Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (320)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • BETTER THAN ADELE'S VERSION

  • I miss hearing her beautiful singing every wednesday and thursday night :( <33

  • In live version she is loud

  • The scars of ur VOICE , they leave me SPEACHLESS , i cant help REPLAYING !! :D ... JUST WOW !!! ♥

  • i love her....

  • the live version is better

  • @hait3k there are 2 diferents things: one has more emotion (growl, etc...), and this is like more perfect, i mean witout mistakes, like more clean, anyway i prefer live version too!

  • she sings it better than adele herself. HANDS DOWN. i cant stand adele. i think she's terrible. haley's the one kind of singer that has the type of voice that can sing this correctly ( besides glee's version because lea michele is amazing) I LOVE HALEY REINHART!!! go haley!

  • @broadwayxdude06 bitch, please.

  • @djoscicsa first, no names, got it? second you do realize that this is HALEY REINHART, not adele. if you're on HALEY REINHART'S page and you realize that people are talking about haley's version of the song and how they compare it to adele, why bother commenting?

  • HALEY REINHART is the best Idol ever! She has 5 memorable performances with longevity forever on American idol. Bennie and the Jets, Rolling in the Deep, House of the Rising Sun, I Who Have Nothing, What is and What Should Never Be. See how she makes people go so jealous over her, they can't even understand her talent because they are close-minded morons. A talent like no other, she is just wonderful and is going to be a success for sure.

  • what the fuck happened to youtube??

  • this. is. amazing.

  • Why are there so many haters in this world???

  • I love this song Haley's version not Adel's

  • SHE IS SO PRETTY AND GOOD AT SINGING

  • I love this song, i thought she was gonna win 4 sure, but she didnt

  • my favorite voice in the whole world no joke!

  • 27 people are so damn insecure

  • Like it

  • that's amazing! I lobs you Haley!!

  • She sings sexy. ;)

  • @SuperBornConfused lol thats what steven tyler said to her :P lol hehehe

  • @SuperBornConfused i love her so much.

  • @12384Beester

    No talent? Cocky attitude? The night Haley performed Earth Song, Steven told Ryan on eonline, "Randy's not a singer...She nailed it. She used her voice just the way she was supposed to...she delivered it like the blue plate special, it was just so good...it showed she had emotion, and it showed she could sing...(the bussing) pissed me off...the best singers have character...If you watch Reinhart up there, every bad comment she gets, it rolls right off, that's how good she is..."

  • @LookingAtYouFool I stand by what I said. I believe she is cocky with no talent. Quit trying to shove her down my throat. It's not going to happen. I'll NEVER like her.

  • @LookingAtYouFool I stand by what I said. I believe she is cocky with no talent. Quit trying to shove her down my throat. It's not going to happen. I'll NEVER like her. I only support artists who ACTUALLY have talent.

  • @LookingAtYouFool I stand by what I said. I believe she is cocky with no talent. Quit trying to shove her down my throat. It's not going to happen. I'll NEVER like her. I only support artists who ACTUALLY have talent. What Adam Lambert sees in THAT, I'll NEVER understand. You'd think someone with talent like his would know what talent is....

  • @JoeTTelford,

    The judges DON'T know music? That's funny, considering they've been making music for YEARS!! And actually, I don't care for Randy.

    If she was SO great, wouldn't she have had more fans and people voting for her? I thought so.

    My FAVORITE moment this season was when she fell flat on her face and you could actually hear the thud! So funny I actually kept repeating it on YouTube!!

    The BEST in all of Idol history was Adam Lambert, hands down. No competition.

    Moron. You're just

  • @12384Beester this voting thing is manipulated i think. and i dont say that because i wanted haley to win, i just say it, cuz i think so, okay? ^^

  • Comment removed

  • @12384Beester CALM DOWN!!!! Pia Toscano WAS THE BEST IN IDOL HISTORY!!!!!

  • @rasoto1999 Pia was definitely better than Haley...that's for sure!

  • @12384Beester ... and Adam Lambert

    

  • @rasoto1999 What was this even in reply to?

