This is the first russian movie I've seen, and I am very well pleased with it. I do not speak russian, thank you for posting the movie with subtitles. I will try to watch more from your channel. I really appreciate it. Thank you again.
A tous, gratuits sur You Tube j'ai trouvé des centaines de films Soviétiques et Russes (sous titrés en Anglais) en entiers - certains sont superbes et loin de la connerie americaine des Rambo ou des Rocky - je vous conseille vivement une recherche
Coming here on a Russian movie thread to avoid all this Anglo Saxon Shit spaming the other threads and enjoying CULTURE and guess what I find : fat American bastards ! FUCK sake !
Fact id that czarist Russia was one of the poorest and most underdeveloped countries in Europe, with one of the lowest life expectancies (around 30 years) and an 80% of the population working in agriculture and with no education. In 1960 for example life expectancy was around 70 years same as most west-european countries, a high percent of the population had superior education. So bolsheviks didnt actually ruin the country in the long term.
@alviandar Well far beyond Hollywood films of the present time. The acting in this movie is beyond compareson to an American movies. Konstantin Khabensy, Evgenia Boyrskya and Sergey Bezrukov - superb!
Amazing movie. Excellent production. A very involved and interesting story. That we here in the USA of A could produce movies like this one rather than the fantasy drivel that we are seeing now, like Harry Potter and all sorts of garbage on our screens now.
Isn't it interesting how every western news service and every liberal soviet/russian leader were and are all pawns of the CIA? i mean boy those CIA agents were really something hu? controlling several top russian politicians and apparently conspiring to the fall of the the only real progressive and free nation in the world all buy there lonesome self. And yet those brave russian citizens were never fooled! they all saw and heard the truth from there state run radio and television providers -_-
revolutions are not always good. the french revolution saw innocent people sent to the guillotine just for having money, and the russian revolution obviously caused tons of death and despair. even the american revolution had its low points with the loyalist minority citizens often getting property confiscated by vengeful patriot neighbors. social upheaval only goes so far without an establishment to keep things under control.
You don't need Russian nor french revolution to murder people on a wide scale - each month some 15 000 innocent people are killed for no obvious reason in Irak (same as 11/09) if not seizing their ressources - You are the usual brainwashed uneducated prick still convinced that he is part of the GOOD when the rest of the world is just waiting for your country to be razed from earth surface !
Greetings to our Russian mates - You US disgusting bastards - Fuck off
@mindxestep i was just making a point about how certain historical events can be misconstrued, not a political statement that you seem to be attempting. i would debate that outrageously inaccurate figure about deathtoll, but what good would it do? you are totally convinced that you know what is right, yet you insult my national origin and tell me to fuck off. that doesn't prove anything other than that you have a pathological hatred for the united states
@mackshayster dealing with french and russian revolutions and you necesarily find in a position to deal with "politcs" - If you don't want to; simple : shut up !
Yeah as a french citizen i'm perfectly entitled to tell you to FUCK OFF as well as your country is a distateful pile of rubbish which is not worth a piss- no patriot act in Europe, we feel free to speak our mind the way we want to.
I don't mean to dwindle on a comment you posted a month earlier, but your opening and closing remark expresses an inherent contradiciton in your argument. Revolutions occur in absence of an establishment, its often a defining feature of one - they also (usually) occur with majority support. Thus it can only occur when the system is not already providing for the majority, hence something to revolt against exists.
Atrocities can occur in the midst of revoultions, no one denies that. But the point is that they will be better off in the long-run, once the status-quo they're revoling against is removed. The argument that, "revolutions are not always good" in my opinion, can only be validated when the emerging system (or what have you) is worse than the last. It shouldn't be judged upon the actions inbetween - which is what you're doing in the examples you give.
...@vodka: Add to that the thousands of "suspects" brought to the stalinist Lubyanka headquarters (and who dissappeared without a trace after being tortured for days or weeks) the maybe millions of "class enemies" butchered or starved to death in the gulags, and you have a nice summary of what the POLAK Felix Dzherzhinsky has left to Russia. Yes, he was a Pole! So be careful in using the adjective "Russian". The name Yeltsin or Yalcin is fairly common in Turkey.... Stalin came from Georgia.
@avginkel same can be said about CIA prison camps. you dont come out of those places. and hey, its still going on. so what is your point? its security forces.
@vodka1983 if you want to keep believing that the Soviet Union was heaven on earth, it´s your right to do so. Guessing your age, I think you were only a child when the SU fell and you know it only from stories. Millions of skeletons in the Karaganda and Vorkuta region can´t speak up against you, so you just go ahead. I have experienced the Cold War being on the "other side", and its memory still chills me. I have learned to respect the Soviet Union for what it was. But never again will it return
@avginkel you are just the kind of ungrateful jews that arent thankful to russians for saving your race and most of the modern world from nazis and the kind of westerners that always are pouring dirt over Russia.... politics. i know. you are not the first and not the last, we are hated for what we are - survivors and masters of the biggest country in the world. lived in that country i saw it been taken apart by greed. I never seen bread lines and i have much family from stalins era and ww2.
@avginkel oh yea. millions of skeletons. right. you seem to be the other expert here. seems to be a pattern. please just stay out of that country. your kind is not welcome and neither are your perceptions of its history. go watch BBC, CNN and other propaganda channels and enjoy your life to the fullest inside your little box where they tell you that all communists are evil and USSR was an evil empire. USA is and always will be. just dont get me started on explaining why.
