it was a good performance overall. there were more than a few notes that she lost control of though. 7/10. no one's going to out-perform mariah carey's version. her version is 10/10, it's the measuring stick for all.
@buloy99 really? Right now I'm addicted to listening to Mariah Carey's version, but other versions like Celine Dions offer something else. Also Whitney Houston's version is really excellent in a gospel kind of way. I don't think Mariah Carey's is the measuring stick by any means. One of the best of course, but not the only best.
This is so beautiful. No music just the sound of amazing voices. Kelly Clarkson is the epitome of awesoness!!!!!!!!! Her performance of this song gave me goosebumps and brought me to tears. She is so wonderful. What a voice!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
She has a good voice, but she mimics dozens of other singers and has no originality. I couldn't listen to the rest of this song, I found it irritating.
I agree that her voice is good. I also found the song a bit irritating. But what I thought was bad was not that she wasn't original (and she wasn't), but that she took the jazz-it-up (hey look at me) route.
This is a beautiful traditional song and should be sang that way, or at least close to it.
Research the Rockefellers. They are pure evil. They are eugenecists. They are the American branch of the mostly Rothschild-controlled new world order. Watch "Endgame" on YouTube to learn more about the Rockefellers and others.
i would love to hear her sing this today, it would sound amazing. this performance i personally think isnt her best, celine's vercion kinda blows hers outta the water(n im a uge kelly fan ppl), but i think if she sang it today, she might jus give celine a run for her money:)
She looks gorgeous and sounds amazing, it is live people leave her alone. First of all a lot of singers these days do not even sing live and let alone sound that good doing it. She has a pure voice and natural talent, it cannot be denied.
So basically what you're trying to say is that she sucks nuts but you love her anyway? You are obviously not a musician, and a total idiot in addition to that. That thing you call shaky is something we musicians call vibrato. She sings amazingly and with emotion, live nonetheless. She is an excellent vocalist, and this is six years old! You can't even dream of being as good as her one day, and here you are playing voice coach. Damn we need some filters to keep you idiots off youtube.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
huh??!! HOW DARE YOU!
I happen to be a vocal coach of many yrs so don't tell try to "explain" to what vibrato is..i already know DUUUUUUHHHH...I like Kelly but this was not a good vocal performance. I didn't bad mouth anyone so just calm down & quit being an immature cry baby
Lol, just because you're a vocal coach (which I highly doubt, dry and shaky sound like amateurish terms) doesn't mean you are good or know what you are talking about. Almost everyone has their own theories on proper vocal technique, there isn't a clear "good" technique yet.
And Kelly is one of the few contemporary singers I know of today who can actually sing with emotion, she is regarded as a soulful and masterful interpreter and rightfully so.
i agree i can't wait for christmas in rocketfella center 2009 that and the macy's parade is the kick to christmas it isn't christmas without them. does anyone know who's performing this year?
i cant stop watching her live performances...she is just so amazing to listen to.. she has some pipes on her. she can sing like an angel, or she can sound FIERCE with a kick ass rock sound, she can sound like anythng!
and i just cant remember the last time i was so excited and pleased to watch an A.I. finale like the night i watched Kelly win. I have been so disappointed every year after the first season of A.I., nobody can compare to kelly!!
i like her alot but didnt like the way that song was done seemed off abit maybe with music behind her it would be much better not sure though still love those celtic woman doing christmas songs just amazing voices
I agree I love Kelly, especially her version of my grown up christmas list, but i just didnt like this version of the song. I thought there was too much going on...or something, it just wasn't right.
Simplesmente incrível ♥
leestardar 1 month ago
Dowwnload the audio from this track at searchripgrab doht cohm.
