within temptation - enter ( live )

[Thrashzone005]

Oh I admire her beauty.

[heroesdrhouseaddict1]

I like all their albums, but honestly i cant listen to the new one. Rock bottom quality. But this here is magic

[noctemaeternus13]

i love this stuff myself but at least they're somewhat innovative. enter was gothic and somewhat doom, mother earth was pagan and folk, the silent force was kinda like evanescence, than the heart of everything and the unforgiving were both much heavier but still had their soft points if they had done the same thing as enter and the dance for the last 16 years theres the chance it would have got boring

[TheDeutschlandgirl]

i miss their old music ♥

this song is soo amazing *__*

[Atheistenpapst]

Mehh... What's your "Old WT" anyway? No WT album sounded like the previous one, ever. Enter-The Heart Of Everything was an evolution to the way they really wanted to sound like. And with THOE, in their eyes, they have perfected their sound and they didn't know how to make it any better. Sharon said this in various interviews. 2 choices:

"Stand still" and go on making albums which would most likely all sound alike just 4 the monehz

Or try out something new, because they love making music.

[MorganAQP]

i love  them!

[superalexanderimjihy]

when within temptation were decent

[Graafschap31]

This is the music from lowlands 2002 and the clip in from pukkelpop. You can see it when Sharon say: Ruud!! She doesn't hold her microphone to her mouth. Sorry for my bad english.

[Ocarina654]

Probably their best song. Enter and Mother Earth era are the greatest. After that it's all not so great. BUT MAN IS ENTER GOOD!

[sh4rk51]

WT 4EVER !!!

Always in my mind, always in my heart...

Sharon I love you.

[RockRiverAsh]

This is SO great! They still turned out good, I won't dispute that, and I like all their music, but I do wish they had remained closer to this path. The few vids on YT I can find of this concert (only 3 songs, I think)  are some of my favorites ever!

[Missjolinha]

IMG this is insane! I've just saw a WT concert 3 days ago in Lisbon-Portugal, and although i absolutely loved it, i must say (after saw this) that her voice changed, and not for better, it's not so crystalline (disadvantages of motherhood) and they're passion it's not the same, probably result of the change of thei're style, wich is less dark and magic than the albuns before to The Unforgiving. And they didn't play this song!! But i've really loved to see them alive. I wish I can see them again!

[ExaKeiroz]

@Missjolinha I've been at that concert too. It was an awesome gig, but this is another level. But they're amazing, no questions asked. I've almost cried with Our Solemn Hour.

[Missjolinha]

@ExaKeiroz i was a admirer, but now, after seeing them a live, i'm kind of developing an obcession! It ready was amazing. I'm speechless until now...

[beyondthelol]

1:20..incredible

[IceQueen625]

I'm one of those who loves all versions of WT. I love the new album, but would kill to hear this live. I'm glad they at least play Deceiver of Fools live still, and Sharon sounds great singing it. But I wish they'd throw in a little music from Enter or The Dance once in a while for us :).

[XtremeCTAWP]

The best song of Symphonic Metal!!!

[TheFilmkunst]

The best song of Gothic Metal!!!

[nunomfa]

Although they have changed over the albums, they never lost the magic! WT Love the past and the present! otherwise, they play Rock Gotic and not metal! any band gets when they have commercial success. that means they are good musicians! We can only love them!

[nLiOkWoEs]

when W.T. were metal band

[MultiTimification]

where's the three people that need shooting for disliking this?

[MarFish101]

They all stop head banging and shit once she starts singing , lol

[foamulator]

Sharon: Bring back the wonderful songs like this one! We miss the enchantment and dark majesty of your old songs. LOVE TO WT

[sasukenayrb907]

HOw i miss Enter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Dont bad understand me, i love the Unforgiving, but this new album is nothing compared to Enter ;(

still, WT RULEZZ!!!

[ivandbt]

Stupid crowd... it's nobody headbanging... ohhh c'mon ¬¬

[Alienne14]

i wish i had been there... i'll never hear this song live anymore TT

[nearnextdoor193]

COMPARE IT TO SINEAD OR FASTER

JUST SAID !

[2009orfeus]

AVE REGE!!!!

[Molaa96]

Sometimes I think they were better before.

[hyerkill]

I've still got chills listening to this song!

