Soy un fan de Argentina, Lanus Bs AS, son lo maximo en musica que he escuchado en mi vida y su musica siempre estara vigente!!!! Gracias Wright, Gilmour, Nick y Waters. GRACIAS.
Hello brother. Now Japan has encountered serious by the earthquake and tsunami disaster. Japanese people need help. If not, please support Japan for you and your friends. Japan saves your good intentions. Thank you please.
david gilmour is one of the few that have reached inmortality through music.... he become one with the music he plays... one whole being of pure music, that aims to heaven, and so, reaching inmortality... some times i can abstract my existence and walk beside him... some times i feel inmortal, specialy with this song.... actually, only with this song.... :´)
Never get tired of listening to this song and Dave's magic. I saw this concert in Earls Court in 1980 (or was it 1981), an experience I will never forget.
Only one other guitarist comes to mind who is on the same level: Andy Latimer of Came. Search for CAMEL ICE (live) and you will know what I am talking about.l
You are more than welcome, I am glad you liked it. Camel is a great band and Andy Latimer is actually prog rock royalty. In addition to the song ICE there are tens of other song just as mesmerizing by Camel.
most of it isnt his writing...he is the greatest there ever has been in my oppinian! his greatest solo well there isnt one! they are all musical perfection....and the good thing is i HAVE MET THE LEGEND HIMSELF!!! MY HERO!!!!!!!
@mattaystig i honestly dislike you now cuz you've met him... lol jk but i play guitar and honestly can lay one of his solos and thats time from pulse.. he's the best there ever was and i should have seen him in minneapolis but he didnt show up sadface... but your the luckiest person ever to get to meet him... he's my NUMBER 1 hero
THE MUSICIAN COMPOSER DAVID WORLD'S GREATEST PINK FLOYD THE GREAT BAND THAT TIME FRAME WILL NEVER LIKE ANOTHER BAND DIE WITHOUT YOU ARE ONLY SO MANY TALENTED AND AMAZING RINGTONES THAT LED TO ME SO LONG WAYS YOU NEVER JUST WALKING
It just doesn't get much higher than this...wthout blasting off into outerspace. Like a low orbit where you can still see...EVERYTHING. FYI, this was supposed to be a tune on David's 1978 solo album and didn't quite make it...so it evolved into a piece on The Wall. It's not to say I think it would have been better without Roger Water's ugly fingerprint on it. It's a great song as a FLOYD song. I'd still bee interested to to hear Dave's personal first studio outtakes on it pre-Wall.
i like when, in a live performance, you can catch that small signals between the musicians, to mark the end of a section or like in this case, the end og the song. wonderful!
I think that Rick was singing much better on that tour than on the Pink Floyd tours in the 80s and the 90s. Also, he and David sounded wonderful when they sang together in the harmony. Too bad Rick is no longer with us.
Anyone know what effects Gilmore kicks in on the second solo? ...sounds like echo with a touch of flange and overdrive, but I just can't quite place the sound he's getting.
its called a band !! everybody gets some 'light,dave does this song better .that aint the point with a reunion .floyd has yet to be matched on record or record CHARTS...IT SPEAKS FOR ITSELF.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think Wright make the song pretty good :)
But he should sing it a bit more like Waters do, without the real pitch or what i shall describe it as... Good preformance. What is it, some kind of music video?
Close your mouth louismarcil, you have to learn more about the music. Wright had an amazing voice and he perform this version of the song beautifully. And What happen to you with the people who play the keyboard? So, you can say everything you want to say, but think about this: "Your lips move but I can´t hear what you are saying"
6:10 the best part of this amazing solo, for my. This is the best song of all times , and it will keep been the best. Unless Pink Floyd do another song better than this. But only Pink Floyd. Comfortably Douglas.
how can you compare David Gilmour with others??? Gilmour is the man...nobody will have such a beautiful sound ever...! And how can u compare him to a guitarist that mainly shreds ...David is a melodic player and a master of Guitar sounds...! There is no comparison...
its david gilmour, its easy for him, i can just improvise a solo over comfortably numb and make it sounds good, its not how well you play but how you feel what you play
gilmour is definately one of the most underrated guitarists....he doesnt necessarily play fast but he is flawless and he plays with so much emotion....not to mention his songwriting
He's my idol, I love every single thing he does BUT one thing that contribute to his greatness is his underrating ;-) ain't it?