CelisseCazzola445 1 year ago
she has an amazing gift .....what a stunning voice
tommysladdie 1 year ago
it was a good performance overall. there were more than a few notes that she lost control of though. 7/10. no one's going to out-perform mariah carey's version. her version is 10/10, it's the measuring stick for all.
buloy99 1 year ago
@buloy99 really? Right now I'm addicted to listening to Mariah Carey's version, but other versions like Celine Dions offer something else. Also Whitney Houston's version is really excellent in a gospel kind of way. I don't think Mariah Carey's is the measuring stick by any means. One of the best of course, but not the only best.
c6h12o6glucose 1 year ago
This is so beautiful. No music just the sound of amazing voices. Kelly Clarkson is the epitome of awesoness!!!!!!!!! Her performance of this song gave me goosebumps and brought me to tears. She is so wonderful. What a voice!!!
MsDottie09 1 year ago 2
best singer alive next to jennifer hudson. final answer!
ExoHmusic 1 year ago
Kelly is amazing indeed.
Lisa Lavie does this song amazingly as well. I'd say as good as Celine and I NEVER say that, LoL.
Peace
OneSteveUnderGod 1 year ago
so sweet voice :) so gently :)
Kokoszek 1 year ago
I love her voice. It is one of the best.
lizzyvance 2 years ago
god damn, you mother fuckers nag so fucking much.
sjkim88 2 years ago
Her voice is beautiful.
TheJenniferhappy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She has a good voice, but she mimics dozens of other singers and has no originality. I couldn't listen to the rest of this song, I found it irritating.
asclarice 2 years ago
bummer, you should have listen to the second half.
jillxxbrickman 2 years ago
Ok, maybe I'll give it another try.
asclarice 2 years ago
I agree that her voice is good. I also found the song a bit irritating. But what I thought was bad was not that she wasn't original (and she wasn't), but that she took the jazz-it-up (hey look at me) route.
This is a beautiful traditional song and should be sang that way, or at least close to it.
MajorHaze 2 years ago
So true!
asclarice 2 years ago
@asclarice It is a xmas song. Personally it annoys me and probably many other when people mess with it.
norag1 2 years ago
Yes, it is a Chistmas song. When I said she has no originality, I meant the way she uses her voice, not the song. : )
asclarice 2 years ago
She's SOOOOO good!!! I love the way she sung this song!! Merry Christmas everybody!
KristinandRobarecool 2 years ago
Research the Rockefellers. They are pure evil. They are eugenecists. They are the American branch of the mostly Rothschild-controlled new world order. Watch "Endgame" on YouTube to learn more about the Rockefellers and others.
bigb47 2 years ago
she kill it !
GGPRx24 2 years ago
i would love to hear her sing this today, it would sound amazing. this performance i personally think isnt her best, celine's vercion kinda blows hers outta the water(n im a uge kelly fan ppl), but i think if she sang it today, she might jus give celine a run for her money:)
Apollo4420 2 years ago
Amazing!!!! Shes blew this song outta the water!! Way to go Kelly!
endlessjourney87 2 years ago
She looks gorgeous and sounds amazing, it is live people leave her alone. First of all a lot of singers these days do not even sing live and let alone sound that good doing it. She has a pure voice and natural talent, it cannot be denied.
beachbutterfly 2 years ago
i want her to perform this again
shadzko 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like Kelly but she needs vocal training I dont feel her emotion. it sounds sooooo dry....& shaky...i love her though
Avalita07 2 years ago
@Avalita07
So basically what you're trying to say is that she sucks nuts but you love her anyway? You are obviously not a musician, and a total idiot in addition to that. That thing you call shaky is something we musicians call vibrato. She sings amazingly and with emotion, live nonetheless. She is an excellent vocalist, and this is six years old! You can't even dream of being as good as her one day, and here you are playing voice coach. Damn we need some filters to keep you idiots off youtube.
BtArocks3133 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
huh??!! HOW DARE YOU!
I happen to be a vocal coach of many yrs so don't tell try to "explain" to what vibrato is..i already know DUUUUUUHHHH...I like Kelly but this was not a good vocal performance. I didn't bad mouth anyone so just calm down & quit being an immature cry baby
Avalita07 2 years ago
Lol, just because you're a vocal coach (which I highly doubt, dry and shaky sound like amateurish terms) doesn't mean you are good or know what you are talking about. Almost everyone has their own theories on proper vocal technique, there isn't a clear "good" technique yet.
