I still love Crimson and to me their music from the 1970s is timeless. Watching this you are reminded how good a guitarist Fripp was, but he doesn't look very happy. I can undertand why many of his bandmates had problems relating to him. David Cross,, the violinist, was fired shortly after this. Bruford's drums seem too high in the mix, while you struggle to hear Cross. They were a great band.
This is what you call dynamics in music. How it starts all quietly with that eerie wail and like the adrenalin you get when you get slowly but very angry and how it builds up like prickly hairs do with goosebumps. All these so-called extreme Metal bands could learn a thing or two from this. Or better not. Fuck them and their whooarghs! I want to keep this moment special for myself without some face painted Norwegian stealing it. God, if only K.C. could play more often & make a record also!
Such a naughty bassline! This song is love. In the recorded version isn't there a saxophone solo? Was the sax player a permanent member of the lineup then?
@scotmunda90 Really the only permanent member of the lineup is Robert Fripp. The band wrote this song and performed it live about a year before releasing it on the "Red" album in 1974. The studio version contained the saxophone solo (by either Ian MacDonald or Mel Collins- I forgot which).
@auburngoalie and i don't mean to dump on anyone, but bruford is so much better than the 'almighty' neil peart. i think peart is a good drummer, but one who does mostly the same thing every song and dramatically overplays everything. bruford is just so timely. sure he's complex and fast, but because the song calls for it. peart just seems to always be showing off
@auburngoalie Honestly? LOL! Bruford is doing his best to impersonate Art Blakey. Learn your music history, mate. His "borrowing" of Bu is totally tedious and unremarkable.
@spabook69 Odd you would think that. I've been a fan of Bruford and Blakey for decades, have seen both in concert several times and don't see many parallels between the two. To me Bruford is a much more mathematical and classically oriented player who played rock but was in love with jazz and Blakey a more lyrical and melodic drummer tho powerfully rhythmic and most def a jazz player. I have to say I prefer Art's drumming but Bill is the master in the odd time signature department
Yes! Thank you for posting this. My favorite line-up of my favorite band. Bruford and Wetton! To this day, Starless and Bible Black (the album, and this song from Red) is the most beautiful of rock music creations, IMHO. Man, you can feel their energy. Thanks!
The reason why Bruford left Yes. Bruford would not have been able to play like this over anything from "Tales From Topographic Oceans". Alan White fit that music like a glove.
At 3:55 Fripp and Bruford have become completely "lost" (absorbed) in their music. Are they even aware of anything else? Watch Bruford's face at 4:28. We don't see Fripp's face, but I've watched him enough times to appreciate the levels of concentration he is able to put into his music.
Vaya final!! Ese sonido único con sólo tres tambores,(no hace falta ningun almacen de tambores para sonar grande), de Bill Bruford es tan especial e inconfundible como lo fue Blakey en el Be Bop: dos creadores de escuela. Fripp, un genio fuera de serie total, wetton en su mejor momento y Cross lirico a tope...que más se puede pedir!!! Mamma mia!!! Starless=2012?
@mousetop19 If you listen to the live "Great Deceiver" Box Set, there's one tune in particular where right before it starts, an audience member yells: "Bruford !!! Billy Cobham eat your heart out! " It's really funny because Cobham was drummer for Mahavishnu Orchestra at the time, a band that was an influence on Fripp & Bruford . Cobham was considered the greatest fusion drummer at the time in direct competition with Bruford as greatest rock drummer even though he started as a total jazzer.
@shivabel The music and video are in sync on the "Red" 40th anniversary DVD. Not sure what went wrong here. If you're a KC fan the DVD is money well spent for all the extra material.
I get totally blown away EVERY time I hear this piece. It was so good to see these guys live back then. I get goose bumps & my hair stands on end every time!
@vivelavidarocka You got that right--I love the way it just builds, like you know somethings coming, then when it finally does come--still two notes. Fripp is a master of guitar and everything that could possibly be done with it! this is one of my all time favorites from the Wetton era of KC
@vivelavidarocka Bruford said that Fripp loved being the rhythmic center to a song and letting everyone else create swirling rhythmic chaos around him. Not many other guitarists would be brave enough to play two notes for five minutes straight.
