趙學而 - 痛愛

[MSYYY100]

好可惜...

[auaukib]

講真，你地唔覺得容祖兒愈唱愈hea 咩

我絕對係好客觀咁睇

[coldeartiger]

有D人又借學而黎踩祖兒...

根本兩個唱功都好....(雖然我特別鍾意祖兒既唱歌份感情..­.)

祖兒有今日咁既地位, D人都仲可以質疑佢實力...

總係有一班人冇咗先黎後悔...

一堆好有talent既歌手唔再活躍係樂壇喇, 又係度嘈"點解佢唔紅"

永遠都唔去珍惜下又紅又有實力果D!!!

[Cwyeung0912]

為何她總是後補的那個？

[forevero2er]

呢D乜鬼嘢BEAT 嚟GA = =

[wingwg500]

趙學而唱得好好



[Sebykwong]

唱得好過原唱

[fishermanfish]

A very impressive LIVE performance!!!! :)

[elviskwok]

支持呀~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~­~~~~

[kincheung1113]

我亦支持趙學而: )

[jameskui]

CONCERT YY WYMAN 講過容祖兒當日一午先唱唔到。咁即係趙學而係得一個下午去彩排。­仲要唱得咁好。我唔比較啦！ 大家都有唔對既耳。聽出嚟既野都唔同。

[sleeptheclockaround]

2011, 看完Concert YY 再回來聽這個。喜歡。

[cleantime]

唔好和拍得唔得真係好煩

[safarihk]

容祖兒冇楊生撐住,死咗10年喇,你估容小姐有第2間唱片公司簽­佢咩,趙學而出道做"娛樂新聞眼"嗰陣,容小姐仲係學生妹一個同­發埋啲明星春秋大夢咋,容小姐謙虛啲喇,唔好以為7奪最XXX女­歌手就點點點,你啲咁嘅 " 爛獎" 係楊生用錢同你買番嚟咋,你呢啲所謂巨星,天后......點解­以前小風姐,梅姐,蒨雯,慧嫻,憶蓮,都係天后,但冇咩聽過佢地­啲負面新聞囉.

[conradhk1]

@safarihk 就係因為有你呢d人, 負面新聞就係咁黎

[safarihk]

@conradhk1

Thanks a Lot .

[kayletse]

客觀地講( 唱功 ), 我覺得兩個差唔多, 因為我唔係專業 但音樂從來都主觀, 所以我覺得學而版本正D 有D人用紅唔紅黎做客觀標準, 紅=唱得 咁容祖兒O係香港都算唔失禮, 尤其呢幾年佢真係有進步 但係(我覺得)佢係天后之前, D人已經捧到佢上天... 如果紅=唱得, 咁, TWINS某段時間都好紅下WO 楊千嬅都OK WO (我覺得佢唱得好聽, 但唔算好勁) (呢個有D爭議性,可以IGNORE), 仲有STEPHY有排都OK紅WO... 何韻詩, 盧巧音, 關心妍等等, 唱功一致好評, 但係O係香港又係咪好紅? 參照外國, KATY PERRY, TAYLOR SWIFT 2個都好紅WO 但係咪好唱得呢????????如果你覺得佢地好唱得, 咁 恭喜你, 你應該會過得好快樂 其實都係想講, 紅, 除左歌手本身條件, 努力之外 同公司關係都好緊要, 如果公司冇宣傳,支持, 唱得再好, 都好難發圍 唔好咁膚淺覺得紅就一定係有TALENT啦...

[SRTOASRAK]

咁多個版本(包括男歌手唱)我最中意都係陳奕迅>古巨基>容祖兒­>趙學而>林峰>黃耀明>陳小春

[lpy031504]

@SRTOASRAK 林峰 WTF?

[Pandoralau01]

趙學而唱歌好好聽!



[safarihk]

趙學而唱得超好聽.可惜有18個人耳仔有問題.

英皇成立以來,只有趙學而一個識唱歌,其他只係識擘脾.擦鞋.

[lovejinyoung1]

@safarihk 都吾係,謝先生都色嘅~不過柏芝好過佢姐~

[safarihk]

@lovejinyoung1

謝先生,你講緊我.哈哈,我都姓謝,哇咔咔...

