Eso es el alma judía, no sólo poseemos un alma para vehicularnos con el mundo, sino tambiéen poseemos un alma divina, que es parte de D-os y que hagamos lo que hagamos permanece intacta. Si sos judío investigá más en la página de Jabad.
Agaga je m'apelle Jean-Sol Parte et j'habite au pays des aigris où l'enfer c'est les autres. Je n'ai pas envie d'argumenter face à ce déchet; Freud voulait expliquer l'âme humaine (encore faut-il y croire) donc il a inventé plein de conneries et s'est fait du fric au passage le bougre. Tous ces psychanalystes, philosophes m'ennuient terriblement. Si les vieux schnok se complaisent dans l'ennui c'est pas encore mon cas.
At least Freud had the candor and honesty to attribute accountability to man for the bestialities going on down below, while most have built a fortress to so defend their ego that they can't even admit its existence upon waking.
It's not ego it's reason and critical point of view. If people are so suggestible to believe all the shit they read it's not my problem. Freud is a kind of religion like the others for people who can't think themselves.
At least Freud had the candor and honesty to attribute accountability to man for the bestialities going on down below, while most have built a fortress to so defend their ego that they can't even admit its existence upon waking.
Il aurait du en rester au complexe d'infériorité/supériorité le pauvre narcissique, ça lui aurait éviter de vouloir faire évoluer n'importe comment un domaine totalement vide d'utilité. J'aurais bien voulu qu'il soit vivant que quelques personnes intelligentes le renvoient à sa réelle nature 5 minutes.
Le pauvre mec était tellement défoncé qu'il adaptait sa pensée à ce qu'il écrivait, au lieu d'écrire ce qu''il pensait. Il était pas mythomane ? La psychanalise est vraiment le domaine des débils.
Propageons la mort de l'âme, de la vie. Lisons Freud ! Bande d'idiots aigris qui ne savent pas s'arrêter de lire de la merde pour occuper leurs journées. Le précurseur des No-Life c'est lui ! Il explique les choses au lieu de les vivre, ce mec est un con.
I tkink he's the most hateful guy that the earth has ever known (after Hitler and his "friends"). This Jew is just a boring intelectual lifeless guy, he should have played TAM TAM with the doors he would have been great. Don't read his books or just enough to realise that he was stupid and had no friends.
@raeven1988 when you will discover the same amount of thing as he did and when you'll bring an important contribute to the science as he did you will be allowed to talk.
I never mentioned religions...I know your reasoning abilities are sloppy; but are you capable of reading? Science is inconclusive because there is no theory for everything, and the way the human consciousness works remains a mystery in many respects. I know your mediocre professor told you that psychoanalysis is a scam but your rigid, hackneyed mind needs to read more and grow up. Lol, Ernest Becker report for school...I know you've never read the man because you haven't a clue. Just trite words
Unfortunately for you, insults don't prove anything. Once again you demonstrate that psychoanalysis relies on faith and not evidence (like for scams or cults like scientology).
I'm sure you're not even aware that thousands of Freud's papers are locked up in the Library of Congress until the year 2113! (sociology, anthropology, medical sciences don't hide datas for so long... only religions do that).
Once again you prove that you don't know what your talking about. Faith? Everything we do requires an amount of faith, from the believe in causality to the believe in the atoms I can't see...read some Hume moron. And Freud was wrong, but your idiotic attack was on psychoanalysis in general...the point is that we have constructive criticism beyond the premise that sparked the criticism, you fail to see this because your rigid & linear, is it a scam? No. It sparked new theories and premises. Duh.
This was never about Freud being wrong, it was about you saying that psychoanalysis is a scam...Freud was wrong in his rigid, sexual-based theories for the unconscious but he was right in that there is more at play in the unconscious and how we as humans repress certain truths. So yeah, rigid Freud is wrong. Open-minded psychoanalysis divorced of rigid Freudianism may not always be right but it is a foundation in which constructive criticism may build more correct theories about the mind. There.
That's not the definition of a scam it's one man's subjective impression and your subjective impression...there is no objective clear-cut theory for how the mind works, and psychoanalysis has merely posed theories as others have posed theories. Repression is real...psychoanalysis at least got this right, along with how certain rigid people act neurotic. It's not a scam as far as that is true. You have the same fear of life and death just as much or more as any other person...that's human nature.
Freud was a pathological liar. Let's begin by the first analyzed patient, Anna O., who was analyzed between 1880-1882. In his book (Study on hysteria, 1895) Freud wrote that she was fully cured at the end of her analysis in 1882. He NEVER mentionned that she was hospitalised 3 times between 1883-1888 (though he was fully aware of that). That was the beginning of psychoanalysis...
A scam is when someone lies to promote a treatment.
Okay, I thought we already moved beyond Freud...let's call it 'psychotherapy' if Freud and pyschoanalysis are both the same things to you. Repression and neurosis are real things...and by the way, this is just a question, are you an atheist or a theist?
I suggest the reading of Ellenberger's book "The Discovery of the Unconscious" that is an internationaly recognized historical reference on psychotherapy (and Freud's lies).
If you can read french I suggest "Le livre noir de la psychanalyse" written in 2005 after the publication in 2004 of the INSERM report on psychotherapies that concluded on the inefficacity of psychoanalysis.
The french article in Wikipedia "Critique de la psychanalyse" has a nice bibliography.
