospel.
cptjeff 5 months ago
@9Nienor what do you mean "change everything"? I'm so tired of those book fans taking a dig at the movie every chance they've got. You can't deny that the lyrics fit much much better with the melancholic scene of Faramir charging to his death. I say props to Peter Jackson for finding the connection here. Taking a song from as early as FotR and connecting it to something in RotK requires much more understanding and complexity than keeping the song as a merry walking song that it mite not even be
burningSunset78 4 months ago
@9Nienor pippin said he didn't know songs for "evil" times.
these lyrics may refer to "walking" in the sense of leaving something behind...
But they can be interpreted in other way which is relevant to the situation. I like the choice!
EntreriSeraph 3 months ago
@9Nienor Because it's saying that they're on a sort of hopeless walk through darkness. And that's what Faramir's doing, he knows it's going to fail, but he keeps going anyways. And the "all shall fade" part is basically about Faramir dying.
adamyoungfan56 2 months ago
I LOVE EVERY THİNG ABOUT LORD OF THE RİNGS ! especially the soundtrack...
heismyonlyweakness 5 months ago
Why isn't pippin singing it.
Leonniket 5 months ago
@Leonniket because I covered the song. ;-)
Steedrider 3 weeks ago
Great vid. In truth, he only made the rythmn/tune, not the lyrics. The lyrics are in the fellowship of the ring.
crazyredsimpkins 5 months ago
@crazyredsimpkins
no one was disputing that man..
NormbrettaMod 5 months ago
Most Beautiful song I have ever heard
asteven1994 6 months ago
very very lovely and amazing voice
rain9129 6 months ago
@rain9129 thank you :)
Steedrider 3 weeks ago
@ page 103 ;)
BEFsize 7 months ago
I Love Billy Boyd! Wish I could meet him! Someday some how ill try my best to! :)
breezecowgirl 7 months ago
Billy's voice is soooo magical in soooo many ways.. mysterious yet magical.. and when i found out that Billy just made up a tune for this poem which was originally made by Tolkien, hands down to Billy.. such talented lads they got for the movie, which will always be one of my very favs.. :)
09shohoku 7 months ago 16
@09shohoku They had him make up the tune because they didn't have time to do it before shooting. He literally had a night to come up with it.
thenerevarine13 6 months ago
@09shohoku All true - but you do realise this is not Billy's version, don't you? ;)
Steedrider 3 weeks ago in playlist Folk / Celtic / New Age
/watch?v=md8VDETzoFY&feature=related Sorry for being critical, but until you can record better, I'm going to be listening to this one.
XxC0ldH3artxX 7 months ago
*_* <3 Awesome, just Awesome....
NeoPaganMosher 8 months ago
keep singin
jonah214 8 months ago
This is hauntingly beautiful. Your voice is so amazing.
OminousNerdGirl 9 months ago
Beautiful, love. You could have been a wee bit faster, even though it is a dirge.(just creative critisiam, you dont have to take it.)
Keep singing, darlin'
starchildbladesinger 9 months ago
Haha well, like always, Wiki is wroooong again. This is a poem made by Tolkien himself. Billy just made up the tune for it. Never listen to Wiki....
flapperkyle 10 months ago
@DarkJafar I only do ONE post to trolls, and I am never posting again.
Jasper2428 10 months ago
BEAUTIFUL...Waw :O
lendak85 11 months ago
really, really good job. You should sing the full song! :p
vampbaby1 11 months ago
just beautiful
180Punisher 1 year ago
what a voice!! I am amazed!!
donnie2110 1 year ago
The song in the movie is an adaptation, by Billy , called "The Edge of Night", of "The Walking Song" poem from the first book in the LoTR series written by Tolken.
Hunnyelf 1 year ago
That just gave me goosebumps. While of course I love the original from the movie, your rendition was BEAUTIFUL. You have an amazing voice.
vcat10 1 year ago
Even in poor quality this song is amazing
Quadraxis 1 year ago
beautiful voice...!
one thing- i don't know how it's Billy's composition if it's a song by Bilbo in The Lord Of The Rings books, meaning it would technically be by Tolkien. Maybe Billy made the notation for it? Either way, amazing job!!
xAizaOnigirix 1 year ago
@xAizaOnigirix ...... The song in the movie is an adaptation, by Billy , called "The Edge of Night", of "The Walking Song" poem from the first book in the LoTR series written by Tolken.
Hunnyelf 1 year ago
Very pretty (:
cutiepye1995 1 year ago
the most beautiful song in the world maybe? and you have a beautiful voice!
PatriaFinlandia 1 year ago
make another one with better sound quality.