[Flyingnugget346]

I am an audioholic, I listen to vast amounts of music from all genres and Sharons voice is the most beautiful thing I have ever heard, no contest.

[Kanydja]

Love this song so much... fucking epic! what happened to WT?

[fatimazuz]

I love this old times when Sharon was so amazing (she still is but not like this way)....

I love all their albums until this new album... I really don't like that, just my opinion but I think that it is a radical change.. I just like one song "The last dance", that song I think is amazing but the other don't

[chloboshoka]

I love the passion between Robert and Sharon.

[emil9412]

i gotta say i prefer their older sound over their new but... seriuosly people stop whining, just litsen to "the last dance", it gotta be 1 of their most beautiful songs ever. Also "in the middle of the night" is really awesome... a little diffrent but still awesome :)

[fuckcommercialmusic1]

The beginning till 1:20 is fucking epic.

And the rest is like usual good.

[filth69ify1]

i wish they went back to the gothic style like this. They sound much better.

[13MrG13]

Best song they ever made :)

[mattyb97]

Do you know what i find quite disgraceful, Is that fans of Old Within Temptation songs have decided to crowd round this video and say Within Temptation are no longer making good music, Peoples styles change, and some people dont like all music, but atleast appreciate what they are making, because its still brilliant, infact am i the only person who likes every piece of WT music? From Enter to their now new album The Unforgiving? Listen to the song, not critique the bands new styles....

[grodeligrodeli]

@mattyb97 Totally agree with you. Sure I miss their old style a little bit but the new stuff is also really awesome! People should open up their eyes and realise that

[subwaytosally18642]

@mattyb97 You're not alone! I listen to everything WT has done, from Enter to The Unforgiving and I love everything they have released. But everyone is entitled to have different opinions and if he wants to say it, he should feel free to say his opinion. Maybe not under every second video but maybe once or twice would be enough.

[xELLISxP]

He sound so creepy :))

[WeinenderGrabstein1]

xRatedL its a Festival in the Netherlands, i think!^^ Sorry for my bad bad English! ;)

[xRatedL]

ehm can any1 tell me what ''Pukkelpop'' is?? never heard of it

[DarkSlasherZ666]

@xRatedL Its a Belgium Festival where alternative music is being played, like this.

[edgarinn13]

i miss sharon :/

[missrosepetals]

I'm not majorly into metal, but this song just blows your mind and touches the core of you. Same with The Dance. Love this band.

[088Fallen]

unfortunately they changed, and for her it's not really good, she wasting so unique voice, and such a potential..

[finl4nd4ev4]

Oh god I love the ending when it picks up the pace.

[618jose206573]

then they did faster..... i mean why not create a new symphonic metal song like older times. enter was real good.

[Alienne14]

i'd die to hear this song live.

[misscassie20]

man, this is so cool think about it he sings with this devil voice and she with an angels voice and they both together in real life! AND THEY sing so good together, the chemistry you see between these 2 is always so fun, i love it, i love within temptation from the beggining to the forever! but yes, i will like to see this song being played in a concert now, will be awesome

[foamulator]

The Black symphony marked the the beginning of the decline of this Band, IMHO

[theGazettERequiem]

@foamulator YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[GOTHICDIETY]

THE BLACK SYMPHONY IS THE BEST

[GOTHICDIETY]

THE BEST SYMPHONIC BAND,SHARON IS THE BEST,WISH YOU CAME IN PHILIPPINES,GOD BLESS

[evansmcr]

AWESOME!!

[LovelyEmoBoy89]

i neeed old WT !!!!!!!!!!  : //// : C echhh.....

[Molaa96]

Very very amazing!

[vailismyname]

Ya one thing's for sure, that little something they had back in the day, they sure don't have it anymore. Their music use to be so heavy, not in the heavy metal sense, but in a heavy thick deep rick dark chocolate cheese cake of forbidden desire and mystery sort of way. Difficult to explain.

[chicavampiro]

The dont play this song live anymore :(

[gidrotlejdbsis]

@chicavampiro yeah the man can't "sing" like that now... In fact, sharons voice change too. WT is over for me

[chicavampiro]

@gidrotlejdbsis well I think this is a great song, but they're still a good band. I mean, have you hear Jillian, or The promise? they're great songs. I think that just because they changed a bit their stile, it doesn't make them a bad band.

