Added: 3 years ago
From: MrCoolDog
Views: 29,678
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (450)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Muito mau!

  • one m0:20re time uahsuhasuhsauhsahuhasuhasuassa­uh

  • hey girl anette,please let real artist sing !!!! tarja pls reunited with NW a sing for us one more time in czech republic !!!!!

  • Well.. I must say, that Anette has a big heart.. even though she was ill, she still had the courage to stand on the scene and give the performance to the audience :) Tarja didn't.. she just cancelled the show so the boys were standing back.. but Anette is completing it totally 100% through, and that's why. I like her a little better than Tarja.. :)

  • @SuperNightwish1

    Not true.

    Tarja WAS ill when they recorded "End Of An Era".

    I'm not making this up - read Nightwish's own book, "Once Upon A Nightwish".

  • holy shit! this girl sucks!!!! Tarja ist the best

  • If she is sick, that's fair for me. Although I don't understand why Nightwish chose this inappropriate singer.

  • KATASTROF ! ! !

  • She sounds like a 16 year old Amy Grant with Bronchitis!

  • horrible

  • THE ONLY THING I KOW IS THA I'VE NEVER HEARD TARJA WITH '' ILL '' VOICE

  • What a brilliantly constructed arguement here! ''Anette was ill, yet her voice does not sound different when she is not ill'' Well, why don't you find another soundclip and compare it as evidence?? Secondly it was recorded with a crappy phone so of course it's going to sound abit off.

  • lolwhut.

    I respect Anette and all, but god does she make this song a lame joke to my ears. Seriously, I can't stop laughing my ass off...especially when Marco was, like, "DREEEAAAAAM OOOF MEEEEEEEEEE~~" :))))))))))))))))

  • Mini skirt?! wtf? She is a metal singer not Britney Spears...She is nice,but she really should think about her dressing...

  • Anette should NEVER sing the songs which were composed for Tarja´s voice. This version breaks my ears.

  • That is actually really bad

  • shes has got no voice ...sorry...

  • @fantasyminas and her, does she respect you? Lol x)

  • jaja she's losing her voice poor anette xD i do respect her of course but i just her voice dosen't fit with Nightwish!

  • HEHEHEHE epic fail. "ever felt*HIIII* away..." Hahahah that's ridiculous..

  • I like how she sounds here... *shrugs* She sounds very hard rock.

  • To shut up your mouths bout her, check it live version then:

    watch?v=dMR1rwRvwfo

  • @minimaster4734 what difference does it make? she still sounds like she is shitting

  • @IvanTsarina Totally, hehehe that's not like if she changes her singing between two videos hahaha!

  • I don't like it ._.

  • I actually love this one! She is trying, and I like that sqiuicking sound :) Cant wait to see them again on a concert

  • If you think this is bad, ok, think it.

    I really like it!

  • o boże ona fałszuje!!! Ale kompromitacja

  • She is not singing she is killing this song.

  • is a big big error from the guys of Nightwish, try to make Anette sing the same songs that Tarja. Is impossible for her!!

  • ahahaha the introduction ahah FUNNY

  • Loool... that very high "iiiiik" is killing me xDDD

  • she cant sing very high can she......

  • THIS IS RAPE!! RAPE!! SHE IS THE WORST SINGER ALIVE!! WTF IS THAT SQUEAKING?!?!?!?!!?!

  • Tarja forever!

  • poor anette? - lol pooor nightwish poor world , thats terible and i thing its not too different from normal annets "singing"..............

    and seccond thing nightwish were simphonic metal band but anette is pop singer .......... lol

  • lool realy nice :D:D:D:D

  • CRINGE CRINGE CRINGE, i cannot listen to this without the cringe........awfl, terribly awful *cries*

  • Poor Anette...;=(

  • perra canta imundo

  • Tarja i miss you...

  • Annette reaaalllyy needs to stick to her own songs. Tarja is amazing. Annette, not so much. Whenever Annette tries to sing anything Tarja did, she just makes a fool of herself. Her singing abilities are no much for Tarjas. If she sticks to the new stuff she's much less likely to be compared to Tarja and she won't fail quite as much. I never got a chance to see Nightwish with Tarja in concert, it's a shame, and I have no intentions of seeing Nightwish now...

