Xpenzif free energy screw magnet motor Replica DEBUNKED!!!!!

[frenchy137]

those screws are magnetic?

[boboghoghogh]

what a load of old cock, you magnet rapist go lick some tape and stick your head in a rusty spoon

[lokeycmos]

im with dodecadude

[DodecaDude]

I gave this video a thumbs down because I can't hear what you are saying over the music. Pet peeves: 1) video sound polluted by background noise (TVs, Music, traffic, fans, machines, pets, etc.) while trying to communicate an idea. 2) Absence of a nifty tool called a "tripod" to hold the camera steady. 3) Low lighting. I watch videos because I'm interested in what you have to say, want to see what you have to show & comment to help you be more effective at communicating your thoughts.

[fox9577]

wtg man awesome

[silver91183]

let me tell you in plain English Its Shit....

[WarzSchoolchild]

Full marks for the attempt at replication, but why could you not find an old scrap hard drive? there must be millions of them out there! and why did you use wee tiny flat disc magnets, and not cylinder magnets as demonstrated? I don't even think your screws were the same. You do science a disservice if you botch a replication, not a service!...none of us are left any wiser. just frustrated!...but thank you for "doing" rather than "typing useless comments".

[MrHobiecat]

wasting your time. Free energy machines area scam, they violate the known laws of physics and the people that promote them are CON ARTISTS. You cant debunk a CON ARTIST with truth or reality, because they are not dealing with reality, they are looking for suckers who will hand them money to develope their BS ideas. And by develope I mean they take your money and spend it on something ELSE.

[Justwantahover]

@MrHobiecat "And by develope I mean take your money and spend it on something ELSE". That's the only thing I suppose, but there could be a "fantasy phenomenon" as well and they genuinely and sincerely are totally convinced, and have even built one and comment that it works. Like young earth creationists, their belief is astounding!

[theonethatgoofs]

make your noise in front of walmart . .

[garotomorto]

I'll try it. very cheap to build

[ktm626sxc]

Everyone wants to do somthing special..BUTT THIS IS NOT IT...its just stupidity

[FreakEyy]

@ktm626sxc is a fag

[gasgasbones]

You should give up mate!!!!!

[CRutgerXryzis]

would this device work if you made a think diagonal line, going downwards across the suface of the circle, followed by an immediate thin diagonal line, then a thickdiagonal line, etc.etc. like a screw but then without the base getting smaller.

[spikeychops]

Come on..props for build effort, but your example of replication leaves a lot to be desired when considering how well engineered yours is, compared to the original motor, even as a crude prototype.

Don't get me wrong, i appreciate you effort, but there are many things wrong with yours. The whole screw tube wobbles violently, and approaches the magnets quite a way..the stator isn't. It is allowed to move, when it should be still. One or both of these could be causing braking, not acceleration.

[shadowbender]

whats the name of the song?

[ottgooroth]

looks like your mounting for the magnets are at the wrong angle.

[ILoveSoImAlive]

there is one simple method to understand such devices better. if there are some small simmilar parts, just try to see them as one bigger part. so just look at 4 magnets like at one magnet and 4 screws like one piece of metall. what will u predict after that? magnets and metall will attract each other and stop where whole distance between magnet and metall is at minimum. <|

M <| <|

something like that

[ILoveSoImAlive]

@ILoveSoImAlive doh u cant see the ascii picture. spaces and nextlines are removed.

[TechPro3]

it requires more preciseness

[antorise1]

hi i have a video of a pretty working simple decice that really works. want it send me a message or call me. colombia 57-3158334959

[kimuhsleinad]

The "stator" is too far away from the screws is the first observation. Secondly that is the crappiest, cheapest, most wobbly built in 20 mins peice ive seen out of all these free energy vids. Debunk, lol more like dejunk, throw that thing in the dump dude cuz it sux.

[Mastahscott]

man that one that worked was in balance and things were even and even then it was hard to get going , you need a lot more quality in your build , things need to be more even and the magnets need to be shielded from each other , dont say it doesnt work based on your build , cause your build is not right and the screws are not even place right, if you did research before you started as you say , then you didnt follow your own research or your comprehension sucks.