@vodka1983 simply put, i would rather live in america witha good standard of life(mostly) and not worry about spontaneously being picked for "people's labor projects" and dieing of hunger or thirst than live in the soviet union. i dont think the soviet union ws evil all the time, but stalin was. gorbachev didnt seem too bad though. the soviets also didnt have freedom of religion, as the orthodox church was said to be "helping to establish a bourgeouise elite"
movies is not bad, but REAL life Kolchak was a PIECE OF SHIT. he was the bloodthirstiest of all white renegade general. if you take notice for example, Denikin was never persecuted by the reds and well respected long after revolution ended. this movie does not portray the real man this person was.... all lies.
@vodka1983 For 70 years nice things had been said in the former Soviet Union about Felix Dzhershinksy, the founder of the Cheka / NKVD / KGB. Till the day the Moskovites tore down the statue of this murderous psychopath in front of his butchering place called the Lubyanka prison. Millions and millions were killed by this man, his successors Yezhov and Beriya. So, now the tables have turned, and now it's Kolchak's and Wrangel's turn to be portrayed in a positive light.
@avginkel are you high? Lubyanka is not a prison. lmfao, its FSB headquarters or former KGB. Statue was torn down by same people that try to destroy legacy of political system before them. Its always like that. every time there is new government it shits over the old one. I don't know what millions and millions were killed, do you have REAL data? nope. Kolchak was a bloody murdering bastard, he killed many people. read before watching this trash. Only real russian officer was Denikin.
@vodka1983 I'm not high :-) hahahaha, in fact, I now see that the phenomenon of Holocaust deniers in Germany has been duplicated in Russia.I have been in the Soviet Union, I have spoken to people who have escaped the Stalinist death camps in Siberia, and I haven't forgotten the personal confession of Stalin himself to Churchill in 1942, that about 10 MILLION peasants were killed during the forced collectivization in the 1930s by the NKVD troops (Gorbachev's dad was one of them).
@avginkel Churchil? the guy that said all russians are barbarians and red hordes must be slaughtered? the guy that at one point considered negotiating with hitler a truce to fight the russians together? oh, that guy? what else have you heard stalin "confess"? civil war in russia was the cause of millions of deaths. its not 1 persons fault. and collectivization occured in the 20s, IDIOT. you don't know russian history yet you talk big game. shut the fuck up please.
@vodka1983 I know very well what I am talking about, you joker, loser from a bankrupt country. I hold a masters degree in history and I could teach you a thing or two about your country´s history. Snot nosed guy, I guess you werent even born when the SU fell. At least I still have respect for what WAS your country. It was a leader in culture and science. Now its a bankrupt country led by two former thugs of the KGB.
@avginkel ha, you have showed your true self, thanks. I was born and lived as a kid in SU, i guess you have never heard a saying Assumption is the mother of all fuck ups? it could be your mom too. I dont care for your degrees, you showed enough ignorance here that shows me where you got your information. Western view on russian history has been greatly influenced by politics and is ALWAYS in negative light. We are just barbarians. Still no idea WTF are you talking about. bankrupt?kgb? what?
@avginkel far from bankrupt. russia is one of worlds biggest creditors just like china. one of the biggest gold and currency reserves. enormous wealth of resources. financially its much better off than US or EU at the moment. I think you are smoking crack. Finance is my domain. dont cross it.
@vodka1983 i am also well familiar with Russian history, but i think you confuse it with the Soviet one ... Kolchak as far as most historians suggest was not as you describe him , but closer to the view of this film. He was a nobleman by birth, well educated and disgraced AFTER the revolution much like ataman Mahno. His image was made similar to that of Petlura who actually was a bloodthirsty genocidal outlaw who used the chaos in the land to ... well make more chaos :)
This movie was not realistic at all regarding the revolution.... nobody showed the social situation of the common people, workers, peasants.... just fairy tales how the elite was "honorable" and "faithful" to their czar.... same monarchist crap nostalgia as in Mihalkov's "The barber of Siberia"....
the main thing thats wrong with communism is that the proliteriat dictature has never ended and the communists had the extremely bad luck of having paranoid psychopaths for their leaders (zherdov, stalin, ....).
As long as money and economic growth is the only measure of the quality of our lives , we are going to ruin our planet ! The real quality is living in a clean invironment without chemical and nuclear waist , using new technologyes and make a sustainable living ! Watter, sun , wind and geothermal energy and natural materials are the wellknown keys ! Just have to say NO to the consumer society - THAT IS HARD?! But the only way, despite all nice political speaches and threads! Just hawe guts!
@kkppk1 Dont be sure about that, because Europeans (Russians included) are dying out, our homelands are being filled with non white immigrants. Europes dying and including Russia. If Russians die out, then Russia is dead. Slava Rusa
Unfortunately, the Revolution did not kill enough of the tzarist vermin. Same thing after 1945, in the new Communist countries. Vivat the heroic Red Army, the peasants and the workers who died for the fatherland, and who were betrayed by the criminal Gorbachev!
@TheLoyalOfficer This is not simply a question of one's world view but of the fact that no other ideology than capitalism aims at the systematic destruction of the environment and one's living space.
@Hellof7 Communism doesnt aim at that the leaders who governed did it, plus Capitalism went down the toilet dont u know? oh dont get me wrong i dont give shit about either but i will defend both political ideologies from biased and ignorant comments.
@Hellof7 P.S. have you been fucking drinking? Capitalism is by far worse than Communism Imperialism and Fascism put together, the only difference is how thing are done.
@chubowu Which rights? Which freedom? The one that allows certain people to gain wealth regardless of the consequeces? Such a distorted self-understanding against the general concept of life and survival is the reason for the human race going on exterminating itself from this planet inexorably.
@DIHORY spoken like a western propaganda cock goblin. because of hitler soviet union lost over 23 million of its citizens. majority was civilians killed by the nazis. you know very VERY little of real russian history. keep reading your american and british book with lies about my country.
