@aesopr theres no need to compare... this is GEM's rendition of the song. She sang this song emotionally and beautifully. Feye is Feye, GEM is GEM, both were able to sing out their stories with this piece. I am usually not a fan of GEM, but this song she sang was beautiful, true, and touching. A great performance! Way to go GEM
天籁!
FSnack 2 days ago
原来还有广东话版本……好听!
FreddytheRay 3 days ago
我已經不想跟你痴纏
我有我的尊 不想再受損
bk520who 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
2個字 屈機
24331282 4 weeks ago 2
好清純
lovein2010andyou 1 month ago 3
我諗如果冇啲抖氣聲可能會更加好.
brucebruzboo 1 month ago 2
M...唱得太用力..咁GE話D淡淡的哀傷都變得好實呀..唉 SOR GEM呀... 我唔滿意
lamhinghing 1 month ago 4
@lamhinghing 迪克牛仔唱得更勁喇。
rokorobot 4 days ago
用哭腔唱很有趣另外一種味道、
mark01152001 1 month ago
唱到把聲咁尖都唔岩呢首歌,王菲句句都係好輕咁帶過
TheCharlielielie 2 months ago
唔係想拎你同王菲比, 但係你唱緊王菲首歌, 點樣唔比
只能夠講, 同王菲比真係差幾皮....
flyrodsfai 2 months ago 2
@flyrodsfai 唔覺得王菲有幾超班, 鄭秀文都好過佢
唔同唱法~
kittencat1983 1 month ago
@kittencat1983
王菲唔超班...鄭秀文先係歌后
Tranky001 3 weeks ago
@Tranky001 點可能呀 王菲論唱功 名氣 同 樂壇地位都高過鄭秀文囉-.-
Ricovbomb0229 2 weeks ago 3
@Ricovbomb0229 名氣 同 樂壇地位可能高少少, 不過唔覺得佢唱功好過鄭秀文羅~
kittencat1983 1 week ago
Comment removed
rokorobot 4 days ago
@Ricovbomb0229 我很喜歡王菲,雖然她常常走音,我仍然覺得她比鄭秀文好,因為我喜歡她嘛。
rokorobot 4 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Tranky001 我很喜歡王菲,雖然她常常走音,我仍然覺得她比鄭秀文好,因為我喜歡她嘛。
rokorobot 4 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kittencat1983 雖然王菲常常走音,我仍然覺得她比鄭秀文好,因為我喜歡她嘛。
rokorobot 4 days ago
Comment removed
aesopr 2 months ago
覺唔覺得有d harsh, 次次唱得好就搵人同佢比
你比得個時係咪即係覺得佢夠比先係到插呀gem?
如果佢冇料, 又做咩冇啦啦拎佢尼比??
又唔見你地拎william 同 呀gill同佢比??
stome123 2 months ago 5
the problem is she put too much emotion into the song.
concentrated on small details,but missed the big picture.
ahsougnas 2 months ago
王菲,唱了幾年才是天后。
鄧紫棋,才當了幾年歌手。
比較也無謂。聽歌,除了拍子音準的客觀因素外,就是聽者的感覺了。
以她的年齡唱成這樣,已經8,90分了。
jacky3800 2 months ago 11
哇塞兩種語言好厲害喔...
sunnygirl0724 2 months ago 3
首先要说唱得真好。这是一首女人的歌,唱这么man干嘛。。不过唱的真的不错,就是对歌曲的理解不太好。还是太年轻了,没什么经历。王菲在对歌曲的把握上要好很多
lkfczzw 3 months ago
@lkfczzw 不管人在任何方面都是要拿经验的,王菲的强项就是唱情歌而且已经唱了那么多年对GEM来说已经是前辈了,给新人多磨练的机会有一天也会有王菲的成绩....凡是往正面想吧,朋友~
hisahko 2 months ago
同王菲沒得比~SO SAD....
aesopr 3 months ago
@aesopr theres no need to compare... this is GEM's rendition of the song. She sang this song emotionally and beautifully. Feye is Feye, GEM is GEM, both were able to sing out their stories with this piece. I am usually not a fan of GEM, but this song she sang was beautiful, true, and touching. A great performance! Way to go GEM
alexchan338 3 months ago
Comment removed
aesopr 3 months ago
@aesopr on99 係要係度罵戰
聽歌係主觀角度 ok?
winghowwh 2 months ago
Comment removed
aesopr 2 months ago
最欣賞她的哭腔
foralfred 4 months ago 4
當批評一個人唱歌的時候看看自己是不是也能唱得比他好!
不要在那裡批評這個那個,
我相信音樂界的人會覺得他唱得好是他有實力!