[count3rculture]

I thik it needs to be exact in all dimensions with rotation and everything also it needs to be frictionless and sturdy aswell as lightwaight

Its notviable as a large engine but still godd as a perpetual desktop toy

[TheLoonwolf]

Hmmm. Interesting how you 'debunk' it by making it so badly. I've seen another video of a much better made one that actually seems to work. Hard to say though. But I think it MAY be worth trying this one out, since it is so simple to make.

[kmusco89]

This was the biggest waste of my life why do pathetic people like you find it necessary to make pointless videos like this?

[spindlegrinder]

All I'm saying is get it spinning and producing power so the rest of us can learn

[spindlegrinder]

Too much talk not enough action

[Greenpeace82]

right

[DieTheDeath]

@ greenlivingitup . com it shows how to build a free energy device with magnets

[Bramm1982]

The attracting forces are always the same as the repelling forces. You can use square magnets, tubes, give them an offset or do whatever you want. You'll gain zero! An uneven distribution might turn the ring 359 degrees, but it won't have gained enough (like in more than the starting) energy to pass the starting point again and accelerate.

[Mwstmrlnd]

Unless it has some sort of starting force, you wouldn't get any rotation. I completely agree. Clearly, since he has to use gravity to even start it spinning, this isn't a true magnet motor. The thing I like about this vid though is that you can see that whatever goes on in the vid is not faked in any way.

[kurbage]

If your going to put someone elses work down then atleast build it the best you can and if that is, then just give up and apologize when the rest of us figure this out. Anything is possible you should be supporting ideas helping it work better. Im not sure if the screw method works but im not going to spend my time debating about it.

[MegaTweek420]

lol..its called super glue,dude!!!easy on the tape!!!

[antonio79b]

totally agree withwealthfinder192!!

[camellude97]

i just wasted 6 mins of my life....

[wealthfinder192]

My theory is some detractors on you tube are working for companies opposed to magnetic motors. Including Govt and oil companies. These will be both people posting videos and those commenting on them. As for this video unfortunately the machine was not made very well and the stator is too far away plus the uneven spin etc. Leave it up to your own imagination. I know it can and has worked just not this one. There are plenty already made and working so why people insist on making more is beyond me.

[killerbeenl]

I've seen the orriginal video. Buth you're screw alignment is not nicely like a correct a wave he did and the motion seperation of the rows isn't correct. Buth if it works if you do so. I don't now.

[ackenna]

could be most efficient if those screw are being replaced with magnet with oposited polarity with the stator. greetings

[1crazyfocker]

see this one proves my point one day it may work but the other one was fake becouse it was going the wrong way

its will move from the smallest point to the larger part or head of the screw

[emmanueljx]

place a electric magnet under the table

that will keep it going if the electric mag is plugged in

[bruckator]

:'-(

[djahriman]

You teach best what you most need to learn. It seems that (from my humble perspective) you have a lot to learn.

I hope to teach you, and others like you.

[djahriman]

You teach best what you most need to learn, Human.

[xrayrep]

I think my grandson (who is 9 years old) could have put together a more robust and accurate magnet motor. But like all "Free Energy" magnet motors, IT CAN NOT WORK! If free energy was reality, then why don't we see items powered by magnet motors being sold in Walmart? Where are all these free energy motors that everyone claims they made work? The reason why you don't see them on store shelves or in products is because THEY DON'T WORK!!!! WAKE UP PEOPLE! THEY DON'T WORK!!!

[djahriman]

You're an idiot. The world's economy is based upon money. And the biggest most powerful sources of monetary generation in this world today are the energy companies. If energy was freely available to everyone (which theoretically it is, think about the sun), then said companies would be trillions of dollars out of pocket each year.

Get your head out of your arse already.

[xrayrep]

Calling me an idiot only shows what kind of person YOU are. And your argument about the energy companies preventing free energy devices is not valid at all. That is the typical excuse that Free Energy followers use to justify the fact that none of their silly little contraptions work. The only "free energy" you really can get is wind or solar power. You can never get free energy from magnets or water. You need to educate yourself about basic highschool physics.

[djahriman]

Never, not once in my post did I say that free energy was possible nor was it possible to be gained from Water or Magnets. Perhaps you should re-read and stop your primary school assumptions? Just a thought.

