My Thoughts on Freebies & MAC Holiday 2011

[katherineandmichelle]

Love this!

[toliveformusic13]

I def. need to go to M.A.C now :)

[marianadoll]

Hey Tiffany! I would really really love if you did a new bridal/wedding makeup look, but focusing on the skin... How to make a really beautiful, glowing, amazing movie star skin (and photo friendly! hehe)... Thanks! xoxo

[bribaybayx3]

ahhh i wanttt some stufff haha (: your so pretty <3

[happychichappy]

pretty items!

[rissa204]

awww!! love that necklace - saw it on Lorraine's videos! I want, just can't afford it!

[DancerChic31]

i love this video! and Tiffany, i love that you speak to us as if you were giving advice to your best friend. i always feel like i'm getting a totally honest opinion :)

[MissClaireTully]

ahhh love your honesty :) i think you just became my new role model. so head strong! xo

[cpoc4]

i love that your honest!

[ellage7]

how did u start receiving Mac products for review?...

[peanutgirl81]

Love your honesty & transparency! That's why you're one of my favorites!

[Twinkers46]

Bahhh Im so jealous! I so want that lisa taubes necklace!!!

[ImmaShiaholic]

I bought the same brush kit you showed, and I really wanted to love it but I experienced too much shedding with the 187. I don't know if I want to keep them or not, since they're my first MAC brushes and $50 is a lot for me :/

[boldkawaii]

I would always wonder "why does she by sooo much Mac?" but now I understand and I'm completely fine with it. I am so happy that your honest and say they give you it. I love you Tiffany!:)

[nevershoutkaelynx3]

you're such a genuine person. i love that about you :)

[natthecattt]

Do you have a video on your education (college, licenses etc) on becoming a makeup artist?

[irishlov71196]

tiffany your eyebrows look SO much better this way much lighter

[LaVieEnchantee1]

I think it's sad that you had to include this huge disclaimer at the beginning of your video. The fact that there are "gurus" out there providing positive reviews for products that are crap is unforgivable. They're only concerned with making a quick buck (or hundred) and that should NOT be allowed on YouTube. Tiffany, I always trust your reviews and opinions on things because you tell it like it is and you're not afraid to say if you don't like something. Even when you got it for free.

[modestlambchop]

Just ordered the snowglobe sultry compact. Excited but I agree that the packaging is rather obnoxious.

[babyjaetn]

I really apprieciate that both you and Leesha (aka xsparkage) are honest about your reviews. You show what you got and give your actual opinion on it.  You don't say that its the best thing ever and push people to run out and buy it just because it was sent to you.

[Yiuglow24]

I have to admit that I like your honesty. Love MAC but with all there collections it can be quite expensive. I wish I would receive at least a free paint pot lol... Keep it up Tif. PS if u don't use all your products u can always give them to me lol

[cynthiavcaridad]

So do you think buying the Let's Skate paint pot is worth it?

[msaudioangel]

u have some frizz sticking out at the part of ur hair ..lol looks kinda funny, and ur hair is almost always perfect. love ur vids anyways

[vlevy01]

Tiffany I love the transparency... life would be better if everyone was. I have been a subbie since the beginning and I think you have integrity!

[gabbyluvsfashion]

I think the people that hate on gurus getting free stuff don't make video's. We put so much effort into our videos and we deserve it. I work sos hard on my videos and I think we all should get so incentives!

[Lollipoper42]

I just wanted to let you know that if you did decide to let this youtube experience be a little career I'm proud of you that you r able to earn money to do what you love and since you will genuinely honest we will love you and not judge you!

Like if you agree!

[HUMAiraHUMA]

i know for sure your reviews are honest because ive bought things you've recommended and they're fantasic!! thanks for being so honest :D

[Danceforeverx201]

Mac toootallyyyy cheated with this collection :/ you can't just make the same product twice and call it something different every time... Especially if you do that to every product in the entire collection :/ I'm disappointed

[jennahock]

Oops, trying products for us free or not. The reason you r sent the products is because you are professional, consistant, truthful, wonderful at what you do etc...this is a terrific venue for new products to be used and raved or smacked. With as much work and time as these videos consume of your life you should get a truck full weekly. I have never, ever been dissapointed in a product that you have recommended, dont be stifled by what some of these people say, let them try out the french fries

[iasoaita]

good for you for standing up to the companies and being honest. as your subscribers, we really appreciate it.

