Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (292)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm speechless... that's why I'm typing this

  • i get so wrapped up that i spend hours just watching you!

  • he is why i watched the x factor i love his gruffness i love vocalists with that kind of talen like caleb followill and corey taylor

  • just lovely!!!! amazing!!!!! and fantastic>>>>> voice.

  • what a soul this man has. Only true musicans can recognize the touching pure talent this man possesess

  • josh u send chills down my spine when i hear u sing... i love u and im pissed u didnt win but i know i will hear ur beautiful voice again.. love u babe ur awsome

  • @sabrinagraves88 even though he lost i am pretty sure he will be more successful than melonie

  • Josh, you  make me smile and cry at the same time. What a voice! What an artist!

  • best song ever on this season if he song this for the finaly he would have won he is amazing thumbs up if you think he should have won ...

  • Remarkable voice. There is no part of his register that doesn't have amazing depth and richness, from the whispery soft lows to the achingly pure glory notes to the falsetto. And, he can add the growly rasp wherever he chooses. So many colors in his palette and he has complete mastery of all of them. What an artist. This is breathtaking talent.

  • I love his music!!!!!!!!

  • An Amazing, Touching, Heartfelt Performance

  • Brilliant. 10/10 brilliant. Best version I have heard of this. x

    

  • his voice is powerful..I cry everytime I watch this video..:)

  • INCREDIBILE.....

    

  • probably replayed this like a thousand times so far... cant even describe how i feel when i listen to him....ghose bumps

  • why do the best people always lose....when i heard this song it really touched my heart i even cried and heck....im only an 11 year old kid....

  • wow you my friend are a vocal wizard. My favorite song (wild horses(cover) - bush) was just blown out of the water. Your voice and story are a true inspiration and the world could use some of it right about now. Im looking forward to your future cd. Thank you and your aspiration to get your music through too as many people as possible and make a difference in this shitty era for music. Truly thank you!

  • God damnit he should of won and he did in my eyes

  • Absolutely amazing!! When is your CD coming out???

  • 1:01 Her soul is trying to go away... just like mine

  • Man...! I love your voice. Never quit singing, please...

  • es la voz de un angel!!!! mientras respire y aun sin ella, quisiera volver a cantarla y oirla.. gracias joshua!!!

  • He should have one, Hands down...

  • Amazing performance, he really did this song justice.

  • Josh should have WON xfactor!! i was really upset when he placed second to Melanie, who is an amazing singer in her own right, just not my kind of music. Josh has the voice, he has the heart and he definately has the musical talent to be the next big thing ... I am patiently waiting for my Josh Krajcik CD <3

  • @withoutmedication I agree completely. Melanie was very good, but Josh should have won

  • still lovin you

  • Would love to have a soft spoken album with songs such as Hallelujah on it. In my opinion it would sell well for those who love that type of music. There is a large baby boomer age span at this time that can appreciate the style. I was rocking in the 70's and still love it but also would love a "chill out" cd. Josh you are exceptional!! xo

  • @clarkrcdc I AGREE!!!!!!!!

  • BEST PERFORMANCE OF SEASON 1

  • he needs to record this song on his first album

  • I'm not a fan of the type of songs that Josh sings but this, this is AWESOME! He has the voice for this song that none of the others could probably sing.

  • Paula's crying!

  • Very honest and beautiful performance!!

  • the man just makes me close my eyes and smile

  • Why so low quality...damn it.

  • @Jzscrstsprstr You need speakers. I had to get some to be able to hear his music properly. It made an amazing difference. I knew I needed some, and when I couldn't hear him the way I wanted, I received some at Christmas. Man, am I glad.

  • Definition of perfection!!!

  • Love you Josh! Would pay anything to watch you live in concert. You're by far the best! Wish we could have voted from Canada. Hope to see you in Toronto one day live in concert at the ACC!

  • Por Dios que grave ya un cds josh te amooooo

  • i love you josh!

  • Meh this was my least favorite performance from him so far.

