Added: 4 years ago
From: chsilber
Views: 175,127
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (243)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What a lovely duet. Netrebko was born to sing Jolanta!

  • chsilber! it's not "nepan atna", it's "ne ponyatno"! :)

  • Роландо блестяще ведет свою партию!!!!

  • je me délecte de la beauté de cette femme

  • Iolanta is a glorious opera and Netrebko has performed a concert version recently; Really it should be staged and taped for commercial DVD release; if reams of baroque opera currently being committed to tape surely Iolanta deserves the same--especially with Anna

  • Здорово!

  • I love this piece. Anna's performance is superb. While Rolando would not pass as a Russian, amongst non-native singers of Russian, he is remarkably good. I cannot recall, offhand, a non-Russian who sings Russian this well.

    They are both great. A very moving performance. Bravo!

  • Rolando looks like he is a wearing a costume from Star trek haha But beautiful singing as always! :)

  • one of my favorite tandems, Anna Netrebko and Rolando Villazon.

  • wonderful together...

  • Rolando is great!!! This duet in his voice sounds wonderful.

  • @caper064 i agree

  • Dos cantantes que suelen ser estimados en poco por los "entendidos"son capaces de llevarle a uno por los senderos de lo excelso...a Villazon le cobran su mexicanidad ,el uso de su garganta de manera non académica... y a la rusa le cobran su belleza...Solo escuchemosles..asi como el aplauso final de un publico exigente y colegiremos en la ingratitud de los calificativos que se les suele endilgar....

  • @JorPove Lo mismo pasaba (pasa, mejor dicho) con el mismo Tchaikovsky...

  • @neuronauta Cierto. A este compositor se le ha ido reconociendo mas y mas conformee pasa el tiempo.

  • @neuronauta Es correcto a este compositor se le aprecia mas y mas conforme pasa el tiempo.

  • Rolando's Russian is wonderful!

  • This is remarkable. I would like to hear them sing together again in another opera maybe.

  • I love this <3

  • She has an incredible power in her voice especially when she needs it.

  • Netrekbo is the best soprano I've ever heard!

  • Utterly fascinated by the whole thing!

  • They are great! And of course, Netrebko owned the role.

  • Amazing music. I've never heard this duet before.

  • Nice duet!

  • Beautiful music well performed.

  • Великолепно спето!!! Они прекрасный дуэт, Rolando очень старался, а Анна как всегда великолепна.

  • THANK YOU FOR POSTING THIS AMAZING MASTERPIECE! I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS FOR SOOO LONG! I LOVE THIS OPERA SO MUCH!

  • C'est de la profanation de la dignité humaine! Anna, arrete de mentir et de profaner ta langue maternelle, encore ce débile de Villazon, on peut fermer les yeux sur son incompintence totale. Pauvre de vous, pauvre de Tchaikovsky!!!!

  • @Mekertitch Oh,perhaps you must be aware of Russian operas something, but you have no idea of Russian language and her Russian soul of course ..Yes,mr.Villazon was a bit sharp and incorrect in his Russian libretto but he was Anna's stage partner and he did his best at least ,he certainly was not imbecile.I wonder how person like you can discuss human's dignity when calling an artist like imbecile?

  • Excellent <3

  • Anna is soooo amazing and beautiful! That dress...wow! Love her!

  • It sounds like Anna and the concert master/mistress tuned up on different notes in this one. Why, I wonder? Too few rehearsals? Or does she warm up back stage and then can't adjust to the orchestra because she's nervous? Or is the concert master not reliable? Rolando is sometimes sharp, but when he's on, he's really ON.

  • KE MERAVIGLIA! PROPRIO NELLE OPERE MINORI E MENO CONOSCIUTE SI TROVANO LE ARIE E I DUETTI PIU BELLI!

  • Dos voces maravillosas!!

  • HE IS SO RIDICULOUS, WHAT DOES HE THINK HE IS SINGING YAGO???

    ANNA IS GREAT.

  • This is lovely. The video and the singing and she is not overpowering Villazon at all. A sensual duet!

  • bravi

  • Por esta aria, Iolanta debería ser rescatada del olvido... Muy inspirado el tema... algo propio de Tchaikovsky...

  • Such nasty comments in spanish about these two wonderful artists are shameful, so I write this opinion in English. Both of them are wonderful. REF the APPLAUSE FROM THE PUBLIC, who at the end are the real judges. Did they ENJOY the performance or was it a GIGANTIC CLAQUE who unanimously requested a Bis by sytematic clapping? Pls, erase the comments below.Tks,JRT

  • супер!!!!!!

  • pero q forma de arruinar a Tchaikovsky con comentarios de tan baja clase U_u. . . .

    otherwise thanks for the upload, the music and the voices are beatiful :)

  • Thank you for this video.