[KJRvegetarian]

Thank you Tiffany for being such an honest and reliable person! I seriously respect you more than ofthers, who do paid positive reviews, and I just wanted to let you know that. I seriously felt like you were one of my girlfriends at the beginning of the video, and that's what I love about you! You are so down to earth, and I always look forward to your videos :) Thank you so much!

[jennahock]

Dont defend yourself for t

[donaldduckstar]

can you do a video on products you dont like :D

[MsRocky44]

Love you so much! You keep it real with us LOL <333 miss your videos! Do some fashion videos pleasee!

[buttonsandsmiles]

the packaging looks like dollar store but anyways great video

[blondchick4]

please tutorial on this Look!

[alansmit08]

the white packaging looks so tacky...

[MajorMovieStar]

I truly appreciate your transparency on freebies. I cant begin to tell you how many gurus have lost my subscription because they are gungho about one thing this week and gungho about something else the next week. I have spent more money than I have on recommendations from gurus whose recommendation/soul was purchased by a company. It took me longer than a minute to realize that they were getting freebies and being paid. Thats fine if you are honest and let us know this from the beginning.

[TheCoca84]

Could you please do more outfits of the day....I really like to see what people are wearing.!

[eilishn]

Intro waaay to long ..

[btrphlyksz818]

That is totally false to say just you get it for free you're gonna "Like" or "Love" it. If a product is crappy its crappy... whether you pay for it or not...

[jjbabie91]

LOVE the intro <3

[Leabeaxo]

your honesty is amazing and i respect you for that

[gwynneio]

Haters gonna hate!

[HellloKitty84]

where can u get that warm kit its soldout online!

[MsTnag]

could you do a tutorial with the cranberry colour!!

[gwynneio]

I love your honesty!

[joeytrtl]

thank you so much for the explanation of receiving freebies. Love how honest you are and it's really good to hear you say these things. I totally believe you :)

[holliswoods775]

The mistletoe nail polish looks like Perdot by Chanel!

[Karatefreako]

You seem so down to Earth (:

[AlyssaDyck]

@MakeupByTiffanyD The NEW Urban Decay Naked 2 eye shadow palette is out! Pleaseeee do a review and swatches for us! I don't know where to find it, but i'm sure you got sick hook-ups! :)

[johns2jc]

right on! *fist in the air* :) keep doing you. love your channel.

[ABetterDay00]

when you said for free at :28, I immediately thought of Britt from bridesmaids. Was I the only one?

[scorcher219396]

I love how honest you were in this video!!! thank you!

[Jamietownlol]

that was the longest disclaimer ever :) but thanks so much, you are so honest and so down to earth Tiffany :)

[elfbeauty1]

if u guys like mac but are looking for more of a diversity try bobbi brown! i just bought some of their products and their amazing! :)

[xLoveMe66]

Your eyeshadow looks really GOOD! That pallete is good for you

[LiveAndLaughForever]

(:

[MakeupGoneScandalous]

yayyyyyy another video!! love ur vids!!

[glamfaceuk]

Love your reviews please do a deep smokey eye look with the eye shadow palette. Thanks x

[thegr8lamina]

I recently subscribed to you and have really enjoyed watching all of your videos. I'm a working mom and don't have as much time as I used to to try out new products. Thank you for giving your honest opinion. Do you do videos where you shre your favorite products for different eye color? I have amber eyes and stay with a neutral brown palette but it's be nice to get suggestions in a tutorial format from you. :)

[iMurderMuffins]

what did she say at 8:25 ? haha

[amydrauch]

you seem so down to earth:)

[DeeDoesMakeup]

I love how honest you are!You are a true guru:)

[amyxx1]

thankyou, im so happy to hear your thoughts in this video :)

[vivaglamification]

HIIIIII UR THE BEST!