See, but at least you must agree with Freud in that God is a delusion?...To me atheism is just as illogical as theism is, in that they both fall victim by using argumentum ad ignorantiam...so they are both scams in that respect. In order to prove that god does or doesn't exist you must know all of existence, and that is impossible. And I nver agreed with psychoanalysis in practice, I merely agreed with it in that there are such things as neurosis and repression.
I agree with you that one cannot prove or disprove the validity of religion or psychoanalysis (argumentum ad ignorantiam and unfalsifiable theory as explained by Karl Popper). No systematic study has demonstrated any efficacity of psychoanalysis. That's why proposing it as a therapy without mentioning that to the patient is a scam.
severe neurosis or psychosis or repression....I merely said that it was valid
and un-scam-like in bringing these certain symptoms to light, or too more examination. For the most part they can't really be totally treated because humans are naturally neurotic and repressed, is there an aspect of psychoanalysis which (is) scam-like, yes, but what can't be seen as scam-like these days...look at our government.
Psychoanalysis is unfalsifiable (the theory can never be demolished because of this). Of course, severe mental disorders cannot be traeted by psychoanalysis. The more benign disorders can be helped by psychoanalysis (but also by anything else...).
Freud didn't invent the unconscious or repression. He didn't impress the medical community at his time. The only honour he got was the "Goethe prize" for literature...
p.s. 1)How many patients do you see per week? 2)What are your diplomas?
Well yeah, I strongly disagree with Freud and the methods he employed, and they have been shown to be false...but I do believe in a Hegelian-like evolution of learning, in that if Freud at least brought some thesis, and science brought an objective antithesis against this, then the synthesis is a combination of what is valid from what is invalid.
I am just an inquisitive writer, I've never sought to practice psychology professionally, only in the observation of everyday life and people...
gracias al cielo por este hombre irrepetible que dió todo de sí para sus postulados, formación y establecimiento de su teoría aún en contra de sus opositores, la época en la que vivió e inclusive el cáncer del cual padeció durante sus últimos años.
Freud marcó pautas, hizo la diferencia...dejó huellas, todo un legado!! la psicología, la psiquiatría, las ciencias de la salud, de la conducta y los que formamos parte de algunas de estas ramas estamos agradecidos!!
One thing I can not understand, why do not you left for England after the exodus of Einstein in USA; Doesn 't be enough this move or believed that the NAZI going to let live and work because they were the Freud; The result? many people to die in concentration camps.
I love how people tout their little PhD's on YouTube...wow, ya want a cookie!...And that really does show how much you know if you think Freud is the be-all-end-all of psychoanalysis, when anyone with a half a brain on the subject knows that Otto Rank made tremendous gains in the field, as well as many others. Success story? wtf do you mean? He helped some patients, but that is beside the point; he laid down the groundwork for others leading all the way up to Ernest Becker. You don't know squat.
You are very good at insulting people on the net... but unfortunately for you that doesn't prove anything.
I'm still waiting for a "success story" from Freud. Can you tell a single name ??
Concerning Otto Rank, he was part of the "secret comity" of Freud for many years and Freud approved his concept of the birth trauma. That was until Freud dismiss him because he accused him of anti-Oedipal heresy.
Secret comity, heresy, excommunication... all the signs of a cult.
First off, this was NEVER about Freud or me proving that he was 'successful'...it was about you saying psychoanalysis is a scam, which is a very hackneyed thing to say...because it isn't, as it has paved the way for many new insights in sociology and anthropology. It's like me saying psychology PhD's are scams....are they...well I guess in someways.
Now you are talking about sociology and anthropology !
No study shows any efficacy of psychoanalysis. On the contrary it doesn't demonstrate any effect on a wide variety on mental diseases (you probably don't know the INSERM study of 2004 that systematically reviewed all the studies on psychotherapies and concluded on the inefficacy of psychoanalysis).
Promoting a therapy without any scientific back up is a scam (with or without your insults).
It shows in that human consciousness is more complex than science can fully know...the id, the ego, and the superego (even if they are hypothetical abstractions) are apart of a working frame to build more theories. Geez I wonder why Freud is regarded highly even if his theories have been disproven...I wonder why Ernest Becker, a revolutionary anthropologist isn't so quick to give Freud petty labels...I guess you must know more than Becker, huh? Give me a break, science itself is inconclusive.
What you just said apply to religions (hinduism, scientology, christianity...) because as you said "science itself is inconclusive" to disprove their validity. And like you said religions claim that their beliefs are "more complex than science can fully know". That's why psychoanalysis is a scam (or a cult).
p.s. Are you doing a high school homework on Ernest Becker ? Don't forget to tell me my freudian's success story !
La que de lastima sos vos. Analfabeta poco informada, morite en la ignorancia de vivir una vida opacada por tu estrechez cerebral. Suerte con tu fantastica visión del mundo y el psicoanlisis, allá, en Ignarolandia, donde debes habitar muy tranquila siendo presidenta de algún fan club de cantantes pop latinos.
son todos ustedes unos chupa cul..el psicoanalisis se basa sobre la teoria y analisis de un solo boludo. y lo quieren hacer pasar por ciencia citando a otros tarad..como lacan...jajaja..parecen de la iglesia ortodoxa por como lo veneran..me dan lastima
Claro como no es Bruce Willis ahi si no... Quedate con tus dioses nortamericanos y tus maricas cantantes latinos... Pero nunk burles todo lo que FREUD estudió en su vida... algo que nunk haras!
His studies lacked validity and reliability, he generalized from single case studies. However, his theories were seminal and had some heuristic value.