@DIHORY there has been much unrest and sabotage following death of lenin and revolution. its popular nowadays to cry to be a victim of his regime. of course, all polizai and traitors that worked with nazis are victims lol. criminals, etc. russia had huge issues with crime and poverty. things had to be done to restore order and keep the country from falling apart. actual numbers of people in gulags and work camps were around 3-4 million over a period of 10 years. this doesnt count POWS.
@vodka1983 Have you heard of Holodomor in Ukraine? Around 10 million ukranians were killed by Stalin's communist regime. In Russia the army was wiped out by Stalin, officers who fought for the tzar were disposed of by killing them. Millions upon millions of russians were killed by the bolsheviks. Later the communist regimes of other russian presidents killed many people. This happened all across eastern Europe. Have you read about "Pitesti experiment" in Romania? Read about it!
@DIHORY HHAHAHAHAHAHHA golodomor?? biggest fucking lie ever. it was starvation for many nationals, not ukranians lol. you seriously believe in that hoax? i guess lack of education nowadays allows for that level of idiocy. this is something idiots in ukraine made up. Ushenko will burn in hell, you will see. there is sooo much disinformation, everyone is re writing history nowadays. US and EU loves to sponsor such things. anything to poor dirt over russians they are all for it.
@DIHORY why is stalin a criminal? he was paranoid, persecuted enemies of the state left and right (especially in the 30's, yet he was a great leader, strategist and project manager. Thanks to stalins perseverance and russian labor force russia re-industrialized from the ruins. Now jewish bolsheviks were in large park eliminated by him, something that Lenin couldn't do. many of those jewish bolsheviks like Trotsky were the scum that needed to be killed off, extremists.
I assumed this movie was intended to be pro-Kolchak but instead it reveals why the old regime fell. Russia is starving, losing a war, about to collapse and the aristocrats are having parties, high tea and cheating with each other's wives. The Communists were evil but you can see how the "Whites" had no credibility and were bound to lose a civil war. if only the forces of the middle, the true democrats had been more organized.
@ddpresearch07 It was literally a black or white thing during this time, a third way was not relevant. I don't appreciate this movie, it has great special effects but it is technically as much propagandistic as the old Soviet films.
@ddpresearch07 Communists were evil?Please define what u mean by evil? Have you lived in a Soviet state before? Or are u just saying things that the Western media has spun? Without any knoweledge of ur own?
Thanks for your comment. In one month I hope I can to upload the big movie-epopee "The Liberation" about World War Two. Of course with English subtitles. ;)
By the way, I have another film of Kolchak (10 mini-series) but unfortunatly, English subtitles for this film are not ready yet.
So how much is actual truth in this and how much revisionism? I know that according to some people anything that communists did was bad and everything that the Czar did was good, although not according to facts.
Not everything of what the Czar did was good, actually it's vice versa, there was no another reason for that revolution except the stupidity of Nicolas II.
But bolsheviks were bloody maniacs during revolution and first years after.
the monarch would have never collapsed if nicolas wasnt so useless and dealt with the situation rather than bury his head in the sand and
basically when the monarch collapsed the parliament either arrested, shot or deported all officers to stop a revolution from happening, however it didnt really work as the russian people wanted an end to the war and not to the monarchy, soo another revolution was started in saint Petersburg (petrograd at the time)
as the bolshivicks took saint petersburg , which at the time was the capital, they came to power and ended the war but another war started between the bolshivicks and the right
after this war they again killed every1 to stop a revolution
basically whoever won was going to kill people as they wanted to keep in power and not have another revolution
as for the tsar, well he was just as bad as the reds and whites
@Pseudologic People hated the Tsar at the time, but when they got Communism the people thought "oh man.." and hankered back to better times.. By Stalins time people were becoming utterly institutionalised, there were so many purges, so many people in GULAG - there was not contact with the outside for most people outside the elites - Russians were brainwashed and did not know any better, those who did remember better times knew not to speak of them openly.
The "millions" of people sent to the Gulags is by all estmates vastly exagurrated by Western historians with an interest to make the USSR look as bad as possible. A more realistic number are hundreds of thousands and what should be taken into account then is that most criminals was sent to the Gulags, not only political 'enemies' of the bolsheviks. There where murderers, rapists, robbers and so on in the USSR too.
@Pseudologic When the Red Army went into Europe Stalin was terrified of the troops seeing the far higher standards of living and becoming restless on thier return - to counter this the men were encouraged to act as criminally and as bestially as possible - essentially bringing everything to the Soviet level. When POW's were released from the concentration camps, they were sent straight to GULAG as they had been in contact with Western civilisation!
@andy7666 I don't think it was like that, after the Germans murdered 20 million Soviet civilians, I think revenge was in order, so Stalin allowed his troops to do as much harm as they want.
Before the War ended most Red Army soldiers liberated from Nazi captivity was conscripted back into the Army since there was a need to fill up the gaps so to speak. They where ofc screened for possible fascist elements before being allowed to rejoin. The reason why Red Army soldiers destroyed so much in Germany was according to themselves that they became angry at the Germans for invading and destroying their own homes when the German houses where much better built.
@ma82fo Bullshit! They wre ALL sent to Siberia, usually with a 10 year sentence! Read the stuff by Robert Conquest. And it was the Jews such as Illya Ehrenberg who encouraged the Russian troops to behave like a batch of wild beasts when they invaded Germany.
From what I have heard Conquest is known for slandering the Soviet Union and vastly exaggerate the numbers of victims in Stalins terror. Everyone, myself included, knows that Stalin was a paranoid man who sentenced several hundreds of thousands to their death in Siberia but in the case of former prisoners of war it is just not true. What happened when the Red Army liberated POW:S was that NKVD/SMERSH set up facilities to 'screen' for fascists but the vast majority was rehabilitated.