[biancastefanii]

I really love your eyeshadow. Which products did you use? xo

[lex7799]

Think its great that you have been so honest, you can tell. How much you genuinely feel about your channel, and we feel the same. X x

[vividuff2]

i appreciate your honesty, but i wish you introduce us products that you didn't like. it probably help us a lot when we look for products.

[intajuicegirl678]

Love the video! i understand that you are trying to go faster but i think it would be really nice to hold the products and swatches closer to the camera and let it focus for a little longer(:

[MakeupByTiffanyD]

@intajuicegirl678 Thanks! :) I have really detailed, quality swatch photos on my blog (linked in the more info section) so that you guys can see the products that correspond to the video. That's why I don't make such a big deal about showing them up close on camera. :)

[BeeAngelful]

going to check out MAC website now!

[jazzzie83]

I hate it when you explain ur self I mean people, whatever you do they'll just look for something to complain about. If someone doesn't like how you do your videos then can just switch to something else and they can suck it up cause I don't feel you have to explain anything to them! Thanks for the haul Tif <3

[lesshlyashhes]

I just subscribed to you yesterday and I already love your videos and the way you come off as .. [:

[LizN3]

I'm glad you spoke your mind and got it out there as far as what companies offer you etc. I just don't think its anyones business. Why? what does does it matter to anyone what you accumulate free or not? Just watch and ejoy the videos, thats it. Good Luck, I've enjoyed your videos ever since the IMATS LA Haul video you did the summer before last.

[mzc0905]

HAHA!!" I don't like that, I don't do that, I don't play that" 1:02 LIKE A BOSS

[xmetalbabyx]

That is awesome they send u freebies to try every month! That is every girls dream! Lucky lady :) I love that ur so honest about the products when u review them too xxx

[majolica0majorca]

<3 you tiffany i dont understand sponsored video hate either

[Tinkerchelli]

Thx so much Tiffany, I just bought the Miss Piggy Pink eyeshadow wanted to check that out. Wished I could afford a more. love watching your videos.

Lv Lucille

[mqs7524]

I do get excited about Holiday & Summer Collex.

I ended up getting a few things.

I especially love Snow Globe Beauty Powder. :-)

TY T!

[veronicashleyss]

I hope all other beauty guru's see this :)

[dayanden]

I agree with @rmlmakeup I love the make-up you're wearing. I would love a tutorial on it!

[ilesx3]

your one of the gurus that i watch and always trusted , you seem to be honest about products whether you purchased them or not =)

[happyjc77]

THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH for swatching and actually showing us the swatches on your hand! They may not be perfect swatches and I know you always post pics on your blog but it's great to see them 'live'. Please do it every time!!!

[Mzkimmy1000]

I believe ya 100 percent Tiffany :)!!! Ya always talk about really good products and i always buy them! :D

[jamieeevlogs007]

I LOVE how you're completely honest with us :)

[ktangelbaby8]

i bought the morning frost paint pot and i love it. such a nice champagne color

[amyamyamy17]

i really appreciate and respect your honesty. thank you for that!

[kristaselene]

I love MAC (the majority of my collection is MAC) and look forward to the collections especially at holiday time. I was obsessed with the Tartan Tale line but this year's did nothing for me. I thought all the products were unoriginal and looked really cheap. The swatches I've seen have also been extremely lackadaisical. I didn't buy anything... not even as a gift for friends and family who aren't nearly as picky as I am.

[mamaj08]

It is so refreshing to see a guru here on youtube who WON'T promote or talk about a product JUST because she has been sent the product. I have a tremendous amount of respect for people like you <3

[MyMakeupLife100]

I got the lipstick in whirls & twirls!! But I want to buy a mineralized eyeshadow too, they look so pretty! :)

[grabruloot]

Good for you Tiffany!