Psychoanalysis today is a branch of philosophy not science. This doesn't detract from the validity of Freud and Lacan's theories. Freud's early work was groundbreaking and Psychology as we know it owes its very existance to those primitive beginnings. It is only Freud's later work that perhaps deserved criticism and is responsible for US ego psychology (think Dr Phil). If you wish to critique Freud's work then i suggest you familiarise yourself with it!
I agree with you MzAnaDub .I can tell you about the validity of the psychoanalysis.The theory is consistent.i´ve been laid down in a coach for a while.just one advice ,only good psychoanlaysts make good psychoanalysis.
This theory didnt suceed and never will because the great resistences that causes in the status quo of the social mechanisms.Nevertheless,it´s one of the greatest invention of mankind ever.
freud escribió al finalizar el texto sobre su paciente dora una frase genial y tan verdadera y tan consecuente con la reacción al psicoanálisis: "06 febrero
Lo que Leo y me sorprende, y me gusta.
"Quién, como yo, convoca los mas malignos demonios que moran, apenas contenidos, en un pecho humano, y los combate, tiene que estar preparado para la eventualidad de no salir indemne de esa lucha"
FREUD, S. "Fragmento de Análisis de un caso de histeria" (Dora)
Si actualmente aplicáramos a Freud sus propias teorías, lo destrozaríamos, pues además de enriquecer notablemente a la ciencia, con ello puso de relieve también sus conflictos no resueltos y sus ansiedades
You cannot accept that we are not the masters of our domain. Freud gave us remarkable insight into human nature and development with no sugar coating. People's resistance to Freud is fierce becuase he disturbed the slumber of mankind. What studies ever disproved Freud's theories: NONE!
the only thing allday is trying to say (i think) is that psychology is incomplete science, eventhough i believe in freud, still scientist have doubt and other are against his work. its just psychology hehe =)
1)Okay, i'll clear the air, apparently I'm the only real psychologist talking here. Psychoanalysis is just a part of psychology: people who mistake freud for psychology know as much about it as people who equal physics with einstein. His ideas stem from 100 years ago, and even back then there was a great deal of discussion within psychology. And freud got his ideas about his conception of the mind from the writings of a.o. Schopenhauer and Nietzsche (these are the real innovators, believe me).
2)freud's ideas were formulated in a non-testable fashion, therefore they should be considered nonscience (also: psychology as a whole is mostly empirically testable, the bulk of findings are in accord with 'true science').For people to test his hypotheses(but he didn't have any, that's the point), they have to split it up for it to be examined. These studies have massively disproved his theories. Psychoanalysts just respond saying if you split things up, the results won't have any significance.
what he showed was that Freud's methods were unfalsifiable, not that psychoanalysis itself is unscientific, there are many attachment theory studies that are experimental/hypothesis test driven....
Keep searching for Utopia and and slapped in the face by reality. Of course there is inequality in life. Freud was a realist, and accepting humans aggressive nature is the first step toward a better world.
grace à toi et tes théories je comprend le comportement des algériens ...et surtout les musulmans ...dans leurs tètes il n y a que l'hypothalamus et l'hypophyse ...ils sont 100 pour 100 endocrinologiques ..
Imaginent si holocauste nazi produit cinquante ans plus tôt, contribution de Dr. Freud's à la société aurait été manqué. Maintenant, cinquante ans après, imaginent les qualifications de résolution des problèmes, et toute autre richesse, qui ont été perdues.
sw1w, les livres de freud ont été brûlés par les nazis aux même titre que les livres d'autres grands penseurs. Freud a dit alors : "Au moins, je brûle parmis les meilleurs". Les fous, les tordus, les malades, les mégalomanes, les ultra-narcissiques, auront toujours un problème avec la psychanalyse. Les juifs, les homosexuels, les personnes handicapées, les malades mentaux, tous ceux qui n 'étaient pas blonds aux yeux bleus en ont souffert.
Its a well known fact that he was addicted to cocaine and prescribed it to friends and patients alike, of course that line was blurred by his intoxication, even prescribing it to himself. One of these patients died form the toxicity of the drug under his supervision. Read "Cocaine" by Dominick Streatfield if you dare expand su mente.
I've always been told that he experimented cocaine for its analgesic effects and was only addicted to one thing; nicotine. He never had an addiction for cocaine. What you say is interesting, I will sure look it up.
Though Freud certainly has had a great influence on the world of psychology, I think a lot of his viewpoints are overrated and outdated. Still interesting though...
oh yeah? well he beat me up when I was 12 and took my hat and then said that it was still bothering me when I was 17 and then he pulled the teeth out of my vagina!
great footage`pity marx nietsxche not like this, , where the music ??, woudl upls add me to trade material this rare`and old, im a hIstorian, my msn: faridtjg
I don't understand all you say me, overall the short words!
Anyway if you looking for other old videos on Sigmund Freud you can check this site http://www.milibrary.com/test/fulldetails.asp?id=00781&Title=&Description=Sigmund% and this http://www.freud-museum.at/freud/media/video-e.htm
In my video there is no music because in the original is without it. At the Freud Museum the same video is showing with a audio commentary from his daughter Anna Freud.
el legado del maestro
nacho24894 3 months ago
el legado del maestro
nacho24894 3 months ago
Maestro de los maestros
pablicimo 8 months ago
ESPLENDOROSO, MAGNÍFICO, INCOMPARÁVEL!