Anyway, IF you're that blind to see my point about energy companies, that's fair enough and I really do not care. I just wish the general population wasn't as blatantly retarded as you.

Please keep your assumptions to yourself, and please try not to assume that we are all as retarded as you.

[xrayrep]

Free Energy IS possible and people make use of it every day. The problem that I have is with people who actually think that they can get free energy from magnets or water. YouTube is FULL of guys like that. But hey, if they have nothing better to do I'd rather see them working on those perpetual motion machines than doing drugs or robbing banks! LOL

Have a good life (you need to get one!).

[djahriman]

Then please don't be one of those wankers and PROVE it when you say that Free Energy is possible!

No offense, but don't say shit you can't back up, please. Personally i'd rather the world come together and spend all our energy on positive and procreative things, absolutely one hundred percent. You're quite right though, most of the stuff people post here are either full of shit, or just posting for "LOOK AT ME" status.

Immediate future of free energy I can see is only the Sun. For now!

[xrayrep]

You called me an idiot, then you said that I'm retarded TWICE, and now you say "No offense"?? Whether you know it or not, those attacks were quite offensive, pal. When someone starts attacking on a personal level rather than attacking the subject matter, it just proves that your argument is very weak, and so you feel that you need to attack the person by calling names. That's something that school children do.

Anyhow, yes free energy is being used in the form of wind and solar power.

[djahriman]

You idiot retard, retarded idiot, lol.

You had the ability to debunk a so called personal attack by a higher level of thinking, which you did not, thankfully making your intellect apparent.

I have to lol though. I urge you not to take life soo seriously, let alone the inane ramblings of some retard online (that being myself) so seriously.

AND geothermic energy too dude... it's unfortunately not used as much as it should be.

But when we get to the quantum level, things will get better.

[djahriman]

By the way. All I did was ask you to prove it when you said free energy was possible, backing it up whenever necessary. Then I went on a compatible tangent agreeing with you, and you spark this "i'm offended" tirade, which only proves your own point about how your own subject matter is very weak.

You've given me food for thought though.

I assume you'd be a terriffic person to debate things in person with, albeit primitive. As all debates tend to be (especially on the internet).

[maox1001]

im too lazy to read all of these comments, but i dont see any of your arguments about energy companies not preventing free energy devices developing. basically, if i was in charge of any electrical company, i would think a million times before letting this kind of technology go, causing my traditional methods of gaining electricity not wanted.and thats all about money.

and about that free energy stuff.i more than sure,that this is possible,probably even with magnets.just a little more insight

[goonerno14]

yea i watch the one by xpensiv , from what i saw on his one is that he had some how cut the screws in half and flatened the heads of the screws, where yours look like there round and also still got the slots in them , also your magnets are a quarter of the size . i dont think he faked it just think when he nudges it to get it started thats the energy that makes it go and eventually it will stop , it wouldnt keep revolving forever .

[maxdownhill]

The crappiest crappiest crappiest presentation.. WHATS WITH THE MUSIC DUDE; MAKES ME SICK!! And your "tech" sucks! Practice with LEGO before moving on to empty rolls of tape.. Sorry for the mean words,. I appreciate you taking time and trying to do this... But PLEASE, this whole presentation is lousy!

[lmusho]

Bad replica, poor construction. Otherwise it might actually work

[jacoscience1]

show it spining

[JaycubL]

If you make another, the slant of each column should be more.

[chadthailand]

I hope you did not give up. Three guys have told you the answer. Just get a better understanding of what a ferromagnetic does for xpenif's device. I've already built a working replica. Don't give up that is not true genius. Like a magic trick when you know how to do it, then you wonder how you didn't see the answer right in front of you.

[sarahsharmaine09]

Your replica should be made more accurate. And your voice must be audible enough to get your point. Thank you anyway for you effort.

[FreeMagneticEnergy]

It's the shape of the heads on the screws is the problem, as they are not tapered the same. The heads of the screws have way to much bulk on them. Use the exact same screws for best possible results.

