people is so silly !! shes amazing and before she joined we r the fallen she already had the tattoos and her Gothic style s please dotn say shes trying to b like amy
I'm still seeing Carly Smithson videos and seeing comments about Amy Lee and Evanescence. Both bands are similar, but they do have their differences and BOTH bands are completely amazing. I love both bands, and people sort of need to get a grip and realize that they are both amazing.
HER HAIR IS GODDAMMED BLACK!! STUPID PEOPLE WHO ARE JEALOUS OF HER SUCCESS AND SPEND THEIR TIME HATING COZ THEY KNOW THAT THEY WILL NEVER REACH HER LEVEL..=]
HATERS YOU GUYS ARE JUST JEALOUS CAUSE THIS GIRL IS HAVING THE TIME OF HER LIFE.....AND FROM WHAT I'VE HEARD THE ALBUM SOUNDS GREAT ....WE ARE THE FALLEN ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank God she didn't get the first record deal otherwise we wouldn't have We Are The Fallen plus shes probably more known now than any of the other contestants
ok seriously. i think she is trying to be amy lee abit. she looks so bright and airy here and she has changed!!! she has changed since she went into we are the fallen. as an Evanescence fan... im not taking sides though, i have listened to we are the fallen, but she has changed, and she looks more like amy and is trying to sound more like her aswell. if you cant see it then your a littl bit blind. dont take sides and just look... then youll see.
I would not say she is being amy lee. AT all. She is her own person and own unique voice. AND BESIDES AMY IS OLD AND SHE IS NEW. Not the same music at all. But. still she is her own .
LIFEANDOBLIVION fuck you fucker!Carly is great!Listen to WATF im the only one.AND stop all you fucker put carly in the same jar with Amy.Amy is Amy and Carly is Carly and both are wonderful.so shut up and suck your own cock!
What looks like Amy, has a band fill of Evanescene ex bandmembers, what's to be like Amy by dressing gothic.......this wannabe does!!!! She's no Amy Lee and never will be no matter how much they try they can't beat the fact that Amy is the Gothic Queen so gothic that she wears white to announce that she's the Queen. Try to beat that wannabe!!!!
she is an angel, sue me if i'm wrong, but she is so truly sweet and honest person, she is so talented. ever since i discovered her she is my favourite singer, my best influence. she is great :)
la copia barata de amy lee...maquillaje todo es igual que amy lee...ni en eso pueden ser creativos????
cheap copy of amy lee ... everything is like makeup amy lee ... or it can be creative?? I'm sorry, but here there is no room for another amy lee, amy lee was able to win the public. end of story, voice talent ... their way of singing ... like her no
She has such a beautiful voice! She really should have won, but alas, AI is family oriented so an awesome rocker chick with tats wasn't going to win. But I still cannot get over how much she looks like Amy Lee. Certain angles, a certain way her hair is done, her smile. Ugh, it's so strange. I love WATF but I still cannot get over their look. I'm really glad she decided to stay in a neutral zone about Ev and WATF.
@emptywhisper There are a couple interviews of her outright denying ever even having heard Ev's music yet shes covered three of their songs. IDC if Ben helped co-write some or not, thats Ev's music. She knows who they are. Listen- I like her as a singer I don't like people who bend the truth. If she'd just say yeah- Im in a band full of ex-ev members, therefore we mat sound alike but were here to make some music end of story. They fight the 'similiarity' thing so hard that they hurt themselves.
@homeede Dont diss her because of Ben. She was offered her job and she took it because it's what she wanted. I used to hate her too until she DM'd me on Twitter. She's really nice and she's said nothing but nice things about Ben's former bandmates. It's not like she did it on purpose... Give her a chance. She's such a wonderful person, so quit hating on her. :)
@LacrymosaMay1 Well, I'm with you- but she denied completely in one interveiw sounding like Ev and went on to say that she'd never even heard the music. Yet... I can think of AT LEASt three videos of her singing Ev's music. I just can't stand liars.
no she isn't gonna do country she joined forces with the evil Ben Moody and is making a clone of Evanescence!! She is so stupid. I hope she fails at it!