I wouldn't like people to stay Gilmour is the best guitarist, I prefer they get a boner about Slash or Buckethead (I hate both) and just let us (poor minority made of real music lovers) the true one ;-)
and after you try to play like him, and fail...then imagine having to do it live, standing up, while singing. and best of all it's his own music. just gtfo. never post another comment. you don't deserve to be a youtube member.
any one can play like david gilmour it's just he's been playing for so long he's just more experienced with playing. In my oppinion Jimmy Page is the best and David is my 4th favorite guitarist.
I love gilmour's playing and he has plays with a lot of emotion but you're wrong when you say that page plays with no emotion because if that was true, then how would you explain Stairway to Heaven, Since Ive Been Loving You, and All of My Love
That is just amazing! I get chills down my spine when the solo begins. It's unbelievable how some people can affect me just by playing an instrument. He is definitely one of the best guitar players ever!
I got many tears in my eyes when I watch Pink Floyd at the Live 8 playing this song. It's so intense and perfect, everytime I drop some tears. And also it's probably the last time we saw them play together, which is really sad.
He was born on March 6th, 1946. So he just turned 62. Anyway, I really hope Dave and Roger get together again before it's too late. I went to Roger's show last year and he still have a lot in his tank.
Soy un fan de Argentina, Lanus Bs AS, son lo maximo en musica que he escuchado en mi vida y su musica siempre estara vigente!!!! Gracias Wright, Gilmour, Nick y Waters. GRACIAS.
tolkeyen07 9 months ago
Just a note to the poster of this amazing video, David Gilmour hates being called Dave.
bryanjeffrey06 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello brother. Now Japan has encountered serious by the earthquake and tsunami disaster. Japanese people need help. If not, please support Japan for you and your friends. Japan saves your good intentions. Thank you please.
caotain1 11 months ago
I tell everyone out there...he's still "hot" and still great...mulitpattyc
MultiPattyc 11 months ago
this like a warm up before live 8 or something or a rehearsal ?
geoff101001 1 year ago
After all these years, Gilmour's voice and guitar playing is still incredible.
mev321 1 year ago
Feeling > Shred
distumorbenasty 1 year ago
david gilmour is one of the few that have reached inmortality through music.... he become one with the music he plays... one whole being of pure music, that aims to heaven, and so, reaching inmortality... some times i can abstract my existence and walk beside him... some times i feel inmortal, specialy with this song.... actually, only with this song.... :´)
d4v1d14david 1 year ago 2
Never get tired of listening to this song and Dave's magic. I saw this concert in Earls Court in 1980 (or was it 1981), an experience I will never forget.
Only one other guitarist comes to mind who is on the same level: Andy Latimer of Came. Search for CAMEL ICE (live) and you will know what I am talking about.l
mertsi1340 1 year ago
@mertsi1340 duuuude i cant believe ive never heard that before, i just watched it, excellent stuff!
swanski100 1 year ago
@swanski100
You are more than welcome, I am glad you liked it. Camel is a great band and Andy Latimer is actually prog rock royalty. In addition to the song ICE there are tens of other song just as mesmerizing by Camel.
mertsi1340 1 year ago
Believe it or not, but thats the worst possible tone he can ever get out of a guitar.
timemaster20 1 year ago
most of it isnt his writing...he is the greatest there ever has been in my oppinian! his greatest solo well there isnt one! they are all musical perfection....and the good thing is i HAVE MET THE LEGEND HIMSELF!!! MY HERO!!!!!!!