  • @12384Beester

    "The BEST in all of Idol history was Adam Lambert, hands down. No competition."

    .

    That would be the Adam that said of Haley, "I love the sound of her voice, the texture of it. Musically, her choices are incredible." He gushes, "I don't even think people are realizing the things that she's doing vocally. I think it's because she's so effortless about it."

    .

    Moron. You're just

  • @LookingAtYouFool OMG i fucking love you!!!

  • Shes amazing

  • @theGLEEfull1 She is annoying and irritating. Didn't you watch the show? Anytime she sang I always had to mute the tv.

  • @12384Beester You are actually retarded.. She was the best, the judges were fucking morons who don't know music. Tyler was the only capable judge. And if you actually like Randy as a judge, you suck at life.

  • Haley sucks. She always had bad attitude. She thought she knew better than the judges. She was cocky and arrogant. And she couldn't take criticism when she sure as Hell deserved it! I'm sooooo glad she didn't make it into the finale. She's annoying and irritating. And she can't sing!

  • @12384Beester What cracks me up the most about this comment is that you called Haley annoying and irritating.

  • Haley is the best female vocalist to show up for many years...unique tone, perfect pitch, great use of dynamics, effortless jumps in pitch, precise riffing, and control of her instrument from sweetness to belting out rock. I like the live versions best so far, but only because the studio didn't record and mix the tracks as well as should be. Idol doesn't do well ever on their studio versions of anyone IMHO,

  • @GoodShepherd1011 I think Haley's studio of "Bennie and the Jets" is one of the two best in Idol history. I would say the other is David Cook's version of "Always Be My Baby". They're both great, IMO.

  • Shes so much better then Adele's for sure... love this song.. and i hate this song.. but now that shes singing it.. its alot better.. and i dont like any other songs... she sings.. only this one.. lol..

  • I liked Haley's spunk (as well as her voice) Anyone who can "belt it out" like her is great in my book!

  • Adele is the best but this is a very good cover. she should have been runner-up!

  • sooooooooooo good! Haley I await your first album.

  • I think Haley's voice SUCKS! She always growls. I will say she did amazing at this song, but I usually hated her performances. AND YOU WANNA KNOW WHY SHE DIDN'T WIN? 1. Because she doesn't have die-hard fans like Scotty does. 2. SHE CAN'T TAKE CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM!

  • i cant believe she didnt win...

    she was one of the best amarican idol every had

    but both her and scotty deserve the winning spot

  • @erincansmile UH UH hAYLEY AND sCOTTY SHE STINKED SRRY NOT TRYING TO BE MEAN THAT'S MY OPINION

  • Haley, this song was made for you. but you still suck

    

  • I believe that this song was made for haley. She sings it much better than Adelle. Love you Haley. :)

  • This song sounds better suited for her than Adele. Can't wait for Haley's album <3

  • Perfect! Waiting for her soulfoul album

  • This chick is awesome

  • @McKenzieRecords Hahaha yea, my brother tried out today, he didnt make it, but the girl in front of him could sing like hell, but she didnt get it so that made him feel good:)

  • I think that they all were GREAT!!!

  • i understand why. it's cuz she sucks.

  • I don't understand WHY she was eliminated!

  • @MegaVideoGirls because she did'nt get enough votes, lol

  • best version

  • I always love how see play with the lyric of every single song!

  • I worship Hayley, my brother is trying out for american idol cause of scotty won.My brother was like, if scotty could win he could win cause scotty honestly shouldnt had one it. I live in North Carolina also...yea he won it for north carolina...But he sounds like another country singer. Im just pissed he won.

  • @TheFingerstudios your only hating because he won, i wanted haley! but im not abusing scotty because she did'nt win thats been a poor looser!

  • @ilovegrangehill You right man, but do you get what im tryin to say here, Like yea hayleys a way better singer than Scotty, but maybe scotty had a better story, like here his story, but maybe his grandmal had cancer or something, you know what i mean? And maybe hayley, was just a awsome singer coming to win american idol for a record deal and blah blah. thats all im tryin to say.