I need to take my headphones everytime I listen to this because there's this muted sound in the background that sounds exactly the same as my telephone :)
she is awesome, carly is a nice person and great singer, she shouldn't have been eliminated that early, she did really well that week, she was definitely one of my favorites the top 4 should have been her, brooke, ramiele, and david archuleta with david as the winner, all of them have talent, great voices and are all very nice and unique unlike david cook who is boring, jason castro just plain sucks, both can't sing at all, syesha was ok, but she doesn't compare to archie or my 3 girls.
Carly is not replacing Amy Lee. She's the lead singer of the new band The Fallen which has a former member of Evanescence, Ben Moody and a couple others. Amy and the band are still together and Amy said that she was working on new music for 2010.
Amy and the band ARE NOT together yet. They split up. Carly will replace Amy because the other members are the same, of course, the band has another name cause Amy has the copyrught Evanescence. That`s it
Apparently you did not read Amy's blog. Carly is not replacing Amy. The Fallen is a different band that has former members of Evanescence in it. There are still two members of Evanescence with Amy and they're making new music. I've looked into this already. We will have both bands, end of story.
The members of Evanescence who are in (We Are) The Fallen are FORMER members. Ben Moody left in '03, John and Rocky shortly following. That being said, The Fallen will have absolutely no impact on the current Evanescence line-up. Keep in mind that Marty O'Brien, who is in no way connected to Evanescence, is ALSO joining, again differentiating between the two bands.
Having been a huge fan of Evanescence from the beginning, I'm thrilled that Ben and the others are resurfacing. :)
The name The Fallen was already owned so they had to go with the (We Are) tacked on there. As long as Carly's singing though they could call the band whatever they want.
Carly is currently in the studio recording her album. You can follow her on Twitter for all the latest updates on her music. Her album is gonna be amazing-can't wait for it!!!
Carly is a singular talent, I look forward to her future output and miss seeing her on Idol to this day, especially with the limited talent that this season seems to possess.
How can you call someone that when you don't even know them? I met her more than once on the tour and she's very sweet and down to earth. She's definitely not creepy. Carly is amazing!!!
Ever since I saw Carly Smithson in San Jose at the Idols Live tour I've been going back and watching some of these older videos. She has a fascinating story/history behind her. I have to agree with "critics" who call her a ringer though, I think she was clearly the most talented person on the cast this year. And when I'm say talented I mean strictly on singing ability not the ability to make young girls squeal with delight.
Carly seems so at peace with her post Idol self I don't feel so badly about her getting the shaft. Her tour performances, from what I've seen on YouTube, are excellent!
Carly is so charming and talented that watching her for eight minutes just flashes by like that [snaps fingers]. This gal really sings the crap out of those Heart covers. What a VOICE!
i so love carly! from the very first episode of the top 12, i had the feeling that the davids and carly will be the top 3. carly should have been 3rd at the very very least. i would've loved to see david cook and carly in the finale.
by the way, carly's and michel johns' duet, the letter, was awesome! i hope carly lands a record deal, and i'll be one of the first ones to grab a copy!!!
From the very beginning, my favorites were (1)Carly, (2)Michael, (3)The Davids... I really think Carly should have won and I only think people stopped voting her is because of the whole "she's already had a record deal and it failed".. So what!? She's much better now and she definitely should have won!
My favorite performance, by far, was the first Beetles round where she sang Come Together!!! I loved it!
I just *love* her. What a talent!!!! I was really impressed with her interview too. She's got a good head on her shoulders and good perspective of the business. Go Carly!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
She's such a freaking liar. She has met Mariah more than once before and she herself had an album out and she is not new to performing. I can't stand liars.
And where did you read that MamaMia5150 on Vote for the Worst? I didn't hear her claim that she never had met Mariah before, if in fact she had as you claim, or that she said she was new to performing, either.
I don't mind foolish people making foolish statements, in fact, it seems like these Youtube Text Comments are sort of a place for the fans of the less talented to vent their spleens. It seems like a lot of Jason fans are on the getting very hostile.