  • JOSH

    i love the fact your happy were you are on the way to were you are going

    its not about the money ! its about the gift GOD GAVE YOU .

    use it well josh !

  • OMG he gives me goosebumps, it has been a long time since any artist has this affect on me. What an original talented singer he is.

  • Is the most wonderful thing i ever hear!

  • the perfect song for the perfect moment ;)

  • te amo josh krajick!

  • amazing voice Josh!!! you voice touch my heart and soul

  • this is just so beautiful. :')

  • MY wife noticed it but I hear it I can heard a little Bob Segar in his voice

  • @eloozhun I said this exact thing before, I had hoped he would sing Turn the Page during the show.

  • THIS SHOW IS FIX .... UNREALISTIC HE DIDN'T WIN A TRUE ARTIST WITH THE xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxXX­XXXXXXXXXXxxxxxxxxxxx FACOTR... THIS PREFORMANCE MADE ME TEARY EYED

  • Josh you inspired me to soar to new heights! I have re-written this song and I call it "My Broken Hallelujah!". I hope family, friends, fans, the judges, your peers and you will give this version a listen to as well. It really goes out to the broken hearted. Those who feel washed up, down & out and and depressed to the point of suicide. This is my broken hallelujah, on my knees before God. There is a God who cares. There is hope. There is healing. There is redemption. There is deliverance.

  • Amazing voice!! :)

  • First time I've seen this as I don't watch the show. WOW. Tears streaming...

  • OH how I adore him. I can't get enough of him and that voice. I agree with one on here when they said, "JOSH IS ALREADY a winner". He has won my heart with that voice. Sing it to me again Josh and again and again and again. I have already bought everything you sang but it's not enough laughingggggggggggg I WANT MORE!

  • He is so incredible, I hope for our sake and for his that he gets the opportunity to make more music. Better comparison than Elvis (?!), look up the White Buffalo's Love Song #1, another big man with a voice you have to hear to believe.

  • @Cacaw1 Simon Cowell gave confirmation that Josh is getting a record deal Hallelujah! :)

  • Hope he makes a cd with all music with him and his piano! His voice doesn't need more than that!

  • Someone please explain how do we vote in twitter!

  • Carlysu response. Thanks for your response. I should have known I might get in a little trouble with that comparison without a better explanation. I am comparing only their ability to put that special feeling and inflection in a song. Not many singers have that special "soul". That is why so many great singers on AI have faded into the landscape not to be heard from again. As for Josh's scruffy look it is going to be interesting to see if they spruce him up--I bet they will.

  • chills from head to toe

  • This video give me chills. It's perfect.

  • Josh tenes que ser el ganador de este concurso desde COLOMBIA te admiro y tengo 14 años!!

    saludes desde COLOMBIA!!

  • @Davincho97 Desde otros paises se puede votar los miercoles en la noche por 6 horas consecutivas utilizando twitter. 

  • Epic face at 1:33

    but still amazing

  • This song is the reason why I love him.

  • Can't stop playing this video. It's magical. Haven't felt this way about a performer in a long, long time. Keep thinking about all the songs that would sound so much better with him singing them. Especially now...imagine a Christmas album! Cannot wait to buy his music. Like Nicole said, he's a gift. L.A. Reid must be numb.

  • Marcus gone... and Chris is on his way out... say "byebye" Chris

  • @MrSvenghouli agree i think its between Melanie and Josh in the end and it was for a long time

  • @Newbpwng Agreed..still wouldve loved to see Rachel in top 3

  • @PraiseTheWitches I'm sorry but I thought we were all entitled to our own opinions.. I stated my opinion.. if you dont like it just ignore it.. no need to get all uppity about it..=)

  • If this competition was based solely on vocal talent, either Josh or Melanie would win. He is such an amazing singer! He has a beautiful voice with it's rawness and passion!

  • I love u Josh! Open the heavens like this,yea!!!!

