Actually have to admit, Gary sounds like he's singing this just for the sake of doing the cover. He's playing the chords, he's hitting the notes, but there's a definite absence of something here...
only damien rice can sing this and have you feeling like someone stabbed you in the liver and you're rolling on the floor bleeding. damien rice has his melancholy, gary has his sadness - it just so happens that this cover didnt work.
Not an easy cover and I would have to say it was an excellent effort. Damien Rice is a tough act to follow. All in All very nice. For a lovely version in Brazilian Portuguese search Ana Carolina -Sue Jorge blowers daughter. Even if you can't understand the language, the music and their beautiful voices as well as the natural beauty of the Brazilian Portuguese language is guaranteed to move you.
Thanks for all the comments, positive and negative! Everyone has their own opinion and in mines Gary does a cracking job taking this song on! Was quite a gutsy thing to do with all the love for the original.
Omg, he and Damien Rice is soooooo different. :D I love both versions. This, I love because it's so... Gary, it's soo him, and the original version shows Damien fully, so... no difference, but still, they're not the same. Don't compare, it ruins it all :)
You have it all wrong. Damien Rice wrote this song in 2000-2001, and Ana Carolina did a cover of it with Seu Jorge in 2004. Damien Rice wrote the original, the man is genius as a songwriter.
Na verdade, o original é do Damien, ele lançou no disco "O" em 2002, já Ana Carolina e Seu Jorge traduziram a música em 2004 para o DVD Ao vivo intitulado "Ana e Jorge".
ohhhh Gary, you beautiful man you...i love Garrrrrrrry... Gary, Damien Rice, and Glen Hansard should all get together and do something (besides the thing for Make Trade fair). Or they should at least do a photo shoot together...if they havent already...i need to look into that. But then i might explode from looking at too much hotness...ok, scratch that idea...i couldnt take it...
wow its weird to hear the scottish accent comin through in garys voice, pretty cool, im used to hearin it like an irish accent, but then when hes doin a song thats usually a stronger irish accent its clearer... if you know what i mean lol, go gary and damien (Y)
He did a doughty jog - not perfect but good. :-)
Sterndi1 3 weeks ago
@Sterndi1 Job, you idiot. ;-)
Sterndi1 3 weeks ago
I SOOOO love Gary's voice.
javicons 3 months ago
Actually have to admit, Gary sounds like he's singing this just for the sake of doing the cover. He's playing the chords, he's hitting the notes, but there's a definite absence of something here...
Nekhben1 3 months ago 2
i just wish it had better quality .. so could enjoy this beautiful song more !
TJakonia 3 months ago
Irish!
IwudDie4You 4 months ago
I hoped that he would have made this sound differently, beautifully good ......but sadly he didn't......
MyMarsters 5 months ago
I like snow patrol but this is awfull...
tsoglani81 9 months ago 2
only damien rice can sing this and have you feeling like someone stabbed you in the liver and you're rolling on the floor bleeding. damien rice has his melancholy, gary has his sadness - it just so happens that this cover didnt work.
agentapathy 9 months ago 3
Brillant song <3 i love it :) xxx
leanne4musicx 1 year ago
I'm a big fan of Gary Lightbody. But this is unacceptable and emotionless.
randomly0selected 1 year ago 5
Not an easy cover and I would have to say it was an excellent effort. Damien Rice is a tough act to follow. All in All very nice. For a lovely version in Brazilian Portuguese search Ana Carolina -Sue Jorge blowers daughter. Even if you can't understand the language, the music and their beautiful voices as well as the natural beauty of the Brazilian Portuguese language is guaranteed to move you.
Krazede 1 year ago
this has been a ole fave of mine thx for adding x
mrshubbles 1 year ago
It just so equisite. I have no words--just beautiful.
1Domokun1 1 year ago 3
This is clearly Damien's song and always will be but Gary's voice is so beautiful. Loved this!
skiergirl67 1 year ago 3
this song is beautiful!
Gary with that wonderful voice accompanied by such lovely Irish accent ... it was just perfect!!!
marrenta100 1 year ago 3
Wheres the passion? that's what makes the song stand out, I like snow patrol, but Fuck me, That's Terrible
hawkins10101 1 year ago 3
I really like his lisp
DarkSwordlessLink66 1 year ago
I love this version his voice is beautiful...
alouise32 1 year ago 3
Thanks for all the comments, positive and negative! Everyone has their own opinion and in mines Gary does a cracking job taking this song on! Was quite a gutsy thing to do with all the love for the original.
robinl93 1 year ago 8
never like Damien...there are no feelings. go and clear some snow
statusquo000 1 year ago 5
this is amazing!
jack1707 1 year ago 3
I can't take my eyes off you " Gary " (fact)
dianaeumema 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stick to chasing cars Gazza.
timmyedwards 2 years ago
don't agree..I think Gary actually has a better voice, sounds clearer or fuller, but doesnt mean I dont appreciate Damien's version though:)
lauramegg 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well done this guy for butchering a modern classic.
dankw90 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sounds like a dodgy bootleg.
paultgreen 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This sucks. I thought it was Ray LaMontage, now that gay can sing.
eemorn 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
GAY
ratical30 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lightbody LIGHTWEIGHT!!
oldcrowmedshow 2 years ago
OMG OMG OMG OMG...is so beautiful !!!!
dianaeumema 2 years ago 16
One of the greatest songs ever written.
dirtydawg1 2 years ago 3
Don't shoot me but ... I actually like Damien's version more (that being said, I know/love more songs by Snow Patrol than songs by Damien).