MrLoiraaa 9 months ago
youtube.com/watch?v=76u3zAxZJhM -house of JUNG EN LAGO ZURICH-
ThePoltergueist 11 months ago
Comment removed
Achilles1389 1 year ago
Comment removed
Achilles1389 1 year ago
Comment removed
Achilles1389 1 year ago
Comment removed
Achilles1389 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Eso es el alma judía, no sólo poseemos un alma para vehicularnos con el mundo, sino tambiéen poseemos un alma divina, que es parte de D-os y que hagamos lo que hagamos permanece intacta. Si sos judío investigá más en la página de Jabad.
belleketer 1 year ago
Muito bom. Um patrimônio em vídeo.
WalisonPsi 1 year ago
j'ai pas le son c'est normal?????
laviedevantmoi1 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you are such a motherfucker stupid asshole so....you will never understand freud ..so shut up your dirty mouth ...and go fuck yourself
gigistekno 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well I think you are a brain fucker like Freud!
newfan7 2 years ago
motherfucker is you.
semideus2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
FREUD IS MY GOD HE's THE MOST WONDERFULL MAN OF EARTH
gigistekno 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You are stupid - Freud was a charlatan!
newfan7 2 years ago
your mother is a charlatan...freud is the most honest man he tells the truth
gigistekno 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
How do you want to know? - Freud was a liar!
newfan7 2 years ago
damn you trippin!!
bluemagickbo 2 years ago
ThelipstickfemmestESPDreaMSGD4CBC
PhilosophyarGStudiesUniversaleilakeyE
Dreams-Gala of Strangness UPsIdEdown
FreaKOnALeasHDIAMONDReDnaMCapE
SigmunDFreuDIDDENEmSquaredDream
FreaKOnALeasHDIAMONDReDnaMCapE
Dreams-Gala of Strangness UPsIdEdown
PhilosophyarGStudiesUniversaleilakeyE
ThelipstickfemmestESPDreaMSGD4CBC
UkDgAwellWeyeAM 2 years ago
Agaga je m'apelle Jean-Sol Parte et j'habite au pays des aigris où l'enfer c'est les autres. Je n'ai pas envie d'argumenter face à ce déchet; Freud voulait expliquer l'âme humaine (encore faut-il y croire) donc il a inventé plein de conneries et s'est fait du fric au passage le bougre. Tous ces psychanalystes, philosophes m'ennuient terriblement. Si les vieux schnok se complaisent dans l'ennui c'est pas encore mon cas.
fridgeboxy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"Tout ces psychanalystes, philosophes m'ennuient terriblement"
Well, then why don't you eat shit and die?
melancholium 2 years ago
Comment removed
fridgeboxy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sometimes interesting (less than science fiction stories) but never true.Liar liar liar liar liar liar liar.
raeven1988 3 years ago
Dr. Freud, his ideas with male preoccupation might interest all
cingle2004jp 3 years ago
dvgsdg
DTRUTHbTOLD 3 years ago
At least Freud had the candor and honesty to attribute accountability to man for the bestialities going on down below, while most have built a fortress to so defend their ego that they can't even admit its existence upon waking.
serpentineflame 3 years ago
It's not ego it's reason and critical point of view. If people are so suggestible to believe all the shit they read it's not my problem. Freud is a kind of religion like the others for people who can't think themselves.
raeven1988 3 years ago
At least Freud had the candor and honesty to attribute accountability to man for the bestialities going on down below, while most have built a fortress to so defend their ego that they can't even admit its existence upon waking.
serpentineflame 3 years ago
Il vous a tellement ramolli le cul pour que personne réponde ?
raeven1988 3 years ago
Il aurait du en rester au complexe d'infériorité/supériorité le pauvre narcissique, ça lui aurait éviter de vouloir faire évoluer n'importe comment un domaine totalement vide d'utilité. J'aurais bien voulu qu'il soit vivant que quelques personnes intelligentes le renvoient à sa réelle nature 5 minutes.
raeven1988 3 years ago
Le pauvre mec était tellement défoncé qu'il adaptait sa pensée à ce qu'il écrivait, au lieu d'écrire ce qu''il pensait. Il était pas mythomane ? La psychanalise est vraiment le domaine des débils.
raeven1988 3 years ago
Propageons la mort de l'âme, de la vie. Lisons Freud ! Bande d'idiots aigris qui ne savent pas s'arrêter de lire de la merde pour occuper leurs journées. Le précurseur des No-Life c'est lui ! Il explique les choses au lieu de les vivre, ce mec est un con.
raeven1988 3 years ago
J'espère que tu te rends compte de la débilité de ton intervention/argument ?
Morronight 2 years ago
I tkink he's the most hateful guy that the earth has ever known (after Hitler and his "friends"). This Jew is just a boring intelectual lifeless guy, he should have played TAM TAM with the doors he would have been great. Don't read his books or just enough to realise that he was stupid and had no friends.
raeven1988 3 years ago
@raeven1988 when you will discover the same amount of thing as he did and when you'll bring an important contribute to the science as he did you will be allowed to talk.
pitch89 1 year ago
The supidest man not alive. He's dead when he was born... poor guy
raeven1988 3 years ago
Religion is not a form of neurosis lol.
anthonypalladeno 3 years ago
I never mentioned religions...I know your reasoning abilities are sloppy; but are you capable of reading? Science is inconclusive because there is no theory for everything, and the way the human consciousness works remains a mystery in many respects. I know your mediocre professor told you that psychoanalysis is a scam but your rigid, hackneyed mind needs to read more and grow up. Lol, Ernest Becker report for school...I know you've never read the man because you haven't a clue. Just trite words
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
Unfortunately for you, insults don't prove anything. Once again you demonstrate that psychoanalysis relies on faith and not evidence (like for scams or cults like scientology).