  • @Liu666able ahora no es momento para hablar de tus padres

  • @famosadicto Yo al menos conoci los mios tu no sabes de quien eres hijo

    Tu reputa madre se tiro tantos tios que perdio la cuenta de quien es hijo de quien

    Villazon t esa puta son una mierda y quien los admira(como tu)es aun mas mieda.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • this is beauty, passion, musicality and quality all spun into one thanks to Ms. Netrebko and Mr. Villazon! love it

  • Video genial.

  • he has no idea of what he is saying. It sounds as Othello,

  • @Federicopera Usted hace dos afirmaciones: una que el tenor canta sin saber lo que dice y otra que a Usted le "suena a Othello". Permitame preguntarle respecto de la primera afirmación: Usted la infiere o esta seguro de ella..? .Gracias.

  • @JorPove Estoy seguro de que puede saber lo que dice pero no lo entiende.

  • i've seen today ms. Anna singing this aria. she is goddes of opera

  • Placido Domingo también se hizo en México. Recodemos que sus padres Plácido y Pepita Embil vinieron a éste país y fundaron su propia compañia apoyados por nuestro gobierno. Por tal motivo Plácido Domingo se siente tan mexicano como nosottros y agradecido por la hospitalidad que tantos años recibió.

  • @maliz82 Y esa es la desgracia de mexico:que un mafioso como domingo imponga a esta mierda de tenor en todo el mundo.

  • Ayaz amir sb or anyone can translate these french lines into english.Shahzad shah

  • Bravo!!!!!

  • Bravi touts les deux! AV

  • I find beautiful this song and both singer

  • bravo!!!!!

    ya dejen de organizarle conciertos al flacido domingo y ya denle el lugar que merece a rolando aki n mexico!!

  • Comment removed

  • Anna!!! Ich weine wenn ich Sie höre!

    BRAVA!!!

  • bellisima..... la canciòn, en voz de estos

    grandes de la musica

  • Wow!

  • Perfektno !!!!!!

  • impresionante

  • Such a beautiful opera. Don't know why it doesn't get performed more often!

  • Tchaikovsky is more famous on the instrumental.

  • Which is a shame... Eugene Onegin is my favorite opera of all time and Mazeppa has my favorite female aria of all time.

  • ugh! On itunes I can only get this song if i buy the whole album, but i don't like the other songs on the album as much as this one. so that's somewhat annoying. I really just want this song.

  • Comment removed

  • What a force, this is music at the highiest level, I love Rolando and Anna good look for both.

  • Sorry to say but Rolando Villazon looks like Mr. Bean.

  • That's true.

  • And he sings like an angel.

  • lol. i was thinking that when i saw this. hahahaha

  • Anna is very beautiful...

  • Yes rowan atkinson. Why is this spammed?

  • I'm still trying to remember that name... hmmm

  • Mr. Bean!!!

  • that can be the only explanation as to why someone would give a thumbs down to someone that comments that Tchaikovsky is their favorite composer...what's wrong with that?

  • Le migliori voci nel panorama lirico attuale. Rolando sarebbe stato anche un ottimo baritono.

  • Iolanta is a wonderful and under-appreciated opera. Anna is spot on and Rolando is excellent as well, even his Russian is passable!

  • A beautiful duet from Tchaikovsky, particularly the first half ! He's my favourite composer ever !

  • OMG!!! Only Tchaikovsky could pull off a finale like this and only Anna & Rolando could do it justice. BRAVO!!!

  • 2 gyönyörű, és természetes hang, nagyon jó technikával és nagyon jól átélik azt, amiről énekelnek

  • Son la pareja operistica por excelencia, superan ampliamente a Pavaroti y Stherland, por su alegria, delicadeza, fisico y saber estar en el escenario

  • You will notice how many complimentary comments on Netrebko videos get multiple thumb downs.

    This is because there is a disturbed YT troll with multiple accounts infesting her videos.

  • yes I've noticed that...on many of her videos...disturbing indeed...I always think to myself well everyone has a right to an opinion, but some comments do not deserve thumbs down..especially not on every single comment....thanks for pointing that out LOL...well I really shouldnt laugh but whoever is doing this is quite pathetic and needs to get a life.

  • Rowan Atkinson?

  • You've guessed it.

  • i guessed it too.

  • I like this performance very much.

    They both have easy range and beautiful voices.

    Hers is a little bigger than his but they form a nice couple.

    I didn't hear any pitch problems as some of the previous reviewers claimed.

  • I personally like Netrebko. Just cuz she happens to be fit, it doesn't mean she can't sing well--which she can!

  • Hi Thugman30, if you don't like Ms. Netrebko's singing, why bother listening and even wasting your precious time to write many bad comments?

  • because she's promoted as the best. Where's the depth?

  • Interesting point.

  • LOL Andre Rieu. She's sharp again here.

  • You are not important!!

  • Yeah, but I would never be fooled with her depthless, shallow and popera voice.

  • Many people? Hahahahah...... only you!!

  • Thank you Thugman for your discretion!

    All Netrebko fans love you!!!

  • Oh shush, will you!