Just my honest opinion. Peace,
dmgamboa 2 years ago 31
Omg, he and Damien Rice is soooooo different. :D I love both versions. This, I love because it's so... Gary, it's soo him, and the original version shows Damien fully, so... no difference, but still, they're not the same. Don't compare, it ruins it all :)
Bogyesszamissza 2 years ago 2
gary u no wat lad, thats a cover of a tune......
cmon the irish, im a lurgan man u no folks 23 miles from this guy
MrKieranlittle 2 years ago
kermit at 1.08
manunut79 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol, well put.
i hate this cover. bloody awful.
skbfamiliar 2 years ago
this about 3 yrs ago...i mean the pic and the recording as well
mrshubbles 2 years ago
One of my favorite songs..not bad! The beard is not good though!
mayajane3 2 years ago
omg perfect ur irish u got the voice for it love this song by damien rice too :) xx
myusernamesux321 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the original is not from damien rice...... you should hear it in brazilian, that's the true and best version. "ana carolina e seu jorge - é isso aí"
anateresaserafino 2 years ago
You have it all wrong. Damien Rice wrote this song in 2000-2001, and Ana Carolina did a cover of it with Seu Jorge in 2004. Damien Rice wrote the original, the man is genius as a songwriter.
fmrc69 2 years ago 3
Na verdade, o original é do Damien, ele lançou no disco "O" em 2002, já Ana Carolina e Seu Jorge traduziram a música em 2004 para o DVD Ao vivo intitulado "Ana e Jorge".
Daniel1809 2 years ago
what does this say about damien rice's songs if he's doing a cover of it on radio 1 lol
bobbsta 2 years ago
i dont know.. what does it say?
weeirdal 2 years ago
theres really no scottish in that accent when is talking, its a typical belfast accent man
proclame 2 years ago
theyr both irish! aint they ..?
myusernamesux321 2 years ago
tHIS GUY WHO WROTE IT HAS THE FELLING AND OF COURSE HE SINGS BETTER.
masqueradeseries 3 years ago
:) Love Damien Rice!
cluedo1 2 years ago
Damien Rice is better in my opinion of cours
maharasztra 3 years ago 5
aey too right, it lacks something waht damien rice gives it
kyliroth 3 years ago 2
duh.
covers never invoke the same feeling as the original.
xlyricallies7x 2 years ago
agreed. I bet if Gary sung the song first then they would say Oh Damien doesnt sing it as well! some people just dont get it. Great version of it
xiadyn2205 2 years ago 3
he sings good but i like damien's orginal version
olkinia 3 years ago 5
I love this song, but not this version of it.
MonaLieske 3 years ago 2
Didn't Gary and Damo have a bit of a row over Lisa at one stage?
Scoob505 3 years ago
ohhhh Gary, you beautiful man you...i love Garrrrrrrry... Gary, Damien Rice, and Glen Hansard should all get together and do something (besides the thing for Make Trade fair). Or they should at least do a photo shoot together...if they havent already...i need to look into that. But then i might explode from looking at too much hotness...ok, scratch that idea...i couldnt take it...
veedle18 3 years ago 7
wow its weird to hear the scottish accent comin through in garys voice, pretty cool, im used to hearin it like an irish accent, but then when hes doin a song thats usually a stronger irish accent its clearer... if you know what i mean lol, go gary and damien (Y)
lonestarinfinate 3 years ago
Gary's from Belfast!! He has a gorgeous voice, wherever he is from
janetlovescally 3 years ago
I know, but hes spent a lot of time in Scotland, giving him the other half of his accent... not sure if thats what u mean.
lonestarinfinate 3 years ago
Oh i understand what you mean now!!
janetlovescally 3 years ago
TBH I here all bangorrrr like:)
Onetreehillroxloads 2 years ago
nice one
lauraburke81 3 years ago 2
Love the song, and Snow Patrol is my favorite band, so this makes me SO HAPPY!! Beautiful cover!
kaitie07 3 years ago 2
its very good, but not anywhere near the original, but then i suppose it wasnt really wrriten to his style
gunner2903 3 years ago 3
Nice
krusader85 3 years ago 2
I love Gary's version!
LemonOperations 3 years ago 3
perfect.
danita90stars 3 years ago 2
no offense but that lisp or w/e..."i cant sake my eyes off you"...is really bothering me...but a fellow irishman's efforts should be rejoiced
didoma73 3 years ago 2
I swear...Gary Lightbody can cover ANY song!! AMAZING!
19valleygirl88 3 years ago 3
BEAUTIFUL!!!!!
undomiel152003 4 years ago 4
exellant version of this song.
beanofgauze 4 years ago 4