Carly sang Alone in the Hollywood round of American Idol this year and Ramiele sang it during the finals. So the answer to the question below is that both of them sang it. Both Carly's and Ramiele's Idol performances are up on Youtube.
Carly actually sang it during Hollywood week, before Ramielle sang it. But I think they could probably sing whatever they want, and most just choose to sing songs they've recently practiced.
This "Irish girl" needs a record deal, some good songs and some radio support and just watch out. I think the media response to Carly post-Idol has been heartening, they know she is a fantastic singer and so do the Internet bloggers.
LOVE HER, still do. SHe was so gracious when she left. She should've stayed on longer...I wanted either her or David C to win so at least David won lol! BUt I think she shoulda been in the top 3.
she wore this on top 9 result show, it's ramielle's elimination. this when simon's makes a sorry to carly for critizising her wardrobe when she sung here you come again.but she looks gorgeous in black.
people is so silly !! shes amazing and before she joined we r the fallen she already had the tattoos and her Gothic style s please dotn say shes trying to b like amy
karithmey 1 week ago
I'm still seeing Carly Smithson videos and seeing comments about Amy Lee and Evanescence. Both bands are similar, but they do have their differences and BOTH bands are completely amazing. I love both bands, and people sort of need to get a grip and realize that they are both amazing.
TakatoJoshuaKai 4 months ago 3
@TakatoJoshuaKai Thank you, you are absolutely perfectly right!
Argentina891 4 months ago
@Argentina891 Thank you.
TakatoJoshuaKai 4 months ago
@TakatoJoshuaKai ;)
Argentina891 3 months ago
Holy. Shit. She can sing! I didn't watch that season, nor do I give a shit who won, it's obvious who the best singer from that season was.
polaris20 5 months ago 5
At first I thought her accent was British.
Then I realized that it was Irish.
Oops.
pompapartygal 7 months ago
I like her accent its like a mixture of American and Irish
akaboo69 7 months ago
I didn't realize how beautiful, talented and sweet she was when she was on the show. She really is a class act with a great voice!
BlushingBride818 8 months ago 2
HER HAIR IS GODDAMMED BLACK!! STUPID PEOPLE WHO ARE JEALOUS OF HER SUCCESS AND SPEND THEIR TIME HATING COZ THEY KNOW THAT THEY WILL NEVER REACH HER LEVEL..=]
dogiemole 9 months ago
HATERS YOU GUYS ARE JUST JEALOUS CAUSE THIS GIRL IS HAVING THE TIME OF HER LIFE.....AND FROM WHAT I'VE HEARD THE ALBUM SOUNDS GREAT ....WE ARE THE FALLEN ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
buratmong69 9 months ago
@buratmong69 Amen! :D
rocketregios 5 months ago
Thank God she didn't get the first record deal otherwise we wouldn't have We Are The Fallen plus shes probably more known now than any of the other contestants
MrBda27 9 months ago
Who wonned it anyway??
Milton2k 10 months ago
her hair is brown here lol "we didnt dye her hair black carly cant help herself she is how she is not trying to be amy lee" BULLSHat
jessica56786789 10 months ago
She is great!
MrWinestyle 10 months ago
ok seriously. i think she is trying to be amy lee abit. she looks so bright and airy here and she has changed!!! she has changed since she went into we are the fallen. as an Evanescence fan... im not taking sides though, i have listened to we are the fallen, but she has changed, and she looks more like amy and is trying to sound more like her aswell. if you cant see it then your a littl bit blind. dont take sides and just look... then youll see.
Lise2802 11 months ago
@Lise2802 shes bright and airy cos shes happy! shes in a band and finally geting to live her dream. now stfu & get over it.
omfgyourmomsugly 10 months ago
@omfgyourmomsugly Actually, everyone is entitled to an opinion so you get over my opinion and Stfu!
Lise2802 10 months ago
@Lise2802 LOL. yeh so im entitled to MY opinion
omfgyourmomsugly 10 months ago
@omfgyourmomsugly yeah but i wasnt the one being mean about it?!