[wawawawaxd]

@safarihk 除左泳兒

[siuman1921]

支持joey 板本多d

[lovejinyoung1]

到E+,

JOEY有咁多機會練歌,

BONDY都仲係勁過佢,

好心人地叫你做天后,

你都米認LA,

梅姐係離開左,

不過你當SAMMI,BONDY,羅敏莊死架!?

吾好挽LA~

[hihi5845201314]

@lovejinyoung1 -=.=冇人話當SAMMI,BONDY,羅敏莊死WO 你會唔會諗多左~

[lovejinyoung1]

@hihi5845201314 你又知容姐有冇??話你咩?-.-

[mcyaya66]

真係好聽.

[lovejinyoung1]

BONDY有新CD,TRINITY,160$正到咩咁,

係HQCD尼架,

遲D會有BLUERAY,接近母帶!

買LA買LA~

[msJade1220]

香港唔係冇實力派,,,係D實力派唱極都唔起

[sk6f13]

大家唱痛愛方法都唔同 有咩好講 joey近年系比較用力同用比較雄壯黎唱痛愛 2者都唔同 有咩好講 重有 唔該唔好系到話事旦一個明星好唔好 我覺得e加d系系愈黎愈對人不是對歌而系到話人 如果冇人玩針對 又點會大家對一隻歌而嘈起黎??

[chong4311]

係算唔錯,不過我中意joey的版本多d^^

佢唱這首歌把聲尖了點

[lovejinyoung1]

@chong4311 可能係收音有問題,不過BONDY係高音D架!!!=]

[paullam1025]

唔識野係到亂吠趙學而係容祖兒師姐呀!!!!

[suyhtb627]

容祖兒紅足十幾年，睇下學而？姐係唔係話窒佢，只係覺得話學而勁­過JOEY果D人無腦囉

[imkitlam]

@suyhtb627 但我覺得佢唱得好好

[bearbear1231220]

@suyhtb627 紅就係一定識唱歌? 趙學而識唱歌 係無人捧咋! 滄海遺珠.. 唔係串你 但係趙學而真係唱得好過容祖兒囉.. 駛唔駛話人無腦呀, 宜家似係你無.....多d囉。

[lovejinyoung1]

@suyhtb627 吾好意思,吾係趙學而出道早吾會咁,

佢個期有梅姐,有JESLIE,有咁多勁人,

佢米吾起眼LOR~

吾好諗住你知好多,

吾係學而可中意英皇作風,

佢吾紅過晒班死橙,

吾知邊個冇腦睇表面.呢呵?!

[InfernalSatan]

我都係擺脫唔到佢皆大歡喜入面嘅八婆look =(

[salem4226]

唱現場佢真係好過好多一線歌手﹗

[becky9393]

i think she's better than joey yung indeed

[whitecarcar]

有十二個容祖兒死忠

[loveundercover2011]

好聽過容巨星幾十皮!!

[seansean84]

Agree. She is simply one of the best singers in town.

[magician226]

the applause say all

[fai2861]

講真的,个人覺得趙學而真的唱live得好過joey!!!!!­!!!!!!!!

[derekyip88]

學而...現在在何方呢?

[vs26980606]

趙學而勁 容祖兒收皮啦 趙學而不知勁幾多

[beybladeplayer]

評分證明了一切

[mintjambaby]

好明顯就JOEY 好聽好多啦....唔好講技巧, 感情已經贏晒~

[lovejinyoung1]

@mintjambaby 你好勁啵,聽到感情,咁你隻丐耳梗係有D問題.架LA~

[babycaca13579]

在攻擊祖兒的人請看number6演唱會版本的痛愛~~無論情緒­,爆發力各方面都絕對比祖兒過去或其他人的版本好!!!!

[kristofferhk]

其實趙學而由每隔兩秒 開始, 就紅, 雖然唔係一線, 但都二線頭!! 唱片又賣得, 只係佢當時的唱片公司--飛圖被收購, 改名叫 英皇的時候,  即刻被[雪藏].... 冇唱片出, 冇宣傳, 英皇要捧其他新人(包括容祖兒), 情況就好似鄭伊健簽左英皇一樣.... 完全冇晒影.....