  • @PraiseTheWitches lol. didnt know u were hearing impaired..sorry

  • Josh is actually better than Melanie and Chris together. So please you crazy too dear Americans, vote for this wonderful, beautiful and incredibly humble and nice person and treat him the win. He has something indescribably beautiful, what they're able to grab the heart like nobody else. It has a beautiful soul and voice, and he really needs to win, Melanie and Chris do not interfere with him even after the foot!

  • Josh not only has the incredible voice but just listen to what he does with his voice. Everything seems to be in the right place at the right time. Although the voice is totally difference I feel the same ability in Josh that Elvis had. The feeling they both could project in a song is definately rare. I can't imagine how Josh went this long without somebody that could help his not noticing his incridible talent.

  • @jbatton67

    Josh can sing, but I wouldn't really compare him to Elvis. Elvis could sing and act and Charisma. Elvis was handsome and appealing to the eyes. Josh however, no matter how they dress him up, always have a greasy, scruffy mountain man look about him. He had a band, but in all the videos, he always looked rough and unappealing.

  • @carlysu Thanks for your response to my comparing Josh with Elvis. I should have been a little more clear but I didn't want to take a lot of space. Obviously, as much as I just love Josh with his humbleness and "down to earth" style he definately only compares with Elvis with his delivery and feeling in his songs. I am convinced, because of that, Josh is going to sell lots of cds. I don't think this planet will ever get another Elvis

  • @carlysu

    Seriously, comparing Josh to Elvis is like comparing my left ball to my right ball...their both so different but so sensitive.

  • OH MY GOD!!! this was so moving. Like Paula said he sings straight thru you....

  • I love this song...What a great performance Josh,bravo...My husband just simply repeatedly listening to this amicable song.I have a feeling that you'll be the one to beat Melanie Amaro or probably you'll gonna be the Big Winner...Good Luck " JOSH "

  • Josh....Josh....Thank you. My wife always watches these competitions and I never really pay attention. Until now. I voted for Josh 161 times after this performance. Josh also caused me to get out my guitar and keyboard. It's not always about technical skill, its about feeling the song and Josh....Josh......thanks man. My music is back.

  • @antiduffog you definitely feel Josh's music. He's such a blessing! Can't wait to start my Josh collection!

  • i'm suprised that simon was so nice after hearing LEE on american idol. although josh made it hsi own

  • This song never fails to uplift my spirit...and now, with Josh singing it...I L♥VE IT more!!!

  • i cried after i saw dis

  • So incredible. I just love him!

  • You make this song sound original man...goodluck Josh

  • Comment removed

  • This show aired three days ago and this song is still stuck in my head, I love it! I'll be doing something and then HALLELUJAAAHH~ lol :)

  • Remember what happened in American Idol season 5 with Taylor Hicks??? Chris Daughtry tore up the charts.... I can see this happening with X factor. I love Melanie Amaro... but I can compare her to so many. When is the last time you heard a voice like Josh.. The only one I can come up with IN MY OPINION was Joe Cocker, Voices like Josh dont come around very often... He deserves to win the Contract. I luv Chris R. too, but to think of him doing a pepsi commercial is kinda strange

  • I hope Josh gets a recording contract ASAP whether he wins or loses. I'll be right there in line to buy his CD. I LOVE his voice! It's flawless!

  • Oh my God....Josh you are so amazing...you make me weep...you are the winner....xxxx

  • I agree, all judges are great. They truly know TALENT except LA Reid. He may trying to copy Simon's style, but Simon KNOWS talent.

  • I think Josh is awesome!!! He nails it every time he gets on stage!!!! Nicole might be his mentor but she doesn't do anything except be a cheerleader, its all Josh!!!!

  • Josh is going to sell CDs like no one has ever sold CDs from AI & Xfactor. He doesn't have to win--he has already won. He could cut his on CD and sell it one line and get rich. Slinging Burritos is no longer in his future--maybe "singing" buritos. I am also convinced that Josh could go back over the last 50 years and pick great songs and "make them his own" and they would sell big. When he does a song it sounds like a new song.

  • @jbatton67 He's probably gonna get as big as Daughtry, or close. It's gonna be hard to beat Carrie, though, I think. <3

  • @jbatton67 exactly. He could sing the zip code and it would sell. LOVE THIS MAN!