Lise2802 10 months ago
@Lise2802 just giving my opinion!
omfgyourmomsugly 10 months ago
@omfgyourmomsugly yeah well stfu isnt really an opinion but w/e cba to stay on youtube and reply pointlessly anymore.
Lise2802 10 months ago
Shes in the kick ass band we are the fallen.
ninjacombat11 11 months ago 3
where is she today
didilishus 1 year ago
@didilishus trying to be Amy Lee
eacz12 1 year ago
@eacz12
I would not say she is being amy lee. AT all. She is her own person and own unique voice. AND BESIDES AMY IS OLD AND SHE IS NEW. Not the same music at all. But. still she is her own .
passive112 1 year ago 2
@passive112 amy is old and she is new....hmmm nicki minaj is new too and she sucks ass and balls
eacz12 11 months ago
@passive112 well said!
omfgyourmomsugly 10 months ago
@eacz12 lol shes not trying to be amy. we are the fallen isnt evanescence.
omfgyourmomsugly 10 months ago
she'll always be my winner
earforvocals 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
love the accent
anajeremiah 1 year ago
love the excel
anajeremiah 1 year ago
Im glad she didn't win because she's doing so well now. I mean WATF is doing great. Who knows where she would be if she won?
AlicexBrandonxCullen 1 year ago
LIFEANDOBLIVION fuck you fucker!Carly is great!Listen to WATF im the only one.AND stop all you fucker put carly in the same jar with Amy.Amy is Amy and Carly is Carly and both are wonderful.so shut up and suck your own cock!
eastrahman 1 year ago 4
Irish Idol
GreeceOTOT 1 year ago
What looks like Amy, has a band fill of Evanescene ex bandmembers, what's to be like Amy by dressing gothic.......this wannabe does!!!! She's no Amy Lee and never will be no matter how much they try they can't beat the fact that Amy is the Gothic Queen so gothic that she wears white to announce that she's the Queen. Try to beat that wannabe!!!!
LIFEANDOBLIVION 1 year ago
she is an angel, sue me if i'm wrong, but she is so truly sweet and honest person, she is so talented. ever since i discovered her she is my favourite singer, my best influence. she is great :)
SwanSong158 1 year ago
she sucks!!!!
nykytne13 1 year ago
The song sounds kinda like Total Eclipse of the Heart.
sarseabeccas 1 year ago
la copia barata de amy lee...maquillaje todo es igual que amy lee...ni en eso pueden ser creativos????
cheap copy of amy lee ... everything is like makeup amy lee ... or it can be creative?? I'm sorry, but here there is no room for another amy lee, amy lee was able to win the public. end of story, voice talent ... their way of singing ... like her no
angelalexaART 1 year ago
She has such a beautiful voice! She really should have won, but alas, AI is family oriented so an awesome rocker chick with tats wasn't going to win. But I still cannot get over how much she looks like Amy Lee. Certain angles, a certain way her hair is done, her smile. Ugh, it's so strange. I love WATF but I still cannot get over their look. I'm really glad she decided to stay in a neutral zone about Ev and WATF.
emptywhisper 1 year ago 2
@emptywhisper Except she didn't.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago
@PhantoMPhreeK92 I haven't heard anything but good come out of her mouth. Couple interviews I've seen, she keeps her lips closed. But Idk.
emptywhisper 1 year ago
@emptywhisper There are a couple interviews of her outright denying ever even having heard Ev's music yet shes covered three of their songs. IDC if Ben helped co-write some or not, thats Ev's music. She knows who they are. Listen- I like her as a singer I don't like people who bend the truth. If she'd just say yeah- Im in a band full of ex-ev members, therefore we mat sound alike but were here to make some music end of story. They fight the 'similiarity' thing so hard that they hurt themselves.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago 5
A mix of Irish/American accents ends up sounding Canadian...