[illumineprojects]

Nice work (though it's difficult to hear you over the music). Both this device and xpenzif's device ultimately do the same thing: they both seek equilibrium. This one just finds it a little sooner than xpenzif's, most likely due to reasons already mentioned by other viewers. It's relatively easy to find these points of equilibrium if you break the force vectors into their corresponding components (it may also help explain why a device stops at a certain point). Thanks for posting.

[planexzeropoint]

the original wasn't faked it might be something to do with

1: your cardboard tube

2:not using a sweet harddrive as the spindle

3:your stator not being to well made

4:what the screws are made of or

5: dude it looked like that took you 10 mins to build and 8 of these were glue drying.

be careful with the word debunked unless you've built it better and tried all the variables.

but keep it up the more trying to source magnetic energy the better. just take a little more care next time. :)

[MrWombatPPC]

mumbl mumbl...

[rickbriere]

It is good that your trying to duplicate and prove to yourself but but to be fair to the original inventor or poster make sure that you build his design as well or better than he did to validate. I think magnets may be an answer but precision in the design may be the key. Try it again with a precise design and see what happens.

[ddrusa]

just show it spining

[SteveMontuno]

go easy dude,only needs some magnet sheilding

[particlejunkie]

I see this is young man of only 16 years and replication and presenting of information is very poor as with other videos. I not say that this one motor design specifically work but I know of two other unlike designs that do. I see personally and examine them. Therefore to me it is possible. Boy here not know importance of geometry. Maybe he learn geometry and math when he get to 11th high school grade if he make it. Someday he make device that work after the whole universe already have first.

[lbcitezen]

good replication are you kidding me, dude in order for this to work crisp it needs to be calculated correctly.

[SteveMontuno]

great ,,,cant wait :)

[krazeekooladam]

MYLOW121363

[scarlejr]

I believe you need to sand the screw heads down, thats why yours stick. and the stator set up is not good. you need to be able to move it closer and further to find the "sweet spot".

I don't know if it works or not, but those are some suggestions.

[ppitodelos]

bla bla bla eso no funciona .

[elektronanacatl]

Hey send more videos, on this one I think that the magnets arent strong enough, but Im not sure ;)

[SteveMontuno]

hope you do another vid dude. take 2 ~screw magnet motor with sheilding:)

[SteveMontuno]

hope you try it dude

[SteveMontuno]

yes in the original im almost positive hes useing shielding ,,so your so close yet so far because like you say it cant work without the shielding,,,,,so it wasnt faked after all ,you just got the design wrong,,,good luck next time bro

[SteveMontuno]

it wont work without the magnet shielding on the stationary posts dude....and wood aint magnet shielding ,,,so break the shielding out of your hard drive and try it,,,,,nice try,,,tell me if im right :)

[revmkell]

have you ever hand cranked a generator and lite a 60 watt light bulb? Just get it to turn don't cut it.

[zecnobot]

a 6 minute video of a non-working prototype. fail

[doobedoo22]

The attractive force that draws a screw towards a magnet is equal to the attractive force that resists when the screw is moved away from the magnet.

So... it'll actually slow down sooner than if you just made a flywheel.

If you want free energy... build a windmill. They don't try to violate the second law of thermodynamics.

[Stormrunner0002]

This may be a repeat but I didn't see the first one.

4 Differences

1. The magnets are not in perfect alignment. 1 too far in - 2 too far out - 3 and 4 OK.

2. the first had the heads filed down so that the head surface was on the same plane as the screw length. Triangles of flat plate may work or T-pins.

3. Way too much glue was used to attach the screws.

4. Magnet pile looks a little off alignment, but may be the camera angle.

Good try though. The World is depending on you.

[energyscience]

thankz im remaking the motor

[exxxxxxxx]

thanks for wasting my time.

[edstar83]

heard of "outfoxed"? this is outyoutubed.

[energyscience]

well u guyz are paranoid about me working 'with the goverment', if u think you can disprove my replica that it dosent work, i'll accept that this idea was real all along.

:)

[zanobi]

I'm glad your trying to decide for yourself whether this stuff works, but really get it right. try to work until your machine works. don't try to disprove things b/c you don't like them.

btw its a distance function b/c it has to be within magnetic field effects. think about it. the closer they are the STRONGER they attract and repel.