  • Yo tambien queria a Josh como el ganador...estoy muy molesta por la gente que no voto por el,deben pensar que la voz de melanie es una voz muy comun,nos recuerda a Celin,a mariah y a otras mas pero como Josh nadie... Uff me imagino una cita romantica escuchando a Josh Krajcik ooo no quiero pensar en lo que podria pasar

  • @Duraznito4 Totalmente deacuerdo y ésta canción es la mejor, el cantó con mucho sentimiento. Josh era mi favorito y me dolió mucho que no ganara, Melanie no me gusta para nada es otra Whitney/Mariah wannabe, pero Josh es original y el no necesita the x factor para ser un ganador, el realmente tiene the x factor.

  • @jbatton67 Hahaha Singing burritos :DD I do love his voice hes got that rough voice I wish they both could have won 

  • Hey I've uploaded a video of myself singing this song, please listen to it and let me know what you think :)

  • By far the best on the show. But I feel all of these young teenagers will vote for Melanie and Chris more. Which is unfortunate because Josh is 10x better them both of them.

  • @ninjan7ckmaniac That is why we need to VOTE as many places as we can find: Online, my cell, my brother's cell, my mom's cell, anybody' cell phone that we can borrow to put in those votes! :) LOVE Josh!!!

  • la reid is a cunt.

  • I think the best part about Josh is that he Sings with his heart, and soul... when he wins this i hope he keeps doing it!

  • @weeunc1 AMEN!

  • This guy is amazing, great voice. His best performance by FAR

  • we all need to band together and vote Josh to represent America.....He is what we all strive to be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Go Josh!!!!!

  • @13thehulk absolutely! VOTE VOTE VOTE!!

  • josh sang this song beautifully!

  • I <3 HIM!

  • i'm a 17 year old girl who is in love with josh right now. when he sing he take my breath away. I LOVE YOU JOSH AND I HOPE YOU WIN, EVEN IF YOU DON'T YOU WILL ALWAYS BE #1 IN MY HEART AND AMERICA. ( what i'am saying you already win)

  • I love Josh

    get his CD tomorrow, I wish

  • like

  • I reallyhim he made me cry :-(

  • LA RUDE SUCKS!!!

  • OMG this young man is so talented and this song just touched my soul. Don't know how far behind we are in the X factor but I wish him all the best and hope he wins he is AWESOME.

  • josh...he really make me cry..i also love paula abdul...

    love from Malaysia....

  • Ahhh arrepiei... povo do EUA votem nesse cara pra ganhar.. porque no Brasil não tem como.. e ele dos 3 é o que merece... a voz do cara... SENSACIONAL!

  • He does it ALL! Yay, Josh.

  • goosebumps!

  • AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME!!!!

    

  • Missing my friends Jessica Marie Long and M Joseph Clark Jr who passed away this week... they are rejoicing and singing Hallelujah with the Lord now <3 Rest in peace angels...

  • Josh Krajcik all the way!!!!!!!!!!!! It will be him and Melanie, the best singers.

  • Cant wait to see how far he goes with his music. He's come a looong way from Wooster, and Columbus, Ohio!!

  • This man can sing ANYTHING!!! He can take any style or genre of music and make it his own!! Simply amazing!!!! If Josh does not win this competition, then I will know that the show is not about talent, but about the judges favoring the ones they mentor!!! Win or lose, Josh Krajcik is already a star and will be a major music star very soon!!! I'll be in line to buy his CD!!

  • Absolutely breathtaking. This is the best version I have ever heard! I wish he would make a CD for this song just like this! Not going to lie, got a little teary eyed on this. Way to go Josh! I hope you win!

  • I ADMIT THIS GUY REALLY DESERVED TO WIN EVENTHOUGH IM BIG FAN OF MELANIE..TRULY A GIFTED SINGER WITH SO MUCH EMOTION IN HIS VOICE

  • That was so beautiful...