[littlemissgiggleful]

Tiffany, you're so sweet and honesty and just so genuine. ^_^ You shouldn't be bothered by the idiots who dislike your videos cause you receive things for free. They're just petty T_T And your real fans who realize how much money you spend on hauls and most importantly, EFFORT, you put into ALL your videos and we love you for that (: Don't let those meanies stop you from reviewing products sent to you for free cause a LOT of people enjoy them, including me ! (((:

[Princess87Yuna]

really appreciate ur intro speach. !

[ktlevanson]

you're awesome! :)

[10jaynim]

the packaging looks like something you can get at a dollar store...

[tnktpot97]

I love how honest you are with us <3

[RaquelFalkenberg]

Hey Tiffany, I'm looking for a good buffing brush to use for a powder foundation. WHat would you recommend?

[jenniferkmccall]

I've heard that the short handle brushes aren't as good as the full size ones. Do you find this to be true? I have several full size ones and I love them, but wanted to purchase a Christmas set because it's such a great value.

[bethoxo]

can you please do a video on becoming a makeup artist? :)

[asianseyesRpretty2]

honestly. i think u should make a separate video about this free stuffs thing instead of making us sit through ur repetitive intro whenever u review products u get for free. i find ur intro r unecessary long enough already. please dont add onto it

[Cherry109xo]

Can u do a makeup tutorial using products from this collection!

[raquelsbeautyworld]

you tell them tiffany!!!

[BeautyByNour]

i absolutely adore you:)<3

[heartz395]

Defintey picking up some of the globes for Christmas gifts;) thanks for sharing Tiff!

[catherinefb13]

I love your videos! xo i think you help so many girls!

[girlintrouble2]

Some ppl are so funny and jealous of ppl getting things for free. Its good that you have been open about what you get. Im REALLY GLAD you do get some free stuff (its a shame you dont get to choose it!) b'cos we all know you spend lots and lots of your own money on makeup and some of that is due to this chanel which we benefit from. I really liked how you really said what you thought of the MAC collection x

[vickys2xx]

omg tiffany you're so amazing! i dont know how this is possible, but i certainly can see that you are being 100% honest with us, always. i trust what you say so much, that everytime you mention a new product that you like, i'm like OMG i need to try that out! not only because you are just as exigent as me (which for me is a good thing) but also because, like i said, you're very honest! sorry for bad english btw. and i LOVE your videos!

[AStupidLambIsMe]

Love how you say "Faayncey Mooves" I'm from AL, I say it the same way!

[Shellz705]

i love that you're so real and honest, that's why i watch you! :-)

[shoegal915]

i trust you :)

i believe u are the only one i can actually trust on here

[toshNjj]

Well said Tiffany!! You do want you want to do, who cares what some rude viewers think! The people who've watched you since you started know that you tell us the truth and are honest about your reviews :)

[MacAffinity09]

I love when you do mac hauls from their collections. It feels like you're doing the shopping for me so I don't have too lol.

[mscarolking]

I'd love you to do a tutorial on your eye make up in this video, it's beautiful. And you're a beautiful person, take no heed what jealous people have to say!!! Like you I adore make up and plums are my favourite shade, goes great with green eyes. Keep up the amazing work you do, I always enjoy your videos xxx from Ireland

[bookrista27]

Ur so real.ur one of the very few gurus left that are real and true.thank you

[x6angelxface9x]

My last favorite MAC holiday collection was the tartan tale :) I do want two of the dazzlespheres with the lip glosses (coral & pink) I love the colors for them

[MakeupByTiffanyD]

@x6angelxface9x meee too! I wasn't really into tartan tale either :/

[RACHELZGZ]

Tiffany, I just want to congratulate you for the great work you do! I've been following you for years and in that time thanks to you I perfected my technique of makeup, you have given me great ideas, you have shown me countless products until then I did not know ... I've even learned English with you!

Thank you so much all this because thanks to you I learned a lot, you're adorable!

In Spain you have big fans, we love you! :)

[sarahberah1121]

will you please do a tutorial on this look? it's super simple but still really pretty, perfect for me! thanks!

[vsanders100]

I appreciate you being honest! Thanks

[pinknoted]

I don't care if you are biased, or reviewing things for money, or not. It really doesn't matter to me. It's just nice to see what's out there. I enjoy watching your videos! Don't know why people insist on voicing their jealousy over your success. It makes me sad for you and other gurus who have to address this because people insist on commenting on peoples walls to make them feel bad.

