American Idol Top 24 - Andrew Garcia Sugar, We're Going Down

[alyzap22]

HOW DID HE NOT WIN

[laynie422]

0:18-0:21 OH MY GOD AMAZINGGGG(:

[Tetreault445]

Two different interpretations of the song, can't really compare them. I liked it though.

[mike34976]

This is better than the original. thumbs up if you like turtles.

[xJayem13x]

@mike34976 The original is way better :)

[naomi13jf]

@mike34976 i like turtles!! lol

[beckyozz79]

i love this song, from fall out boy thee orginal. but when i heard andrew play this song i was like DANG! Ive never really liked him before, till i heard him sing this song.... anyway i love andrew and fall out boy <3

[dekken231]

i dnt get the judges...? i like his version better than the original

[totalysweetandsexy]

never liked this song until this i heard his version

[azminivanracer]

yah. the guy is super talented, but he absolutely crashed and burned with this song. great talent, just not a good match with this particular song.

[CrazyKarlTheTruth]

he murdered this song. i love the original. this one, not so much.

[ninjakillspirate]

I think that he did it good for the song. I just don't think that song fists being played acousticly ;)

[bethandmegan]

wow o.o

that was awesome<3



[EppicPhail]

I think this guy's pretty good and I think fall out boy is awesome but they don't go good together, sorry, no offense.

[ThewordonRefuge]

Besides some of the lyrical mistakes, I really like this guys style. Great singer.

[TonyJabroni1zillion]

damn I miss hearing his sound.

This song just popped into my head when I read an article with "Number 1 with a bullet" in the headline...(Lol American Idol, you fools :)

[freakypanda8bacon]

I am IN LOVE with his voice

[MrToflan]

hes so.... epic, love you andrew garcia :D

[reyzzz100]

he has the best voice in this season of idol, but why he always pick strange song choice

[ninjasks89]

I think the judges are seriously on crack. It was because of this damn criticism that he changed up his game plan and did what was not usual of him.

[the24thuke]

CHORDS ?!?!?!

[izzy6197]

This is probably the best cover of sugar we're going down because the other one is faster in slower and acoutic like the nadrew version but AI is boring without him I hope lee and him makes an album together and makes a WORLD TOUR! AND breaks the billboards in half!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!

[Jestineez]

i totally like it

[AidanManuelArroyo]

i dont get why the judges didnt like this performance

it was good and cathcy :S

i think andrews vote off was the judges fault

they bashed him, and took his originality and uniqueness out of his song covers

and than he started singing songs that werent really him

if you get what i mean

[AidanManuelArroyo]

@AidanManuelArroyo *catchy

[saedaka88]

Its Funny How He Has Like The Most Views On Youtube [Go To His Other Vids] But He Has Less Votes In Idol .

[twilightaddict2498]

Sugar, U WENT DOWN!!!

[xilaver01]

andrew garcia has been eliminated...

AND IM NOT HAPPY ABOUT IT

[karmaXisXbeast]

I don't get why the judges didn't like this. I like the original version just fine, but somehow my family still pulls it out randomly and then we'll all just in. Even after he got kicked off. I wished they let him express himself more because he originallity got shoved away as the judges tried to mold him into a profile. It's sad really :/

[hulkxxx27]

Next to Straight Up, this is my favorite performance of his.

[hplove4life123]

I love him so much i can't belive he got offf!!! soooo sad!!! :(

[GabbieRawrGruesome]

@hplove4life123 Same ):

[caillo1]

sad that his gone, hopefully he keeps working hard and makes an album

[Whiterevelations]

I LOVE THIS VERSION, Andrew ftw!

[Warrior6795]

i liked it i dont get the judges problem with it i dont like fallout boy but this song has been stuck in my head since he did it

[lilshaq219]

where can i get a guitar tab on this?!!?!?!

[sillygirl2929]

I just LOVE andrew he is amazing I hope he can win it cuz im so voting for him! iloveuandrew! <3 ahah :P

[quilinderinoangeli]

awesome.....!!!

[vanebutterfly]

He turned it into a beautiful song! I loved Andrew's version ^_^

[finolawrence]

wow, he did sing this song?

oh i missed this episode

thank God its here ^^

[hipchiet]

Way better than the original version! rock on andrew!!