Even watching it online with it out of synch (except for the drums for some weird reason) still an astonishing performance. Originality and genius is where its at!
@ ConspireToConspire. Thank you i know that it is from a few concerts in Europa. It is also on the album the Night Watch live in Amsterdam and - live in Central Park NY - bootleg quality.
What i actually mean is that there is apparently no video of Fracture or other live concerts from the seventies, apart from a few from tv and that is really a pity.
@hanskumar1 actually the reason is because that album is really a live recording of a concert with a few overdubs. which is why the feel and depth is amazing to me. i love red but theres a feel to s&bb thats a different kind of haunting. kc released the original concert recordings some years back.
@gillan5 you're shitting by your mouth ! if you don't like it .. its okay .. but say that's no music .. is bullshit ! these guys were ones of the best in the world on what they do ..
@1967nj How would you describe it then? Prog rock includes a lot of different sounding bands. Labels are often inacurate but we use them anyway because, well, langage in general is often inacurate but we have to use something to communicate, don't we? Anyway, not like KC wasn't "self indulgent" from time to time. Nothing wrong with that is there?
@johnarthurknight yeah and we (the audience) forked over $100 for him to do it! You can buy it at the DGM site.... the whole soundscape show was phenomenal, wasn't it?
I'm not quite sure about some of the comments about this performance. I don't know if the expectation is that the piece be played like a carbon copy of the studio version, and I laughed out loud at the comment "Fripp makes a mistake..." - nonsense.
If you ever LISTENED to Crimson live, they play every piece differently EVERY night. They don't try to "play it like the record" - a totally ridiculous notion in the case of THIS song, since it was a live track for many months BEFORE Red !
@pureambient17 This is true and especially notable because this band never got into the studio to record it - Cross left the group before they could. I think the sax that played the violin part on the record was a travesty. The violin was so much better, and I wish KC would add that instrument to their lineup again.
fripp and the boys at the peak of it all
bbooz 3 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
This has been flagged as spam show
Porfavor sube el video completo, los que gustamos del verdadero rock te lo agradeceremos :)
SuperGrangus 1 month ago
One of music's finest ever moments...a masterpiece, pure and simple.
DaveEllis13 1 month ago
@tdichiara2008 me too.
DaveEllis13 1 month ago
~~~ MotherFuckin' Perfection embrace Khaos ~~~
lrtb1983 2 months ago 2
Comment removed
lrtb1983 2 months ago
I still love Crimson and to me their music from the 1970s is timeless. Watching this you are reminded how good a guitarist Fripp was, but he doesn't look very happy. I can undertand why many of his bandmates had problems relating to him. David Cross,, the violinist, was fired shortly after this. Bruford's drums seem too high in the mix, while you struggle to hear Cross. They were a great band.
waterboys3001 3 months ago
wonderfull
migrab1960 3 months ago
oh yeaaaah.... 1974 !!! and no more to say... just fantastic!!!
MrsSTARLESS1974 3 months ago
Why can't the audio be in sync???!!!!
TheTaoistdragon 4 months ago in playlist More videos from leober7
awesome
edwardszzz 4 months ago
Capt. Fripps and his two note tension machine! Love it.
Darrylizer1 4 months ago 3
wish the audio wasn't out of sync with the video, but still awesome.
musicajuro 4 months ago 2
This is what you call dynamics in music. How it starts all quietly with that eerie wail and like the adrenalin you get when you get slowly but very angry and how it builds up like prickly hairs do with goosebumps. All these so-called extreme Metal bands could learn a thing or two from this. Or better not. Fuck them and their whooarghs! I want to keep this moment special for myself without some face painted Norwegian stealing it. God, if only K.C. could play more often & make a record also!
soundvisionary13 4 months ago
It doesn't get any better than this, period! And that black Les Paul is the cherry on the pie!
Chillyfretlesswilly 4 months ago
wow
johnshipe 5 months ago
Emotivooo !!!
malditoopio 5 months ago
2 dislikes love lady gaga
beka7172 5 months ago
Absolutely extraordinary! I love it - the whole thing!