[gidrotlejdbsis]

@chicavampiro Jilian or the promise are old song now. I love enter ( the album ) and mother earth. I like silent force, but after that... Before, they have this little something, you know, just amazing !

[PinkyNiniGirl]

@gidrotlejdbsis No you cannot say that ! Indeed Robert can't sing like that anymore and Sharon's voice changed . But every band evolved with time. I mean they've been around for years, they changed and that makes sense. But even now, in songs like Jane Doe, or even The Heart of Everything or Our Solemn hour, she goes pretty high. They aged and matured, and you can see it in their songs. They're still a very good band, and they still make really good music.

[sasukenayrb907]

@PinkyNiniGirl actually robert still doing some of growls like in Jane Doe (amazing song) in the bonus track of black symphony

and, yeah, they are not what they were in enter or mother earth but the heart of everything still having really good songs like the heart of everything, our solemn hour, and in "the cross" she actually get one of her highest notes its really amazing

and yeah, they are older but they still great and they are a big influence to new bands

and just left hear the new album

[PinkyNiniGirl]

@gidrotlejdbsis Lol je viens juste de voir que tes Français ^^ Mais bon, tas compri mon dernier message ? Si non je te la refais en Français :D

[gidrotlejdbsis]

@PinkyNiniGirl en effet je suis français ^^ Ils sont toujours bons, ça ne fait aucun doute, mais je regrette forcément l'époque où ils avaient ce truc en plus. Question de gout aussi, ce live est génial du début à la fin, j'ai pas accroché autant sur black symphony ( c'est ça le dernier ? )

[PinkyNiniGirl]

@gidrotlejdbsis Oh c'est dommage, le live du Black Symphony est super ! Mais je comprend ce que tu veux dire, c'était une époque différente.

Le live du Black Symphony date de 2008 et oui c'est leur dernier DVD mais en début 2011N(surment fin janvier) leur nouvel album sort et il font une tournée (d'ailleur je vais les voir le 27 mars) donc je pense qu'il va y avoir un autre DVD Live. Voilà :)

[EvDestroyer]

@gidrotlejdbsis I think, now Sharon's voice is better. She sounds cool, more adult, not like a child:)

[Alienne14]

@gidrotlejdbsis i totally agree :(

[vaya88]

Within Temptation at their best!!

This was the first band I´ve ever seen live(In Munich a couple of years ago).

I also get this dvd and I love it! But after this one, with silent force for example, they totaly changed their style. In my opinion they could be one of the best Rock bands ever... Maybe not rich as they´re now, but absolutely unique!

[DemonRuby]

@gidrotlejdbsis I agree with you, I only listen to old WT.. Most of bands have gone mainstream, they sound and look like pop singers now, WTF? don't they understand that they're loosing fans??

[grodeligrodeli]

@DemonRuby WT has not gone mainstream they change their style with every album, and in fact they are getting bigger and bigger so they are not loosing their fans, they are getting new ones all the time.

[DemonRuby]

@grodeligrodeli actually Faster and other songs off a new album sound pretty radio friendly, it can't even be compared to their usual masterpieces. Old fans of WT are upset with this "lighter" and more "primitive" sound, trust me I know what I'm saying. Yes, they're gaining new fans, but loosing old ones, like 95% of metal bans nowadays.

[grodeligrodeli]

@DemonRuby I'm and old WT fan and I love both the new style and the old style. Sure maybe faster and maybe sinead isn't their best songs but songs like Iron, In the middle of the night and a demons fate are still really heavy and symphonic to. And since it's my favourite band I will support them whatever they do :)

[DemonRuby]

@grodeligrodeli I like your attitude, I also supported my favorite band (Lacuna Coil) when they got bashed due to change. Anyway, I hope WT won't go any softer :)

[grodeligrodeli]

@DemonRuby I'm pretty sure they wont :) Who knows maybe they will surprise us with a really dark,heavy and symphonic sound. Would be pretty awesome

[freemandango]

@DemonRuby bands have to evolve, true, but I think there are ways to do it. You mention LC and don't tell me that from Comalies to Karmacode there is no change. I respect your opinion but Karmacode sucks really bad. Same thing to theatre of tragedy, they went from gothic to techno-goth to goth pop and it's ok, some people will like it, others won't. Like I say, it's ok to evolve, but do it one step at a time :)