@ma82fo This is only the "offical" record, according to Soviet propagandists, but Conquest uses original documents to prove exactly what I have stated.
You're right,sir,in 1941 Stalin defined Russian prisioners as ''Traitors to the Motherland'',so they were shot in the spot(by the SMERSH guys) or sent for 10,15 or even 25 years to Siberia,like Alexander Solzenitsyn.And Ehrenburg was that fucking jewish bastard who encouraged Russian soldiers to rape,plunder and murder,not only in Germany because Red Army marked its presence with death,blood and pain in the Baltic States,Romania,Hungary,Checoslovakia and Poland as well.
Great movie! Really great. I´ve seen it twice but I woluld watch it again.
But , pitty the sound is so low.
BUT THE MOVIE IS REALLY GREAT!!!!
klarkkent12 5 months ago
19:05 Then i'm drinking to you Admiral Kolchak! :)
FarsSikenTurkmen 5 months ago
This is the first russian movie I've seen, and I am very well pleased with it. I do not speak russian, thank you for posting the movie with subtitles. I will try to watch more from your channel. I really appreciate it. Thank you again.
MG63mhAzusa 5 months ago
Ok
ivandimars 5 months ago
Thanks for this and all the other movies, PyccoTypucmo, I just enjoyed a pair, and will watch a lot more thanks to you... cheers!
Sholojov 5 months ago
A tous, gratuits sur You Tube j'ai trouvé des centaines de films Soviétiques et Russes (sous titrés en Anglais) en entiers - certains sont superbes et loin de la connerie americaine des Rambo ou des Rocky - je vous conseille vivement une recherche
mindxestep 5 months ago
Coming here on a Russian movie thread to avoid all this Anglo Saxon Shit spaming the other threads and enjoying CULTURE and guess what I find : fat American bastards ! FUCK sake !
mindxestep 5 months ago
Thanks for uploading! A little too romantic with not enough historical focus but I enjoyed it none the less.
gnarkillkicksass 5 months ago
This is a really good movie. Thanks for the upload.
-From America
Cplblue 5 months ago
If I was Russian I'd be pretty pissed off at the Bolsheviks for doing all that and to only ruin the country.
5858marksheen 6 months ago
@5858marksheen
Fact id that czarist Russia was one of the poorest and most underdeveloped countries in Europe, with one of the lowest life expectancies (around 30 years) and an 80% of the population working in agriculture and with no education. In 1960 for example life expectancy was around 70 years same as most west-european countries, a high percent of the population had superior education. So bolsheviks didnt actually ruin the country in the long term.
Subliminalverse13 5 months ago
oh, damn wars...!
ddthienvuong 6 months ago
Some watch this and see a movie... some history .. some betrayal.
Watch this and learn ... even if the dog obays - when master changes
thers no room for U!
JADEKINGsRULE 6 months ago
Red army is the strongest
Punderland 6 months ago
Thank you PyccoTypucmo because you put a whole movie on youtube ,its very hard to find a whole movie on youtube
ThePrisoner12345 6 months ago
Good and quality movie, not far to Hollywood film
alviandar 6 months ago
@alviandar Well far beyond Hollywood films of the present time. The acting in this movie is beyond compareson to an American movies. Konstantin Khabensy, Evgenia Boyrskya and Sergey Bezrukov - superb!
silviyaF1 6 months ago
Amazing movie. Excellent production. A very involved and interesting story. That we here in the USA of A could produce movies like this one rather than the fantasy drivel that we are seeing now, like Harry Potter and all sorts of garbage on our screens now.
SRSchoner 6 months ago 2
What a fantastic movie! Very interesting.
SRSchoner 6 months ago
Isn't it interesting how every western news service and every liberal soviet/russian leader were and are all pawns of the CIA? i mean boy those CIA agents were really something hu? controlling several top russian politicians and apparently conspiring to the fall of the the only real progressive and free nation in the world all buy there lonesome self. And yet those brave russian citizens were never fooled! they all saw and heard the truth from there state run radio and television providers -_-
arcaoon 6 months ago
revolutions are not always good. the french revolution saw innocent people sent to the guillotine just for having money, and the russian revolution obviously caused tons of death and despair. even the american revolution had its low points with the loyalist minority citizens often getting property confiscated by vengeful patriot neighbors. social upheaval only goes so far without an establishment to keep things under control.
mackshayster 6 months ago 9
@mackshayster Good words. Thank you. :-)
PyccoTypucmo 6 months ago
@mackshayster Its true, but if you didnt had the american and the french revolution, we would be probably living in a world withouth democracy.
crocve 6 months ago
@crocve Somehow I think I could survive without it.
ImperialRussianGuard 6 months ago
@mackshayster
You don't need Russian nor french revolution to murder people on a wide scale - each month some 15 000 innocent people are killed for no obvious reason in Irak (same as 11/09) if not seizing their ressources - You are the usual brainwashed uneducated prick still convinced that he is part of the GOOD when the rest of the world is just waiting for your country to be razed from earth surface !
Greetings to our Russian mates - You US disgusting bastards - Fuck off
mindxestep 5 months ago
@mindxestep i was just making a point about how certain historical events can be misconstrued, not a political statement that you seem to be attempting. i would debate that outrageously inaccurate figure about deathtoll, but what good would it do? you are totally convinced that you know what is right, yet you insult my national origin and tell me to fuck off. that doesn't prove anything other than that you have a pathological hatred for the united states
mackshayster 5 months ago
@mackshayster dealing with french and russian revolutions and you necesarily find in a position to deal with "politcs" - If you don't want to; simple : shut up !