  • THIS PERFORMANCE IS PERFECT..10/10..LA REID IS JEALOUS IDIOT

  • @alexis2power yeah, it's the nature of the x-factor setup though. As it stands, only Paula has been free to give her opinion without a vested interest in the outcome. The secondary battle of "mentors" quite often ruins the show.

  • LA reid is terrible..he is cleary jealous of josh talent and scared that he would win over chris rene..thats why he say shit things about him..he is really suck..he is producer untalented ppl like justin bieber and rihanna..he is really a bad judge and cannot see talent..JOSH WAS SO AMAZING AND TRULY A GIFTED SINGER

  • BTW, as for "Hallelujah", yes it's a great song but here's a PSA from Leonard Cohen: 

    watch?v=aGpumEYjDAc&feature=re­lated

  • I'd like to hear Tom Cochrane's "Boy Inside the Man" updated by somebody with Josh's type of voice. watch?v=WXY9wANQIsY

    with thicker base and drums.

  • Everyone eeds to vote for this guy he puts his heart and soul in every performance and we are now down to the top 3

  • WOW

    

  • I believe he will write and sing songs that many people will be married to in the future.

  • He makes me cry, in such an amazing way.

  • listening to this song sung by him gives me chills its so amazing

  • When Josh sings this it's like I've never heard the song before. Just breathtaking, astonishing, and beautifully holy. He has nuances in his voice that no one........and I mean NO ONE else has. If he doesn't win it will be a shame. There's hundreds of Melanie-type voices and even though I love Chris Rene as a person, his voice can't touch Josh's voice. Josh is just totally incredible.

  • I started thinking that Nicole might be the best fit for Josh as a mentor, for she is a perfect cheerleader and that's probably all Josh needs in this competition.

  • @chenyuyufc loved your comment! Nicole is great and you are so right.

  • Josh... one word man, your a SuperStar!!! As noted your my favorite X-man! GO GO GO ~ HalleLujAH ~ =)

  • Josh is one sexy bitch.

  • dis is bobby from hawaii you nailed it man

  • I hate what that one judge said to him!!! ugh i mean, REALLY?! >:O

    JOSH IS THE BEST AND EVERYONE KNOWS IT!!!! :DDD

  • he's a songwriter (suzanne) and a guitar/piano player, AND a singer!

  • josh ftw! as if any other...

  • damn i hope booger wins this.

  • :) 

  • Next weeks final song should totally be joe cocker.

  • I hope LA Reid gets fired from the X Factor. He so full of himself and a bad judge!!

  • @MsDominic20

    I sooooo agree!!!

    

  • @MsDominic20

    relax...relax... who are you to "judge" the judge ?

    LA Rude is mentoring someone still in the competition, he has to say bad thing to his competitor.

  • @MsDominic20 this just proves how sad of a man he is...to critic josh just to make get votes for chris ....so sad....man up LA and admit who the winner is!

  • @MsDominic20 LA AND NICOLE SHOULD GET F-ING FIRED

  • this gives me chills and it's like the third time I've watched this

  • From the first moment Josh opened his mouth to sing AT LAST....I was hooked to his voice! and could not believe it! From that day I decided he was my favorite...NEVER DOUBTED. Right there I knew that guy had something so special! Not only because of that very unique and amazing voice but he just transport you with the song, makes you feel the words, the music...makes magic happen! Then I thought his mom had it completely right! He is so gifted!

  • I THINK HIS VERSION IS EVEN BETTER THAN JON BON JOVI'S

    

  • LA makes it a point that it wasn't upbeat or exciting. Does he think that Marcus, Chris, or Astro had better voices? Or even performances for that matter?

    WTF LA, I thought you'd be a good judge.

  • @mauled13579 .. L.A contestants I don't even bother to hear the listen to the whole songs...they are just not my style! Astro? is that music?!! Chris....can sing decently and it's not as annoying, Marcus? the best voice of the three, moves well but... there is nothing special about him. I have seen better!

  • Majicik Krajcik does it again! Good luck in the finals, Josh!