It's not a big deal if a later version's is better. Is the man who came up with the wheel barrow better than the man who came up with the wheel and the... large pot object. Therapy already had the outline of what to do. All they had to do was improve, not actually create.
i know a whole lot of their songs, but i was pretty much like a bag of potatoe myself (and so were all of my friends), because the thing was so boring, that it didn't make me move my mouth or my feet at all
well I don't know. maybe it was because the gig was in Hungary and they didn't really care much about it. i don't know. but the whole thing sounded as if some high-school tribute band with no musical talent or knowledge would be trying to do their songs. i don't remember if there were too many screwups, i would rather say the whole performance was just FLAT. no life, no energy, no nothing. flatter than on the album, although live performance should be just the opposite
does anyone else think they're worse than crap live? i was so eager to see them last summer, cause i love their albums, but the gig was pretty much F minus, or rather G. huge disappointment, but i still like the albums, and this song as well
@tolvajakos nah, ive seen them 3 times, i'll admit one was a little disappointing, cos it was in a small club, sound quality sucked and the whole crowd stood there like bags of potatoes cos no-one seemed to know their songs, but the band still gave it their all in there. also went to their 20th anniversary thing in london last year which was one of the best gigs ive ever been to :) was so good
oh man, thanks so much for uploading this video. Troublegum was one of the most strange punk/metal records ever made, good thing it came out in the 90s. Before or after it wouldn't be appreciated as it was: an intelligent record for intelligent headbangers! Thanks Therapy?!!!!!
@alexhamster1134 No. Does that disappoint you Pal? Guess you'll just have to go back to wrapping your hamster in duct tape. When it comes to this, you get what you deserve. lol
just recently been turned onto this band by readin them as being influences fr a few great bands of today like the answer, i ave to say joy division seems to be an influence in this tune particularly in the verses.....fr more great modern music check out The Answer, superb pure rock n roll band that deserve to be counted among the greats free led zep etc. they are just as gud,
Joy Division and Ian are masters to me,but this Therapy? version of this song is a lot better than the original,more anger,more noise,more pain,more hate!!!!
Has anyone seen the original Therapy? vid for this - it was fucked up & way better - really edgy - they had someone (A girl I think) imprisoned & were pissing on her & gennerally being nasty, not that I think thats "Good Behaviour" but it really enhanced the lyrics. It was on mtv for 5mins then the next tiome I saw the video it had been changed for this:(
<3 Joy Division,one of my fave bands..but they have so much better songs,this ain't sumthin(original)..this is sooo much better..agree on improvement comment :)
I can't stand the original version, I don't consider this a cover, I consider it an improvement. I saw Therapy? in concert twice in DC. They were fraking awesome! Bought us drinks before the show and everything. They played this song and things went crazy.
good call. great cover though. 'pleasure death' and 'babyteeth', and to a lesser extent 'nurse' were great though (early albums were rough, just like jd would have been live).
actually, i've heard a fair few that are better than the original. more often than not it's because of improved production (see bullet for my valentine's creeping death)
like the vid, prefer teh original joy divsion but they dun a gd job favouriting thsi coz im just gettin in to this band and wana find as much as possible :P
Bravo
serdarzulu 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am so glad that eyeearbrain.webs.com sent me here. Best tune ever!
henceseventytwo 2 months ago
Interesting, he sings the verses with the melody of Atrocity Exhibition instead of the original melody of Isolation.
AmitErezTube 2 months ago
great cover they realy addsomethingtoit
Andreasleon27 4 months ago
I had no idea this was a cover until just recently. So I checked out the Joy Division original. ...yeah...I'll stick with this one.
Rick951 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Therapy? 2
@Rick951 What are you insinuating about Joy Division?
TheJonathantheMoss 2 weeks ago
@TheJonathantheMoss They just ain't my bag, man. At least in this instance.
Rick951 2 weeks ago
@Rick951 Fair enough. Although a lot of their songs were more guitar orientated and less synth based
TheJonathantheMoss 2 weeks ago
Babyteeth is amazing it was like nothing I had ever heard .
superzapper 5 months ago
What the ...
Snowdog000 5 months ago
IRISH METAL UP YOUR ARSE
SummernlightningUSA 5 months ago
12 ppl needs isolation
findejs666 6 months ago 4
@findejs666 You mean 416 and think about what is good and bad.
kivzzzz 4 months ago
@findejs666 I own a great isolation room at my basement and a smaler one atched to my bedroom ;)
TheMardeni 3 months ago
hated it
GamerXY7 6 months ago
You should have been there when We got locked in at the Brixton Academy in 1995.