[twentysevenjo]

Tiffany, you're SO much more open & honest than other gurus! Thank you for that!

[Margalight]

Tiffany, your amazing. I love your videos for a long time now and I appreciate your honest opinion of everything. I just wanted to say that I think that you shouldn't feel like you need to defend yourself on any subject of what you do. I trust you and I know many with me.

[isoto26]

*honesty

[isoto26]

Love how ur so honestmy favorite guru by far : )

[fangparty]

Tiffany is one of the few gurus that I have trusted from the start and continue to trust. Shes real.

[linnerfors]

you are one of the gurus here on youtube that i actually trust when you say that a product is good. i have actually bought a few of the things that you've mentioned are good, and they ARE. so yeah :)

[dragonette3]

Your honesty is what makes you the best beauty guru out there

[ironthefinges]

i really hate the packaging. it looks cheap



[89SpeedyGonzalez]

Your honesty is so admirable! Thank you for making such great reviews, I always trust your opinion! If you say something is good, I always head to the store and try it asap! haha Dont let the haters stop you from doin yo thang. haha

[Samanthalaurencecil]

thank you for honestly reviewing these products that you got, i apreciate tht you give us an honest opinion its very helpful

[marym2011]

I'm pretty sure I watched another guru that said something about the weird circle on the silver bad!

[youmakemewoah]

i LOVE what you had to say about products and your channel

[isawapeach]

Thanks for being so honest, you really seem genuine :)

[bellemorte9]

Tiffany, the reason we love your videos is because you have a genuine spirit that just shines through.

A lot of people who are ~youtube guru partner etc~ seem to forget that the whole reason they have viewers is because they used to do tutorials and product reviews. I swear, 9 out of 10 of these so-called gurus throw together these crap 2 minute videos just to keep their channel going, without the time and effort that you put in. Your videos are always high quality and informative!!

[rosemarie627]

So honest. My respect for you changes after this video! I respect your complete honesty bc I watch TONS and TONS of videos daily for reviews and hauls so if I'm gonna used time I want it to be honest opinions not changed by $ paid to a guru. I already kind of knew you were like this but you coming out w a video definitely helps. GREAT VIDEO.

[luvyafoeva]

Thank you for making this video, I just unsubscribed to the Fowler Sister because I believed that companies were making the calls and the reviews were fake. But I am glad you owned up to it and were honest. Thx.

[DIRTYL00KS]

SHE DON'T PLAY THAT ! lol :) tiffany's a G

[iM8kYouUp]

"If you're an honest person and you actually HAVE a conscience there is no way you could recommend something that you are just a little bit on the fence about to hundreds of thousands of people and sleep at night" My thoughts: MAYBE that's why Elle aka Allthatglitters21 has insomnia so bad LOL!!! Tiffany you are one of the FEW people I trust on here. You're always honest with us. You are not the type to review products just for the money even if the product is crap. THANK YOU TIFF FOR ALL U DO!

[NailsByNatalie]

Wow you look so pretty! Could you do a tutorial with some of these products? And maybe even share some of your favorites from what they gave you? Thanks :)

[Norex25]

Great video. I absolutely appreciate your sincerity and honesty.

[martinawerner92]

i think it's sad that you have to explain to some people that you show us your own opinion and that you don't tell us what the brand wants you to.. if they don't want to watch the videos they should click the x on the top of the page

[excusemeCALMDOWN]

that collection dosn's seem that great

[MsPineappleKiss]

your attitude towards gifts and stuff is really great i think :)

i wish a lot of youtube people would think just the way you do ;)

[katann1991]

I don't play that lol, that"s why i love your videos Tiffany :)

[NancyTang0403]

oh my gosh i love you! you are so honest! so idk why there are so many haters...

[MacFreak04]

but now you only use sigma brushes, what happened to all your mac brushes

[inspiredmom824]

Thank you for being honest. I am much more receptive when you are straight forward. I don't think it is wrong for you to receive stuff for free, as long as you are honest.