[kamtimchow]

我不是Joey和學而

粉絲....但學而唱歌真的好好聽呀!

[carltonlau2006]

she sing so much better than joey ( Be honest)

[kinglonc]

趙學而 唱的刺耳！

[lpy031504]

@kinglonc 你都幾講一套做一套喎: )

[kinglonc]

为什么要骂祖儿 ，祖儿又做错什么了？ 是实话 live 是没有祖儿好听，是没有错， 每个人都有喜欢的人，何必呢？



[jacky090985]

起左雞皮=)

[fionafong1986]

我吾係佢地的粉絲，冇話特別鐘意邊個。不過用一個旁觀者的角度黎­講，事實上容祖兒唱Live係比趙學而好，穩定好多。況且，趙學­而出道o左o甘耐，亦比容祖兒o既經驗多，o甘樣比下去趙學而真­係輸o左。

[tangkeetong]

@fionafong1986 joey唱live真係唔係好得噃... 一首自己歌同人地歌...joey可能用左幾個月去錄去熟自己既­歌, 但人地可以用幾多日去熟悉首歌呢??

[paultungtung]

@fionafong1986

學而係早出道啲，

但佢都冇紅過，而JOEY就一出道就紅到依家，

講經驗反而係學而輸晒。

而且首唔係佢，亦只係代唱，

試問佢有幾多時間去練？

學而假音的確唔係咁好，

不過論真音同音色，唔會輸俾JOEY。

[yanhoighost]

代病倒的容祖兒唱出《痛愛》...點解佢永遠都要做代果個呢.?­?

[alexyan1130]

如果學而際遇好d...容祖兒拍十個馬屁都做唔到所謂天后...­.

[kwok3d]

細聲d好喎...

[fatau1]

where is 學而? Joey fong fei gay. not a trustworthy person

[fatau1]

i think everyone will agree. Joey is an ugly and fake woman and also a lier like ah Sa and ah Gill.

[fatau1]

joey is fake and ugly. 學而 is much better

[darkniel105]

雖然我都係 joey fans，但絕對要講一句，Joey 有今日絕對要多謝學而，如果當年 EEG 擺資源o係學而身上，joey 樂壇天后呢條路唔會走得咁易

[IwithJY]

都幾好聽喔。。。以前好少留意佢。。。佢行淑女，得咖！

[wuqiqi520]

趙學而唱的好好，香港樂壇不棒距真系損失。

[ying0622]

雖然祖兒未能演出是遺憾，但是Wyman形容這時就有天使在她身­邊出現，學而主動代唱，除了Wyman被感動得眼紅紅，現場亦被­感染，一直為學而拍和。

[ying0622]

Wyman表示被祖兒誠意所感動，更特別準備了一束花送給坐在台­下的她，雖然近日受喉嚨痛困擾，但是她依然嘗試試音，但一直未有­理想效果，直到做騷當晚，她依然十分專業地化、整頭、扮靚到場­，可惜沒有奇蹟出現，不過祖兒仍堅持上台以表誠意，Wyman表­示知道她真是盡了力。所以沒有怪對方，希望大家也不要怪。

[HogwartsPotato]

wyman should write lyrics for her!!!!

[jackrosehouse]

goosebumps

[roothilllau]

有心既就去買啦

趙學而 2009 全新錄音《聽聽》

24Bit/192kHz 頂班錄音

全碟 一 Take 過 現場錄製

全港首張 DR14 最高動態範圍評級專輯

全球首張 日本製 HQCD 國語專輯

[mayxuan]

不知道你们是否存心攻击joey?学而出过那么多首歌你们到现在­才发现他唱痛爱比较好听。。。那他以前的歌呢？

[krkicbb]

@mayxuan 是又怎樣？

[realtvb]

Bondy has such a great voice!!!

[grt34236]

I want her to come to Taiwan to make records

[dontgiveashitt]

好聽, 真的不比祖兒差

[KTV1010]

學而的唱得十分好,支持！支持！！

[HongKongDiva]

高音位ma ma地...