MollyTurbin 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She is gorgeous oh my god. Seriously, I'm so proud she has We Are The Fallen now, this is her time :)
MoonInHerEyesx 1 year ago
@homeede Dont diss her because of Ben. She was offered her job and she took it because it's what she wanted. I used to hate her too until she DM'd me on Twitter. She's really nice and she's said nothing but nice things about Ben's former bandmates. It's not like she did it on purpose... Give her a chance. She's such a wonderful person, so quit hating on her. :)
LacrymosaMay1 1 year ago
@LacrymosaMay1 Well, I'm with you- but she denied completely in one interveiw sounding like Ev and went on to say that she'd never even heard the music. Yet... I can think of AT LEASt three videos of her singing Ev's music. I just can't stand liars.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago
no she isn't gonna do country she joined forces with the evil Ben Moody and is making a clone of Evanescence!! She is so stupid. I hope she fails at it!
homeede 1 year ago
now she has a band im proud of her
XXXutubeisgayXXX 1 year ago
She looks better in black, please don't try 2 yellow her up, ellen!
HanaJana9 1 year ago
I need to take my headphones everytime I listen to this because there's this muted sound in the background that sounds exactly the same as my telephone :)
MrJudube 1 year ago
it's so cool that she has her own band now!!! and she reminds me so much of evanescence, i was shocked!
lilaznangel17 1 year ago
i love carly and her accent!
Luv2Rock333 1 year ago 4
she shouldve won! im still pissed that she didnt!
goxredskinsx21 1 year ago 5
she is SUPERBEAUTIFUL!!! and what a VOICE! both when talking and singing!
danka13 1 year ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she has a country voice. she should do country
paularichards05 1 year ago
she is awesome, carly is a nice person and great singer, she shouldn't have been eliminated that early, she did really well that week, she was definitely one of my favorites the top 4 should have been her, brooke, ramiele, and david archuleta with david as the winner, all of them have talent, great voices and are all very nice and unique unlike david cook who is boring, jason castro just plain sucks, both can't sing at all, syesha was ok, but she doesn't compare to archie or my 3 girls.
bn31260 1 year ago 2
shes awesome - hope We are the fallen does well
tjwick63 1 year ago
blah
rockprincess2110 1 year ago
@Lizardbliss
have you heard the stuff she came up with her new band? its awesome.
undefinedtruth 1 year ago 3
can u tell me the name of the song she sang? thx!
QiudiRocks 2 years ago
Alone by Heart. A lot of people have covered that song-Celine Dion, Carrie Underwood, etc.
lubug11 2 years ago 2
can u tell me the name of the song she sang? thx!
QiudiRocks 2 years ago
she kind of sound like a man at some point when she sings.
PutrescentSoul 2 years ago
She is so talented and her eyes are beautiful!
MissKelly518 2 years ago 15
I still can't believe Carly didn't win
7bracelets 2 years ago 38
@7bracelets she did.. look at her new band WE Are the Fallen .. their single "bury me alive" is sooo great! check them out at wearethefallendotcom
puschrein 1 year ago
is it just me or does her voice
sound like celine dion's?
tshaini 2 years ago 3
Was Carly pregnant right before she got voted off... Or rather not voted for?
un0m3asa13ah 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i cant believe that she is going to replace amy lee, i dont see it
truthaboutac 2 years ago
Carly is not replacing Amy Lee. She's the lead singer of the new band The Fallen which has a former member of Evanescence, Ben Moody and a couple others. Amy and the band are still together and Amy said that she was working on new music for 2010.
giannial1985 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Amy and the band ARE NOT together yet. They split up. Carly will replace Amy because the other members are the same, of course, the band has another name cause Amy has the copyrught Evanescence. That`s it
cherry1311 2 years ago
Apparently you did not read Amy's blog. Carly is not replacing Amy. The Fallen is a different band that has former members of Evanescence in it. There are still two members of Evanescence with Amy and they're making new music. I've looked into this already. We will have both bands, end of story.
giannial1985 2 years ago 2
Amy has a blog?
Khihoni 2 years ago
Yeah, on myspace, lol
giannial1985 2 years ago
The members of Evanescence who are in (We Are) The Fallen are FORMER members. Ben Moody left in '03, John and Rocky shortly following. That being said, The Fallen will have absolutely no impact on the current Evanescence line-up. Keep in mind that Marty O'Brien, who is in no way connected to Evanescence, is ALSO joining, again differentiating between the two bands.