mattaystig 1 year ago
@mattaystig i honestly dislike you now cuz you've met him... lol jk but i play guitar and honestly can lay one of his solos and thats time from pulse.. he's the best there ever was and i should have seen him in minneapolis but he didnt show up sadface... but your the luckiest person ever to get to meet him... he's my NUMBER 1 hero
FEARsc0pe 1 year ago
FKin ell. WOW. This is the best comment I can come up with after being blown away by young Gilmour & co
1coachking1 1 year ago
gilmour should have sung the whole thing
anderson5908 1 year ago
THE MUSICIAN COMPOSER DAVID WORLD'S GREATEST PINK FLOYD THE GREAT BAND THAT TIME FRAME WILL NEVER LIKE ANOTHER BAND DIE WITHOUT YOU ARE ONLY SO MANY TALENTED AND AMAZING RINGTONES THAT LED TO ME SO LONG WAYS YOU NEVER JUST WALKING
comfortabily 1 year ago
And who is this person, who disliked this Masterpeace?
Flamingbird1989 1 year ago
@Flamingbird1989 - Probably Roger Waters - - RIP RIchard Wright.
martinaxman 1 year ago
David Gilmour = a God . BEST guitarrist every period!
PortalRealm 1 year ago
Un sommet !
lucbietry 1 year ago
It just doesn't get much higher than this...wthout blasting off into outerspace. Like a low orbit where you can still see...EVERYTHING. FYI, this was supposed to be a tune on David's 1978 solo album and didn't quite make it...so it evolved into a piece on The Wall. It's not to say I think it would have been better without Roger Water's ugly fingerprint on it. It's a great song as a FLOYD song. I'd still bee interested to to hear Dave's personal first studio outtakes on it pre-Wall.
brofjw 1 year ago
david gilmour up to this date has the sexiest lips and nose!!!
fuckyoufuckyou1 1 year ago
the solos of this are just.... no words to describe them, sorry....
AkisColdplay 1 year ago
tan hermosa como la primera vez....!!!!!!!!
bassdiegofloyd 1 year ago
rip ricard
geoff552 1 year ago
When the song ended i relized that i was out of breath
MetalFee666 1 year ago
Wow, during the solo the rhythm guitarist sure is going at it, haha.
zaz214 1 year ago
the only video on this tube worth watching, f----ing fab and then some, gilmour is god, sorry if you don't feel the same way!!!!!!!
robertfd34 1 year ago
Gilmour and Knopfler both have this sparky thing called...emotion. They are the two best guitarist for me =)
surfinspirit 1 year ago
@surfinspirit
Hey don't forget the "spiritual guiding father " of both ( which are my most played by me on guitar) HANK MARVIN , both Mark and David admit so!
joanstring 1 year ago
@joanstring
Sure ! Marvin is a genius too =) And the passion for red guitars seems to be the same for two of these genius ^^ Love these three guys !
surfinspirit 1 year ago
@surfinspirit
That is correct the red guitar strat is from Hank and both Mark and Dave were deeply inspired by the red flamingo strat (made in Japan)
Me too love these 3 genius
joanstring 1 year ago
Gilmour and Knopfler both have this sparky thing called...emotion. They are the two best guitarist for me =)
surfinspirit 1 year ago
bello pieza
TheVitorinox 1 year ago
beautiful!! too beautifull everytime i listen to this song . it just takes me away from it all!! <333
lunasnuvs 1 year ago 2
us and them - amazing !!!!! written and performed by richard Wright . the only song in the world I could listen to on repeat forever!!!
hignut06 1 year ago 4
Genius.....
reoreason 1 year ago 4
RIP Rick
Neorossi13 1 year ago 7
More Genius...
webnutcomputers 1 year ago 4
i still cant find words...
