Nanking Massacre-Concrete Evidence Part 2 of 6

[1Dougy85]

Civilians die in war, it's a reality of war

[undertakerRach]

One of the pictures shows that Japanese soldiers gave gifts to Chinese citizens in Nanking. Photo from the British newspaper North China Daily News, published in China in English on December 24, 1937, eleven days after the Japanese occupation of Nanking.

[closertotruth]

@undertakerRach Dear queen (of the Nile) Rachel: You miss the point and this is NOT CSI TV fictions; wartime real-time pictures are ALWAYS hard to come by, thus in order to tell a story effectively with "thousand words-worthiness," using relevant available picture can be accepted. After all, we use more substantial evidences such as diaries to support it and this is not in the static realm of a litigation junkie wannabe. Get it? LOL

[undertakerRach]

@closertotruth One of the pictures shows that many Nanking citizens, who had abhorred bad deeds done with the Chinese military in the city, welcomed the Japanese military after the Nanking battle. Japanese soldiers and the Nanking citizens in the picture wearing armbands of the flag of Japan and giving cheers, on the day of the Japanese military’s ceremonial entry into Nanking ("Sino-Japanese War Photograph News #15," the Mainichi Shinbun newspaper, published on Jan. 11, 1938)

[SOVIETasTheINVADER]

"The Alleged Nanking Massacre : Japan's rebuttal to China's forged claims"on Amazon in USA

watch?v=qBWxti63Xcw

[thesky1208]

nobody ever wants to think that their nation would be capable of committing such acts. Esp not a proud nation like Japan. However, until the japanese govt issues a sincere apology to the other asian nations for their war crimes, relations will be strained and mistrust will be rampant.

Speaking for my family and other victims' families, all we want is an apology. We can forgive these terrible acts, but not until japan's govt takes responsibility. Hate is a poison that devours from within.

[thesky1208]

@undertakerach you are such a troll. U go around youtube and copy and paste the same lies.

it's funny how people whom have never been to Nanjing China feel that they have right to speak on whether or not this atrocity ever happened. My parents were born and raised in Nanjing China, as was I. As a child I played in the memorial gardens where my ppl were slaughtered mercilessly. My ancestors lived thru this horror. These and even more unspeakable acts really happened to the innocent civilians.

[undertakerRach]

Das Massaker von Nanking war eine falsche Geschichte. Warum chinesische Regierung hat mindestens 143 Bilder in der Massaker von Nanking Museum? Warum chinesische Regierung nicht beweisen konnte, die Ermordung von 340.000, wenn die IMTFE eröffnet wurde? Wo waren 300.000 von Leichen? Warum viele Chinesen kamen zurück nach Nanking nach Japanern besetzt die Stadt? Chinesisch governmnet kann nicht lügen.

[kwansao]

so horrible

[undertakerRach]

Chinese people are always barking lies like dogs. Tell the truth; what Chinese people said about the Nanking Massacre and the Senkaku problem does not have any conclusive evidence. In addtion, they believe that telling lies 100 times lead to becoming true story from the lies. The Chinese have appealed the Nanking Massacre was caused by Japanese even people don’t have any witnesses about that.

[undertakerRach]

Timperley was paid by the Ministry of Information in China for writing the book "What War Means". The book was written about the Japanese atrocity. Zeng Xubai, then chief of the international propaganda division, said in his autobiography (vol. I, p. 201) that the central propaganda bureau funded the publication of Timperly’s What War Means and Lewis S. C. Smythe’s War Damages in the Nanking Area. Both of these books must have Chinese propaganda books.

[MrNoSushi1]

@undertakerRach You fucking Japs need to be nuked off this planet!

[Truth5212]

A person dies , everyone grieves . A million dies , statistics . Up till now , people treat the "Rape of Nanking" as statistics . No action was taken against the japanese .

[psalm1604]

Everyone made mistake, the importance is to be able to admit it and not doing it again. The person who thought he did nothing wrong is bcos he perceive himself is "god".