MrStevestain 5 months ago
two dislikes are gay!
postgyberos 5 months ago
If you like this line up of the band checkout Hight Tide, not entirley the same music (pogressive still tho) but same instrumental line up.
JamesMarshallJohansn 5 months ago
What' Ever !!! i own 13 Les Paul's and still counting Loser Boy
frankiev1231 5 months ago
Nice Gibson Black beauty to bad he can't play it '
frankiev1231 5 months ago
@frankiev1231 That made me laugh. Apart from being able to spot a guitar its too bad you know fuck all about playing one
MOTARDkamikaze 5 months ago 3
...and Fripp on the guitar too!!!
travics77 6 months ago
Bruford is God!!!!
travics77 6 months ago
fantazie
sklomuzicka 6 months ago
I once told Bruford how much I enjoyed his work with King Crimson and he just beamed at me and said thank you.
56BUICKRiviera 6 months ago
Fuck this! Best band ever! Incredible to see a video of an old performance like this...
Vedder2112Man 6 months ago
wish the dubbing was in sync with the video...bummer
uberkernow 6 months ago
AND I DREAM I DREAM I DREAM !!
SICKMANBUYER 7 months ago
Such a naughty bassline! This song is love. In the recorded version isn't there a saxophone solo? Was the sax player a permanent member of the lineup then?
scotmunda90 7 months ago
@scotmunda90 Really the only permanent member of the lineup is Robert Fripp. The band wrote this song and performed it live about a year before releasing it on the "Red" album in 1974. The studio version contained the saxophone solo (by either Ian MacDonald or Mel Collins- I forgot which).
howlrat 7 months ago
This is a great song, which kind of reminds me of a band I've heard a few days ago, Aperco. Hear the similarity at their channel apercoband
Tamgeopose1988 7 months ago
most remarkable!
Similie 8 months ago
is this AFTER greg lake?
chefjohn777 8 months ago
@chefjohn777 yes
capoeira26 8 months ago
@chefjohn777.... Five years after Lake.
nasmformyzombie 7 months ago
Maybe it is the best song from 20th century. For me it is.
migrab1960 8 months ago 4
Are there any good dvds from this era or even late 70s Crimson?
Rambo29 8 months ago
Bruford is just insane.
auburngoalie 8 months ago 34
@auburngoalie and i don't mean to dump on anyone, but bruford is so much better than the 'almighty' neil peart. i think peart is a good drummer, but one who does mostly the same thing every song and dramatically overplays everything. bruford is just so timely. sure he's complex and fast, but because the song calls for it. peart just seems to always be showing off
newfuckingwave 7 months ago 4
@newfuckingwave I definitely agree man.
auburngoalie 6 months ago
@auburngoalie Honestly? LOL! Bruford is doing his best to impersonate Art Blakey. Learn your music history, mate. His "borrowing" of Bu is totally tedious and unremarkable.
spabook69 4 months ago
@spabook69 Odd you would think that. I've been a fan of Bruford and Blakey for decades, have seen both in concert several times and don't see many parallels between the two. To me Bruford is a much more mathematical and classically oriented player who played rock but was in love with jazz and Blakey a more lyrical and melodic drummer tho powerfully rhythmic and most def a jazz player. I have to say I prefer Art's drumming but Bill is the master in the odd time signature department
Darrylizer1 4 months ago
first half of the song - haunting and moving.
second half - fucking epic!
TheArabassist 8 months ago
<33333
XxLizmoxX 8 months ago
Fripp uses tremolo sound with effects a lot : what's his secret ?
Sylvain894 8 months ago in playlist KING CRIMSON
Yes! Thank you for posting this. My favorite line-up of my favorite band. Bruford and Wetton! To this day, Starless and Bible Black (the album, and this song from Red) is the most beautiful of rock music creations, IMHO. Man, you can feel their energy. Thanks!
TheSteveSteele 9 months ago
wait a minute ...0:00 ..Harpo Marx??
ranXerox09 9 months ago
@ranXerox09 hahahh.
joakorush2112 8 months ago
The reason why Bruford left Yes. Bruford would not have been able to play like this over anything from "Tales From Topographic Oceans". Alan White fit that music like a glove.