And Kelly is one of the few contemporary singers I know of today who can actually sing with emotion, she is regarded as a soulful and masterful interpreter and rightfully so.
o0ber 2 years ago 4
shut up!
who are you???
ur a nobody.
machicken808 2 years ago
u need an ego check.
machicken808 2 years ago
this video was 2003! now is 2009! she improve her vocal level !
abbc6085 2 years ago
she did really good in this i give her dat but i think mariah is so much better. but i give her, her props
buck042007 2 years ago
@buck042007 Shit! You sound like kanye!
BtArocks3133 2 years ago 3
Yo buck042007, Im really happy for you and imma let you finish, but BtArocks3133 had one of the best comments of all time!
21meds 2 years ago
Lulz which one?
BtArocks3133 2 years ago
21meds:
LOL Merry Christmas form Virginia!!!!
egy97 2 years ago
Merry Christmas to you too!
21meds 2 years ago
i agree i can't wait for christmas in rocketfella center 2009 that and the macy's parade is the kick to christmas it isn't christmas without them. does anyone know who's performing this year?
khscheer01 2 years ago
one thing for sure
she is the best
markjowell272 2 years ago 4
i agree she is the true american idol and no one can top her.
khscheer01 2 years ago 4
wow. it brought tears to my eyes.
SSchrickel 2 years ago 3
man i still can't wait for christmas in rockefeller center 2009.
StefanoFan27 2 years ago 3
it's only wonderful
mimi7135 2 years ago
god i can't wait for Christmas in Rockefeller Center 2009.
StefanoFan27 2 years ago
This is my favorite christmas song, and I just heard this today....don't ask why I'm looking up Christmas songs in May...but I am...haha!
Anyway, this was one of the best renditions I have ever heard of this! Kelly can sing like nobody's business!
alabama2780 2 years ago 19
i have this version on my ipod and sometimes (Esp. during xmas time) i just listen 2 it over and over. Amazing.
dramaqueengurl 2 years ago 4
i cant stop watching her live performances...she is just so amazing to listen to.. she has some pipes on her. she can sing like an angel, or she can sound FIERCE with a kick ass rock sound, she can sound like anythng!
and i just cant remember the last time i was so excited and pleased to watch an A.I. finale like the night i watched Kelly win. I have been so disappointed every year after the first season of A.I., nobody can compare to kelly!!
she is the true American Idol.
illdymeond 2 years ago 19
she's so fucking talented
19laurel94 2 years ago 4
She looks so cute bundled up :)
Octoberrd64 2 years ago
i think this blew carrie out of the water. and i love carrie..but kelly just wiped the florr with her. that was amazing
alexnamor2 2 years ago 4
you're so rightt
19laurel94 2 years ago 3
i hate to say that..but she did.
alexnamor2 2 years ago 2
She could wipe the floor wit a whole bunch of folks when she sings like this!
FrOmaN1313 2 years ago 2
i think this is AMAZING
XDXD1632 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it wasn't that great. not her type of song
djpacman210 3 years ago
well, i thought it was technically very very good... but i don't think she was really feeling it as she usually does in her performances
VitaminCPingu 3 years ago 2
it's acapella so I think she is concentrating
moonsmilelucide 3 years ago 3
very very nice. guys try to listen charice pempengco's o holy night version.
oklangko123 3 years ago
better than carrie. bravo...
oklangko123 3 years ago 4
Even without instruments playing during the entire song, her singing is still amazing.
twentin08 3 years ago 4
listen to john berry do this song. you wont be able to listen to another version ever again.
homer8777 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HOLY SOULLESS FORMER "American Idol" KARAOKEAN!!!
Berzerker181 3 years ago
she is absolutely awesome...her voice is some kind of heaven...very beautiful...
piper002 3 years ago
IDIOT!!!
Berzerker181 3 years ago
kelly put her heart and soul into this.
LAnneS99 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHE'S HEARTLESS & SOULLESS!!!