  • @ilovegrangehill ?? you didnt say anything.

  • @TheFingerstudios oops i ment to say, its sort of like America's got talent, ally and christina getting to the top 10 just because they have cystic fibrosis, hardly fair on anyone else

  • I WOULD SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO SEE HER IN A CONSERT

  • and...why all of the Scotty talk on Miss Haley's page?? This America- is a prime example of what is wrong in our country...There IS NO RESPECT AND NO ONE HAS ANY MORALS!

  • @Justgardening22 So true, my brother said the same thing...America is going to hell cause of scotty one.. I mean gooddddd!

  • awsome love this version those 19 people that said they didn't like, everyone has there own opinion but i personally thought it was great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she is ok I like Stefano and Scotty better tho

  • she murders 1:03

  • @213coolio Yah, she's pitchy there

  • I'm the biggest Scotty Fan out there, but this is really good. WAY BETTER THEN ADELE AND ADELE IS REALLY GOOD

  • This was my fav song that Haley sung. It was amazing..

    

  • This was my fav song that Haley sung. It was amazing.

  • im a Lauren fan but this cover of hers is Awesome! if u dislike this u got problems! in my opinion her best cover!

  • At 2:46, I'm waiting for the whistling chirp thing she did live... :)

  • You know...Scotty is attractive and respectful. But I don't remember a single song he sang this season. I remember EVERY song Haley sang.

  • @Autumnsmile900

    dude Young Blood, are gonna kiss me or not,Swingin, your man, Long Black,Train,Where were you when the world stop turning,Letter to home,and otheres one lolz. Sorry i'm a scotty fan but i like Hakey 2

  • @Autumnsmile900

    dude Young Blood, are gonna kiss me or not,Swingin, your man, Long Black,Train,Where were you when the world stop turning,Letter to home,and otheres one lolz. Sorry i'm a Scotty fan but i like Haley 2

  • wow, scotty ruined something amazing.

  • @MrsBieberization i know righttt it made me cry when she got voted off i mean i like scotty but i wanted hayley to win 100%

  • @twickey100 rly?! aww that's sweet :)

  • I feel sorry for you haley. You made yourself look dumb and look like a bitch on AI.

  • @ChrissyCat09 why you gotta be a hoe! YOU GOTTA BE RUDE IF YOU DONT LIKE HER THEN DONT SAY NOTHING ITS PEOPLE LIKE YOU THAT JUST MAKE THE WORLD A BAD PLACE

  • Wow she's got it all, sing,dance,sexy,classy,beautif­ul. Wow wow! I love her.

  • she deserves to have won, she killed that song!

  • HAHHAHAHAHAHA..........HAHAHAA­HAHA...........

  • She has a great voice.

  • Wow best voice ever she should of won...Scotty was good but shes better....Dumb votes

  • HALEY SHOULDVE FUCKING WON!

  • @gigigigi52 IM WIT CHU ALL DA WAY ON THAT ONE

  • I much prefer Haley over Adele any day!

  • 19 people are rolling in the shallow :)

  • @tclathrop No... That's getting kind of old like GHOST by MICHAEL JACKSON "19 people are ghosts of jealousy" For every song it's like that!!! HERE'S THE REAL REASON: 19 PEOPLE ARE JEALOUS THAT THEY DON'T HAVE VOICES AS !!!WICKED!!! AS HALEY'S!!!

  • @226526dannygirlxo You had me holding my breath...i wuz scared....ur not mad right??? 

  • @tclathrop WTF DOES THAT MEAN

  • @locococoacrazy the 19 people who disliked this video are rolling in the shallow...deep= good

    shallow=bad :(

  • they take out the growl :(

  • I love the live better... what happened to her voice hear? She sounds like a kid hear...

  • @hecklord i know doesnt she!

  • IM IN LOVE HALEY.LOL i love the way she sings.i love the way she moves.i love the way she talks.i love the way she smiles.and i love the tone that comes out when she says "deeeee-eeeep"

  • Loved this girl! She has it all!