  • @74orangebeetle TOTALLY agree with you. She's nowhere near able to sing the songs Tarja used to sing. She doesn't sound as horrible when she sings her own songs, but that's because they were written for her voice and she would be doing herself (and all us old Nightwish fans) a great service if she stuck to what she could sing. I hope one day in the future they do a reunion show with Tarja, Idc where in the world it takes place, it's the only Nightwish concert I would ever go to now :/

  • Comment removed

  • oh... she isn't able to reach the higher note...

    I didn't expect that...

  • She screams where it's neded to be sung :(

  • Hey Mr. Cool Dog, no cantará como Tarja pero si se sale a romper la madre

    "She may not sing like Tarja but she's loose to kick ass

  • Guys, this isnt bad, and if she was sick why did you extract the vocals to showcase? It seems you're trying to make her seem bad, not to mention the vocals are boosted here.

  • Have any of you actually watched a video with a healthy Anette in it???

    In this one her voice breaks on practically every note... In a video with a healthy Anette, you will not notice that...

  • i've seen healthy Anette live (: not some difference, i must say (:

  • Did you hear her sick live too???

    She breaks in this song in this gig... Have you heard her in Hartwall??? She rules this song there....

  • Even better, I actually was at one of the NW-gigs. Anette was just as horrbile as in this one, but as a person, she seemed to be cheerful and nice.

    I have nothing against her personally. But she just slaughters Nighwish.

  • Did you see the one at Hartwall????

    Have you compared one from 2007 to 2009????

  • Why should I ? I listened to her live, I have seen enough videos, I gave her a fair chance to convince me. She did not achieve it, so I am not going to pay for a concert of Nightwish again.

  • I never said that you should go see them live again... I just wondered if you have heard the progress she's made in the last 3 years....

  • yes...but her voice is the same...

    you know..i don't say i hate their music now..it is just..it doesn't give me thrills like once did

  • No, her voice isn't the same.... It's not the same as it was 3 years ago.... she's evolved so much you wouldn't even know who it was....

    It gives me more thrills now with Anette then it did with Tarja in certain songs....

  • her voice is the same..her evolution is different..i agree that she is better now...but i still miss the 2004-2005 times..even earlier..

    this is all about taste...what kind of voice do you prefer..i like, for example, more operatic, cold, but beautiful voices..and..over all these things...the structure that made nw famous was: tuomas, tarja, empuu, jukka and marco..

  • I like voices that speak to me....

    In some songs Tarjas voice speaks to me, in some Anettes does.. In some of Lady GaGas song her voice speaks to me... In some of Mariah Careys songs her voice speaks to me...

    I don't just listen to one type of music... I have songs by Rammstein, Apocalyptica, NW, Katy Perry, Leona Lewis and Black eyed Peas on my MP3... Does that mean I'm less of a fan of NW because I don't just listen to symphonic metal???

  • did i say that? no...i agree with you at this point..

    but ...afterall..it is all about taste...

    i am ending this chapter now...with tarja-anette thing.. we will see what is coming in future

  • When Anette has songs written for her voice and she's worked with it...... We'll se what an amazing singer she is....

  • so with tarja..

  • I've never said Tarja is an amazing singer... But she has songs by NW written for her... Anette doesn't...

  • i've never said that Anette is an amazing singer...but..why do you continue with this nw thing[in tarja's case]? let's see how it will be 'what lies beneath'[she said that it will be more heavy than her first one..so it sounds promising]

    and don't tell me again something about anette..it's clear that we have different options...i know yours and you know mine...both are very good singers...with a very different music style of playing

  • It went a little fast there.... It was supposed to be:

    I never said Tarja wasn't an amazing singer....

    All you have to do is stop responding....

    They don't have different styles of playing... They have different styles of singing....

  • @MrCoolDog To tell the truth, apart from the times where her voice breaks (which is obviously due to her illness) I think this sounds just fine. And yes, I agree with you, it sounds pretty much like when she's healthy, which is... just fine. You're entitled to your opinion of course, but I honestly think this does sound good.

  • @MrCoolDog i so totally agree!!!!! TOTALLY AGREE!!!!!

  • I've heard once that Tuomas trying to find a new singer said it will be the one who will sing "Ever dream" the best way. And he chose Anette. May I ask - was there really REALLY nobody who sang it better?