[glamour1225]

You are so honest and I just love your whole personality! Thanks for being such a great guru:) I have gone out and buy and end up loving a ton of things you recommend. Xoxo

[grantje05]

mac nail polish makes me really mad. i love mac but their nail polish is awful. i have drugstore polishes that last longer and that are way way cheaper.

[victimofstereotypes2]

What is ur opinion on the quality of the MAC gift set brushes compared to the regular individual brushes? Are they worth $50? Or am I paying for the MAC name? I'm considering buying Too Faced teddy bear brushes, has anyone out there tried them?

[mpca66]

Very pretty collection, but I just bought the Tarte Starlet Limited-Edition Makeup Vanity and so I think I'm done buying makeup for the rest of the year :-)

[luckyelfie]

I am so over all the MAC collections. I'm glad you're liking this holiday collection, but it seems like MAC is no longer even trying. The snow globe compacts and makeup bags look so cheap, like something from the dollar store.

[tabs728]

I have been watching you for years and LOVE all your videos. Love all your reviews and LOVE LOVE LOVE your home videos. Who cares about the 'haters'. You keep doing what you are doing because there are a lot of us that really enjoy your videos. Thank you!!

check out my blog: Moon-Orchids.blogspot.com

[rmlmakeup]

Please do a tutorial on your eye makeup, in this video. I love it! Thank you! Ramona@rmlmakeup

[VintagePink100]

I have always trusted you, Tiffany! Don´t let the very few people you talk about who don´t understand ruin it for the rest of us!

[sunshine09bbopper06]

I definately want everything that was shown! My makeup collection is pretty tiny so Nothing of what I own is like that.

Anyways I highly appreciate you taking the time to explain the whole freebie thing. It's annoying to have to explain to other viewers how freebie works especially when they come back at me with snooty comments like "how could you possibly know when you're not a guru." I will always trust that your being honest on something you like or dislike.

[Rachel07Cooper]

im about only 3 minutes into the video and this is by far the best video youve made! in my opinion.

too sweet of you to be so honest

[theresarohm]

Thanks for your thorough review, I've been watching you for 1 year + and I love your reviews on MAC, and since I don't own any I always wanted to splurge and get some, so when I do find any MAC products I will forsure get some :)

[loveangelx11]

For some odd reason, this video made me hungry

o w o lol you look gorgeous by the way

[alesi86]

thank you for your honesty!!!!!!!!

[roglesby74]

You totally save me money and I very much appreciate your honesty <3

[imcrazyforbirds]

thanks for being honest! I think it is awesome that you can be so honest with your viewers!

[jmuswmr]

can you do a tutorial with the gold eyeliner?! pleaseee :)

[polkadotjello1000]

Thanks for this video. I honestly think that you don't need to justify what you do on your channel. Your opinions are refreshing and honest. If someone thinks that your biased, just ignore! You are doing a great job!

[GlamouratziGurl]

You should not shake polish bottles, there are liquid filled beads in polish and if you shake the bottle they break and the liquid inside them make you polish lumpy and thick. You should always roll your polish in your hands! Great video :)

[xMistressxMacabre]

Could you do a look using the three cranberry shades from the 6-shadow palette? Cranberry-plum is an amazing look for Fall/the Holidays, but it can be so hard to achieve without looking muddy. I own Trax and Shadowy Lady and both can be difficult - without the right base Trax can look all bronze, and Shadowy Lady can look chalky, streaky and sheer. I would love to see how you work with these colours, plus the third shade together!

[CelestineVenilia]

I love your honesty! It makes me super happy that I can continue to watch you and know that your genuine!!! Please do a tutorial on your eye look .....it is soooo beautiful!

[tenebroseavventure]

i'm glad you are honest with us! you are a lovely person :)

[kristinlovesgreg]

I wish MAC would send me stuff!!!!!! No fair! :)

[dennyvee22]

You should do tutorial on starter kit for mac. I would love it.

[BelindaBuzz]

Love you for being so honest to your subscribers! :) <33