Yeah as a french citizen i'm perfectly entitled to tell you to FUCK OFF as well as your country is a distateful pile of rubbish which is not worth a piss- no patriot act in Europe, we feel free to speak our mind the way we want to.
mindxestep 5 months ago
@mindxestep Sweet leaping Jesus..........was your daddy fucking you in the ass again last night ?
theburdcotter 5 months ago
@theburdcotter
Oh fuck off and get your cheeseburger you meaningless piece of US shit
mindxestep 5 months ago
@mindxestep but I'm Irish............go eat a frogs arse or a snails penis you fagfuck....oh, and run away from a German while you're at it
theburdcotter 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@theburdcotter
What difference does it make whether you irish, british, my balls --> FUCK OFF
mindxestep 5 months ago
@mackshayster
I don't mean to dwindle on a comment you posted a month earlier, but your opening and closing remark expresses an inherent contradiciton in your argument. Revolutions occur in absence of an establishment, its often a defining feature of one - they also (usually) occur with majority support. Thus it can only occur when the system is not already providing for the majority, hence something to revolt against exists.
Griffinltd 5 months ago
@mackshayster
Atrocities can occur in the midst of revoultions, no one denies that. But the point is that they will be better off in the long-run, once the status-quo they're revoling against is removed. The argument that, "revolutions are not always good" in my opinion, can only be validated when the emerging system (or what have you) is worse than the last. It shouldn't be judged upon the actions inbetween - which is what you're doing in the examples you give.
Griffinltd 5 months ago
...@vodka: Add to that the thousands of "suspects" brought to the stalinist Lubyanka headquarters (and who dissappeared without a trace after being tortured for days or weeks) the maybe millions of "class enemies" butchered or starved to death in the gulags, and you have a nice summary of what the POLAK Felix Dzherzhinsky has left to Russia. Yes, he was a Pole! So be careful in using the adjective "Russian". The name Yeltsin or Yalcin is fairly common in Turkey.... Stalin came from Georgia.
avginkel 6 months ago
@avginkel same can be said about CIA prison camps. you dont come out of those places. and hey, its still going on. so what is your point? its security forces.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 if you want to keep believing that the Soviet Union was heaven on earth, it´s your right to do so. Guessing your age, I think you were only a child when the SU fell and you know it only from stories. Millions of skeletons in the Karaganda and Vorkuta region can´t speak up against you, so you just go ahead. I have experienced the Cold War being on the "other side", and its memory still chills me. I have learned to respect the Soviet Union for what it was. But never again will it return
avginkel 6 months ago
@avginkel you are just the kind of ungrateful jews that arent thankful to russians for saving your race and most of the modern world from nazis and the kind of westerners that always are pouring dirt over Russia.... politics. i know. you are not the first and not the last, we are hated for what we are - survivors and masters of the biggest country in the world. lived in that country i saw it been taken apart by greed. I never seen bread lines and i have much family from stalins era and ww2.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@avginkel oh yea. millions of skeletons. right. you seem to be the other expert here. seems to be a pattern. please just stay out of that country. your kind is not welcome and neither are your perceptions of its history. go watch BBC, CNN and other propaganda channels and enjoy your life to the fullest inside your little box where they tell you that all communists are evil and USSR was an evil empire. USA is and always will be. just dont get me started on explaining why.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 simply put, i would rather live in america witha good standard of life(mostly) and not worry about spontaneously being picked for "people's labor projects" and dieing of hunger or thirst than live in the soviet union. i dont think the soviet union ws evil all the time, but stalin was. gorbachev didnt seem too bad though. the soviets also didnt have freedom of religion, as the orthodox church was said to be "helping to establish a bourgeouise elite"
mackshayster 6 months ago
@mackshayster well good for you. Gorbachev needs to be publicly executed as a piece of shit sellout cia double agent.
vodka1983 6 months ago
At around 8 minutes, why doesn't he say "OГOH" to give the order to fire?
cl0vvntiem 6 months ago
Hoce li Russi jedno napraviti film o Staljingradu,ali za Americku publiku i to 3d verzija !?
limanns 6 months ago
movies is not bad, but REAL life Kolchak was a PIECE OF SHIT. he was the bloodthirstiest of all white renegade general. if you take notice for example, Denikin was never persecuted by the reds and well respected long after revolution ended. this movie does not portray the real man this person was.... all lies.
vodka1983 7 months ago
@vodka1983 You knew Kolchak personally?
PyccoTypucmo 7 months ago 6
@PyccoTypucmo no, just very well familiar with russian history.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 The Russian history - is an unpredictable thing. :-)))
PyccoTypucmo 6 months ago 13
@vodka1983 For 70 years nice things had been said in the former Soviet Union about Felix Dzhershinksy, the founder of the Cheka / NKVD / KGB. Till the day the Moskovites tore down the statue of this murderous psychopath in front of his butchering place called the Lubyanka prison. Millions and millions were killed by this man, his successors Yezhov and Beriya. So, now the tables have turned, and now it's Kolchak's and Wrangel's turn to be portrayed in a positive light.
avginkel 6 months ago
@avginkel are you high? Lubyanka is not a prison. lmfao, its FSB headquarters or former KGB. Statue was torn down by same people that try to destroy legacy of political system before them. Its always like that. every time there is new government it shits over the old one. I don't know what millions and millions were killed, do you have REAL data? nope. Kolchak was a bloody murdering bastard, he killed many people. read before watching this trash. Only real russian officer was Denikin.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 I'm not high :-) hahahaha, in fact, I now see that the phenomenon of Holocaust deniers in Germany has been duplicated in Russia.I have been in the Soviet Union, I have spoken to people who have escaped the Stalinist death camps in Siberia, and I haven't forgotten the personal confession of Stalin himself to Churchill in 1942, that about 10 MILLION peasants were killed during the forced collectivization in the 1930s by the NKVD troops (Gorbachev's dad was one of them).