[SOVIETasTheINVADER]

Falkenhausen and Chiang's strategy was to kill working Japanese people in Shanghai in 1937, and was to lure Japan's main army into Shanghai from Japan. Chiang was convinced that he could beat Japan's main army at the fortress in Shanghai . At last Chiang Kai-Shek carried out the invasion with　von Falkenhausen in Shanghai Aug. 13th 1937. That was beginning of Sino-Japanese War2.

[undertakerRach]

EX-CHINESE OFFICERS AMONG U.S. REFUGEES Colonel and His Aides Admit Blaming the Japanese for Crimes in Nanking　New York Times January 4, 1938

Wireless to the New York Times. SHANGHAI, Jan. 3. The officers, who had doffed their uniforms during the Chinese retreat from Nanking, were discovered living in one of the college buildings: They confessed looting in Nanking and also that one night they dragged girls into the darkness and the next day blamed Japanese soldiers for the attacks.

[MrSonofadaddy]

This is a propaganda

Check the truth on internet or library

[Jedbrien]

China isn't unforgiving but if people don't apologize then many will get angry.Killing innocent women and children is just downright cowardly.This wasn't honorable in any way.Frankly,i think the samurai would have been ashamed

[YONA746]

The slaughter was executed by a Chinese army.

[The208820]

pls dont buy japanese made goods,because the are made by monster, rapist and criminals.

[kaito8209]

@The208820

(Part1)no Japanese high officials had ever become aware of the 'Nanking Massacre'.In those days Japan had no motive for conducting the mass killing of the Chinese citizens. In Germany, the holocaust, which might be frequently compared with the so-called 'Nanking Massacre' recently, was driven from a 'dominant motive' under the 'policy for extermination of Jewish people'.

[kaito8209]

@(Part2)If the 'Nanking Massacre, had actually existed, there might have been some motivation. Indeed it was an argument of motivation that the Prosecution never tried to dispute so far. The Japanese had no 'policy to exterminate the Chinese'. The Prosecution explained that the motive was to threaten Chinese people. But no evidences were shown to prove it.

[kaito8209]

@The208820

(Part3)On the contrary, Japan had a motive to avoid illegal actions.　In those days Japan, running short in natural resources, entirely relied on the U.S. and Europe for the import of munitions and fuel, actually 65% of the import was from the U.S. and Europe. The embargo from the U.S. was barely avoided at the close of the Manchurian Incident, but at the start of the China Incident,

[kaito8209]

@The208820

(Part4)the U.S. government began to think of drastic economic sanctions against Japan. In this situation, if the Japanese Army had constituted an infringement of international humanitarian laws in the manner of repeatedly committing atrocities to citizens and POWs, westerners would have been critical and the U.S. and Europe would have started economic sanctions against Japan accordingly.

[kaito8209]

@The208820

(Part5)The fatal damage to Japan would have been inevitable. Having been well aware of these circumstances, the Japanese government had to absolutely avoid unnecessary and unlawful acts.

Please watch this.

↓　↓　↓　↓

yahoo![ The Alleged Nanking Massacre再審「南京大虐殺」 ]

The208820

[oddballrach]

(Part10) Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence. Chinese government said Japanese killed 300,000 people and raped 80,000 over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people and raped 2000 women each day. Have you seen descendants of Japanese-Chinese half-blood in Nanking?

[oddballrach]

(Part9) He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.

Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000.

[oddballrach]

(Part8) Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society. The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179.

[oddballrach]

(Part7)The very picture is captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." It is indeed a wicked act of secretly switching the picture. Factually, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks. The citys population was 200,000, according to TSZC (The Safety Zone Committee) documents. TSZC documents say the population was 250,000 in Jan 1938.

[oddballrach]

(Part6)One of the Photos displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. This picture has appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze."

[oddballrach]

(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.

[oddballrach]

(Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.

[oddballrach]

(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.

