Added: 3 years ago
From: thesoulbreath
Views: 65,518
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (65)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is the ultimate momemt of music, it can not go any further..

  • Simply Stunning..and FRom a Scottish tv production....we Scots have taste...and yes the crowd Where feeling the vibes Alright...How could One not

  • true epic

  • Is this song on the 2nd episode of misfits season 1?

  • awesome

  • ....fantastic performance!

  • Is everybody in that studio deaf? Had this been filmed in a deaf-folks home??

  • Love you Nick. Blow that crowd your performance was AWESOME

  • Simply stunning...!!

  • Don't you HATE how the audience is just sitting there, not feeling it, not getting it?

    What a effin waste.

  • @100thingsbefore2012 I'm sorry, but you can feel something without going crazy about it.

  • @100thingsbefore2012 how can you possibly know what the audience were or were not feeling?? thats a pretty bold statement mate.

  • If I was sitting in the front row at 2:50 I would be absolutely terrified.

  • So fucking good. Great fucking band....

  • I think I just came....

  • worst audience ever...sitting there like tepid pudding...

  • @Riddler361 maybe they're just ....listening

  • wrong the electric chair is a metaphor for a bar stool and Nick's ongoing struggle with addiction, could reference this a million times over too busy for just that keep it a simple Green Mile link to the Weeping Song/John Finns wife/Murder Ballads that followed etc...

  • wrong the electric chair is a metaphor for a bar stool and Nick's ongoing struggle with addiction, could reference this a million times over too busy for just that keep it a simple Green Mile link to the Weeping Song etc...

  • Thamk you for posting this beautiful version! re: the comment "singular in most of rock music": yes, it does seem stream of consciousness, especially since he switches up the lyrics every time he performs it, which is probably why he's not a master-of-masters in the USa, where we like our burgers to be the same everywhere...

    (...this is what the pure Terror before Acceptance of "The End" sounds like,

    might I say.........might I know...)

  • Thamk you for posting this beautiful version! re: the comment "singular in most of rock music": yes, it does seem stream of consciousness, especially since he switches up the lyrics every time he performs it, which is probably why he's not a master-of-masters in the USa, where we like our burgers to be the same everywhere...

    (...this is what the pure Terror before Acceptance of "The End" sounds like, might I say.......)

  • Thamk you for posting this beautiful version! re: the comment "singular in most of rock music": yes, it does seem stream of consciousness, especially since he switches up the lyrics every time he performs it, which is probably why he's not a master-of-masters in the USa, where we like our burgers to be the same everywhere...

    (...this is what the pure Terror before Acceptance of "The End" sounds like......)

  • Comment removed

  • This is what The End sounds like

  • Anyway I told the Truth

  • w0w man tht cr0wd iz kinna dead..id be up 0utta my seat if he was perf0rming in fr0nt 0f me like tht

  • What a great recording! Thanks very much for having updated the music quality! I think this is my favorite version of that song, too!

  • What a great recording! Thanks very much for having updated the music quality!

  • Can anyone tell me what DVD i have to purchase to get the "Boxed Set", Scottish TV, broadcast of 12 april 2001. I've not been able to find it on Amazon?

    Any help appreciated, thanks.

  • This is a great performance. Thank you for sharing it. Just recently getting into Nick Cave...

  • Great song ,my favourite version.

    Thanks Uploader!

  • I love this version so much... so intense, building up to the climax. And Nick has such an amazing voice! ( :

    Anyone know if this show is available to buy?

  • I heard this song for the first time this morning-this is simply awesome!

  • just perfect......

  • BRILLIANT!!!

  • Gänsehaut!

  • Great! Gänsehaut! The cover of Johnny Cash ist just very good, too!

  • it builds and builds and builds till you think it cant possibly get any more gut-wrenchingly intense.......then it builds some more.

    what. a. fucking. song.

  • @Jefflebowski95 - this is quite possibly the best summary of this song I've seen.

  • Any one know what show this is from?

  • absolutely:

    "Boxed Set", Scottish TV, broadcast of 12 april 2001 Show

  • it's a killer....

    i'm afraid he told the truth

  • This song is singular in most of rock music for several reasons:

    1) It is written from the first person perspective of a character who is not the writer

    2) It seems to be a stream of consciousness

    3) As such, there is the sense that the whole song takes place over the span of only a brief moment or so in the speaker's mind

    4) The song builds in intensity without overtly changing its structure.

    It's really very impressive --you get the sense this is the very moment before electrocution.

  • @mechroboticon i share your opinion, it does seems like a brief moment in, i get the feeling, courtroom, where justice is made of wood and wire, and god is never far away :D

  • @mechroboticon

    1) is not so uncommon - just look at the lyrics to the complete "Murder Ballads", Pink Floyd's "The Wall" or Genesis' "The Lamb lies down on Broadway" for example;

    2) isn't every song text like a stream of consciousness?

    4) this is only present in few songs - Moloko's "Forever more", Björk's "Declare independance" or Archive's "Again" are building up in a similar way

  • @mechroboticon You pretty much summed up most of Nick Cave's work. He tells stories in a stream of consciousness that never really derails from the narrative and quite a few of the Bad Seeds songs don't really change key or structure. A few have chord changes and a few have breakdowns, but most of his songs just start rolling and don't let up. They just keep building and building.

  • @mechroboticon You might want to listen to some Pain of Salvation. They've got plenty of songs written in the first person but from a perspective other than the writer's ^_^

  • wonderful!!!!!the best songwriter ever....

  • this is just insane!

    i love when he goes so wild ! i think he should be more wild in all the performences! i want to see more of his rough punk roots! i want him screaming, jumping , giving his soul and at the end recovert it again!

  • But... he's not prostitute. Yes, the concerts ARE for the public. But what you're writing about is impossible to plan or even act.

  • I would be so scared. I was scared when he was acting like that to me during a Grinderman gig, but this looks even more intense...

  • i've heard so many versions of nick singing this song, but never one as moving as this.

    breathtakingingly genius....

  • I knew the version well and it is the best version and I missed it's prescence on You Tube greatly.

  • great great video thanks

  • That's one of the best Nick Cave's performances ever. Beautiful, very emotional and intense. I saw it on youtube a few years ago, and then it suddenly disappeared. It made such an impression on me, that I kept checking if someone put it back. :) I'm very glad you uploaded it.

  • too strange to live too wierd to die

  • Thanks, my favourite version.

  • Thanks for uploading this.

  • wow! what a performance!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more