I enjoy singing this piece, I'm a tenor, but I have heard so many intreptations that interpolate a high note at the end of the solo, abominable! As an opera buff, I know what the inflection is, high notes indicate tension or a question; low notes indicate acceptance or serenity. The extended instrumental section which follows and often eliminated is an extension of that serenity. Unfortunately, I never bought the only recording of Elisabeth Grummer I saw, Tannhauser, $20.00 was too much!
The boy soprano who sings this air in the video on my channel sings it quite well, and I very much enjoy hearing it. Many female singers today do not have the timbre or focused technique to sing Baroque, and they should not. Elisabeth, however, has an attractive timbre and a solid technique. Thank you for posting.
I enjoy singing this piece, I'm a tenor, but I have heard so many intreptations that interpolate a high note at the end of the solo, abominable! As an opera buff, I know what the inflection is, high notes indicate tension or a question; low notes indicate acceptance or serenity. The extended instrumental section which follows and often eliminated is an extension of that serenity. Unfortunately, I never bought the only recording of Elisabeth Grummer I saw, Tannhauser, $20.00 was too much!
joseph23006 6 months ago
How lovely to hear this! To my ears, Elisabeth Grummer could do no wrong. - John Austin, Australia
jrakg 7 months ago
Like the singing, the accompaniment, not so much.
cakesyes 1 year ago
Merveilleuse voix ! Mille mercis pour cet air célèbre de Bach
saturne46 1 year ago
The boy soprano who sings this air in the video on my channel sings it quite well, and I very much enjoy hearing it. Many female singers today do not have the timbre or focused technique to sing Baroque, and they should not. Elisabeth, however, has an attractive timbre and a solid technique. Thank you for posting.
sfkcbf 1 year ago