I love Leonard Cohen, but it's kind of ironic to me the fact that his isn't the best version. I find both Jeff Buckley and Richard Wainright versions more emotional and touching. This one is rather good, though.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Wow, this is a great song but I had no idea the original was so terrible! The version used in the episode is a vast improvement. The one in "Shrek" is the best, though.
I love the west wing love, but you know that most people finding this, will have been searching for the scene from west wing using Jeff Buckley's version, when Mark Harmon's character dies...might be worth retitling it just to be clear...
there's a RW version! He's amazing. Did not know that...I may be using that soon! thanks. no offense taken. the only version besides the buckley that was used on the show that i didn't want to reuse it, and the shrek one.
Cohen OWNS this song...
yekdeli 3 months ago
I like Jeff Buckley`s rendition, his voice makes me think of an angel singing it.
I like K.D. Lang`s version, her voice puts passion in the song
I like Rufus Wainwright`s version he has heart
Leonard`s version is smooth and it has soul.
geclay 8 months ago
Jeff Buckley's is the best version, I love this one, though... The shrek one is crap
FrancisMcMahon1 10 months ago
Seen/heard the k.d.lang version? LC is the greatest, but k.d. sure does him full justice.
Grongoling 3 years ago
don't miss John Cale's version, he was the first to cover this.
NowIamheretoo 3 years ago
Cohen definitely does this song the best, good choice!
diabolical22 3 years ago 5
I love Leonard Cohen, but it's kind of ironic to me the fact that his isn't the best version. I find both Jeff Buckley and Richard Wainright versions more emotional and touching. This one is rather good, though.
Mloccar 3 years ago
Rufus does a nice job but Buckley lends it that ethereal quality that they song warrants. Of course Cohen is a lyrical genius in my opinion.
TuesdayPillow 3 years ago
Who sings it originally?
musicluver79 3 years ago
Leonard Cohen, who wrote it.
marbethfan 3 years ago 5
stuart- WTF are you talking about? This is best ever No. 2 after KD
bbFUK 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, this is a great song but I had no idea the original was so terrible! The version used in the episode is a vast improvement. The one in "Shrek" is the best, though.
ThereIsOnlyOneStuart 4 years ago
we're all entitled to our opinion. I had specific reasons for using this version.
1) the buckley version had been used on the show itself
2) I like Leonard Cohen
3) The Shrek one is too..shreky...but i love that version.
If I make another I shall use that as a guide.
marbethfan 3 years ago
@marbethfan I like cohen so you're not the only person who can say that
saulneinstein 1 month ago
I love the west wing love, but you know that most people finding this, will have been searching for the scene from west wing using Jeff Buckley's version, when Mark Harmon's character dies...might be worth retitling it just to be clear...
WillBraden 4 years ago
Cool video! Not the best version of the song no offense, the better version is by rufus wainwright :) Cool video non the less!
magicmunchies 4 years ago
there's a RW version! He's amazing. Did not know that...I may be using that soon! thanks. no offense taken. the only version besides the buckley that was used on the show that i didn't want to reuse it, and the shrek one.
marbethfan 3 years ago
Both Wainright and Bucley's versions are amazing. I prefer Bucley's myself, but Wainright's awesome too.
Mloccar 3 years ago
only started watching this a while ago and this is one of the best bits ive seen so far!! rocks
cheeseblue1 4 years ago
Best show ever.
buffington80 4 years ago 7
God I miss WW... nice montage!!
TenThirteener 4 years ago
Thank you!
marbethfan 4 years ago