TheDaki75 1 year ago
<3
Ariyaunna 1 year ago
so sad.... i hope your happy!
now i shall think of the many perils of the world while this is in my head!
500pa4r33k 1 year ago
What fairie tail you from girl?
LordStronna 1 year ago
That was haunting and absolutely beautiful =)
WhiteCrow197 1 year ago
wow, i got chills.
peacexlondon 1 year ago
This is an absolutely brilliant version, your voice is so beautiful. I don't want to sound like I'm on a begging mission or anything, but I make videos and I'd love to be able to use your cover of this song for one in the near future with your permission?
MrsLovett112 1 year ago
Love the voice :) You did great!
Though I still think the movie's version is unbeatable... the pure, male voice just seems to go with it so well.
But again, kudos to you! This is my favorite cover of it :)
MCPOSpartan046 1 year ago
you're an amazing singer. i'm learnign this song for my next singing exam. is there anyone who can tell me where to find the full song with music added to it? x
ChocolateChip63 1 year ago
NERDGASM!!!!
TAYTAYshotu 1 year ago
beautiful...
cherrycat444 1 year ago
amazing!!!!!!
VampireDiariesVids 1 year ago
@Klaacki billy wrote that song not Tolkin u cannot find it in the books, it was created for the movie only google it ;)
TheGreekGuardian 1 year ago
damn, you gave me goosebumps, great singing :)
Thengel123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com
Linaeve 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com.
Linaeve 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You're quite good... usually I cringe at users posting their own rendition of songs that have been professionally produced.... But you have excellent tone and clarity. Keep singing! :-) Can you send me an mp3 of your version? e-mail me randomname000@gmail.com
Linaeve 1 year ago
very nice.
andysim232 1 year ago
btw. this song was written by a young new zealander who was strongly ill ! Before cinema release he died of his disease ! R.I.P
nosdradomos 1 year ago
is this like Suzanne Boil or something? it's really good.
longshanks0971 1 year ago
@Steedrider, is you singing? Thank you, that is very very good.. I'm your fan hehehe Kiss me? kkkk
pirlobrazil 1 year ago
If like Lord of the Rings is a nerd's thing, yes, i'm a great nerd.. :P With proud!
pirlobrazil 1 year ago
bone chilling experience
centralhacker 1 year ago
THis is gorgeous. You have a beautiful voice honey!
OminousNerdGirl 1 year ago
Billy Boyd (the actor who plays Pippin) wrote the words and music to this song himself- Howard Shore the film score composer for LOTR just added some background instrumentation
QueenBeatlesWings 1 year ago
@QueenBeatlesWings Actually, Billy Boyd only wrote a few of the words to Edge of Night. It is from the original books. He did write the melody to it however.
MidniteBlackoutFilms 1 year ago
Beautiful. Enjoy the knowledge, that you made someone's day so much better. Thank you.
JuhanJuhanipoeg 1 year ago
I usually avoid covers but something made me click on yours and am I glad. Your voice and rendition of this song were touchingly lovely. Thanks for sharing this.
KKumokun 1 year ago
Merry did it better, but this one is good too ;)
cyberdaemon 1 year ago
PIPPIN!!
MrFredweasleysgurl 1 year ago
nice!!
Ryouichiify 1 year ago
Good voice, you should learn the full song. Read the Fellowship of the Ring, the hobbits sing it before they get to Bree.
Mithrandir1776 1 year ago 81
@Mithrandir1776 i can't find this song in the book......okay, I'm german, but there must be a translation......is it before or after they met Tom Bombadil?....do you know the name of the chapter?
Klaacki 1 year ago
@Mithrandir1776 where can I find the full lyrics?
AnimatedBeauty1 1 year ago
@Mithrandir1776 not true btw
strv 1 year ago
@Mithrandir1776 Hear hear! The youth of today doesn't have any knowledge of the books unfortunately :(
ShippingUp 1 year ago
Excellent job. You have real talent. I'm a big fan of the movies and loved this song and now I wouldn't be able to tell you which version I like more....... yours or the official soundtrack. If you live in Saint Louis, I'd love to buy you a drink!!!!!!
itonlyhurtsalittle 1 year ago
i hope your proud....you just made me cry ='(
get back to heaven what are you doing here??
00nerd4 1 year ago 140
@00nerd4 =)))) i feel the same way mate ^^
alexandrabutiri2000 10 months ago
wow you have an amazing voice ...
shneaper1 1 year ago
Woah, Honey! Your voice is AMAZING. God bless you, for sounding like such an Angel.
MrDarcyGrl23 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You have a wonderful voice.
dj81632 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You have a wonderful voice.
dj81632 1 year ago
You have a wonderful voice.
dj81632 1 year ago
Awsome voice dudette ! 100/10!