I'm sure you're not even aware that thousands of Freud's papers are locked up in the Library of Congress until the year 2113! (sociology, anthropology, medical sciences don't hide datas for so long... only religions do that).
P.S. Don't forget my success story...
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
Once again you prove that you don't know what your talking about. Faith? Everything we do requires an amount of faith, from the believe in causality to the believe in the atoms I can't see...read some Hume moron. And Freud was wrong, but your idiotic attack was on psychoanalysis in general...the point is that we have constructive criticism beyond the premise that sparked the criticism, you fail to see this because your rigid & linear, is it a scam? No. It sparked new theories and premises. Duh.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
So, you finally agree with me when you say "Freud was wrong".
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
This was never about Freud being wrong, it was about you saying that psychoanalysis is a scam...Freud was wrong in his rigid, sexual-based theories for the unconscious but he was right in that there is more at play in the unconscious and how we as humans repress certain truths. So yeah, rigid Freud is wrong. Open-minded psychoanalysis divorced of rigid Freudianism may not always be right but it is a foundation in which constructive criticism may build more correct theories about the mind. There.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
"There is no compelling evidence, outside
subjective impressions, that psychoanalysis works better than non-analytically oriented therapy or placebo."
Eric Kandel (Am J Psychiatry, April 1999)
Nobel Prize of Medicine (2000)
That's the definition of a scam.
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
That's not the definition of a scam it's one man's subjective impression and your subjective impression...there is no objective clear-cut theory for how the mind works, and psychoanalysis has merely posed theories as others have posed theories. Repression is real...psychoanalysis at least got this right, along with how certain rigid people act neurotic. It's not a scam as far as that is true. You have the same fear of life and death just as much or more as any other person...that's human nature.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
Freud was a pathological liar. Let's begin by the first analyzed patient, Anna O., who was analyzed between 1880-1882. In his book (Study on hysteria, 1895) Freud wrote that she was fully cured at the end of her analysis in 1882. He NEVER mentionned that she was hospitalised 3 times between 1883-1888 (though he was fully aware of that). That was the beginning of psychoanalysis...
A scam is when someone lies to promote a treatment.
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
Okay, I thought we already moved beyond Freud...let's call it 'psychotherapy' if Freud and pyschoanalysis are both the same things to you. Repression and neurosis are real things...and by the way, this is just a question, are you an atheist or a theist?
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
I suggest the reading of Ellenberger's book "The Discovery of the Unconscious" that is an internationaly recognized historical reference on psychotherapy (and Freud's lies).
If you can read french I suggest "Le livre noir de la psychanalyse" written in 2005 after the publication in 2004 of the INSERM report on psychotherapies that concluded on the inefficacity of psychoanalysis.
The french article in Wikipedia "Critique de la psychanalyse" has a nice bibliography.
p.s. I'm atheist (no savior)
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
See, but at least you must agree with Freud in that God is a delusion?...To me atheism is just as illogical as theism is, in that they both fall victim by using argumentum ad ignorantiam...so they are both scams in that respect. In order to prove that god does or doesn't exist you must know all of existence, and that is impossible. And I nver agreed with psychoanalysis in practice, I merely agreed with it in that there are such things as neurosis and repression.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
I agree with you that one cannot prove or disprove the validity of religion or psychoanalysis (argumentum ad ignorantiam and unfalsifiable theory as explained by Karl Popper). No systematic study has demonstrated any efficacity of psychoanalysis. That's why proposing it as a therapy without mentioning that to the patient is a scam.
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
Well from the get go I've never said that
psychoanalysis is going to be able to cure
severe neurosis or psychosis or repression....I merely said that it was valid
and un-scam-like in bringing these certain symptoms to light, or too more examination. For the most part they can't really be totally treated because humans are naturally neurotic and repressed, is there an aspect of psychoanalysis which (is) scam-like, yes, but what can't be seen as scam-like these days...look at our government.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
Psychoanalysis is unfalsifiable (the theory can never be demolished because of this). Of course, severe mental disorders cannot be traeted by psychoanalysis. The more benign disorders can be helped by psychoanalysis (but also by anything else...).
Freud didn't invent the unconscious or repression. He didn't impress the medical community at his time. The only honour he got was the "Goethe prize" for literature...
p.s. 1)How many patients do you see per week? 2)What are your diplomas?
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
Well yeah, I strongly disagree with Freud and the methods he employed, and they have been shown to be false...but I do believe in a Hegelian-like evolution of learning, in that if Freud at least brought some thesis, and science brought an objective antithesis against this, then the synthesis is a combination of what is valid from what is invalid.
I am just an inquisitive writer, I've never sought to practice psychology professionally, only in the observation of everyday life and people...
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
I love Psychoanalysis, id ego & super ego
denialicious 3 years ago
gracias al cielo por este hombre irrepetible que dió todo de sí para sus postulados, formación y establecimiento de su teoría aún en contra de sus opositores, la época en la que vivió e inclusive el cáncer del cual padeció durante sus últimos años.
Freud marcó pautas, hizo la diferencia...dejó huellas, todo un legado!! la psicología, la psiquiatría, las ciencias de la salud, de la conducta y los que formamos parte de algunas de estas ramas estamos agradecidos!!