avginkel 6 months ago
@avginkel Churchil? the guy that said all russians are barbarians and red hordes must be slaughtered? the guy that at one point considered negotiating with hitler a truce to fight the russians together? oh, that guy? what else have you heard stalin "confess"? civil war in russia was the cause of millions of deaths. its not 1 persons fault. and collectivization occured in the 20s, IDIOT. you don't know russian history yet you talk big game. shut the fuck up please.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 I know very well what I am talking about, you joker, loser from a bankrupt country. I hold a masters degree in history and I could teach you a thing or two about your country´s history. Snot nosed guy, I guess you werent even born when the SU fell. At least I still have respect for what WAS your country. It was a leader in culture and science. Now its a bankrupt country led by two former thugs of the KGB.
avginkel 6 months ago
@avginkel ha, you have showed your true self, thanks. I was born and lived as a kid in SU, i guess you have never heard a saying Assumption is the mother of all fuck ups? it could be your mom too. I dont care for your degrees, you showed enough ignorance here that shows me where you got your information. Western view on russian history has been greatly influenced by politics and is ALWAYS in negative light. We are just barbarians. Still no idea WTF are you talking about. bankrupt?kgb? what?
vodka1983 6 months ago
@avginkel far from bankrupt. russia is one of worlds biggest creditors just like china. one of the biggest gold and currency reserves. enormous wealth of resources. financially its much better off than US or EU at the moment. I think you are smoking crack. Finance is my domain. dont cross it.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 Thank god! You are one of the few sane people i have seen on Youtube. Cheers, comrade, for our opinion and for Russia!
Alsemenor 5 months ago
@vodka1983 i am also well familiar with Russian history, but i think you confuse it with the Soviet one ... Kolchak as far as most historians suggest was not as you describe him , but closer to the view of this film. He was a nobleman by birth, well educated and disgraced AFTER the revolution much like ataman Mahno. His image was made similar to that of Petlura who actually was a bloodthirsty genocidal outlaw who used the chaos in the land to ... well make more chaos :)
swampyfrogness 6 months ago
ein schöner Film
ei4marie 7 months ago
@ei4marie Nanu seit wann kukt ein deutscher so ein film ^^
Marshall1816 6 months ago
Marshall1816
it's a offer to my friends Alexej, Sascha and Reinhard
great thanks to Русско Tyrusmo
ei4marie 6 months ago
MI Serbi s Vadim ! :)
limanns 7 months ago
@arcades687 This might be true!
Hellof7 7 months ago
Very Good Movie/Quality in the Special Effects!!! EX-U.S.NAVY!
alivewire13 7 months ago
Thanks from Norway ( north) !
: )
15joey04 7 months ago
This movie was not realistic at all regarding the revolution.... nobody showed the social situation of the common people, workers, peasants.... just fairy tales how the elite was "honorable" and "faithful" to their czar.... same monarchist crap nostalgia as in Mihalkov's "The barber of Siberia"....
charuga51 7 months ago
i dont get this did the sailors turn of the cpts ?
Luke99510 7 months ago
the main thing thats wrong with communism is that the proliteriat dictature has never ended and the communists had the extremely bad luck of having paranoid psychopaths for their leaders (zherdov, stalin, ....).
rambow19 7 months ago
Thanks from the Netherlands, I love these kind of movies.
PeterPanjer 7 months ago 2
Great Film, but is it a coincidence that Kolchak looks liuke Putin or is this a propaganda thing?
xenos60 7 months ago
I love Russia...for a woman....Im sure that ...goes on.
tenyearafter 7 months ago
Thanks from Denmark!
Alphahumphrey2011 7 months ago
As long as money and economic growth is the only measure of the quality of our lives , we are going to ruin our planet ! The real quality is living in a clean invironment without chemical and nuclear waist , using new technologyes and make a sustainable living ! Watter, sun , wind and geothermal energy and natural materials are the wellknown keys ! Just have to say NO to the consumer society - THAT IS HARD?! But the only way, despite all nice political speaches and threads! Just hawe guts!
SRECKORIBIC25 7 months ago
Nice movie.
Well done - good special effects, fine acting, decent historical accuracy.
Thumbs up!
TheLoyalOfficer 8 months ago
life goes on
DraGorian777 8 months ago
The comments by TomDavid88 and Raubritter1488 are highly suspect as 14 and 88 stand for nazi salutes.
Marcus79a 8 months ago
You are wrong - Russia will never die.
kkppk1 8 months ago
@kkppk1
Russia will never die but communists killed her.
PyccoTypucmo 8 months ago 4
@kkppk1 Dont be sure about that, because Europeans (Russians included) are dying out, our homelands are being filled with non white immigrants. Europes dying and including Russia. If Russians die out, then Russia is dead. Slava Rusa
EvilKorbinDallas 7 months ago
Unfortunately, the Revolution did not kill enough of the tzarist vermin. Same thing after 1945, in the new Communist countries. Vivat the heroic Red Army, the peasants and the workers who died for the fatherland, and who were betrayed by the criminal Gorbachev!
kkppk1 8 months ago
@kkppk1
Unfortunately, the Revolution killed more - Russia.
PyccoTypucmo 8 months ago 2
@PyccoTypucmo Capitalism will kill the world, Russia included.