DonConstantinos 1 year ago 3
there are no words to describe the perfection that we have just witnessed
floydfan831 1 year ago 4
R.I.P. Richard Wright, the best synth/pianists ever to walk this earth! David, keep on going bro! Your voice is always amazing!
domenian 2 years ago 4
i really respecting u mr.david gilmour and pink floyd
u becoming older and older but ur voice keep runing between my ears everytime
u r the best singer the best guitarist & best musican
medodedo911 2 years ago 2
i like when, in a live performance, you can catch that small signals between the musicians, to mark the end of a section or like in this case, the end og the song. wonderful!
mergonite 2 years ago 3
el magnifico "phill manzanera" ;D
ricardotorress43 2 years ago
gilmour and floyd for ever :) fantastic four ;D
ricardotorress43 2 years ago
this is better than pulse version!
bayonetemple 2 years ago
fantastic track :) !!!
szymcio146 2 years ago
gilmour the best
sbandat90 2 years ago
if anything this is the best song on the album pink floyd rules r.i.p. whright
weskerwewe 2 years ago
I can't explain, you would not understand. This is not how I am...
rg2027x 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
R.I.P Rick!!!!!
faltsetas88 2 years ago
RIP wright Pink floyd 4ever
xXBuccinOXx 2 years ago 24
RICHARD WHRIGHT!!!!!
santi1salmon 2 years ago 6
I think that Rick was singing much better on that tour than on the Pink Floyd tours in the 80s and the 90s. Also, he and David sounded wonderful when they sang together in the harmony. Too bad Rick is no longer with us.
1985MarcinM 2 years ago 2
Anyone know what effects Gilmore kicks in on the second solo? ...sounds like echo with a touch of flange and overdrive, but I just can't quite place the sound he's getting.
rjworks13 2 years ago
fuzz i think
caca002 2 years ago
chorus fuzz and delay
TaylorGilmour 2 years ago
he uses a special effect called mad skills and something called gilmouricious fuzz
VanfHimself 2 years ago 5
guitar tone n feel cannot get better than this.
anirban747 2 years ago
GEILSTE VERSION EVER 5 STARS
kippensauger 2 years ago
Out of all the guitarists in the world. I'm glad it was david gilmour who inspired me to learn the guitar. Thanks David !
craigcfc107 2 years ago 4
R.I.P. whright
Manualasino 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is this on another brick in the wall album?
triplet1325 2 years ago
yes, the album is called The Wall, just the same as the movie. The track is Comfortably Numb.
scsomike 2 years ago
Yes it is. But the album's name is "The Wall"
darkmachete 2 years ago
its called a band !! everybody gets some 'light,dave does this song better .that aint the point with a reunion .floyd has yet to be matched on record or record CHARTS...IT SPEAKS FOR ITSELF.
feeldhand 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think Wright make the song pretty good :)
But he should sing it a bit more like Waters do, without the real pitch or what i shall describe it as... Good preformance. What is it, some kind of music video?
FenderMeddle94 2 years ago
Close your mouth louismarcil, you have to learn more about the music. Wright had an amazing voice and he perform this version of the song beautifully. And What happen to you with the people who play the keyboard? So, you can say everything you want to say, but think about this: "Your lips move but I can´t hear what you are saying"
-------------- Attentivly, ComfortablyDouglas.
ComfortablyDouglas 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why the hell did they let wright sing?????????????? go back to singing Wearing the Inside Out you keyboardist
louismarcil 2 years ago
dude, wright is amazing, you do NOT insult the great richard wright
floydfan831 1 year ago 5
6:10 the best part of this amazing solo, for my. This is the best song of all times , and it will keep been the best. Unless Pink Floyd do another song better than this. But only Pink Floyd. Comfortably Douglas.
ComfortablyDouglas 2 years ago
Wow the ending is just amazing!!! These old men are real fucking guitar legends!!