    All Russians better sing than Anna, but nobody should find it out !

    You're my big hero!!!

  • No one, no one in the world, sing russian opera like Netrebko does!

  • I wouldn't be so quick on that. There are many Russian sopranos who have more clarity and luster in singing than Netrebko. Even Barbara Hendricks could sing Rachmaninov songs.

  • goodness gracious! so much negativity!!

    i'm an opera singer! i think they did great!

    end of story!

    lol

  • jejejeje, yeahhhhhhhh!!! great Mr. xbcg9489x

  • i'm a girl! hahaha

  • I can't get enough of this duet!

  • i cant get enough of Rolando! amazing! inspiring!

  • This is so beautiful, brava!

  • Nertebko haters do not care about the quality of her performances. They trash everything of hers under condition of anonymity. The good thing is that everyone already knows their names (thrugman30, esradesso etc) and the longer they do that the more pathetic they look. Anna is going GREAT and her voice has doubled in the last couple of years. So, respond to their insulting comments, when you can, and haters would not feel in a safe heaven (like Taliban before 2001).

  • I don't like her in short hair.

  • es realmeten increible los dos canta exelentemente bien.

    nunca habia escuchado de ella hasta hoy.

  • TCHAIKOVSKY GOES POPERA.

  • eff you. don't be e general netrebko hater who doesn't even watch the video and puts something mean. EVERYONE (meaning people in the opera world who matter) says she interprets russian repertoire perfectly and always has.

  • and that was in 1995, look how different her singing then. Now all she cares about is the money.

  • Bravo !!!! What a treat!!

  • You would probably be better of listening to techno!?

  • Anna est splendide, comme toujours!

  • Unfortunaly Beczala  does not have any stage presence and as an actor he is zero.

  • Thank you for this video... I love this opera... lovely and emotive performance...

  • Superb!

  • A pity they won't sing it together at Baden-Baden!,it is so beautiful !

  • Yes, but Piotr Beczala will and he's also superb. Let's hope that Rolando can strengthen his voice so he can sing with the strength and sweetness he's capable of.

  • Да ... Музыка очень трогает !

  • Beautiful!

    I wish I knew what they were saying, though... does anyone have an English or Spanish translation?

  • Sublime musique,servie par une merveilleuse "Anna" ,toujours à l'aise dans le répertoire russe.(J'aurais préféré un autre partenaire!...)

  • такая прекрасная певица. жаль, что в лав стори она бегает в неглиже...

  • Super! Voshititelno!

  • merveilleux, sublime, les deux sont magnifiques et forment un couple unique. je les adore.

    Jackilen57

  • Это просто СУПЕРРРРРРРР!!!!!!!!

  • I love them both ! They are a fantastique couple. Rolando's russian sounds sooo good ! (And his german is fantastic, too ! I know what I'm talking about I am German ^^)

  • Yes, his russian is surprisingly good considering that he doesn't speak it, but he does work very hard on pronunciation.

  • You're right. Anna seemed to be a good teacher ;)

  • IOLANTA:

    ¡Para glorificar a Dios, eternamente,

    caballero, no necesito la luz!

    La bondad de Dios es infinita,

    no tiene límites.

    ¡La presencia de Dios,

    sublime y bondadosa, se manifiesta

    en todas sus criaturas, en el calor del

    día, en las fragancias y sonidos de la

    naturaleza... en mí misma!

  • Signor Iacaf1, credo che lei mi abbia confuso con Alvarito45 che disprezza Caruso come, a suo tempo, egli fu disprezzato dai suoi concittadini che lo chiamavano "canna al vento". Per quanto riguarda Villazon ho espresso le mie riserve e di Caruso, a giudicare dalle incisioni, ho l'idea che sia stato forse il più straordinario cantante mai esistito. Sincrotto

  • wonderful

  • Esta parte de la ópera tan dramática, cuando Iolanta oye por primera vez la palabra LUZ, queda magníficamente interpretada por Anna y Rolando....BRAVISSIMO!!!!!

  • It's WONDERFUL!Perfect!Fantastic!AM­AZING!

    BRAVOOOOOOOO!

    Rolando and Anna is perfect DUET!!!

  • This was YEAR AGO. Everybody knows that he was ill and NOW he is fully recovered. Why you are spending your observer's gifts on what is NOT RELEVANT today..Listen "Luisa Miller" in the concert from Köln..

  • Il Villazon del naso fa trombetta e certo acquista risonanze ma innaturali e forzate. A quale donna piacerebbe sentirsi sussurrare un "ti amo" detto "gni gnamo"? Ascoltate Anna: qualunque uomo farebbe pazzie per sentirla sospirare "ti amo" sul suo viso.

  • certo, sieti corretti!!!

  • Comentario muy a la Berlusconi!!! Los tipos de voz pueden variar. Cuando oigo las grabaciones de tu supuesto Dios Caruso, me parece oir un organillo...será por lo antiguas...o porque cantaba así...