Riot outside so they decided to carry on playing and did "White Riot" by the Clash..!
Best Live Gig I've ever been to......
and a turned over burning car outside.
Some people need to get out more........Isolation?
gabacabriel 7 months ago 2
@gabacabriel I'll never forget that night, was awesome. Walked out post gig wondering what the hell was going on! Priceless...
CrazybladeUK 3 months ago
It's not a big deal if a later version's is better. Is the man who came up with the wheel barrow better than the man who came up with the wheel and the... large pot object. Therapy already had the outline of what to do. All they had to do was improve, not actually create.
DavKatch 8 months ago
This version is neither better nor worse than the original one, it's just different. I like both.
HBFrance 8 months ago
fuck yeah this video rulezzzz god dawn what a memories please 90,s come back
gjoyride1 9 months ago
great band, started to listen to them this morning after years of being away...
MrPessoa79 9 months ago
no.
SongWritingBum 10 months ago
i know a whole lot of their songs, but i was pretty much like a bag of potatoe myself (and so were all of my friends), because the thing was so boring, that it didn't make me move my mouth or my feet at all
tolvajakos 1 year ago
well I don't know. maybe it was because the gig was in Hungary and they didn't really care much about it. i don't know. but the whole thing sounded as if some high-school tribute band with no musical talent or knowledge would be trying to do their songs. i don't remember if there were too many screwups, i would rather say the whole performance was just FLAT. no life, no energy, no nothing. flatter than on the album, although live performance should be just the opposite
tolvajakos 1 year ago
does anyone else think they're worse than crap live? i was so eager to see them last summer, cause i love their albums, but the gig was pretty much F minus, or rather G. huge disappointment, but i still like the albums, and this song as well
tolvajakos 1 year ago
@tolvajakos nah, ive seen them 3 times, i'll admit one was a little disappointing, cos it was in a small club, sound quality sucked and the whole crowd stood there like bags of potatoes cos no-one seemed to know their songs, but the band still gave it their all in there. also went to their 20th anniversary thing in london last year which was one of the best gigs ive ever been to :) was so good
what was so bad about the gig you saw?
andymetaldeth 1 year ago
Comment removed
sanjurodog 1 year ago
Comment removed
sanjurodog 1 year ago
two more weeks and i'm seeing them again after 14 years.........
vorphyltd 1 year ago
This actualy feels darker than the Joy Division original
Realy gets under my skin
I love it
theagk19781 1 year ago
oh man, thanks so much for uploading this video. Troublegum was one of the most strange punk/metal records ever made, good thing it came out in the 90s. Before or after it wouldn't be appreciated as it was: an intelligent record for intelligent headbangers! Thanks Therapy?!!!!!
b1blebash3r 1 year ago
better than the original
wimvanlaeree 1 year ago
@wimvanlaeree Get real mate,nowhere near as good as the original an I'm a HUGE Therapy fan
AccyRed 1 year ago
i was lookin 4 this song 4 so long finally thanks i love this band ......please go back 80 pleaase
gjoyride1 1 year ago
don't like this.
boomhauwer2 1 year ago
I love the way Fyfe Ewing, the drummer (and founder of Therapy? btw), is dressed in this video. So. Bad ass. Yummy.
sanjurodog 1 year ago
@sanjurodog gay?
alexhamster1134 1 year ago
@alexhamster1134 No. Does that disappoint you Pal? Guess you'll just have to go back to wrapping your hamster in duct tape. When it comes to this, you get what you deserve. lol
sanjurodog 1 year ago
@sanjurodog you leave my hamster out of this :p
alexhamster1134 1 year ago 3
@alexhamster1134 LOL
sanjurodog 1 year ago
nice try. original's much better
teddyballgame406 1 year ago
Wicked.
sanjurodog 1 year ago
Dear Therapy,
I admit your version is catchy but you shouldn't touch songs that shouldn't touched.
MrMUGS94 1 year ago
brilliant
dewagen 1 year ago
Both great bands. I just hate Joy Division covers.
sweet518 1 year ago
black and white so much between ...
great vid ...
great song ...
great performance ...
.
tthanks for showin ...