[DemonRuby]

@freemandango they have to evolve but not in the wrong direction. Actually I love both Comalies and karmacode, however, Shallow life was a disaster! but I'm their fan and nothing on earth will change that. I agree about theatre of tragedy. But maybe fans should be more indulgent to bands' musical experiments.. No one's perfect:)

[freemandango]

@DemonRuby true and here is where we have different opinions, karmacode for me is bad and shallow life have some good songs, not the whole record but a few songs are ok. Same thing I can say about Nightwish (and yes it will start a war with the fanboys and haters :P) when Tarja was in the band and now with Annette...it's bad! But like I told you before, I do respect everyones opinion, just respect mine...

[DemonRuby]

@freemandango I hope I haven't said anything that shows that I don't respect your opinion because I hate so called "trolls" who crave for fight here. I'm for peaceful discussions :) I personally like Survive, Not enough, Wide awake and the title track from "Shallow life", but songs from "Karmacode", "Comalies" and their older work are my favourite ones :) To me, Nightwish died when Tarja left, but I have nothing against Annette :)

[freemandango]

@DemonRuby Can't argue with someone that has such a fine taste in music :)

[linkinn18]

The times when within temptation was awesome!!

[LittleMelianna]

Вот бы в живую услышать, жаль сейчас не поют

Great SONG!!!!

[missrosepetals]

Love this song!! Love this performance!!

[evansramms]

she's an angel

[Jugolbrazowy]

"Enter" - the best album of WT. Nothing else to say.

[kojinmalia]

@Jugolbrazowy Enter & Mother Earth... They're very different and both amazing... "The Dance" EP is too..!

[YougMissRothschild]

What control over the crowd... This is an incredible performance.

(Though I don't go to too many myself. It's not really my 'scene'. I just really like this.)

[EmbraceWithin]

@YougMissRothschild They really know how to control the crowd, like sharon waves they wave, sharon headbangs they do, she tells them to sing they do.. It's just amazing!! She rules

[Symphonicify]

Head Banger

[amosthree]

I like the newer within temptation stuff, but their enter era was the best!

I didn't like mother earth that much though.

[esteban957]

I fucking love this song! it rocks!

[Agony1009]

OMG when i first meet WT they dont realy like it even i compare them with Evanescence (sorry , i dont like that band), but then i realized that they are an amazing band realy love it

[TheAtlanteanEmpress]

I do kinda wish Robert growled. And I wish they play this song more! Why couldn't they just play Roberts growling while sharon sings? =D

This song is EPIC. First listened to this band in 2005- Became an instant fan. Never went back =D

[PinkyNiniGirl]

WT is the best band ever ! I love'em and Sharon's voice is wonderful :)

[ciprianism]

this is fuck'in great ! love it !

[blackirises]

I've seen some videos where Robert's grunting wasn't very good, but it sounds awesome here!

[agominator]

why at the begining it says " the promise". there´s a little diference between a so symphonic song as the promise and a heavy song like this one, but i like this song as much as the promise

[gidrotlejdbsis]

Because the name of a the song hasn't been written by a fan, explain little mistake. Not the only during this concert I remember.

[kleinesther]

They have got to be the greatest live band EVER! Love their music!!! And I love the growling :D

[Darkshadewisper]

he doesnt want to do vocals anymore he said once that he had sometimes problems with it

[portishphonic]

lovely,the good old WT...

[marlou2447]

le top comme dab

[sabaoonpamir]

Too bad they became sell-outs and stopped the gutteral vocals

[CelticJew]

oh no you didnt. within temptation is just as awesome now as they were back then, if not more.

[ashestoyoursoul]

they didn't sell out, they just felt like the growls were unnecessary, and robert wasn't that good at them anyway

[agominator]

on the Black Symphony documentary Robert said he damaged his throat, i think it was when singing jane doe on the java island DVD

[ashestoyoursoul]

okay, thanks!

[FearOfTheChosen]

@sabaoonpamir They dropped the growls because everyone was doing it, and they didn't want to be part of a gimmick.

Saying that, listen to Our Solemn Hour and The Heart Of Everything from their latest album and tell me what you hear. ;)

[6Epixa]

They should make more songs like 'enter' !