  • This sounds amazing when you play Adele's version side by side with this version. It's like a little duet.

  • @tmurray7491 Haha, your so right!! It actually sounds really good. :)

  • Honestly - this version sounds better than Adele's.

  • @connorkimbro soooooo true!

  • @connorkimbro i love this version but no. just no.

  • Wasn't a Haley fan, but I did like this song!

  • i'm done with american idol!

    when Pia left I was mad because she was good.

    James what forever my favorite and i can't believe he's gone! i was so pissed.

    i don't like haley but she's clearly very very talented and i can't believe she didn't make it to the finale!

    american idol i now hate with a passion! i really hope haley and james go on to be really famous :)

  • san sya n lang an nanalo....galing kya nya

  • She wasn't my favorite, but she has this song now!

  • i personally think that she did better than the original song

  • haley and lauren should have been the top 2. >:(

  • @missmoviestar13 Yess that is sooo true in my opinion.... people only vote for scottie because he is cute but i think the real talent is in Lauren and Haley and honestly now I think its going to be Scotty because it becomes a popularity contest

  • @ebbonirox i just want lauren 2 win now. she is AMAZING! and shes only 16

  • @ebbonirox yeah america heart's are to scotty but vocally and perfromance wise haley and lauren shine brighter than the stars

  • Like this is you think Lauren should go home...>:(

  • @ILuvEeMobuDDyJAkE ; i totally agree !

  • Haley should've won! America is officailly stupid.

  • @60sandReinhartlover That was known since Pia, Stefano and James were voted off...

  • i feel like im the only one who hates scotty for still being there. think about it, can he hit the voice range that haley can?? seriously! wow he might win and ima b so mad.

  • @aviona123 you are not alone why the hell is he still on the show... !!!

  • Comment removed

  • @bluecastaway can't believe he won. it's stupid.

  • I personally do not like Haley, she screams during singing and cant hit the high notes.. but she deff nailed this song..so i do give her credit to this one ((:

  • YOU ROCK HALEY YOU GONNA WINNNNNN

  • seriously.... i liked all three of the top three and i cried when they showed the hometown videos...

  • Oh my gosh, I LOVE this

  • how can ppl not like this voice!!!???????????

  • 16 ppl must die MUST MUSTT DIEE

  • I LOVE HER! but she dusnt do that growl thing in her studio version... :(

  • I like her version of this song

  • I`d love to see Haley and Scotty in the end.

  • @tiissueboxx same here, they are two of my faves too

  • this is the only song i like of hers......SCOTTY FOR THE WIN

  • @lovenat74 no way.

  • @678trriple98212 YES WAY

  • @lovenat74 go away and stop quoting randy

  • @hotpeacechick im not quoting any one thank u very much

  • @lovenat74 your stupid HALEY FOR THE WIN!

  • @CoutureLoveXx  Im not stupid if its true... She is totally gunn Be gone next week!!! SCOTTY'S GUNNA WIN

  • @lovenat74 u called it haha

  • BEST SINGER

    She takes every song on a NEW path .. and makes it her own ...!

    American Idol 10 FOR SURE.......................! Randy Jackson disses her over and over ... VOTE FOR HALEY and prove him wrong.

  • guys, theres people with alot of talent on the show... but even if Haley didnt make it, im sure she'll get signed with someone...

  • I love Hayley voice is very sensual.

  • She Ish Good But James Ish Alot Better!

  • @Limegreen331 and thats why he got booted, right? lol

  • pure fukin talent

  • can i have this in mp3 ?

  • OK PEOPLE: it's time to think about it this way: Haley is a RISING star. She has taken harsh criticism, she was in the bottom 3 several times and she has never shown any sing of backing down. If anything, she stepped it up. So now, we want her in the TOP 3 and for that to happen, we have to VOTE till our fingers bleed because this is one truly talented girl and I'm sure many people will agree that we want more from Ms Reinhart, so... tomorrow's the day! VOTE VOTE VOTE!