[zanobi]

I wouldn't be surprised if you were working for the government. your ignoring the central relationships of each device. again I've never heard anything about tilting the machine to optimize rotation. these machines are gravity independant. if the screws are placed evenly on the spindel its not unbalanced in respect to gravity. also your magnets should be even on your stick.

[zanobi]

And if you want to disprove the george green motor. first of all its a model/toy.2 he says in the interview with project camelot that you should drill a hole in the circular magnet and run an axel through the hole. now what I've heard in other videos is that when you hook up your a/c power supply your supposed to wire off a 5th or so of your power output back into another electric motor to increase the output of the magnet engine. This also ensures that your engine wont stop running on a load.

[zanobi]

dude you did it wrong. The bottom row of screws is supposed to overlap the top row on the x axis so that it can carry easier to the next one. And your spacing is wrong. The magents spin the wheel faster when they are closer to the wheel. I haven't seen any models before with a swinging magnet holster. optimum distance is <.5cm. yours is almost 2cm.

[thinker757]

Its not like the "orginal"with flat screws.

[2012listo]

A reverse ionic breeze. Lightning. Burning hempseed oil. HHO generators. Adiabatic pedal cars. Compressed air engines filled by windmill. Tapping the earth's EM field. Water-fueled Internal Suppressed Detonation. For every problem, there are MILLIONS of solutions, some good, some not so good. keep trying.

[duwbryd]

Your design looks a little flawed.

[stephenawolfe]

I couldn't agree more. It isn't even designed to complete the cycle; how could that device ever have a chance?

[xXxGenasai]

i get it XD wow, never thought of that :3 but to make it work involes alot of precise equipment

[TheWorldiLivein]

whats the name of this song?

[29846932]

Que ganas de perder el tiempo para algo que no anda ni para atras...

[GlennW125]

This Video is CRAP! not a replica at all. too many incorrect factors play a roll in why this machine doesn't work. screws are not the same stainless steel metal used in the first video, as well as the shape is not the same. the spindle on which your "tape roll" is on sucks as you can see it wobbles so the distance is off, as well as the magnets you were using, there was not enough. fu*k*ng get it right next time.

[devilfirestorm]

one retarded attempt, nice try though, atleast ur honest about it

[ForestWusabbi]

moar liek ghetto generator

[Angelchaparro]

vales verga pendejo

[matantan101]

I don't get why people want to find out new ways to get free energy. we already have solar cells and wind farms which will allways be useing a more reliable, abundant, and much better than most every other source of free energy.

[bronxboyXXX]

The problem with solar is the panels are very expensive & produce very little energy, the problem with wind is its difficult to capture and we are charged for it. & the problem with both is if there is no wind or sun for a few days theres no power.

Also theres no chance you could ever use either to power a four passenger car unless its to charge the batteries of a limited range electric. The bottom line is If everybody had their own personal electric power plant there would be no problem.

[matantan101]

essentialy though, the only energy that it will give of is the energy you use to spin it, and if you attach an axle to a generator from the motor, then it will have sooooo little torque.

[matantan101]

Try makeing the magnet on to top of every row directly over the screw of the next.

[darkeyce02]

ppl are dumb, the wheel spinning by itself, if it did spin by itself is free energy, energy is it purely moveing by itself...

[LifeForVW]

1. mistake - wrong screws!it must have an wedge shape, 2. - the magnets its too small, 3. the distance is to long beween screws and magnet. 4. the spindle should run exactly, you get an changing distances with a radial imbalance

[minde4000]

This is a joke not a replica. Screw SHAPE ARRANGEMENT are CRITICAL factors. Stupid dude glues bunch of scerws and wants free energy. What is your intelligence level??? Its hard to believe there are dumb ass ppl and yet there are many....

[mrlustig]

sorry , this is a bad work

[1x93cm]

they don't create free energy

because you can't extract more energy than you put in!

you've got something similar to a motor at best but you still need external power

[VvidEye]

the magnets you are using are simply puny and your Rig is horridly off balance.

[YTjason002]

Excellent response to the original video. Don't you hate it when people make videos with the attitude of undue excitement, ignorance, or fraud (as in the orginal video).