Iamstilllearnin 1 year ago
wow fuckin wow magic cover
akastuntfish 1 year ago 3
good days
12connection 2 years ago
Ohh Yea! I can always use a little Therapy? and I'm not talking about those bullshit head Docters either.
LokedOut4Lyfe 2 years ago 5
Very true!
"Therapist" breaks down into 2 words:
1 - The
2 - ...
Machimbombo 2 years ago 3
What a great song with amazing lyrics, thanks to Ian Curtis (RIP!)
missedexit 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i just wish the guitar wasn't such a high pitch. ... it'd be a masterpiece if the guitar was tuned lower...imo
his voice has me captivated though...
goal100to95to90 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Goatees are face vaginas
drunkingham 2 years ago
shame your chicken won't fit then. Oh sorry...Cock
fishbaby73 2 years ago
These guys rock, evolution, love, life, technology, vote libertarian, long live the free market, cars are crashing...
libertarianjury 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
anyone seen the singer now ? he looks like a nightclub doorman
dragonfitter 2 years ago
troublegum still owns
ratbatblue555 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
gah! shallow as shite. why does any band try to copy jd. a pointless exercise (1).
coetmor 2 years ago
I totally get you.. it is hard to accept when a newer band comes out with a better version.. I understand your deception..
don't worry! Joy Division is still a great band.
tortelli 2 years ago 23
@tortelli Great retort it pisses over Joy division's version like metallica would say SAD BUT TRUE
emmalogie 1 year ago
@tortelli A new band?????????
You people are crazy this song is from the mid 90s when therapy? were becoming awesome!
Harrysound 1 year ago
@Harrysound but the original dates the early 80's..
tortelli 1 year ago
best band i saw at oxegen
harrvesterofsorrow 2 years ago 2
Rock on. :)
doubtseventhere 2 years ago 3
One of the best covers ever recorded.
Obviously.
ugforthewin 2 years ago 12
bring on oxegen.. cant wait to see them!
oisint2 2 years ago
neil cooper (therapy? drummer) is my drum teacher :P
cornishpasty11 2 years ago
just recently been turned onto this band by readin them as being influences fr a few great bands of today like the answer, i ave to say joy division seems to be an influence in this tune particularly in the verses.....fr more great modern music check out The Answer, superb pure rock n roll band that deserve to be counted among the greats free led zep etc. they are just as gud,
clince121188 2 years ago
It sounds like a Joy Division song because it IS a Joy Division song. Bless X
Theraptorxx 2 years ago 8
that made me laugh the dumbass
dragonfitter 2 years ago
Joy Division rules!
czermy 2 years ago 2
There's no percentage high enough to express how good your statement is.
KidA270 2 years ago 3
They are the Support Band of die ärzte
in Linz in Austria in June!!!
There are 2 great bands on one day!!!
Embrioridkiller 2 years ago
Therapy? are so much better than Die Ärzte...anyway.
See them in four days in Cologne...yeah.
FrankyHaemmer 2 years ago
I am on the gig in Berlin this upcoming Monday, this is gonna be fucking awesome. Never been on a Therapy? gig
GermanMovieMaker 2 years ago
Therapy? are a great live band. Have seen them many times. The new album is pretty good. Their best since ten years, in my opinion.
Have fun in Berlin...it will be fucking awesome. :p
FrankyHaemmer 2 years ago
Getting back together? I didn`t think they`d ever split up??
slaytanic1 2 years ago 3
they didnt that guy knows nothing...
Alkalinetime 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
amazing one of the best bands ever......wish they were still around
saunciefancie 2 years ago
they are still around! they just released a new album ffs lol
adamthecat116 2 years ago 4
lmao saunciefancie you fecking eejit!
Alkalinetime 2 years ago
I miss this band so so SO SO much I seen them live at tattoo the planet In Ireland years ago, they were brilliant.
Whats the story with them getting back together???
Rafterman280 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
they are still around! they just released a new album ffs lol
adamthecat116 2 years ago
oh my god what a great Joy Division cover.. I really like it =)
volec 2 years ago
Andy's glare is creepy. awesome :]
97bugs 2 years ago
Who gave Dante from Clerks a guitar? Ghastly.
Fauxpat 2 years ago 2
@Fauxpat I laughed, you utter fucking genius!