Mikemaniax 9 months ago
amazing how much Bruford did with such a minimal drum kit.
bdfilms01 10 months ago
it was expert playing like this which prompted up the punk movement to come and democratize rnroll
itnow 10 months ago
At 3:55 Fripp and Bruford have become completely "lost" (absorbed) in their music. Are they even aware of anything else? Watch Bruford's face at 4:28. We don't see Fripp's face, but I've watched him enough times to appreciate the levels of concentration he is able to put into his music.
cliffwalkinfool 10 months ago
A true authentic treasure...I'm amazed
blueturtleblues 10 months ago
the video and audio timing doesnt go together
trilobite3339 10 months ago
Holy mother of mercy! Didn't even know this existed, thanks so much!
HellsDonutHouse 10 months ago
thank you so much...
malerba13 10 months ago
the band wich inspired the mars volta... kimg crimson, nobody does...
donaaaN 10 months ago
really cool, loved them most when doing instrumentals!
victorsaint2 11 months ago
CAN YOU UPLOAD TIHS VIDEO IN JUST ONE VIDEO? THE LIMIT IS NOW 15MIN! :)
Rafantomas 11 months ago 19
@Rafantomas BUT FIX THE TIMING ON BOTH! :P
MasterYumyums 10 months ago
@Rafantomas Here is the entire King Crimson performance on Melody TV, runs 29 minutes: /watch?v=eDxnJrzYIj0 also on the Red 40th anniversary DVD.
Hubs88 2 months ago
Is that Bruford's "O face" at 4:24? Long live the King
sabatino1977 11 months ago
Bill Bruford is freaking flying on this one! Fucking nailed it, man.
Horomaru 11 months ago 2
holy fucking shit . 50 STARS!
buddhastalin 11 months ago
They are insane in a good way. :) I like the 74 band the most.
babysnakezappa 11 months ago
Excellent video. Thanks for sharing Tony. Nadine :)
williedb47 11 months ago
Thanks for posting this.
webgeek6 11 months ago
horribly out of sync
please fix
morvelification 11 months ago
music like this just slaps you telling you heaven is possible
TheSizMan 1 year ago 2
Vaya final!! Ese sonido único con sólo tres tambores,(no hace falta ningun almacen de tambores para sonar grande), de Bill Bruford es tan especial e inconfundible como lo fue Blakey en el Be Bop: dos creadores de escuela. Fripp, un genio fuera de serie total, wetton en su mejor momento y Cross lirico a tope...que más se puede pedir!!! Mamma mia!!! Starless=2012?
millonety123 1 year ago
Amazing performance, absolutely amazing.
smeagollu 1 year ago
The way they go quiet at the end was just fabulous
Lightmane321 1 year ago
Thank you for this, you rock! Cheers from Croatia
ertzuiop123 1 year ago
OMG .... this is just heaven
dockaiser 1 year ago
Thank you! This is the best version of "Starless" I have seen.
Possumlivingdotcom 1 year ago
this is sheer pleasure to witness.
cosmicrider287 1 year ago 3
Bruford..crazy man!
mousetop19 1 year ago
@mousetop19 If you listen to the live "Great Deceiver" Box Set, there's one tune in particular where right before it starts, an audience member yells: "Bruford !!! Billy Cobham eat your heart out! " It's really funny because Cobham was drummer for Mahavishnu Orchestra at the time, a band that was an influence on Fripp & Bruford . Cobham was considered the greatest fusion drummer at the time in direct competition with Bruford as greatest rock drummer even though he started as a total jazzer.
metamorphosis67 1 year ago
What a pity the music and the images are not well synchronized!
shivabel 1 year ago
@shivabel The music and video are in sync on the "Red" 40th anniversary DVD. Not sure what went wrong here. If you're a KC fan the DVD is money well spent for all the extra material.
ScootTheCat 1 year ago
I get totally blown away EVERY time I hear this piece. It was so good to see these guys live back then. I get goose bumps & my hair stands on end every time!