PenelopeRos 3 years ago
One thing I can not understand, why do not you left for England after the exodus of Einstein in USA; Doesn 't be enough this move or believed that the NAZI going to let live and work because they were the Freud; The result? many people to die in concentration camps.
bmplefour 3 years ago
Psychoanalysis is the greatest SCAM from the 19th century.
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
This coming from somebody who most likely doesn't know jack squat about psychoanalysis...YouTube...a place to talk out of your ass.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
I've got a PhD in psychology. And you ?
Please tell me only one "success story" of Freud !
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
I love how people tout their little PhD's on YouTube...wow, ya want a cookie!...And that really does show how much you know if you think Freud is the be-all-end-all of psychoanalysis, when anyone with a half a brain on the subject knows that Otto Rank made tremendous gains in the field, as well as many others. Success story? wtf do you mean? He helped some patients, but that is beside the point; he laid down the groundwork for others leading all the way up to Ernest Becker. You don't know squat.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
You are very good at insulting people on the net... but unfortunately for you that doesn't prove anything.
I'm still waiting for a "success story" from Freud. Can you tell a single name ??
Concerning Otto Rank, he was part of the "secret comity" of Freud for many years and Freud approved his concept of the birth trauma. That was until Freud dismiss him because he accused him of anti-Oedipal heresy.
Secret comity, heresy, excommunication... all the signs of a cult.
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
First off, this was NEVER about Freud or me proving that he was 'successful'...it was about you saying psychoanalysis is a scam, which is a very hackneyed thing to say...because it isn't, as it has paved the way for many new insights in sociology and anthropology. It's like me saying psychology PhD's are scams....are they...well I guess in someways.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
Now you are talking about sociology and anthropology !
No study shows any efficacy of psychoanalysis. On the contrary it doesn't demonstrate any effect on a wide variety on mental diseases (you probably don't know the INSERM study of 2004 that systematically reviewed all the studies on psychotherapies and concluded on the inefficacy of psychoanalysis).
Promoting a therapy without any scientific back up is a scam (with or without your insults).
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
It shows in that human consciousness is more complex than science can fully know...the id, the ego, and the superego (even if they are hypothetical abstractions) are apart of a working frame to build more theories. Geez I wonder why Freud is regarded highly even if his theories have been disproven...I wonder why Ernest Becker, a revolutionary anthropologist isn't so quick to give Freud petty labels...I guess you must know more than Becker, huh? Give me a break, science itself is inconclusive.
LeonidasIII300 3 years ago
What you just said apply to religions (hinduism, scientology, christianity...) because as you said "science itself is inconclusive" to disprove their validity. And like you said religions claim that their beliefs are "more complex than science can fully know". That's why psychoanalysis is a scam (or a cult).
p.s. Are you doing a high school homework on Ernest Becker ? Don't forget to tell me my freudian's success story !
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
he was completely nuts
austpom333 3 years ago
J'apprecie Freud beaucoup dans sa qualite d'auteur comique.
modmuss 3 years ago
Il n'a jamais eu le prix Nobel. Mais il a eu le "Prix Goethe" de littérature !!!
ericcartman321 3 years ago 4
what a great man he was
AnonSumy 3 years ago
El padre de la psicologia contemporanea...
linkdarking 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Freud est le meilleur charlatan que le 20e siècle ait connu !
jerrylewis333 3 years ago
bravo!
tautes 3 years ago
cool footage
RamaAmanda 3 years ago
Yes. But isnt Karl Popper the guy who came up with the theory -then-research concept.
BAAT4103 3 years ago
just one thing more.The hope of the development of the theory is put on the young generations.
I beg for an effort to keep psychoanalytic theory alive.
Freud and Lacan are the referents.
Thank you.
daveedine 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
freud est un voleur !!
zaroast 3 years ago
psychoanalysis is not a science, psychoanalysis is not Freud's only ideas either
psychoanalysis is one of the main schools in psychology and the bases of all Self-based psychotherapies
people shouldn't speak of something they've only heard of
vanskid777 3 years ago
Viva Freud
jdar90 3 years ago 5
MIRIAR
La que de lastima sos vos. Analfabeta poco informada, morite en la ignorancia de vivir una vida opacada por tu estrechez cerebral. Suerte con tu fantastica visión del mundo y el psicoanlisis, allá, en Ignarolandia, donde debes habitar muy tranquila siendo presidenta de algún fan club de cantantes pop latinos.
kilichristian 3 years ago 3
son todos ustedes unos chupa cul..el psicoanalisis se basa sobre la teoria y analisis de un solo boludo. y lo quieren hacer pasar por ciencia citando a otros tarad..como lacan...jajaja..parecen de la iglesia ortodoxa por como lo veneran..me dan lastima
miriargentina 3 years ago
Claro como no es Bruce Willis ahi si no... Quedate con tus dioses nortamericanos y tus maricas cantantes latinos... Pero nunk burles todo lo que FREUD estudió en su vida... algo que nunk haras!
jdar90 3 years ago
idol
ArgTincho 3 years ago
His studies lacked validity and reliability, he generalized from single case studies. However, his theories were seminal and had some heuristic value.
Nathanielthan 3 years ago
you shouldn't speak of something you don't understand. clearly you have no idea of psychoanalysis
vanskid777 3 years ago 2
Psychoanalysis today is a branch of philosophy not science. This doesn't detract from the validity of Freud and Lacan's theories. Freud's early work was groundbreaking and Psychology as we know it owes its very existance to those primitive beginnings. It is only Freud's later work that perhaps deserved criticism and is responsible for US ego psychology (think Dr Phil). If you wish to critique Freud's work then i suggest you familiarise yourself with it!