Memoriesmatter94 1 year ago
that was amazing...thank you for making it :) :)
IlovetheeMiranda 1 year ago
With a voice like that I bet the Gods ears opened wide as they descended to hear you sing. It'd be hard to believe otherwise.
DemonexRa 1 year ago
wow, beautiful voice!congrats and thx for sharing
ondynefairy 1 year ago
Billy Boyd has such an amazing voice! Thanks so much for posting!
MegaBookfan 1 year ago
Your voice is so beautiful... It is what I long to hear on the radio...
soXhappyxIxcouldXdie 1 year ago
wait, this isn't the original? Heck, it sounds equally nice!
applelovesHim 1 year ago
btw ponder upon the meaning of this song for a bit ... and consider the fact its a traveling song.
i probably might sing this when i travel up north later.
btw great job on this. you are a soprano if i had to say what type. :)
moa373 1 year ago
VOICE = BEASTLY!!! LOOOVVVVEEEE IIIITTTTT!!!!(:
AmethystWolfStar2 1 year ago
you are really talented when it comes to acapella
MissAlbaNuadh 1 year ago
Home is behind
The world ahead
And there are many paths to tread
Through shadow
To the edge of night
Until the stars are all alight
Mist and shadow
Cloud and shade
All shall fade
All shall fade
93mute 1 year ago
WOW an amazing voice, truthfully brilliant
Serris460 1 year ago
i luv singing this song
named244 1 year ago
Great cover. Loved it!
grappleshooter103 1 year ago
Oha.. you're really a very good singer o.O
MrsLolla 1 year ago
was tryin to find a decent remix of this, but no joy :(
scam92 1 year ago
sorry but i prefer Pippins version. Nice voice though :)
TokyoKazama 1 year ago
Beautiful... so wonderfully musical
breatheslowandlong 1 year ago
i love this song!! when i saw that part of the movie i was like a wow!!!!! he has a nice voice! i love!! pippin!! he´s cute!!! i love him!! and...his voice...
heartkaren 1 year ago
I keep coming back to this version. Thanks.
mussusbutley 1 year ago
LOL I just read my comment lol and I meant to say... All time fave movies! Lol
Bipa06 1 year ago
B-E-A-UUU-T-FUL!! my all tome dave movies! You have a brilliant voice too! WOW!
Bipa06 1 year ago
you sing this??!!!
beautifull song
michielb501 1 year ago
The guy that plays Pippin wrote it.. He is also in a band :P
Great cover btw.. I love you
flimda 1 year ago
Well actually I watched a cast interview on it. They had gone out to Karaoke and Billy Boyd(pippin's actor) was a really good singer. The movie playwright was tone deaf and really wanted a song to go with it.
She asked him and he had about a day and a half to do it. He read up a little on the Stories and wrote it so it would be like the Hobbit's and how they came to the Shire for the first time on a long journey. He said he thought it fit it.
Pandora139 1 year ago
heartwarming
futureshocker 1 year ago
ur joking, u did not sing dat!?
it was downright beautiful!
shweta193 1 year ago
great voice, but the sound quality doesn't do you justice. If you were to re-record it so that it sounded clearer it would be spectacular!
bsballfn1721 1 year ago
the lyrics are actually from the book, from a hobbit walking or travel song or something...
quirkyloopy 1 year ago
You have a beautiful voice! I'm going to sing this song according to YOUR voice.
ps. I'm a twelve year old GIRL by the way.
kiryuzerolover1 1 year ago
It's not the original?! You're kidding!! That was amazing. Beautiful.
RoseTyler31 1 year ago
@RoseTyler31 now all it needs is the creepy/sad music underneath
FishfilmsInc 1 year ago
I just wanna tell people that Billy did not write this song. He wrote the melody. The song is actually a poem found in the Fellowship book.
Bpetty2 1 year ago
it is indeed his own compossision, if u watch the special extended edition, it says they wanted 2 do his song in the book, but thers no actual song in the book(i think) so they c about him singing, and apparenlty som of the cast went 2 a kareoke thing and he sang, and they asked him 2 write a song,(im pretty sure) u would need 2 watch the special extended edition behind the scenes 4 the whole story...
arcticshade1 1 year ago
Great voice, just need a bit more of work on pronounciation. <3
Flaphand 1 year ago
nice voice.. but I immidialty heard the change between you and pippin:)
107459 1 year ago
wow...just...wow....amazing.
arcticwildfire 1 year ago
...so beautiful!!
(L)
sepp993 1 year ago
great version of the song, beautiful voice
IrishMick115 1 year ago
awesome.