Having been a huge fan of Evanescence from the beginning, I'm thrilled that Ben and the others are resurfacing. :)
DancingInObscurity 2 years ago 3
Oh my God, please inform yourself before saying so many stupid things!!!
arturesteve 2 years ago
carly isn't replacing amy. she's starting a new band with former evanescence members
angel0634 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
she would never be able to fucking replace amy.
carlys shit. thats why.
emptyxsilence 2 years ago
then get the fuck out of here. no one cares about your trash talk
angel0634 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
with pleasure. i can't bare to see carly's butt- ugly's face again. :]
emptyxsilence 2 years ago
you're an asshole
angel0634 2 years ago 2
carly´s band names "we are the fallen" not "the fallen"...
puschrein 2 years ago 3
The name The Fallen was already owned so they had to go with the (We Are) tacked on there. As long as Carly's singing though they could call the band whatever they want.
cbotten106 2 years ago 3
It actually has 3 former members
XxD12BerniexX 2 years ago
I'm wanting some Carly Smithson music....NOW!
cbotten106 2 years ago
i love you carly and love ... love your voice .. cant wait to your new album .. it's all good !!!!
atleticon0211 2 years ago 2
Carly we need your voice on the raido! Someone that can sing!
ChicagoCarlaJane 2 years ago 5
I would so do her lol
blue1spiral 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
el 13 de octubre de 1991
un niño llamado nick se tiro de un puente devido a problemas familiares
si ya leiste esto deves copiar y pegar
en otros 5 videos mas o si no
nick vendra por toda tu familia
haslo o moriran porfavor hasme caso
yo lo lei y lo hise & si es verdad..la familia de un amigo murio hace una semana
drimaah 2 years ago
Carly is currently in the studio recording her album. You can follow her on Twitter for all the latest updates on her music. Her album is gonna be amazing-can't wait for it!!!
12345carlyfan 2 years ago
Where is Carly now? I want to hear her sing!
banjovidb 2 years ago
Love Carly! What a down-to-earth sweetheart!! :) x
maevexox 2 years ago 2
such a shock to see her eliminated..
amazing talent! you go girl!!
cant wait for your album!
shaka055 2 years ago 7
Carly is a singular talent, I look forward to her future output and miss seeing her on Idol to this day, especially with the limited talent that this season seems to possess.
cbotten106 2 years ago
How can you call someone that when you don't even know them? I met her more than once on the tour and she's very sweet and down to earth. She's definitely not creepy. Carly is amazing!!!
12345carlyfan 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Ugh ... This skank gives me the creeps.
pkncharlie 2 years ago
pkncharlie, keep your dumbass comments to yourself.
richardpaulgriffin 2 years ago
i am writing this just so you can see all the bad-comment notifications you got.
pretty scene right?!!!!!
archieholic 2 years ago
this is an example of pure talent
colormylife4692 2 years ago 7
She is a phenomenal singer i hope a cd comes out soon! oh and i lover her outfit : )
OceanSunRise4 2 years ago 2
I used to teach her guitar for a bit when she was a llittle girl - she was already great then. It was so obvious she would do well.
siddhaam 2 years ago
ugh she should have won!! love carly!!
heaven4590 2 years ago 5
Carly was my winner
mayreawesome 2 years ago 33
Carly is a fantastic singer!
issaac00 3 years ago 8
Love Carly!!!!
marys2020 3 years ago 4
Carly was one of, if not the best, singer ever on Idol. I think the odds have anyone else of this caliber on the show are slim.
cbotten106 3 years ago 4
Carly was my fave!!!
missjestine16 3 years ago 7
I love Carly, I wanted her to win
crazylazy45 3 years ago 2
i love carly i am so sad she got eliminated at top 6
davidcooklover13 3 years ago 4
amazing
chirozoe 3 years ago 4
i wanted her to win it :)
millybbz182 3 years ago 6
I hope Ellen will invite Carly back after she releases an album!