Hellof7 8 months ago
@Hellof7
Who knows. Maybe you are right. ;-) But doesn't exist the ideal politic system in the world. ;-)
PyccoTypucmo 8 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo Not yet. It must come before it's too late. :)
Hellof7 8 months ago
@Hellof7 Pffft - Bolshevism almost killed the world.
Only Islamism is worse than Bolshevism.
TheLoyalOfficer 8 months ago
@TheLoyalOfficer This is not simply a question of one's world view but of the fact that no other ideology than capitalism aims at the systematic destruction of the environment and one's living space.
Hellof7 8 months ago
@Hellof7 Communism doesnt aim at that the leaders who governed did it, plus Capitalism went down the toilet dont u know? oh dont get me wrong i dont give shit about either but i will defend both political ideologies from biased and ignorant comments.
TheVixvis 8 months ago
@TheVixvis Um, I don't get your attitude. Can't be me who's addressed.
Hellof7 8 months ago
@Hellof7 P.S. have you been fucking drinking? Capitalism is by far worse than Communism Imperialism and Fascism put together, the only difference is how thing are done.
TheVixvis 8 months ago
@Hellof7 so your saying people's rights and freedom are killing the world?
chubowu 7 months ago
@chubowu Which rights? Which freedom? The one that allows certain people to gain wealth regardless of the consequeces? Such a distorted self-understanding against the general concept of life and survival is the reason for the human race going on exterminating itself from this planet inexorably.
Hellof7 7 months ago
@Hellof7 eh what ever. i live in canada so its all fine ~
chubowu 7 months ago
@chubowu ;)
Hellof7 7 months ago
@kkppk1 Nobody killed more russians than Stalin and his jewish-bolsheviks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DIHORY 7 months ago
@DIHORY agreed
MariusChivu838814 7 months ago
@MariusChivu838814 i agree your agree :)
TheAfghanArian 7 months ago
@DIHORY hitler did. times and times over more.
vodka1983 7 months ago
@vodka1983 Hitler did kill more russians than Stalin and the bolsheviks????? You are either HIGHLY uneducated or a communist. Which one? Or both?
DIHORY 7 months ago
@DIHORY spoken like a western propaganda cock goblin. because of hitler soviet union lost over 23 million of its citizens. majority was civilians killed by the nazis. you know very VERY little of real russian history. keep reading your american and british book with lies about my country.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 So what are you trying to say? Tell me how many russians did Stalin (your beloved jew bolshevik) kill? Answer me.
DIHORY 6 months ago
@DIHORY there has been much unrest and sabotage following death of lenin and revolution. its popular nowadays to cry to be a victim of his regime. of course, all polizai and traitors that worked with nazis are victims lol. criminals, etc. russia had huge issues with crime and poverty. things had to be done to restore order and keep the country from falling apart. actual numbers of people in gulags and work camps were around 3-4 million over a period of 10 years. this doesnt count POWS.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 Have you heard of Holodomor in Ukraine? Around 10 million ukranians were killed by Stalin's communist regime. In Russia the army was wiped out by Stalin, officers who fought for the tzar were disposed of by killing them. Millions upon millions of russians were killed by the bolsheviks. Later the communist regimes of other russian presidents killed many people. This happened all across eastern Europe. Have you read about "Pitesti experiment" in Romania? Read about it!
DIHORY 6 months ago
@DIHORY HHAHAHAHAHAHHA golodomor?? biggest fucking lie ever. it was starvation for many nationals, not ukranians lol. you seriously believe in that hoax? i guess lack of education nowadays allows for that level of idiocy. this is something idiots in ukraine made up. Ushenko will burn in hell, you will see. there is sooo much disinformation, everyone is re writing history nowadays. US and EU loves to sponsor such things. anything to poor dirt over russians they are all for it.
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 ha ha ha? You must be a communist hardliner! That says it all.
DIHORY 6 months ago
@DIHORY nope. i just dont shit on my country's history unlike you. i value real history and not something that is made up decades later
vodka1983 6 months ago
@vodka1983 So you are saying that Stalin is not a criminal? How about the jewish bolsheviks?
DIHORY 6 months ago
@DIHORY why is stalin a criminal? he was paranoid, persecuted enemies of the state left and right (especially in the 30's, yet he was a great leader, strategist and project manager. Thanks to stalins perseverance and russian labor force russia re-industrialized from the ruins. Now jewish bolsheviks were in large park eliminated by him, something that Lenin couldn't do. many of those jewish bolsheviks like Trotsky were the scum that needed to be killed off, extremists.
vodka1983 6 months ago
I assumed this movie was intended to be pro-Kolchak but instead it reveals why the old regime fell. Russia is starving, losing a war, about to collapse and the aristocrats are having parties, high tea and cheating with each other's wives. The Communists were evil but you can see how the "Whites" had no credibility and were bound to lose a civil war. if only the forces of the middle, the true democrats had been more organized.
ddpresearch07 8 months ago
@ddpresearch07 It was literally a black or white thing during this time, a third way was not relevant. I don't appreciate this movie, it has great special effects but it is technically as much propagandistic as the old Soviet films.
Hellof7 8 months ago
@ddpresearch07 Communists were evil?Please define what u mean by evil? Have you lived in a Soviet state before? Or are u just saying things that the Western media has spun? Without any knoweledge of ur own?
TheVixvis 8 months ago
I assume this movie was pro-Kolchak but it rea
ddpresearch07 8 months ago
Absolutely beautiful movie! This is such a great interpretation of a scene from history which really doesn't get enough due!
VsFail 9 months ago
Люблю этот фильм.
TheNoob978 10 months ago
Comment removed
teresavivarium 10 months ago
what a great movie!!! Thank you for posting the entire film. I wish this movie is available in the United States.