MzAnaDub 4 years ago
I agree with you MzAnaDub .I can tell you about the validity of the psychoanalysis.The theory is consistent.i´ve been laid down in a coach for a while.just one advice ,only good psychoanlaysts make good psychoanalysis.
This theory didnt suceed and never will because the great resistences that causes in the status quo of the social mechanisms.Nevertheless,it´s one of the greatest invention of mankind ever.
Please to meet you.
daveedine 3 years ago
freud escribió al finalizar el texto sobre su paciente dora una frase genial y tan verdadera y tan consecuente con la reacción al psicoanálisis: "06 febrero
Lo que Leo y me sorprende, y me gusta.
"Quién, como yo, convoca los mas malignos demonios que moran, apenas contenidos, en un pecho humano, y los combate, tiene que estar preparado para la eventualidad de no salir indemne de esa lucha"
FREUD, S. "Fragmento de Análisis de un caso de histeria" (Dora)
Obras Completas Tomo VII.
mariavictorina 4 years ago
There are superiors and there are not, but all are in their context.
rMalk89 4 years ago
Si actualmente aplicáramos a Freud sus propias teorías, lo destrozaríamos, pues además de enriquecer notablemente a la ciencia, con ello puso de relieve también sus conflictos no resueltos y sus ansiedades
LUCAGOGA 4 years ago
freud is quite strange in his hypothesis
in many studies having little apparent truth
this doesnt mean that he isnt very interesting to learn about and as we know his ideas are still carried on today by leading psychologists
alldayDIPSETallday 4 years ago
You cannot accept that we are not the masters of our domain. Freud gave us remarkable insight into human nature and development with no sugar coating. People's resistance to Freud is fierce becuase he disturbed the slumber of mankind. What studies ever disproved Freud's theories: NONE!
orsonfreud 4 years ago 3
the only thing allday is trying to say (i think) is that psychology is incomplete science, eventhough i believe in freud, still scientist have doubt and other are against his work. its just psychology hehe =)
bslbasil 4 years ago
Psycology is science, tough it is no "Hard Science" like physics or chemistry, but it is called "Soft Science".
SweetDragon15 4 years ago
Freud was a scientist, but also the father of Psychoanalysis; there is a significant difference between psychology and psychoanalysis.
LZelikman25 4 years ago
1)Okay, i'll clear the air, apparently I'm the only real psychologist talking here. Psychoanalysis is just a part of psychology: people who mistake freud for psychology know as much about it as people who equal physics with einstein. His ideas stem from 100 years ago, and even back then there was a great deal of discussion within psychology. And freud got his ideas about his conception of the mind from the writings of a.o. Schopenhauer and Nietzsche (these are the real innovators, believe me).
ytzuigt 4 years ago
2)freud's ideas were formulated in a non-testable fashion, therefore they should be considered nonscience (also: psychology as a whole is mostly empirically testable, the bulk of findings are in accord with 'true science').For people to test his hypotheses(but he didn't have any, that's the point), they have to split it up for it to be examined. These studies have massively disproved his theories. Psychoanalysts just respond saying if you split things up, the results won't have any significance.
ytzuigt 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree. The philosopher Karl Popper showed how unscientific psychoanalysis is, he placed it in the category of astrology and other non-sciences.
willardsheen 3 years ago
what he showed was that Freud's methods were unfalsifiable, not that psychoanalysis itself is unscientific, there are many attachment theory studies that are experimental/hypothesis test driven....
hanniballecturer 3 years ago
actually Popper's points were made against Adler.....
hanniballecturer 3 years ago
Also Freud. Read his "Conjectures and Refutations".
willardsheen 2 years ago
you are all knobs!
fentomship 4 years ago
freud and darwin both, show EXTREME implications of Platonian idaes of supremecy and inequality.
hurryupche 4 years ago
Keep searching for Utopia and and slapped in the face by reality. Of course there is inequality in life. Freud was a realist, and accepting humans aggressive nature is the first step toward a better world.
orsonfreud 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Realism is boring. Superego is overrated! I can fly if I want to!
hellpartyboy2008 4 years ago
Then jump off a building without a parachute or some other device: Please do it!!!
orsonfreud 4 years ago 3
oh ma doctrine mr freud
grace à toi et tes théories je comprend le comportement des algériens ...et surtout les musulmans ...dans leurs tètes il n y a que l'hypothalamus et l'hypophyse ...ils sont 100 pour 100 endocrinologiques ..
islaiciste 4 years ago
Shadow remnants of a man who tried to further foster our understanding -- thank you for sharing this.
tenpennyplayers 4 years ago
en realidad es freud
que pedo
pos una de las mentes mas brillantes que ayan exixtido
guau
wow
srmakina 4 years ago
kien me explica este video....
No lo entendi y me da flojera entenderlo...
eeac1988 4 years ago
yyyy si hay personas como vos a los que le cuesta entender
campanita0022 4 years ago
Wow :O
chelseagrrrl 4 years ago 2
What a brilliant human being- so keen on looking to help people. That dynamic psyche is ace.
Ayius 4 years ago
Ich hätte Freud so gerne kennengelernt!!! Tolles Video!