Darkblade886 3 years ago 4
i love her tat
uttad123 3 years ago 6
Ellen did a good job on this interview. It is one of the better Carly Smithson interviews that I've seen.
cbotten106 3 years ago 2
shes soooo cute. im still waiting for a new album!!!!!!<3<3<3<3
rbdancr401 3 years ago 13
CARLY THE BEST!!!!!!!
victorvillegas88 3 years ago 15
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ellen had all contestants on her show exept for archie..and she talks smack about him
i have lost all respect for ellen.
DaxFlameLover51 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why wasnt David Archuleta on her show?!!!!
now i hate her!
FUZZLE33 3 years ago
He did.
Go watch it.
ratandkow 3 years ago
Archie did get on the show eventually. Don't judge! Watch that before you jump to conclusions about Ellen.. There was some complication
ratandkow 3 years ago
her voice got better as the show went on... her voice is beautiful and raw and pure at the same time. its beautiful. MY FAVORITE SONG!
countryprincess92 3 years ago 11
I hope I get to meet her and some of the others.
MUSICROX83 3 years ago 8
Ever since I saw Carly Smithson in San Jose at the Idols Live tour I've been going back and watching some of these older videos. She has a fascinating story/history behind her. I have to agree with "critics" who call her a ringer though, I think she was clearly the most talented person on the cast this year. And when I'm say talented I mean strictly on singing ability not the ability to make young girls squeal with delight.
cbotten106 3 years ago 9
couldent have sed it better myself!!!! ^_^
cazam 3 years ago 4
haha yes she is incredibly talented but I still squeal with delight!
heartbhoys 3 years ago 6
Carlys history is just that i agree she is a total sweet heart too
eileenregina 3 years ago 8
i love hearing my favorite song by someone with such and oustanding voice. plus she's a fellow Irish [:
PinkLoverSammy 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
mmmm # RANDOM# if you fancy a hot chat/webcam chat with me Ella come pay a visit to ... Play-Cam(.COM) ...
snowboardmommy 3 years ago
Shes so pretty I hate it :( But I love her! : )
irishsweethearttx 3 years ago 6
she is absolutely gorgeous.
emteezy 3 years ago 8
carly smithson is abosulely fantastic .
i cannot wait to meet her and see her on tour .
her record will be so amazing .
vannersx3 3 years ago 6
amazing voice
ChristinaJedra 3 years ago 9
she was the best and should have won!
sarahfan56 3 years ago 11
i love her accent!
TrishyxLou 3 years ago 16
I loved Carly on the show. I think she's such a great singer and has an awesome personality.
HPPirates 3 years ago 11
Carly seems so at peace with her post Idol self I don't feel so badly about her getting the shaft. Her tour performances, from what I've seen on YouTube, are excellent!
cbotten106 3 years ago 2
I cannot believe she got voted off. That was a good week, and she was amazing the whole way through the competition!
Mannn that sucks.
ohboyitskayla 3 years ago 11
Amazing she should have won she is just amazing. Can't wait till i get to see her on tour.
maxandmayaandzoey 3 years ago 4
ugh why didnt she win?!??!?!?!?!?!?!
i miss getting to watch her on tv (idol should start eliminating by ones at the top 20)
i hope amazing things for her she's seriously one of the best voices ive heard in my life
BlingyDamon3 3 years ago 5
i think that she had one of the best voices in that competition. and shes soooo pretty!
kitcattt09 3 years ago 7
I loved her on idol and I would love to meet her on the tour in sept.
MUSICROX83 3 years ago 3
I MISS U CARLY!!!
carrieunderwoodcool 3 years ago 3
Her voice is amazing!
Qee1001 3 years ago 4
I love ellen she is the best OH and Carl was in my top two
KYHist 3 years ago 3
Shes just amazing..
I god she has a sexy accent..
I love her..
I was so po'd when she was voted off..
Jason and Brooke needed to go a while ago..
shoulda came down to Carly and D. Cook
try2getme10 3 years ago 7
Carly is so charming and talented that watching her for eight minutes just flashes by like that [snaps fingers]. This gal really sings the crap out of those Heart covers. What a VOICE!
cbotten106 3 years ago 5
Wow! She is amazing. I was so shocked when she got voted off so early! She was my favorite girl. Her voice is just piercing and she is just so sweet.