Berzerker181 3 years ago
and you know this how??
LAnneS99 3 years ago
your mother!
singingmar1 3 years ago
It is between Kelly and Mariah i lean towards Kelly a bit more
stallion321 3 years ago
Better then carrie!
greenemerald152 3 years ago
AMAZINGGG
markupyourlife08 3 years ago
Come back to me when you decide to speak English, otherwise don't speak to me
ai bem....nao aguenta....bebe leite
bjoosnaomeliga:******
lolazx 3 years ago
she looks so pretty, and sounds amazazing!
<333333
Jelly10100 3 years ago 4
She is amazing....
lcmagnum21 3 years ago
3:08 to the end is unbelieveable.
ilovekelly75 3 years ago
i like her alot but didnt like the way that song was done seemed off abit maybe with music behind her it would be much better not sure though still love those celtic woman doing christmas songs just amazing voices
rexwooo 3 years ago
I agree I love Kelly, especially her version of my grown up christmas list, but i just didnt like this version of the song. I thought there was too much going on...or something, it just wasn't right.
OceanSunRise4 3 years ago
you know your a good singer when you have no music and you still sing great!!!
mt100irish 3 years ago 6
wow, she's so amazing. definately one of my idols!
saammxo 3 years ago 5
love this, she is amazing.
except the chorus in the background got waay ahead in the beginning.
then it gets back to normal at 1:47.
repentyourselff 3 years ago 3
i love her shes awesome!!! she beats all singers
yczworld 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
buck042007 3 years ago
u is? Where did you go to school?
mzsandy1023 3 years ago
Comment removed
buck042007 3 years ago
Come back to me when you decide to speak English, otherwise don't speak to me.
mzsandy1023 3 years ago 2
@mzsandy1023 haha would ur punk ass like ta knw go fuck ur self n dnt worry bout me shawty.
buck042007 1 year ago
Comment removed
buck042007 3 years ago
AHHAHA, while i do agree i like mariah's version better, i still think kelly is a tad better than her.
carrie cannot even come close to kelly, carrie sucks, HAHA.
repentyourselff 3 years ago 5
right on!
carolinagirl009 3 years ago
I'll give you Mariah.
But Carrie?
Really?
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago
i agree with repentyourselff, carrie sucks
bro0klyn0riginal 3 years ago 3
lol carey did so good but still kellys so humble
carries a joke, get real
alowaaaaa 3 years ago 4
A Joke? Carrie Underwood? Both, Carrie and Kelly are FANTASTIC singers! Love them both!
lancelaneles 3 years ago
i agree with you hate carries voice so annoying kelly is the best singer that AI ever search next to her is chris daughtry...
bakulawtau 3 years ago 2
@yczworld naw deff MARIAH CAREY GOT DAT BEAT UM JESSICA KEYISHA YEAH. um shes good but not dat good
buck042007 1 year ago
a little to much ohh yeahh OOHH yeahhhhh yeahh
for a christmas carol is you know what i mean, but yes AMAZING
xoxoLizxoxo 3 years ago 2
kewl yule
olivertinkler 3 years ago 2
Damn! She's got an excellent voice :)
lobodude03 3 years ago 3
Damn! She's got an excellent voice :)
lobodude03 3 years ago
Oh wow, I'm not even particularly religious and this had me saying hallelujah LOL Absolutely brilliant!
Cynthsam21 3 years ago 2
Pretty cool ending just about the last 30sec
dukeforsinging 3 years ago
FLAWLESS!!!!
CriztopheThe1andOnly 3 years ago
She's so awesome!
The choir at my school are doing her version for christmas
SpongeBlog007 3 years ago
AWESOME performance!
Potrebitelka 3 years ago 7
Spectacular perfomance
mandrake842 4 years ago 8
Amazzazing! What a gift! :)
HowIFeelRightNow 4 years ago 9
she rox! -jimis sis
jimifan199214 4 years ago 10
gr8 song for a gr8 singer like her
katiefren 4 years ago 9