  • Of course!!!

    Amy Winehouse. But she was drunken. ;-)

  • "singing" says it all.

    just horrible.

  • Respeto tu opinion. Yo la verdad no creo que sea horrible la interpretacion de anette. simplemente es direferente.

  • Ok...so I know she's sick here, but isn't that always her excuse?? Tarja was sick at the End of an Era concert (the one on dvd) but who could tell??

  • @gladiatrixangel I could!

  • I think at this time she had a cold. there are other videos on youtube showing anette singing ever dream and they don't sound like this!

  • Anette is a good singer, and even the best singers have off days. Tarja was never pitch perfect all the time..

  • no tarja was always perfect. the end of an era was the nightwish's best show , and tarja did perfect although she was ill

  • ugh!! this is adisrespectful to Tarja ='(...sorry Anette Ozlon is a pop singer. I love Nightwish still, but not for Anette, but for Tuomas, and Marco, and Emppu and Jukka. I will always love Nightwish, and i think the guys are all great musicians and they still sound good, but Anette...she is not good for nightwish. She should stick to pop!!

  • ....soon she will throw her throat in the toilet

  • Yeap guys...that sucks...poor Anette throat ajc .......sic !!! is it hurt ?

  • sheet... this is not funny at all, she is gonna hurt her troath or some shit, she is forcing her voice way too hard...

    i like her, but she is not for this band.

  • Annete sucks...Tarja Forever X3

  • Every felt AAA-way!!!

  • EPIC FAIL!!!

  • I miss old nightwish! Anette sucks!

  • Anette is a good singer in her own right, however that being said she needs to stay clear of tarja's songs as she dosen't sing like tarja. Anette has her own style and its not tarja, the reality is that Nighwish is different yet almost the same with anette's voice, but they can't carry tarja's voice without tarja. So, they have a new singer and new voice, they need new songs not tarja's songs.

  • This song is definitely not for her voice but she's good at other songs

  • I'm sorry, I LOL'd at 0:20. I honestly think that Anette would be a good singer for something slightly different, but not the best for Nightwish. Tarja gave them a very unique sound. I miss her dearly :(.

  • but i hav to say... its not reali fair for annette to be constantly compared wif tarja..... isnt this why she keep trying to sing the older songs? to prove she isnt jus a replacement for tarja?

  • she jus cant sing the older songs hahas

  • penoso... o.o povera..

  • i think that she sounds good tho she is sick and her voice IS a little different. you ppl need to get over the fact that shes the new singer. tarja was going solo after end of an era anyway. they both are great singers. so shut up

  • Thou shes the new singer, it doesn't make her good.

  • well, no. but i think that when she sings her songs that they wrote for her, shes good. and even if ppl dont like her, they dont need to insult her.

  • Annette is good, but I think that her voice is not good with this kind of music.

    The band has done a very big change with Annette, but they can't make her sing sings like Ever Dream.

    Tarja has a very awesome voice and she could reach notes like these in Ever Dream that Annette can't reach..

    Annette has a good voice, but it's terrible with Nightwish style.

  • Tuomas wrote many songs to fit Tarja's voice. Forcing Anette to sing it is stupid. Another mistake of Tuomas, other than have kick Tarja off the band. Too many mistakes for a band to survive.

  • i fucking hate Annette's voice. its so plain and bland. So many people can sing like her, he definitely can not reach the high notes. D: my friend sent me a link to this saying how much better Annette was to tarja. FUCK THAT totally not true! why is Annette trying to sing songs adapted for tarja's voice?!

  • classical versus anette-vid.

    worst sound quality, worst performance, worst pictures...

  • If you call this "worst sound quality", you obviously don't watch YouTube-Vids often. This is as good as it can get, it was recorded directly from the monitoring desk in Sydney. Pictures are chosen totally random, I didn't put in much effort.

    I would say this is a classical "Defend Anette" comment. Blame the sound quality, blame the chosen performance, blame the pictures.

  • quality record, directly from the monitoring ? so, sydney can't have a really good equipment.

    it's the same shit with guys like you since years...

    how long do you need to accept that Nightwish good a new singer? tarja wanted to leave the band after the next album, so tuomas kicked her out.. anette just joined and got critized from beginning. and she's much better right now.