[oddballrach]

(Part2)Thats why Chinese people called CPC, Mao soldiers, 共匪 which means communists pirates because they raped many women, plunder many towns, and murdered. R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants "often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese." In fact, The 228 Incident, also known as the 228 Massacre, was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government.

[oddballrach]

(Part1)During the Shino-Japanese war, Chinese military killed Chinese people as if they were a worm. One of the Chinese men whose name was梁啓超 called Chinese people戮民, which means never mind people die for victory.The Chinese military characteristics were the same not only KMT (Kuomintang, Chiang Kai-shek) but also CPC (Mao Tse-tung ). CPC acted more brutally than KMT.

[Ramoa111]

omg. how do u gookers expect the west to learn anything if everything's in chinese!!

[SOVIETasTheINVADER]

Nanking Massacre is fake by Chinese Communists Party.

[changofsingapore]

The 2 atomic bomb on japan is well deserve.

[kaito8209]

【explanation of Photo in 8:46 】NO,2

for example, there was a case of gibbeted heads in the French Concession in Shanghai on February 12, 1938.

Denialists allege that these were the heads of bandits or political criminals killed in the Chinese civil war.

[kaito8209]

【explanation of Photo in 8:46 】NO,1

This photo is used as purported evidence of Nanking Massacre victims, but Higashinakano points out that there was no such custom of gibbeted heads among the Japanese after the 1870s. Among the Chinese this custom was still observed in the 1930s;

[lycfmtkl]

Why the Chinese hate Japanese???

1. The Japanese never admit there was "Nanjing Massacre".

2. The Japanese soldiers never raped any Chinese woman.

3. The Japanese only had "confrontation" with China that Japanese "enter" China to settle the "dispute" during WWII.

4 The Japanese lost the war against China ended 1945. But the Japanese never admit the truth of it.

WHAT A LOT OF BULLSIT TOLD BY THE JAPANESE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[98555501]

Got to run like rabbits. Run like dogs. They called us the "Sickman of Asia". What a castratrophy?! Try attacking China today. See what will happen. If time horizon can be adjusted, all these soldiers of the Imperial Japanese Army will be castrated as enunchs to be paraded naked in the Beijing Olympics Games.

[MrDreamDestroyer]

after all Japan have no army now, and yet they're still proud that they're the most superior race on earth. Just ignore them, they have no defense, they're US bitches, and several nuclear missiles are pointed at them and the moment they do ass-shit, they will be turned into a burning radioactive wasteland.

[98555501]

My heart grieves when I see so many innocent Chinese lives being lost and so many families being torn apart by these merciless invaders. In today's world order, these proliferators will not go unpunished. The emperor of Japan should be the first to be hanged. Then comes the generals and the rest of the Japanese Imperial Army.

[hkistink]

@98555501 is a chinese

I told you people, this guy is a chinese

[dennis11381138]

hope ccp won't do similar act to his own ppl and taiwan just to hold their power.. :)

[Rachel0041]

(Part7)China government is manipulating you behind the scenes. The government hasnt changed their strategies. Wake up and watch what cruel crimes have happened in Tibet and Uighur. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said in the Washington Post (June 6, 2009), she sees no progress in China on human rights.

Free Tibet!! Free Uighur!!

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

Do the vocal proponents of human rights truly believe in human rights?

If so, how do they account for their role in the conspiracy with Unit 731?

[Rachel0041]

(Part6) Exactly, the government use anti-Japanese education for blind the peoples eyes from such cruel incidents. In other words, they afraid the second Tiananmen Square protests happen. While Chinese are criticizing Japanese old acts in 75 years ago, the government is safe. This is one of the Chinese government strategies of diplomatic skill. In other words, the authorities didnt want the people claim to the government.

[Rachel0041]

(Part5)Do you know why Chinese government forced to teach anti-Japanese education to kids? The Chinese government wants to hide a lot of serious problems from Chinese people. 190,000 of Uyghur were killed by Chinese nuclear test, and government agents entered in many sacred temples in Tibet for investigation. Even now, the devil have committed a lot of crimes and controlled the mass media.