[gidrotlejdbsis]

yeah but it's an old song... Now, their music doesn't sound like that...

[6Epixa]

I know, and it's sad :(

[EvDestroyer]

@gidrotlejdbsis yea, but their new songs are so different. On the one hand we have excellent songs like The Heart of Everything, The Truth Beneath the Rose, Final Destination. On the other hand we have songs which are made for people who like pop music( What Have You Done, Frozen...). I want more excellent songs in new album. Their very old music has a lot of features of power metal which i don't like too much. Their last album was the best in my opinion. Enter is very simple song but very good.

[ashestoyoursoul]

that's only your opinion, it's no the absolute truth

[mamasboy1231]

robert sounds like the freeking cookie monster

[jackjoker7]

robert is de bom. ik heb zijn hele wikipedia pagina opgekalevaterd (samen met de rest van de wt wiki en die van de andere bandleden)

[themarcosbg]

el mejor tema de este recital,la amo a esta mujer

[mamasboy1231]

poor robert sounds like the cookie monster and how did u get that close to the singers and the band just curious

[keezzzzzz]

Ge-wel-dig dit, WT maakt me toch geniaal mooie muziek, en Sharon zingt als een engel. Performance is ook helemaal OK.

[silentspring2]

Everytime I listen this song, I feel in a big forest, it's so inspirer for me, WT can pass what they want to pass! They are great!!

Sharon den Adel rules!! \o/

[linkinn18]

@silentspring2

I feel the same when i head Pears of Light...

Enter is an awesome record!

[silentspring2]

The intro is made by keyboard? I want know :D

[keezzzzzz]

Fantastische song, en mooie solo vanaf 5.24. Magic!

[chelley9905]

i really love her dress in this video...i think it's one of my favorites of hers but then again all her dress are really pretty

[101BurtonFan101]

I love the bit that sharon does in the beginning! =D

[LittleBitTragedy]

I don't really like WT but the album Enter is great!!

[sweet69nightmare]

Enter and Mother Earth are the best Within Temptation's Albums Ever!

[Prisciladollgothic]

this music is perfect . I love Sharon ♥

[aloneriz]

sharon te amo

[EmmenceSwan]

I love when Sharon Den Adel starts just amazing.

[dembinho75]

c'est tout simplement magnifique!!

[Szovk]

\m/ \m/

[gelamakaa]

amazing again and again and again!!!

cheers and namaste!!

[Aurone]

I understand why WT hasn't done Robert doing Gutteral vocals, since at the time everyone esle was, but since it's been a while, I think they should have him do some new songs with his gutterals.

[alextre77]

Its because you wont get high into the charts, and sell many records with Roberts growls in it. They turned to more mainstream and this means only Sharon is singing, its simple as that

[ashestoyoursoul]

that's not what sharon said in an interview

[coheed987]

alextre77 - hey bud, you can sell albums with growls and screams on them!

i think they stopped it because their music in Mother Earth was much faster and less doomy than the stuff on Enter.

besides...robert isnt exactly the best growler ever... :-/

[Supernature06]

if you don't like them why are you watching this vid then!

[mendelok]

супер,слів нема

[bihwt]

I love this song. Sharon's voice is perfect :DD

[Hippydude777]

o come on, whadyou mean wt's not like this anymore, vivid and creative like this? They've always been that way just look at blue eyes? the truth beneath the rose? the howling?

but I wounder why he stopped growling

[kiotocitystories]

He had some vocal problems

but it was great :)

[Bloodtanker]

Go Robert! :D Sharon = best.

[HartiaKozu]

Robert's vocals were lamentable xD Anyway, I liked the ancient Within Temptation much more than the actual one.

[kiotocitystories]

He did the vocals for "Jane Doe" in Eindhoven

[petervoodoochild]

I definitely would =_=

[Enangar]

This is from Mother Earth Tour in Pukkelpop I love WT!!!!!!

[6Epixa]

Great! =)

Can anybody tell me in which year this performance was?

[THMSHRTHLT]

1:56

A beautifull shot :)

[venenodark666]

wow

its bigest

[leadu13004]

Robert has improved ^^

[lalruang]

fuking great, I mean it really is

[Szovk]

Круто