ZR1Terror 2 years ago
how can you compare David Gilmour with others??? Gilmour is the man...nobody will have such a beautiful sound ever...! And how can u compare him to a guitarist that mainly shreds ...David is a melodic player and a master of Guitar sounds...! There is no comparison...
loliaris 2 years ago 2
The new Gilmour Strat....Monster sound as the old and fantastic Stratocaster PRE CBS.....
Fenderfan1975 2 years ago
why isn't nick mason on drums here@
andyjcannon 2 years ago
That's a song performed by David Gilmour(Solo) here, Richard is just a guest here.
CrazyBCRICH666 2 years ago
Watch his face, he's into it, what passion!
Amvet69 2 years ago
wow
muscledd22 2 years ago
sounds so easy ,but he had to come up with this out of the blue,snatched out of time and space
feeldhand 2 years ago
its david gilmour, its easy for him, i can just improvise a solo over comfortably numb and make it sounds good, its not how well you play but how you feel what you play
friend120 2 years ago
WELL SAID>.............
scottymaxxx 2 years ago
beautifully said my friend!!
ZR1Terror 2 years ago
gilmour is definately one of the most underrated guitarists....he doesnt necessarily play fast but he is flawless and he plays with so much emotion....not to mention his songwriting
cmorisey 2 years ago 51
ya i totally agree. his songs are so mellow but when the guitar solo comes he just takes it home. its indescribable.
guitarlegend1218 2 years ago
Yeah, but I think he should stay underrated.
He's my idol, I love every single thing he does BUT one thing that contribute to his greatness is his underrating ;-) ain't it?
I wouldn't like people to stay Gilmour is the best guitarist, I prefer they get a boner about Slash or Buckethead (I hate both) and just let us (poor minority made of real music lovers) the true one ;-)
Cause usually, majority likes crap.
Hope I'll not be misunderstood
arasu90 2 years ago 2
it´ll be better if everyone knew gilmour
santiagodebellavista 2 years ago
It's not talking about being known or not, it's talking about rating
arasu90 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
buckethead is one of the best....
and autistic...
he plays different music then dave
its like an entirely different genre
so to compare them doesn't do either of them justice
layla251 2 years ago
Saying he's one of the best is comparing him to other isn't it? You can just say he's GREAT and then it'll be okay ;-)
It'll do justice to both of them, isn't it?
arasu90 2 years ago
@cmorisey Bro I feel the same way. More than underrated no one plays with the emotion that he carries.
joizzy87 1 year ago 3
@cmorisey underrated? he's definatly known as a legend. nothing less
kennykins420 1 year ago 5
@cmorisey underrated?He's know as one of all times best players aint he?
gibderfenson 1 year ago
@cmorisey He's not under rated.... just no need to compare him to anyone.
beautifulmusical 1 year ago
@cmorisey Best coment on youtube!
jorgeezuncho 1 year ago
amazing
Trapper2159 2 years ago
he should hv been playing this solo for hundred times, if not thousand times
it's indeed one of the greatest guitar solo ever
hermesw 2 years ago
dave is playing the NOS there :D
Joyster2212 2 years ago
and after you try to play like him, and fail...then imagine having to do it live, standing up, while singing. and best of all it's his own music. just gtfo. never post another comment. you don't deserve to be a youtube member.
illy984 3 years ago
anyone can play like david gilmour?????!?! LOL, how ignorant are you?!
illy984 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
any one can play like david gilmour it's just he's been playing for so long he's just more experienced with playing. In my oppinion Jimmy Page is the best and David is my 4th favorite guitarist.
meng12345678 3 years ago
teribly sorry, page had no feeling in his playing
jkrych 2 years ago
I love gilmour's playing and he has plays with a lot of emotion but you're wrong when you say that page plays with no emotion because if that was true, then how would you explain Stairway to Heaven, Since Ive Been Loving You, and All of My Love
JMLproductionz 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yes page did have feeling, just not as much as dave
ironledtallicafloyd9 2 years ago
You spelt 'mOng12345678' incorrectly.
husky041 2 years ago
Comment removed
meng12345678 3 years ago
DG has more talent in his nail clippings than 99% of todays guitarists.
esa1810 3 years ago 45
@esa1810 thats a huge exageration
anderson5908 1 year ago 3
How can you not like this ?