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

Does telling kids about Japan's war atrocities equate to anti-Japanese education? Should this unfortunate chapter in history be erased from history textbooks then?

[Rachel0041]

(Part4)Moreover, in China, the teaching guidance history book for teacher is written like this:

1: Instructors should teach to kids who will have hated Japanese using Nanking incidents.

2: Create a mood of classroom for anti-Japanese education class and the mood effectively help the kids will have bad image of Japanese.

3: Make kids hate Chiang Kai-sheks nonresistance and Japan using pictures and videos.

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

The "teaching guidance history book" does not exist.

[Rachel0041]

(Part3)According to the report from Safety Zone Committee, the total rape crimes happened 361 cases. And among them, there were only 61 cases, which definitely clarified who witnessed the cases, which heard and reported. Among these cases, only seven cases were clarified to be crimes committed by Japanese soldiers and notified the Japanese Army of the crime in order to disclose the fact and to capture the suspects.

[Rachel0041]

(Part2)The number of the 'cases of rape' Chinese claim is from 20,000 to 80,000 cases. Suppose Japanese took this number, there should have been from 500 to 2,000 cases of rapes occurred daily. This number is absolutely not trustworthy.

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

There were many Japanese soldiers. One woman can be raped 20 times or more a day by different men. The statistics are of course shocking, but very likely to be true. Scandals were never easy to believe.

[Rachel0041]

(part1)According to the testimonies in The International Military Tribunal for the Far East, Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000. Therefore, the KMT was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE. In other words, the KMT had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence. This is true story.

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

Please leet the source of this anecdote be known.

[Rachel0041]

These photos were taken by Chinese government agent during WW2.

Almost all of pictures were inspected by historians and photo specialists in both countries. All of pictures are fakes. Chinese government took a lot of fake pictures which Japanese committed cruel act deliberately. The Chinese government couldnt say any word when the investigation group showed the facts. They are still killing peaceful people in Tibet and Uighur, and they have controlled mass media. This case is happened now.

[twilightfantasy]

Have you been to Tibet? I am a forth Tibetan myself and visit there constantly. SHOW ME EVIDENCE OF KILLINGS!!! Most people in Tibet are proud of their Chinese government. Speak that to those in China who have lost their family. Tell people who have lost their spouses, brothers, and sisters, "These photographs were fake thus your grief is unnecessary and faked." Yes, because that will replace what can never be replaced. You disgust me.

[InTheNameOfJustice09]

Who were the historians & photo specialists from "both countries" who verified that the photos were fake?

Pleae provide proof on "Chinese govt took a lot of fake pictures which Japanese committed cruel act deliberately. The Chinese government couldnt say any word when the investigation group showed the facts. "

What has Tibet and mass media got to do with the fact that Japan invaded China and committed atrocities against humanity?

China media doesn' fabricate reports like BBC/CNN.

[marcelotowers]

Why Mao Tse Tung in "On Protracted War" don´t make even one reference of a massacre in Nanking?

Mao did address japanese strategic errors however, and in citing one of them (failing to take advantage of opportunities to annhilate more soldiers en Nanking).

Why Mao Tse Tung don´t mentioned the massacre???

[marcelotowers]

We can´t believe in that lies. It´s good only for USA, France, Great Britain and other imperialists, who made the hell in Asia before the I and II war.

[sakurasakura2424]

Nanjing has been proven to be propaganda.

It is being assumed by unfair Tokyo war crimes tribunal lack of evidence.

It tells a lie that 300,000 people were killed in the insistence of China.

At that time, the population of Nanjing is 200,000 people.

Is there a person who can explain these?

The civilian is not denied to have become involvement in Nanjing either.

However, there was no one like the slaughter.

[bobhope346]

Stop anti-Japan propaganda!

[Jrhni11]

truth2011

Thousands of nukes are waiting for you on top of your heads. look up.