Thanks for the upload & for sharing!!!!
xbxbear 1 year ago 3
Only Fripp could use only two freaking notes and give 'em such a range of emotions. Materpiece of minimalism.
vivelavidarocka 1 year ago 45
@vivelavidarocka You got that right--I love the way it just builds, like you know somethings coming, then when it finally does come--still two notes. Fripp is a master of guitar and everything that could possibly be done with it! this is one of my all time favorites from the Wetton era of KC
Revvin 6 months ago
@vivelavidarocka Philip Glass
psirou 5 months ago
@vivelavidarocka yeaahhhh D:! in fact its the same note , just on the other string, so that makes it even more amazing : s
bernich88 5 months ago
@vivelavidarocka Bruford said that Fripp loved being the rhythmic center to a song and letting everyone else create swirling rhythmic chaos around him. Not many other guitarists would be brave enough to play two notes for five minutes straight.
Dooality 5 months ago
@vivelavidarocka endless trip
guitar602991 4 months ago
@vivelavidarocka i know!!! the guy is a guitar-god !
juandhaltrich 4 months ago
i always get goosbumps when the beat comes back in at 4:50. stunning.
deathmetalinsanity54 1 year ago
thanks so mauch for sharing
it's hard to find any vintage material of KC especially in Chile
you ROCK
pornis90 1 year ago
THANK YOU FOR THIS INCREDIBLE FOOTAGE
azurenscens 1 year ago
Even watching it online with it out of synch (except for the drums for some weird reason) still an astonishing performance. Originality and genius is where its at!
goldragons 1 year ago
Has anybody ever heard of shredding on the violin?..Well, now you have!
Mzler1387 1 year ago
@ ConspireToConspire. Thank you i know that it is from a few concerts in Europa. It is also on the album the Night Watch live in Amsterdam and - live in Central Park NY - bootleg quality.
What i actually mean is that there is apparently no video of Fracture or other live concerts from the seventies, apart from a few from tv and that is really a pity.
So if ever anyone finds it !!!
hanskumar1 1 year ago
is it just me or is the audio/video off...
DrumRemixRequest 1 year ago
@DrumRemixRequest
Yes the sync is off... can we get this fixed?
TheMilford 1 year ago
I am just totally _______ . What a vid. The music.
871185 1 year ago
oh my god
awesome jazz rock psychedelic and spontaneous genius
rudy
rcmorabito 1 year ago
Starless and Bible Black!
LapisLee 1 year ago
hey Fripp, handsome!!
beatlebeck 1 year ago
Incredible, Thank You So Much!!!
Cryptic2002 1 year ago
Indeed!..I'll buy that for a dollar!!
soremongs 1 year ago
Indeed!
soremongs 1 year ago
Anybody knows if there is anything more, anywhere on the net from this tv show. Looking for a live version of Fracture for a long time.
There seems to almost nothing of the Starless and bible black album on the net, what a pity.
hanskumar1 1 year ago
@hanskumar1 actually the reason is because that album is really a live recording of a concert with a few overdubs. which is why the feel and depth is amazing to me. i love red but theres a feel to s&bb thats a different kind of haunting. kc released the original concert recordings some years back.
ConspireToConspire 1 year ago
Best enjoyed at a very HIGH volume!!!!!!!
ksjoyjespeace 1 year ago 4
What is that? - Music? - No, it is cat`s crying! With all due respect to King Crimson.
gillan5 1 year ago
@gillan5 what?
axleri 1 year ago
@gillan5 you're shitting by your mouth ! if you don't like it .. its okay .. but say that's no music .. is bullshit ! these guys were ones of the best in the world on what they do ..
buxadonoff 1 year ago 4
Fripp could do this in his sleep.
skaterat121 1 year ago
@skaterat121 He looks like he IS asleep...
Kharmaireth 1 year ago
@1967nj How would you describe it then? Prog rock includes a lot of different sounding bands. Labels are often inacurate but we use them anyway because, well, langage in general is often inacurate but we have to use something to communicate, don't we? Anyway, not like KC wasn't "self indulgent" from time to time. Nothing wrong with that is there?
