I just facebooked this video. I watched it as a child and found it very moving (may have cried). Am now a veteran. On Vet's Day I often think of this poem. I don't know why it hasn't been made into a dvd.
@DartBoi77 you sound as if you never studied 20th Century history in regards to World War I. Have you ever been to a Veterans March in regards to remembering all of those who fought & died for the freedoms that we now have. If so you would realise that the poem signifies the feelings of horror,fear,helplessness & devastation that took place in the trenches of France during WWI & the hope that when it is over their sacrifices will not have been in vain. A lesson we still haven't learnt yet.
I keep waiting for this special to be released on DVD. This won a Peabody Award for "distinguished achievement and meritorious public service" in broadcasting. As much as I love Charlie Brown shows, this one is definitely one of the best ever made.
Thank you ... thank you for giving us this clip. I used to watch this as a child and cry. My mom forbid me to watch it because I'd cry every time ... but I loved it. This will always be one of my favorite poems, and I have Linus to thank for it! Thank you for sharing!
Why would you cry about this as a child? when I was younger I didn't get what this poem was saying, where it care from or what it was about. just asking
@galacnor I was always very sensitive to the more emotional side of things, even as a child. With lines like "We are the dead; Short days ago we lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow," it didn't take a big stretch to identify emotionally with what the soldiers had gone through and the toll the war left in history. It was so beautiful, so stirring, so tragic ... it really moved me as a child.
@galacnor I can understand why, I was 8 when I saw this cartoon for the first time, and when Linus recited the part 'scarce heard amid the guns below, we are the dead', I just got goosebumps. And as they were leaving the American cemetery and looked back, Linus asked that and I just wanted to cry because I was so upset by the deaths of the soldiers and knowing that was real, but I didn't, but I felt like my whole insides had just turned black or something. VERY moving cartoon.
Can you believe John McCrae would have thrown this poem away? I'm so glad an officer saved it and published it. Normally I hate poetry, but this one blew me away.
I just facebooked this video. I watched it as a child and found it very moving (may have cried). Am now a veteran. On Vet's Day I often think of this poem. I don't know why it hasn't been made into a dvd.
bethaniejify 2 months ago
@DartBoi77 you sound as if you never studied 20th Century history in regards to World War I. Have you ever been to a Veterans March in regards to remembering all of those who fought & died for the freedoms that we now have. If so you would realise that the poem signifies the feelings of horror,fear,helplessness & devastation that took place in the trenches of France during WWI & the hope that when it is over their sacrifices will not have been in vain. A lesson we still haven't learnt yet.
mclaughlin72 6 months ago
Indeed, what have we learned?
thehappyfew 1 year ago
I keep waiting for this special to be released on DVD. This won a Peabody Award for "distinguished achievement and meritorious public service" in broadcasting. As much as I love Charlie Brown shows, this one is definitely one of the best ever made.
cra0422 1 year ago
Thank you ... thank you for giving us this clip. I used to watch this as a child and cry. My mom forbid me to watch it because I'd cry every time ... but I loved it. This will always be one of my favorite poems, and I have Linus to thank for it! Thank you for sharing!
DartBoi77 1 year ago
@DartBoi77
Why would you cry about this as a child? when I was younger I didn't get what this poem was saying, where it care from or what it was about. just asking
galacnor 1 year ago
@galacnor I was always very sensitive to the more emotional side of things, even as a child. With lines like "We are the dead; Short days ago we lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow," it didn't take a big stretch to identify emotionally with what the soldiers had gone through and the toll the war left in history. It was so beautiful, so stirring, so tragic ... it really moved me as a child.
DartBoi77 1 year ago
@galacnor I can understand why, I was 8 when I saw this cartoon for the first time, and when Linus recited the part 'scarce heard amid the guns below, we are the dead', I just got goosebumps. And as they were leaving the American cemetery and looked back, Linus asked that and I just wanted to cry because I was so upset by the deaths of the soldiers and knowing that was real, but I didn't, but I felt like my whole insides had just turned black or something. VERY moving cartoon.
TheBookWorm1718 8 months ago
Can you believe John McCrae would have thrown this poem away? I'm so glad an officer saved it and published it. Normally I hate poetry, but this one blew me away.
Dauntless07 2 years ago 11