Blutmond666 4 years ago
Monsieur Freud, je suis heureuse que tu aies existé
rimacol 4 years ago
Cher Rim,
Imaginent si holocauste nazi produit cinquante ans plus tôt, contribution de Dr. Freud's à la société aurait été manqué. Maintenant, cinquante ans après, imaginent les qualifications de résolution des problèmes, et toute autre richesse, qui ont été perdues.
Acclamations de,
del-garçon.
sw1w 4 years ago
sw1w, les livres de freud ont été brûlés par les nazis aux même titre que les livres d'autres grands penseurs. Freud a dit alors : "Au moins, je brûle parmis les meilleurs". Les fous, les tordus, les malades, les mégalomanes, les ultra-narcissiques, auront toujours un problème avec la psychanalyse. Les juifs, les homosexuels, les personnes handicapées, les malades mentaux, tous ceux qui n 'étaient pas blonds aux yeux bleus en ont souffert.
rimacol 4 years ago
The Jews, the homosexual ones, the handicapped people, the mental patients, all those which were not fair with the blue eyes from of suffered.
Dear Ri,
thank you for the response to my comment.
Del-boy
sw1q 4 years ago
Google translationon two pages:
Dear sw1w,
The books of Freud were burned by the Nazis on the same basis as the books of other large thinkers.
Freud said then: "At least, I burn parmis the best".
The insane ones, twisted, the patients, the megalomaniacs, the narcissistic ones, will always have a problem with the psychoanalysis.
sw1q 4 years ago
Dear Rim,
Imagine if the Nazi Holocaust happened fifty years sooner, Dr. Freud's contribution to society would have been missed.
Now, fifty years later, imagine the problem solving skills, and other riches, that have been lost.
Cheers.
from,
del-boy.
sw1w 4 years ago
this man was nothing short of amazing!
shamshel4 4 years ago
Sigmund Freud is the mag daddy of psychology.
asslaslades 4 years ago
amazing vid =)
mrfatd 4 years ago
What a cocaine addict.
juanpablotocino 4 years ago
stupid comentary,el tocino te esta llegando al cerebro
bostonpublic2 4 years ago
For the best books ...go to ebay / choose user gunner (underscore) uk .
p2009 4 years ago
Its a well known fact that he was addicted to cocaine and prescribed it to friends and patients alike, of course that line was blurred by his intoxication, even prescribing it to himself. One of these patients died form the toxicity of the drug under his supervision. Read "Cocaine" by Dominick Streatfield if you dare expand su mente.
juanpablotocino 4 years ago
I've always been told that he experimented cocaine for its analgesic effects and was only addicted to one thing; nicotine. He never had an addiction for cocaine. What you say is interesting, I will sure look it up.
FrighterZ 4 years ago
Lol yeah...he certainly was!
MacdaddyMcguire 4 years ago
Sigmumd Freud, grazie di essere esistito.
mattanam 4 years ago
Freud was 1.72 m (5 ft 7-3/4 in) tall. He moved gracefully.
AnaKosta 4 years ago
He is full of ticks.
ElAurenz 4 years ago
Though Freud certainly has had a great influence on the world of psychology, I think a lot of his viewpoints are overrated and outdated. Still interesting though...
87Kirsten87 4 years ago
Cara Giulietta
Ho visto alcuni video tuoi e mi sono piaciuti...
I miei cumplimenti
Anch'io sono psicologo clinico e abito a roma
un saluto
Leonardo
lepasqua 4 years ago
Un saluto a te Leonardo e grazie. :)
giulietta 4 years ago
hes mad me suffer so much! damn essays
chiefkeckers 5 years ago
haha agreed %100!! same for me..
snoopy9352 4 years ago
oh yeah? well he beat me up when I was 12 and took my hat and then said that it was still bothering me when I was 17 and then he pulled the teeth out of my vagina!
I DONT EVEN HAVE A VAGINA!!!
MacdaddyMcguire 4 years ago
Grande Sigmund! Maestro!
Eltintolo 5 years ago
This is the same video that wen can watch at his house's museum, in London :)
So great!
iremanews 5 years ago
An ode to Freud and all he has given to the world of Psycoholgy! From a Psycoholgy student :)
flarenixie 5 years ago
the man that freed mankind
ravensncrows 5 years ago
great...
I've not seen before any Freud's videos;can't believe I just was watchin a man who's done for me so much.
Sigmund Freud rulez :D
HappyLittleMayniac 5 years ago
Very unique and precious video.
Thank you so much!
pangea2000 5 years ago
Very unique and precious video.
Thank you so much!
pangea2000 5 years ago
fantastic!!!
thami1978 5 years ago
please canu send this video to me? im studying psychology and i need it
eneida7 5 years ago
Do you need it? What for? You're weird, dude.
gondorado 5 years ago
is this LOndon 1939`?
faridjabba 5 years ago
great footage`pity marx nietsxche not like this, , where the music ??, woudl upls add me to trade material this rare`and old, im a hIstorian, my msn: faridtjg
faridjabba 5 years ago
I don't understand all you say me, overall the short words!
Anyway if you looking for other old videos on Sigmund Freud you can check this site http://www.milibrary.com/test/fulldetails.asp?id=00781&Title=&Description=Sigmund% and this http://www.freud-museum.at/freud/media/video-e.htm
In my video there is no music because in the original is without it. At the Freud Museum the same video is showing with a audio commentary from his daughter Anna Freud.
Ciao.
giulietta 5 years ago
msn ?
faridjabba 5 years ago