87Julius 1 year ago 2
Damn never seen this! Best Crimson Ive seen
suchness9 1 year ago
bruford is the best.
mediawest 1 year ago
@1967nj Haha, do you have any idea how self-indulgent YOU sound with that comment? =)
peeniizz 1 year ago
This is fucking incredible.
metalcore929 1 year ago
Fripp is the coolest but Bruford is also the coolest! He's in trance!
gunnsgthartman 1 year ago
and I'll take Wetton over Greg Lake any day of the week
cliffburton333 1 year ago
oh my fucking god that was sick. wow.
cliffburton333 1 year ago
Absolutely great, especially Wetton and Bruford ^^. The final sounds better with the saxophone than with Fripp's guitar, though...
MrSuperdico 1 year ago
best sh*t on youtube
juanscv79 1 year ago
this song makes me want to buy a violin and a melotron, a new guitar and lessons
boibad12 1 year ago
Go Bill Bruford! Go!
mikedrud 1 year ago 2
improves on the already good studio version
good show fripp/bruford/wetton/cross
motherbrain86 1 year ago
Bill Bruford is SICK on the drums !!!
rixwerld 1 year ago
haha you gotta wonder why they wanted David Cross out of the band for Red when he absolutely is burning it here on total top form
lalalalala5151 1 year ago 2
is this the video footage thats on the Red bonus dvd?
ACrackInTheWall2006 1 year ago
so awesome when bruford goes mad, it shows his true colours.
rexasul 1 year ago
13/8
enricocassia 1 year ago
Amazing!
ravenwindsong 1 year ago
Fripp has done solo versions of this. I saw him do it in March 2006 in St Louis.
johnarthurknight 1 year ago
@johnarthurknight yeah and we (the audience) forked over $100 for him to do it! You can buy it at the DGM site.... the whole soundscape show was phenomenal, wasn't it?
yoursaxman 1 year ago
I was blown away. Totally.
wund3k 1 year ago
U R welcome, friends of mine!!!
leober7 1 year ago 15
I knew it, i've known for a long time...but now i've seen it....Thanks pal
(got some wine on the shelf and this seems like the right time...)
EMILIOMARENGO 1 year ago
I'm not quite sure about some of the comments about this performance. I don't know if the expectation is that the piece be played like a carbon copy of the studio version, and I laughed out loud at the comment "Fripp makes a mistake..." - nonsense.
If you ever LISTENED to Crimson live, they play every piece differently EVERY night. They don't try to "play it like the record" - a totally ridiculous notion in the case of THIS song, since it was a live track for many months BEFORE Red !
Think!
pureambient17 1 year ago
@pureambient17 This is true and especially notable because this band never got into the studio to record it - Cross left the group before they could. I think the sax that played the violin part on the record was a travesty. The violin was so much better, and I wish KC would add that instrument to their lineup again.
danxenatro 1 year ago
awesome!!!!
diogobobsin 1 year ago
Ooooh that bass guitar... It looks like Jesus Christ played it himself...
eliottelescorielese 1 year ago
fripps guitar sound kinda like a synth
PAULisDEADMANnumber9 1 year ago
who plays violin and keyboards?
luislacave 1 year ago 2
@luislacave David Cross on violin and melotron...
leober7 1 year ago 11
@leober7 thanks, this is Crimson at his best!
luislacave 1 year ago
@leober7 Fripp plays mellotron for most of this song though
electricuncledave 1 year ago
out of sync
rubberdu 1 year ago
Ascolto questo gruppo e mi rendo conto che l'85% della musica di adesso è merda.....
CasaApicella 1 year ago
Incredible, what a band!
bribeanbabybopdelux 1 year ago
Thanks, This video is an authentic treasure!!!
Dikablan 1 year ago 24
Comment removed
Dikablan 1 year ago
Ah wow thank you SOOOO much for this!!!!!!!!
mclainrose 1 year ago
Fripp described the Wetton/Bruford rhythm section as a flying brick wall. This film is a pretty good illustration of why :¬)
HeidiLandRover 1 year ago 27
@HeidiLandRover I would have to agree with Fripp & you;)
ravenwindsong 1 year ago 2
@HeidiLandRover What does that mean?
cavemanfarts 1 year ago
@HeidiLandRover A perfect accompaniment to his discordant melodrama! I love it all!
Malzarin 1 year ago