FALLinLOVEwithME 1 year ago
awesome voice... too bad the micro makes some noise =p
Bolorinvasore 1 year ago
Everything in this film is beautiful!!!!
LADY1Z1 1 year ago
wow =)
u got a reallyz nice voicez
sorry to say but tht was better than billy boyd singing it =)
ryanparslow 1 year ago
nice voice:) VERY nice:)
ilovemybrotherpiotr 1 year ago
i thought this was toilken's lullaby
philham423 1 year ago
WOW AWESOME JOB!
are you saprano????????? o__O.
THAT WAS AMAZING YOUR VERY GOOD
5/5
do you sing any other songs?
UnitedSting 1 year ago
you have a wanderfull voice :)
youlivewhatyoulearn 1 year ago
I'm going to have these song lyrics carved on my gravestone.
thewolfpoet 1 year ago
AMAZING voice one day wi will hear your voice on tv and radios keep up like tath and never stop singing
Cristiancrohr 1 year ago
Great voice indeed. :)
GohanWarscream 1 year ago
i agree you do have a great voice
GoofyDudeMan 1 year ago
I really loved this part in the movie because its so dramatic. The song is very simple yet very beautifull
lvsitiwdr 1 year ago 2
lol^^ wir haben ja die gleichen singstimmen =P
5634749383 1 year ago
A large portion of this song's lyrics are in the first book.
DraikSith 1 year ago
u hve the best voiceive ever heard : )
heidindrew 1 year ago
Billy wrote the melody and sang it, yes, But the lyrics were already written and givien to him. I love this song though! It´s so beautiful and he is such a talented singer. LUV IT
Sandra2Jonsson 1 year ago
@Sandra2Jonsson What i heard was he made it all, including lyrics. he had two days to do it, and no one had heard it before. he thought about what place and situation he was in and how it had to be something pipin's ancestors must have sung and wrote the whole song. it was entirely original. i agree he has and awesone voice. this is a great song. i wish i could write like that.
inuhimesama 1 year ago
GOD DAMN!
mesmerizing voice O_O
10 out of 5!
wooshra 1 year ago 2
wow! itš just beauty
emulicka 1 year ago
?>>>>33
baltazrinho 1 year ago
Like Lúthien Tinúviel
drawer1995 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
russellbrandandkaty 1 year ago
your name just explains this comment.
nothinbuthax 1 year ago
U did good ignore that little shit Russell and just keep on sining XD
PurpleHillSeeker 1 year ago 2
cheers :)
russellbrandandkaty 1 year ago
HOLY CR*P. Your voice is AMAZING!
colincucatto 1 year ago 3
very nice
MissMarinda 1 year ago
Comment removed
russellbrandandkaty 1 year ago
FUCK U RUSSEL SHE WAS GOOD U LIL SHIT!
PurpleHillSeeker 1 year ago
Comment removed
russellbrandandkaty 1 year ago
Your voice is lovely.
kristalcarolyn 1 year ago
amazing voice!
EarFromPoland 1 year ago
after lookin at the comments.. isnt this the music from the movie?? if it isnt WTF it is almost exactly the same!!
caysha27 2 years ago
Billy Boyd did the singing for the movie. He has a light voice, but it's still distinctly male. The singer here is obviously female. So no, not the same. Still a great song though.
atradominadono 1 year ago
WOW! i thought I was listening to a professional recording for a few seconds. Your voice is gorgeous and perfect for celtic music. Great breath control, and I can really hear the emotion.
lizzygurl798 2 years ago
You have a beautiful voice.
OnlyHer27 2 years ago
I usually dont like much of the singers on youtube....but that was haunting.
UndercoverCracker 2 years ago 3
I loved the way Boid sang,but you are great too!
MissErendis 2 years ago
Yet another amazing song by you! Truly fantastic! =)
hardworker359 2 years ago
The most beautiful movie ever made! A cool song ;x I love Lord Of The Ring especially Aragorn
MrBiliboy 2 years ago 29
wow!!! that was awsome! i thought it was the original but them i heard you miss some notes in world. but anyhoo that was beautiful. gave me goose flesh. and trust me i'm not easy to impress :)
izzypony88 2 years ago
That was outstandingly beautiful.
CrtlAltDeleted 2 years ago 21
got a shiver up my back
Ketersimax 2 years ago 3
Great Voice!!! Outstanding - 5/5!
solidsnake9215 2 years ago 15
@solidsnake9215 thanks :)
Steedrider 2 years ago 4
bad song quillity and my english is bad -.-
YuoNoob2 2 years ago
awesome song actually
Ketersimax 2 years ago
song is awesome but quillity of your video is bad
YuoNoob2 2 years ago