FiREFLYSerenity408 10 months ago
Why isn't Russian movies more mainstream into the world? It's not right that US is monopolising our attention and pushing out other worthy films...
SuperDave619 11 months ago
@SuperDave619
Hehehe... I'd like to know too. ;)
PyccoTypucmo 11 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo
Yeah. Me too. By the way, thanks for this fantastic movie. Hope you upload identical movies about heroes of Russia.
SuperDave619 11 months ago
@SuperDave619
Thanks for your comment. In one month I hope I can to upload the big movie-epopee "The Liberation" about World War Two. Of course with English subtitles. ;)
By the way, I have another film of Kolchak (10 mini-series) but unfortunatly, English subtitles for this film are not ready yet.
PyccoTypucmo 11 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo Ты из Антарктиды??? не холодно ли вам? :)
TheNoob978 10 months ago
@TheNoob978
Прохладно однако. Вчерась опять шёл снег... ;) Апрель, блин, называется... :)))))
PyccoTypucmo 10 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo :D ты там как участник экспедиции?
TheNoob978 10 months ago
@TheNoob978
Живу я там. :Ь :)))
PyccoTypucmo 10 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo Антарктида стала независимым государством?
TheNoob978 10 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo Антарктида теперь независима?)
TheNoob978 10 months ago
So how much is actual truth in this and how much revisionism? I know that according to some people anything that communists did was bad and everything that the Czar did was good, although not according to facts.
Pseudologic 11 months ago
@Pseudologic just google "red terror".
Not everything of what the Czar did was good, actually it's vice versa, there was no another reason for that revolution except the stupidity of Nicolas II.
But bolsheviks were bloody maniacs during revolution and first years after.
malicesgossips 11 months ago
@Pseudologic
its all complicated
the monarch would have never collapsed if nicolas wasnt so useless and dealt with the situation rather than bury his head in the sand and
basically when the monarch collapsed the parliament either arrested, shot or deported all officers to stop a revolution from happening, however it didnt really work as the russian people wanted an end to the war and not to the monarchy, soo another revolution was started in saint Petersburg (petrograd at the time)
jgascoine011 10 months ago
@jgascoine011
as the bolshivicks took saint petersburg , which at the time was the capital, they came to power and ended the war but another war started between the bolshivicks and the right
after this war they again killed every1 to stop a revolution
basically whoever won was going to kill people as they wanted to keep in power and not have another revolution
as for the tsar, well he was just as bad as the reds and whites
jgascoine011 10 months ago
@Pseudologic People hated the Tsar at the time, but when they got Communism the people thought "oh man.." and hankered back to better times.. By Stalins time people were becoming utterly institutionalised, there were so many purges, so many people in GULAG - there was not contact with the outside for most people outside the elites - Russians were brainwashed and did not know any better, those who did remember better times knew not to speak of them openly.
andy7666 10 months ago
@andy7666
The "millions" of people sent to the Gulags is by all estmates vastly exagurrated by Western historians with an interest to make the USSR look as bad as possible. A more realistic number are hundreds of thousands and what should be taken into account then is that most criminals was sent to the Gulags, not only political 'enemies' of the bolsheviks. There where murderers, rapists, robbers and so on in the USSR too.
ma82fo 9 months ago
@Pseudologic When the Red Army went into Europe Stalin was terrified of the troops seeing the far higher standards of living and becoming restless on thier return - to counter this the men were encouraged to act as criminally and as bestially as possible - essentially bringing everything to the Soviet level. When POW's were released from the concentration camps, they were sent straight to GULAG as they had been in contact with Western civilisation!
andy7666 10 months ago
@andy7666 I don't think it was like that, after the Germans murdered 20 million Soviet civilians, I think revenge was in order, so Stalin allowed his troops to do as much harm as they want.
Unit987654321 10 months ago
@andy7666
Before the War ended most Red Army soldiers liberated from Nazi captivity was conscripted back into the Army since there was a need to fill up the gaps so to speak. They where ofc screened for possible fascist elements before being allowed to rejoin. The reason why Red Army soldiers destroyed so much in Germany was according to themselves that they became angry at the Germans for invading and destroying their own homes when the German houses where much better built.
ma82fo 9 months ago
@ma82fo Bullshit! They wre ALL sent to Siberia, usually with a 10 year sentence! Read the stuff by Robert Conquest. And it was the Jews such as Illya Ehrenberg who encouraged the Russian troops to behave like a batch of wild beasts when they invaded Germany.
Tom David
Minneapolis
TomDavid88 9 months ago
@TomDavid88
From what I have heard Conquest is known for slandering the Soviet Union and vastly exaggerate the numbers of victims in Stalins terror. Everyone, myself included, knows that Stalin was a paranoid man who sentenced several hundreds of thousands to their death in Siberia but in the case of former prisoners of war it is just not true. What happened when the Red Army liberated POW:S was that NKVD/SMERSH set up facilities to 'screen' for fascists but the vast majority was rehabilitated.
ma82fo 9 months ago
@ma82fo This is only the "offical" record, according to Soviet propagandists, but Conquest uses original documents to prove exactly what I have stated.
Tom David
Minneapolis
TomDavid88 9 months ago
@TomDavid88
You're right,sir,in 1941 Stalin defined Russian prisioners as ''Traitors to the Motherland'',so they were shot in the spot(by the SMERSH guys) or sent for 10,15 or even 25 years to Siberia,like Alexander Solzenitsyn.And Ehrenburg was that fucking jewish bastard who encouraged Russian soldiers to rape,plunder and murder,not only in Germany because Red Army marked its presence with death,blood and pain in the Baltic States,Romania,Hungary,Checoslovakia and Poland as well.
Raubritter1488 8 months ago