  • You don't have the right to say she can't sing as someone who doesn't know much about music, and u don't, otherwise u wouldn't write on this low league.

    Just accept it's over with Tarja. And if u don't listen to her solo albums.

    Nightwish split from Tarja, and thats the reality.

  • Critizising Anette has nothing to do with Tarja. In fact, I accepted that Tarja will never again be the singer of Nightwish a long time ago.

    I critizise Anette because she is ruining my favourite band. I don't want Tarja back, I want them to get a new singer that is actually able to sing all their songs.

    And yes, this is directly from the monitoring. If you don't hear that, you are obviously tone deaf, but seeing that you are defending Anettes weak performences, you must be tone deaf.

  • totally wrong. critizising anette has sth to do with tarja. u actually say "ruining my favourite band".

    well, what changed since before? the singer changed & nothing else.

    that means, you liked tarjas opera style more than anette's alternative singing style. so, u see, it has sth to do with tarja.

    no1 who doesn't know tarja & old nightwish would criticise Anette. because you hate anette for replacing Tarja.

  • remember one thing: nightwish wont change singer again. if anette got dropped out ( won't happen, btw, because most of people still got taste enough to like Nightwish now, before, and may be in future.), nightwish would split, there wouldnt be any nightwish band again. there is no sense to critisice Anette & just turning vid quality down.

    anette won't leave. and if she does one day, it would sure be the last fact in Nightwish's history.

  • First, I don't hate Anette. Why should I ? I don't even know her. She might be a nice person, I have no problem with her.

    The only thing I don't like is her singing.

    Second, many bands have changed singers more than once. Why are you so sure that Nightwish couldn't do it a second time ? Its not like fans have become so attached to Anette that they would refuse to listen to NW if Anette left.

    Third, yes, I like classical trained singers like Tarja or Simone, but I also like alternatives.

  • Oh, and if you add &fmt=18 to the link of this video, the quality will improve drastically. Try it.

  • Seeing that you pick a number where Anette is singing while being ill as the evidence of her "singing", you are obviously very biased. And enjoying her moment of weaknes.

    She doesent sound like this in any other recording.

  • True, sometimes she is even worse. And I have seen her myself, I went to one of the concerts in 2008 because everyone on YouTube said she would sound much better, the records would not do her justice.

    I found they did her justice.

  • Lol. She is not. Anettes voice hasnt ever bothered me live. Just the opposite.

    But then again I dont know what would it take for me to stop enjoying Nightwish's music.

  • A matter of taste. I don't like Anettes voice, you do. I see no problem here.

  • Sounds quite as fucking crap as that Wacken live one.

  • 0:18

    EH-BER FELT AHEEEEAH WEI WITH ME!

    Lol.

  • this version is poor :S

  • soud of video is bad T_t

  • gruselig...sorry aber das ist echt gruselig...

  • hated it and thats it...

  • Love this version.

  • This version sounds cool !

  • Why did they pick Anette out of the THOUSANDS of people who auditioned?? Just curious.

  • they were 2000 from what i heard, but if i stay and think about it, it'n not a big number... because it's not like ALL those girls were talented ( the best 2000 singers in the world)... not to mention... that she was a friend of Hietala's...

  • Sounds like she's pretty well on key, especially for being sick.

    I don't know why everyone has to be so damn picky about everything.

  • TARJA COME BACK! CANT STAND THIS

  • the poor song

  • iak.......

  • I hate how she cuts off the ends of lines in the chorus. Sounds like's she's remaking the beautiful, flowing melody in some crazy wannabe-rock. "Ever felt away with ME!"

  • O.O nooo....what did she done to this song ???!?!?! this song was beautiful

  • Kill it with fire, please.

  • OMG after I watch it i decided to kill myself.

  • gag

  • tarja was amazing she was wowo this girl sucks she is a hord singer she can sing the songs like they were ment to be sung and she is ugle as hell...............she needs to go

  • ShE'S UGLY????? UGLY? YOU'RE GAY DUDE. GAY

  • I don't see what his sexual orientation has to do with it... although he could have stated his opinion a bit nicer, like: "I don't think Anette is that beautiful".

    No insults, please.

  • let me tell you, he's not that straight

  • oh and by the way i dont respect anette as a person she insulted my friend's country -.-' she said something like this : "why should anyone sing in Greece?"