FieryBiscuits 1 year ago
Joy Division and Ian are masters to me,but this Therapy? version of this song is a lot better than the original,more anger,more noise,more pain,more hate!!!!
prozacpeople 3 years ago 2
so true! totally agree with you
tortelli 2 years ago
when this was played live no1s feet were touching the floor
milkit06 3 years ago
Has anyone seen the original Therapy? vid for this - it was fucked up & way better - really edgy - they had someone (A girl I think) imprisoned & were pissing on her & gennerally being nasty, not that I think thats "Good Behaviour" but it really enhanced the lyrics. It was on mtv for 5mins then the next tiome I saw the video it had been changed for this:(
skylandmountain 3 years ago
Best Joy Division cover!
Great Therapy?
nahtyman 3 years ago 2
nice!!
10tacles 3 years ago
Never knew this was a JD cover when i first heard the Therapy? version years ago.
They do make it their own though.
fadeintoyou77 3 years ago
deff the BEST Joy Division cover ever! TY for postin =)
mrrotweiler2 3 years ago
best band to ever come from n-ireland
AdamCW2k5 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
GUESS wot the singer/guitarist in this band is my second uncle whoo im rock royalty!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tom36450 3 years ago
guess wat no one gives a fuck
spudsucker 3 years ago 17
@spudsucker
the lads in therapy probably do though
shanahanism 1 year ago
Dont listen too em, be proud! (But let this be a lesson in how mean the net is)
PS
that other guy is kinda right though!
skylandmountain 3 years ago
wtf why am i getting negatives for no fucking reason? you fucktards...
Tom¬_¬
If at first you dont succeed pretend that you never tried
tom36450 3 years ago
nice
harryhillys 3 years ago 2
<3 Joy Division,one of my fave bands..but they have so much better songs,this ain't sumthin(original)..this is sooo much better..agree on improvement comment :)
laelar101 3 years ago
I can't stand the original version, I don't consider this a cover, I consider it an improvement. I saw Therapy? in concert twice in DC. They were fraking awesome! Bought us drinks before the show and everything. They played this song and things went crazy.
JesterTDA 3 years ago
UR RITE THAT IS THE COVER a love it
loopylas101 3 years ago
Best.cover.ever
Pissedman 3 years ago 3
Superb band. Check all their albums out especially 'Never apologise, never explain'.
eamonreillydotcom 3 years ago
David Brent can rock too. Fact.
MrSifter8 3 years ago
Excellet cover!
facu6 3 years ago 5
yep.
RUReady2BUnplugged 3 years ago
great cover.
BryanUK666 3 years ago 3
Nice cover, but I prefer the original.
neph57 3 years ago 2
good call. great cover though. 'pleasure death' and 'babyteeth', and to a lesser extent 'nurse' were great though (early albums were rough, just like jd would have been live).
miceal27 3 years ago
I can also hear a bit of Atrocity Exhibition in there - two JD cover versions for the price of one
fl3mster 3 years ago
I've been looking for this song!!
thanks!
Infinitypart2 3 years ago
So cute... Andy looks like a Teddy Bear!
ThePortugueseAtheist 3 years ago
Lest we forget that Therapy? still rock. Find "one cure fits all," indulge through listening...then await their next album
wingspanpenworthy 4 years ago 3
Great version, even better than the original....just my opinion.
ichabod1920 4 years ago
Que canción y que época! Mediados de los 90's! Gracias por colgar éste video hermano.
uea978 4 years ago 3
savage,this band had some great tunes
irishgunner32 4 years ago 3
one of the few cover versions that are better than the original, really
weldzuma 4 years ago 4
no way but not bad at all
therabbit27 3 years ago
actually, i've heard a fair few that are better than the original. more often than not it's because of improved production (see bullet for my valentine's creeping death)
Negimaniac 3 years ago
Immaculate ?
Rawlinson16 4 years ago
like the vid, prefer teh original joy divsion but they dun a gd job favouriting thsi coz im just gettin in to this band and wana find as much as possible :P
Nek1a 4 years ago
A great cover.Therapy? took the song shaped it to their own musical style, but yet the singing reminds something from the original.
brokebackgio 4 years ago 3
my early years nice sing
notss1 4 years ago
nice Joy Division's cover
DabaMyroad 4 years ago 2
nice song.
adhemir82 4 years ago
Awesome!!! Great album and excellent band. I wish more songs from Troublegum gets uploaded! ^^
Thanks, MelomanoAntiguo for upload.
soul4tran 4 years ago