[truth2011]

Be not deceived by Chinese fascists and communists.

Search "Every photo of NANKING MASSACRE seems to be fake" on YOU-TUBE .

sdh-fact(dot)com

[hopingpeace]

u r pathetic!!

The Japaness should should learn from the Germans, they recognize the war was a crime and willing to change! Thats why the president got Nobel peace award!!!!!!

And what do Japanese people do? Changing history book to braing wash next generation!

cruel and evil are in Japaness's nature!!!

get educated and learn the world history

sorry, i forgot, 1/2 of ur government are ganster anyway! what is the point??

[anarazel08]

@hopingpeace your right dude..... 2 thumbs for you... you understand the whole situation clearly... unlike other japanese dogs shit here who support them..... no wonder why the Chinese government strengthen their army in order not to happen this massacre to their country anymore...

[undertakerRach]

@hopingpeace (Part1)The 'Nanking Massacre' in which the Prosecution claims the 'massacre of 300,000', has never been so proved. However, any other unjustifiable killings by Japanese troops are regarded as punishable war crimes during the battles against the Chinese Army, and these should be processed under the international humanitarian law. On the other hand, in case of Germany, they were not fighting the war against the Jewish people.

[undertakerRach]

@hopingpeace (Part2) The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity', and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed.

[cutestfaction]

@undertakerRach - All Your Reasoning Saying Japan Entering China Illegally, Violate China Laws, Steal China from Chinese, Kill Chinese, China Winning Country Have no Right to Hold Imperial Japan Leaders, General & Soldiers Accountable, Victim Banded up with Other Thief to Punish Biggest Theft & Criminal Minded Imperial Japan

Imperial japan Leaders, General, Soldiers & People Crime to Many, Crime of Humanity include Murder, Enslavement, Imprisonment, Torture or Inhumane

[cutestfaction]

Part 2 - International Trial Court Sure to Make it More Easier to Charge Imperial Japan Many, Many Crimes Just Combine it into One Offense, for being Inhumane, crimes Against Humanity.

Crime was due to Japan morally bankrupt political and military strategy, military expediency and custom, and national culture.

The heart of Japanese always bounded with devil.

[undertakerRach]

@cutestfaction Why don't Chinese establish the Mao Massacre Museum?

Mao killed at least 300,000 Chinese.

In fact, 65,000,000 people had been victimized in China, still exists under the stupid political system. On the other hand, they criticized the so-called Nanking Massacre which happened in 1937, but not even clearly defined. They are still making much stupid evidence of that.

[cutestfaction]

@undertakerRach - Reply to Why don't Chinese establish the Mao Massacre Museum?

Part 1 - Who are No Moral Value Japanese Tell Chinese people to Built Say "Bad Things Mao Museum", Mao join in Fighting & Defeating "No Moral Value Japanese: who for Reason but "Greed" & just "Criminal-Minded" Invaded China, Kill Chinese People

[cutestfaction]

@undertakerRach - Reply to Why don't Chinese establish the Mao Massacre Museum?

Part 2 - about Moral Value & Ethics - "No Moral Value" & "Criminal Minded" Japan must last to ask Chinese to built Slander Mao Museum, Mao is the Man who Fight you, Abduction Chiang Kai Shek to Unite China to Fight "Mo-Moral Value" & Criminal-Minded" Imperial Japan.

He Make Contribution in Defeating"Criminal-Minded" Japan, Your country Last to ask or must not ask that is Japanese People

[JasonTsao1117]

@undertakerRach 65,000,000? wtf

[undertakerRach]

@JasonTsao1117 (Part1)In fact, it estimated that a far larger number of 65,000,000 people had been victimized in China, is still existing under the dictatorial political system, and still persecuting minorities and committing human right violations ceaselessly. Especially in Tibet, more than 1,200,000 people, corresponding to roughly 20% of the total population, were massacred since being unfairly annexed to Communist China in 1955.