Kmrules79 3 years ago 4
i so love carly! from the very first episode of the top 12, i had the feeling that the davids and carly will be the top 3. carly should have been 3rd at the very very least. i would've loved to see david cook and carly in the finale.
by the way, carly's and michel johns' duet, the letter, was awesome! i hope carly lands a record deal, and i'll be one of the first ones to grab a copy!!!
09224260001 3 years ago 5
From the very beginning, my favorites were (1)Carly, (2)Michael, (3)The Davids... I really think Carly should have won and I only think people stopped voting her is because of the whole "she's already had a record deal and it failed".. So what!? She's much better now and she definitely should have won!
My favorite performance, by far, was the first Beetles round where she sang Come Together!!! I loved it!
wendicalz 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
WORST version EVER
kelliepik 3 years ago
I just *love* her. What a talent!!!! I was really impressed with her interview too. She's got a good head on her shoulders and good perspective of the business. Go Carly!
geezluizann 3 years ago 3
should have been in the top 4 she was way better than Brooke n Jason put together
ny11764 3 years ago 6
She should of won.
maxandmayaandzoey 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's such a freaking liar. She has met Mariah more than once before and she herself had an album out and she is not new to performing. I can't stand liars.
MamaMia4545 3 years ago
And where did you read that MamaMia5150 on Vote for the Worst? I didn't hear her claim that she never had met Mariah before, if in fact she had as you claim, or that she said she was new to performing, either.
I don't mind foolish people making foolish statements, in fact, it seems like these Youtube Text Comments are sort of a place for the fans of the less talented to vent their spleens. It seems like a lot of Jason fans are on the getting very hostile.
cbotten106 3 years ago
holy god what a voice! i dont care if she did a record or ten, this girl deserves a second chance at a record deal.
go Carly!
steelsheen 3 years ago 5
Didn't Ramielle sing this??
THey usually sing stuf that THEY sang..
oh wellz... no biggie
TheTeenScoop 3 years ago
Carly sang Alone in the Hollywood round of American Idol this year and Ramiele sang it during the finals. So the answer to the question below is that both of them sang it. Both Carly's and Ramiele's Idol performances are up on Youtube.
cbotten106 3 years ago 3
Carly actually sang it during Hollywood week, before Ramielle sang it. But I think they could probably sing whatever they want, and most just choose to sing songs they've recently practiced.
raindropcharlie 3 years ago 3
luv u carly!!!!!!
Baoao 3 years ago 2
yaaaay go carly!
i was soooo sad when she was eliminated from Idol, but she seems to have gotten over it.
i hope she keeps singing 4 ever!
noxblackergirl 3 years ago 2
This "Irish girl" needs a record deal, some good songs and some radio support and just watch out. I think the media response to Carly post-Idol has been heartening, they know she is a fantastic singer and so do the Internet bloggers.
cbotten106 3 years ago 2
she sang this better than ramiele
Schweinsteigerr 3 years ago 4
She is freakin awesome
hottyMcl 3 years ago 3
Carly Smithson, David Cook my top 2.
Fortunately, David still got it!
trlgal 3 years ago 4
agreed!
nemo057 3 years ago 3
LOVE HER, still do. SHe was so gracious when she left. She should've stayed on longer...I wanted either her or David C to win so at least David won lol! BUt I think she shoulda been in the top 3.
AllAboutCarrie 3 years ago 3
GIVE IT UP 4 CARLY! I TOTALLY HEART HER!
Afterschoolproductio 3 years ago 8
Caly was the best! she is beautiful, sweet, and humble. i loved David Cook 2.
Afterschoolproductio 3 years ago 6
she wore this on top 9 result show, it's ramielle's elimination. this when simon's makes a sorry to carly for critizising her wardrobe when she sung here you come again.but she looks gorgeous in black.
kenjimora 3 years ago 4
DAVID COOK ALL THE WAY!
saralovejonas 3 years ago 2
carly has the best vocals on the show i really thought the final at least 4 wouldve been carly the two davids and ramiele.