  • lol! Somebody fire her! She's destroying every little bit of Tuomas' work!

  • The raspy kinda sound she makes cause that she is ill is kinda sexy :3

  • She's clearly sick, quit looking for things to rip on her about.

  • Plus, the cracking doesn't sound bad either.

  • shes really sweet if u ever get to meet her in person! and tarjas songs arnt good for her...the dark passion play is great for her thought!

  • yes, she cant sing like as high as tarja.. but the new songs from dark passion play, are made for her.. she has to sing this song different, like in concert that i saw.. its just..different.. she shouldn't try to song so high like tarja.. Anette is a good person, she sings not for money like tarja xD. yes Tarja ruled, but its over, so we have to accept that :p

  • You can clearly hear that she is sick. Her voice doesn't break like that when she's not.

  • poor girl ... I has to be realy painfull to sing in this condition!

  • she is everyday in this condition

  • LOL why does she keep squeaking?

    ohhhh because she cant hit a high note like Tarja!

    Duh :D

  • Anette screaming!! OMG!!!! -.-

  • Her performances are GREAT. You can tell she was sick here because of all the squeaks and crap.

  • she don't know singing this song

  • i think that they should leave the old songs in the past (i know that thats a lot of songs and its not my choice) but the old songs where made for Tarja (and her vocal range) and Annette doesnt sound well singing them, like it said in the video i dont like her voice but i do respect her

  • i agree. and they have plenty of new songs that she can actualy get to :)

  • annette is not a vocalist shit

  • Why the quotations around singing?

    Are you implying that she's doing bad? You clearly don't know ANYTHING about music to make such an assumption.

    1.) I'm certain she was sick.

    2.) She was STILL on key.

    Why are Nightwish fans so arrogant and foolish? Jesus.

  • 1) Yes, she was sick. But I was on another gig where she was not sick, and she sounded exactly the same.

    2) No, she wasn't.

    Wow, you don't know anything about me but you claim I don't know anything about music ? Isn't that a bit arrogant and foolish ?

  • "But I was on another gig where she was not sick, and she sounded exactly the same."

    Can you post a link please? This was definitely her worst gig.

    " No, she wasn't."

    She most definitely was on key. Theres just the rasps and squeaks from being ill.

    I find it funny that someone takes Anette's worst performance and posts it as if this is how she sounds.

  • I am so sorry that I do not record every single second of my life... wait, I am not.

    Seriously, just look for any other live-performance of her.

  • How about you look for other live performances considering you're the one who seems to be mistaken.

  • Blah blah... lets stop this. I am not in the mood for another pointless "You are wrong" "No you are wrong" type of discussion. Lets agree to disagree.

  • "I am not in the mood for another pointless "You are wrong" "No you are wrong" type of discussion."

    Well I'm not wrong so that discussion is impossible. But it's okay that you're wrong and I accept your apology. =]

  • ...

  • XD !

  • i love annete n all nd i lvoe traja to. but annet shoudltn try singign the old stuff. and thsi video is proof of that.

    she realy cant hit the notes...

    thats why the enw stuff is suited more for her vocal range :/

    x

  • Nightwish cannot play only Dark passion play's songs in lives!!!

  • well they could.

    but take the instrumentals from the past. and the ones only sung by the men.

    :)

  • Come on....Dark passion play's songs are not enough for a live...They need more songs...

  • dios que mal que canta, no se da cuenta, me cae bien pero no le van los agudos le van los grgaves, por lo tanto no puede cantar en nightwish y menos los viejos temas

  • lol!

  • OMG!!she cant sing:O,Tarja 4ever

  • She was sick during that show IDIOT! Don't make an entire assumption on a little clip like that.

    PS: Tarja sucks

  • "PS: Tarja sucks "

    PS: She does NOT suck, but YOU do.

  • Tarja rules

    Anette rules

    Nightwish rules

    Nobody sucks

  • YEAH!!!I totally agree with u!!!!!

  • annette sucks ... lol all sucks 

    XP

  • No, this song does not sound good with anette, but that is because this song wasnt meant for her dipshits!

  • lol dude sings better than here during the chorus xD

  • she IS at the same range with that woman calle d "TARJA" one-name pop-singer...

    nettie rockks  she brought LIFE into nw......