[Kamskuld]

I already had a similar idea, but you cannot do free energy like that because it's need the same amount of energy to move the magnet near to the other than the energy the push will give. And the angle you choose between the two magnet doesn't change anything.

[daverex04]

Wow you have a very bias position on this...

[daverex04]

Fuck why do you fags put music

[46hammer]

you shoulda kept the whole thing in view of the camra....itlooks bad othr wise...good luck

[sdfab]

You dont beleive in free energy eh? hah what do you think makes the existence of the universe possible then? I await your reply

[energyscience]

any one with a decent knowledge of science will that the universe is in perpetual motion, but im talking about real life applications. in that scenario, free energy does not exist!

[sdfab]

what keeps every single proton anywhere and everywhere orbiting a nuclei then? And yes there are many ways to tap the quantum flux for sub atomic electron extraction. And if you beleive otherwise then i guess youre a slave to the incomplete stoneage model

[doobedoo22]

sdfab, if you extract energy from atoms in that way, you've got nuclear fission or fusion.

It's not free energy, just good old-fashioned mass/energy conversion, as described by E=mc^2

Of course, mass/energy conversion could still be useful, if it's clean... but that's nothing to do with spinning magnets. Xpenzif's machine is nonsense, and your own intuition should tell you that.

[serpentphoenix]

what keeps every single proton anywhere and everywhere orbiting a nuclei then?"

lol, i doubt if ure even updated with the latest theory of the atomic model, protons dont orbit the nucleus, theyre ON the nucleus, electrons orbit the nucleus, NOT THE PROTONS. and thats atomic level and subatomic level energies, theyre diffrent from what we're trying to do for practical apps. if u can prove me wrong sdfab , please post a video of it in response to his :)

[minde4000]

So you build a system with whatever screw spacings it does not work and you post it here? We all understand srew locations and spacing are absolute key between working or not working concept. koneheadx is right on. Do not build BS and post here. Thx

[poppydephary]

he was trying to disprove a post for another vid....please bother to read the writer comments

[koneheadx]

problems i see:

1) Plasitc cup holding the magnets is not centered (!!)

This is ritical to correct if you really want it to work.

2) The screws are not spaced like niente's vidoe shows! His third one up is cenetered between rows - in yours, the 4th one up is centered between rows!! So there is now "latch space"

3) the screwheads should be dug in to the plastci so the screws face more at 90 degrees to magnets

4) magnets are too weak and should be tube shaped so poles do not loop-around

[serpentphoenix]

and as i have said, you can get a 180 degree turn only if u tilt it, but thats about it.

[X00000013]

The original sat on a stepper motor, giving the device a triforce effect like the searl.

[serpentphoenix]

this one is also on a steeper motor.

[X00000013]

within the first minute of the vid, the builder says "it is freely rotating on a spindle", sorry but steppers do not free spin like that, just tryin to help

[serpentphoenix]

spin like how? free? even steep motors spin freely lol!

[gradvol]

we need to ask ourselves in what kind of instability we have to put the system so that the only stable state is the one we need, in this case continuous turning of the wheel...

[gradvol]

why this kind of devices don't work is simple logically. the wheel will turn as a reaction to the forces applied, but why would it continue to turn when the situation doesn't change by the wheels turning (magnets always encounter the same configuration of srews as they move) - it might as well be still and not spend energy...and to change the situation every step of the way you have to bring external energy into the system which is sadly more that you get...

[TheWiccanBitch]

"xpenzif" sold his hoax on ebay, and the top bidder did not know it was a hoax until after the bidding ended. He refused to pay for the sham device after he learned it was a swindle. Why he didn't just ask a physicist or an engineer first is a mystery to me.

[TheWiccanBitch]

The original video was proven to be a hoax over 200 years ago. Why did you waste your time showing what everyone with an adequate junior high school education already knows?

[devilfirestorm]

well, atleast you told us the truth abt this device. thankz anywayz. ur one of the few sensible people investigating this stuff..

[serpentphoenix]

why are u guys calling him an idiot? he says he dosen't believe in free energy. people who believe are otherwise.

[MakesMeAngry]

It saddens me to see this; surely you must have known the original device was a hoax, yes?