Brrrrr43 3 years ago 3
RIP Rick
nikhiljo 3 years ago 4
best guitarristtitit ever,haaaaaaaaaaaa
JOTAP11WEST 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm gonna get flamed but I actually prefer the cover version of the solo that KOBIBA does, it's on here.
snookmundy 3 years ago
Lol @ 2:39 he looks kind of like Clint Eastwood. David Gilmour rocks.
onapoda 3 years ago
I piu' grandi di tutti! EKKOLI!!!!!!!!!!!
SteveVai16 3 years ago
Two great musicians, i can't explain my respect to them.
Long live David and RIP Rick!
martinxxx72 3 years ago 5
David Gilmour = BEST guitarist ever. That's it, No more Comments
2113229 3 years ago 15
amazing
bobbbyyy1 3 years ago 3
God Bless you Rick Wright.
Killinfloor 3 years ago 8
That is just amazing! I get chills down my spine when the solo begins. It's unbelievable how some people can affect me just by playing an instrument. He is definitely one of the best guitar players ever!
Awtn 3 years ago 7
just goes to show u don't always have to do 2300000 notes per seconed to be an amazing guitarist
dimebagalways 3 years ago 13
Well said :)
NorwegiaWeightlift 3 years ago 2
Dave's voice has like no difference at all even nearly 30 years later. That's pretty darn amazing.
TWern9 3 years ago 7
He is by far the best guitar player ever.
libertyfalls 3 years ago 2
maybe not the best but he's close. He is top 10
floydfan12345 3 years ago
he's top 3
Jimi Hendrix
David Gilmour
Van Halen
bielkun 3 years ago
No, he is the greatest player ever. Sorry.
jvandle 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jimmy page?
vareela94 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Van Halen ? LOL
Hendrix
SRV
David Gilmour
marvelbraw 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
1. evh
2. page
3. gilmour at least these r my favorites
freesleeveband 3 years ago
WOW ive got a tear in my eye.What a performance...
vpproddy 4 years ago
I got many tears in my eyes when I watch Pink Floyd at the Live 8 playing this song. It's so intense and perfect, everytime I drop some tears. And also it's probably the last time we saw them play together, which is really sad.
poprip 3 years ago
the best song & guitar solo from Pink Floyd.
neanclatov 4 years ago 3
maybe best solo ever!
metalheadcolton 3 years ago 3
This must be fairly recent?? Dave and Richard still sound awesome!!! Where is the drummer Nick?
steveb250377 4 years ago
It's David's tour, last year.
There'a also a DVD out now. It is grandiose!
poprip 3 years ago
This must be fairly recent?? Dave and Richard still sound awesome!!! Where is the drummer Nick?
steveb250377 4 years ago
This must be fairly recent?? Dave and Richard still sound awesome!!! Where is the drummer Nick?
steveb250377 4 years ago
actually sushiseattle he turned 64 today...
Specialboy1 4 years ago
He was born on March 6th, 1946. So he just turned 62. Anyway, I really hope Dave and Roger get together again before it's too late. I went to Roger's show last year and he still have a lot in his tank.
sushiseattle 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
it's too late...
digginsjp 3 years ago
i love you mr.gilmour
rashock12 4 years ago
wow this is great so they can do what the whole team did
zos2322 4 years ago
mitici...
luigino866 4 years ago
grandi
juventino1988 4 years ago 4
(speechless.....)
JamalBass 4 years ago 2
62 and counting. This man is a phoenix. I hope he comes back for more touring.
sushiseattle 4 years ago 3
Good is relative ,this is the Best.
scifu777 4 years ago 4
How good is this!!
fleepit 4 years ago 3