[ts2602039]

你既聽力都ma ma地

[gelgel813]

wow...

dunno she can sing this well in a live performence!!!!

love her voice better than joey's

guess she could use some luck for her career.....

[bondychiuclub]

her voice is awesome:)

[katzlouie]

學而的唱功十分好呀!!

[lcw2374]

絕對唔比joey差

[HG1668]

支持！！

[yting0519]

咁又唔好下下人比人,,可能佢唱歌技巧同聲係好過joey,但係­我覺得佢唱得冇咩感情喎...

[ricssssss]

但這個recording 很差 = = /

[itzMEEkk]

代病咗嘅joey唱... 者係臨時代唱??

都唱得好好wor...

唔知有無practice呢唱之前... 就算有都唔會practice得好耐啦 right??

support!! =)

[spike378]

you suck

[rockyteng]

barbiekwok57係垃圾都不如!

[ricssssss]

- -'''

不如由李惠敏 / 彭羚 唱一唱... 或 學友 唱一下 就看出什麼是 "只有誰唱得好"

原唱 唱得好的話.. 不用寫reply 也自然聽得出.

[menamedodo]

痛愛只有容祖兒先可以唱得這麼爛

[spike378]

I wish someone actually sponser her a cd singing originals instead singing other people song. She is really good. I didnt like ting much because all the songs are jazz acoustic

[fung174138]

係勁過初出度ge容祖兒

但係而家容祖兒進步jo咁多

我覺得趙學而 而家ge容祖兒冇得揮wo

[dragon845051]

支持你呀

[jeffrylg64]

I didn't know she can sing this well!!

I feel so amazed and I think she is a really good singer who could compete with Joey ^^

[babe2345]

好似泳兒

[ts2602039]

唉......呢d先叫唱歌!!

[kwok630chung]

一流的聲線!

[mh9978]

无运，可惜

[KooDevil]

i truely think she is way better than joey lor

she sings really good and i like her style too

[safarihk]

趙學而唔需要喺英皇仲好啦,英皇全部都.....咁差.學而咁有­才華,唱歌得,做主持,拍戲,瓣瓣都咁掂,以佢咁優秀嘅條件.識­欣賞佢嘅自然大把人欣賞,永遠支持學而.

[andesextrem]

佢把聲係 唔錯 而且唱得都好有技巧

而家聽返 原來joey 把聲好似佢^^

[lpy031504]

正~~

其實我覺得佢同joey各有各好

但我覺得學而d唱腔比較有個人風格 :)

[appleorange200606]

仍然係Joey 好d

[urfrienddarren]

wow shes not bad!

[diulayla]

u motha fucker..she was famous before u dumb ass...open up ur ear u bitch..she;s good as joey......not famous doesnt mean she can't sing u bitch

[tzxmm111]

无运，可惜

[csklmf86]

far better than joey chicks

[nibelungensohn]

Surprise surprise. Bondy is a bit better than Joey. I'm sorry but that's the truth.

[bondychiuclub]

do you happen to have the whole preformance?

[excusememe]

joey唱功都唔錯架wor

[hellog2]

學而唱歌好好聽呀^^

佢係飛圖個陣好勁嫁,可惜運氣不夠/.\

我覺得佢同joey各有各好,不過我鍾意學而version多d­^^

[chickhead]

She's 10 times better than Joey yung.

On everything

[GraceC]

She is my fav girl singer!!

[jesseeee2006]

She sings very well!

[menamedodo]

he sang much better than Joey

[bondychiuclub]

WOOT BONDY LIVE! I WANNA SEE MORE!

[jennybil]

perfect!!!!

[ArSa00]

bondy is really good. even on live

[l3byj3ss]

the audience spoke for me ^ . ~

[Sh0pah0lic4Eva]

i luv bondy!! i wish she will have new CDs out. She has so many fans she really should have a new CD out.

[Sh0pah0lic4Eva]

i luv bondy!!! i wish she has new CDs coming out.

[sleeptheclockaround]

WHOA. love it!

[smileydude66]

Go Bondy, Go Bondy, Go Bondy!!! Don't you ever give up singing!