唱歌是個人的,
不喜歡聽就走一邊!
無上你的耳朵!
nikitaling83 4 months ago 3
@nikitaling83
#當批評一個人唱歌的時候看看自己是不是也能唱得比他好!#
有幾位台下歌唱評審唱得比楊宗緯之類的好呢?︿︿
jacky3800 2 months ago
希望在ktv可以有這個版本
Yukc1670 8 months ago
看著她唱歌是一種頂級響受
gn01953588 8 months ago 7
gem 歌聲好特別!!!別有一番風味>///<
ManCar000 8 months ago
那些在靠杯難聽的人
有鄧紫棋歌唱實力的一半在來講話
沒有的話就好好聽歌
a860096 8 months ago
哭腔好難頂 !!!
聽佢唱歌, 總係造作。
honeytube888 8 months ago
@honeytube888 佢聲底本身比較美式feel, 唔系哭腔lor大鄉里-.-
系你聽外國歌聽得少姐-.-
0315Jan 4 months ago
@0315Jan 唔係哭腔, 美式feel 慳D la, 外國人聽到都想嘔,你聽鬼唱啦, 唔係哭腔囉, gem 人
honeytube888 4 months ago
当时才18岁,现在应该好多了。
lukeleeee 8 months ago in playlist 鄧紫棋
才18歲 你想怎樣....
cheung1z 8 months ago
真的哭腔太重了點,這樣唱法不夠自然。感情鋪陳也缺歷練。
ligiaung369 8 months ago 4
@ligiaung369 唱的比你好......
122788645 8 months ago
@ligiaung369 agree!! too fake!! she sing like someone die... wtf
MissMaggieLicious 8 months ago
Comment removed
MrTransmigratioN 8 months ago
下一個香港,亞洲天后,非GEM莫屬.....
只要再多兩年時間,等候GEM改善,絕對就係香港女歌手既霸主~
poui237580649 9 months ago 10
同代的歌手中,她的歌唱實力是不容質疑.
當然她在情感的演繹,呼氣/咪的控制還是有進步空間^^
加油~~~~~~~~
jacky3800 9 months ago 3
I love her singing ^___^ !!!
blueblue318 9 months ago
實在太有實力.
owodogkaki 9 months ago
不識聽歌的87
876543210324 9 months ago
有什麼好比呀 白木
876543210324 9 months ago 10
和王菲比,还是有差距吧!!
skyhawkmly 10 months ago
@skyhawkmly 有差距是很正常, 一個十多歲的小女孩, 跟當時三十多歲的成熟女人, 感情一定比不上;
再加上先天的上鄂萎縮症, 平時說話都會漏風, 如何比? 不要把她們作比較, 單純地評論GEM的表現..
mineko1819 9 months ago 6
棒....^^
gsgs9065 10 months ago
很少機會聽到她唱這種歌曲,真的很好聽!
尤其是我很喜歡她的假音。
kitsiufc3s 10 months ago 7
唱得王菲得利有d gem
居然唱到雯女d歌
愛死了
newtonyip 10 months ago 4
王菲D歌好難唱ga...
G.E.M.都可以唱得咁好聽
果然係巨肺G.E.M.
pungkywong 10 months ago 4
感情同技巧滿分呀! 系普通話到仲差小小姐><
MinKL0veJB 10 months ago 4
十卜gem
cherry219100 11 months ago
唱到好好听。。香港未来的希望!
wee5377 11 months ago 5
good~~
abgjlbann 11 months ago
LOVE GEM
tomchow121 11 months ago
She can sing!
xdivisionx 1 year ago
無就叫,返到佢身邊吟又點呀,一次比一次痛...
Wornout100 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
好x樣衰lo
yuriaseckiller 1 year ago
@yuriaseckiller 你試吓閉上雙眼.....音樂要用心去感受
IeongSC 1 year ago 14
Comment removed
leehh8888 1 year ago
声音與唱功.香港新人當中實屬頂级!!
leehh8888 1 year ago 21
@leehh8888 OMG! she is the BEST!
jimli2000 1 year ago 3
You're the best - I love you!
winfor168 1 year ago
juichic 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
juichic 1 year ago
Comment removed
juichic 1 year ago
Comment removed
juichic 1 year ago
嗯嗯
好聽耶
saayandclaire 1 year ago 6
she's crying~
so emotional!!
so touching!!
VinZNT 1 year ago 57
@VinZNT I posted this?
VinZNT 10 months ago
好正,gem正到冇得頂!!
tk061462 1 year ago 125
nice song
MrSeanchne1991 1 year ago 5