Mashallah he did good! Oh and about the music topic, from my knowledge (and correct me if I'm wrong) there is halal and haram music. Music that incites one to do sinful acts such as sex, drugs, steal, kill, are haram. And during the Prophets time their was music that he made permissible.
no of course he did his part, but it left me curious to why he left the beats in the first place.
I just thought the idea of those who try to follow the quran and sunnah to the fullest without bidah, shirk and kufr. were those who are most likely against music
what scholars say only music with sexual material is haram? Ive never heard of that one,is this from modern western scholars?
Im not trying to start a debate, Im curious b/c I thought the ruling was simpler than it is
@marcelcol69 The issue of ma'azif is not a simple one indeed. Ibn Hazm disagreed with the majority of scholars based on the strength of the evidence used. unlike others, he didnt merely explain the evidences, but he went further to weigh them.
Which video did you go over this event with Ubn Hazm?
Would you say beats as long its accompanied by islamic lyrics or w.o lyrics at all are not haram? Or would you say music made by a kaffir can also be permissible to listen to?
I think I heard from a Shi'a quoting our hadith saying thaT if people played drums at their homes every night for 40 days would then be cursed, correct if theyre actually shi'a sources b/c it is unreliable
lol Your boy Towers over everybody. Mashallah 11:49 i know u was screamin.... i would have been lol
sequal420 3 months ago
Masha Allah, how can anyone dislike this?
iris9mm 5 months ago
Mashallah he did good! Oh and about the music topic, from my knowledge (and correct me if I'm wrong) there is halal and haram music. Music that incites one to do sinful acts such as sex, drugs, steal, kill, are haram. And during the Prophets time their was music that he made permissible.
iiiTOXSICKiii 5 months ago
@iiiTOXSICKiii 100% correct.
dawahworks 5 months ago
@dawahworks 2:02 sounds like pokemon, u like pokemon?
3litepker 5 months ago
@iiiTOXSICKiii all kind of music is haram only "duff" is halal
lo0lo0007 5 months ago
@lo0lo0007 Wrong!
iiiTOXSICKiii 5 months ago
@iiiTOXSICKiii true unless you are not sunni :p
lo0lo0007 5 months ago
I spoke on this in past videos.
dawahworks 5 months ago
Comment removed
marcelcol69 5 months ago
@marcelcol69
Not all muslim scolars agree on that. Some say all music is haram some say music that contain sexual materials is haram.
So take your pick. And if you believe in the first one, then he has left you a warning in the description. From my point of view he did his part.
snowc3ed 5 months ago
@snowc3ed
no of course he did his part, but it left me curious to why he left the beats in the first place.
I just thought the idea of those who try to follow the quran and sunnah to the fullest without bidah, shirk and kufr. were those who are most likely against music
what scholars say only music with sexual material is haram? Ive never heard of that one,is this from modern western scholars?
Im not trying to start a debate, Im curious b/c I thought the ruling was simpler than it is
marcelcol69 5 months ago
@marcelcol69 The issue of ma'azif is not a simple one indeed. Ibn Hazm disagreed with the majority of scholars based on the strength of the evidence used. unlike others, he didnt merely explain the evidences, but he went further to weigh them.
dawahworks 5 months ago
@dawahworks
Assalaamu Alaykum akhi
Which video did you go over this event with Ubn Hazm?
Would you say beats as long its accompanied by islamic lyrics or w.o lyrics at all are not haram? Or would you say music made by a kaffir can also be permissible to listen to?
I think I heard from a Shi'a quoting our hadith saying thaT if people played drums at their homes every night for 40 days would then be cursed, correct if theyre actually shi'a sources b/c it is unreliable
marcelcol69 4 months ago
@marcelcol69 I did not produce a Video on Ibn Hazm. Just google "Ibn Hazm music" & read about it. Then we can discuss further.
dawahworks 4 months ago
mashallah he stands out amongst the rest
may allah make him a string mujahid for islam inshallah
call2allah 5 months ago