[pinkahyie]

iloveyou Andrew....soooo goooddd....

[A2AAfangirl]

I personally like FOB's version the best, but Andrew did an okay job with it.

[houstonrockets1992]

The problem that has come about with Andrew is that the style that was in the Paula song and this song was not liked from the judges and because of that he is singing songs that is way out of his style. Andrew needs to go back to this style because as you see in this song, he absolutely killed this song! The judges are the one that will run his opportunity to continue.

[stupivideoswithKnE]

While watching this, I was singing along and I was telling my mom "This is fucking amazing. He's got this and I bet the judges are gonna LOVE him." How wrong I was. I still LOVE Andrew. TEAM ANDREW GARCIA <3 (And Lee Dewyze, but that's another matter <3)

[Crusaderrak]

way better than the original in my opinion

[latestgal]

hmmm....when I saw him playing&singing I thought the judges would luv him, but it was the complete opposite....I liked the version heheh m=)

[zmvs1234]

it's because of the judges comments on this performance that Andrew lost his game... after this week..he started being just okay... gah! Andrew be yourself again! WE KNOE YOU CAN WIN THIS! <3333

[MingoCue]

The judges contradict themselves so much!

They're like "you need to make it your own." then when they do that, they bitch about how they "changed the original."

and they say to "take a chance" but when they do that, they say to "play it safe" or it "wasn't a good choice."

what the fuck do they expect?!

[mistyminxy15]

i cant beleive the judges didnt like this!

[davie416]

i'm so underwhelmed over there judgment. They told him to do it like "straight up" cause AI is an entrainment tv show, but yo isn't it hard to modify songs without changing the original sound of it? Judges want surprises from Andrew....hey Simon it won't be a surprise if you're expecting it. Just let him do his thing and give andrew some good critics.

[davie416]

Peter Wentz, a member of the fall out boy Band SAID on twitter that he Killed it , That he was amazing and he typed "Team Andrew Garcia" ...So dude who knows better than the guy who composed the song ? screw the Judges!! and if you dont trust me go check his twitter.

[davie416]

go andrew!!

[hYpErStRiPs]

Wow lads yeah he's version of straight up was breath takingly wow but...... seriously how many people out there can actually sing a fall out boy song like that?

come on patrick stump is hard to top but wow that wass poiifect

<3

[frecklemama8]

I absolutely LOVED this. I can't get it out of my mind. I downloaded it on iTunes and think it's fabulous.

[cheezymint]

I really love this version!

[imacrazy101]

RBJ*

[imacrazy101]

@RJB true dat

[imacrazy101]

@13thAngel and WestHitler, WTF is wrong with you guys?! So what if he's Hispanic he fucking beats you assholes at singing so I would shut up! And why do we need a White winner? You are seriously messed up.

[Guitardude8794]

I really liked this version of this song. Its alot smoother and jazzy then its Original version. Pete Wentz surely liked it :)

[clara9300]

i liked what he did with the song

[Dvirus666]

OMG ! Pork Buritto can Sing .

[WestHitler13]

last winner was white, two three four five years ago was also white. let s keep this year winner white again.

[13thAngelLucifer]

he has good voice to perform in the street or subway. but not good looking enough to be a Star he is Fat Four eyes Fuckin Hispanic. DO NOT VOTE HISPANIC! drag his fat ass to bottom 2 and..bye bye bye bye....

[theladiesman1987]

andrew kicks ass!! this was a great performance by him...you can really tell his style is unique

[mih102]

I absolutely loved his interpretation. Not really sure what the problem was for the judges, he totally drew you into his performance. Great job Andrew.

[WindyCityWoman1]

After listening to the original version of this, I really really like his interpretation of the song. I don't think the judges are listening to as much music as they lead us to believe. Andrew took risks, was creative, and did a great job.

[psychotsunade]

I disagree; we all have our opinions, but Pete loved it.

[DidThatJustHappenTV]

Andrew Garcia's has the best voice out of the guys. It was the wrong song for him, but guaranteed he's still gonna make it to the later rounds.

[RBJ92]

You say that, and you're a fan of Twilight? Nice one.