Let me tell you that this man is not telling everyone the whole truth,why ?Becouse he does not know enough hadith.All scholars agree unanimously that there are 7 authentic compilations of hadith.Bukhari,Muslim,muwatta,abu dawud,ibn maja,nisa'i and attirmidhi.This young man only takes hadith from Bukhari and muslim and some select hadith from the others and not all of them.He is giving everyone limited knowledge and twisting it with extremists interpretation.Is that what you want ?
Then on another night I went again in his company and the people were praying behind their reciter. On that, 'Umar remarked, 'what an excellent Bid'a (i.e. innovation in religion) this is; but the prayer which they do not perform, but sleep at its time is better than the one they are offering.' He meant the prayer in the last part of the night(Tahajjut).
In the volume entitled cIlm as-Suluk, ("The Science of Travelling the Way to God"), which consists of the entire 775 pages of volume 10 of Majmaca al-Fatawa, he says (p. 516): "The great Sufi shaikhs are well known and accepted, such as: Bayazid al-Bistami, Shaikh Abdul Qadir Jilani, Junaid ibn Muhammad, Hasan al-Basri, al Fudayl ibn al-Ayyad, Ibrahim bin al-Adham, Abi Sulayman ad-Daarani, Ma'ruf al-Karkhi, Siri as-Saqati, Shaikh Hammad, Shaikh Abul Bayan.
i will continue to celebrate the Birthday of RasoolAllah salalaho alyhi wasalma till the day ov judgement inshaAllah! Nothing wrong with expressing LOVE for the Bleoved of Allah salalaho alyhi waslam... it doesnt say anywhere that you cant celebrate mawlid un nabi salalaho alyhi wasalam so i will continue 2 do so inshaAllah! <3
@4urinfo786 anywhere it says dont pray with an finger in you eye, anywhere it says dont dance 1 hour after each prayer! Does that mean i can do it? certenly no! Every Ibadah must have a proof, without a proof its bid'a. There are some ppl celebrating the Birthday of the Prophet and mixed that with shirk! If you do a bid'a either its haram or not haram you open a door for the shaytan and this is dangerous. Look at the sekts in Islam, most of them started with something small.....
@kaydolien jummah is the celebration if adma laihe salaams birthday,it states in hadeeth that jumma was created as a celebration as it is the birhtday of adam.
prophet(pbuh) also left this world on 12 rabiulawal.why not get sad??instead of doing ibadah,us people are always after entertaiment.. putting flags up reading shirkia naats..
because look at this ummah, people are corrupted, salah is better than sleep makes us realise that excessive sleep is the act of shaytaan and there are hadith which support this
In the time of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وآله, the `athan for salaatus subh didn't include the phrase "الصلاة خيراً من النوم ". Why isn't that bid`ah rejected?
fie upon u..... did not our Holy Prophet salal alyhy wasalm keep fast on monday because of his birthday. Do not u feel happy when your son born. why do you built masjid so beautiful while the sahaba did not do because you love masjid more then them... unbelievable how u miss guard the people..u should be in ......
you say that birthday celebration of Prophet is not good? tell me, always i see people putting the Holy Quran on the ground next to their feet. that is real bid'ah and disrespect. you should stop that first
ISAIAS 53 5 Mas él herido fue por nuestras rebeliones, molido por nuestros pecados; el castigo de nuestra paz fue sobre él, y por su llaga fuimos nosotros curados.(D) 6 Todos nosotros nos descarriamos como ovejas,(E) cada cual se apartó por su camino; mas Jehová cargó en él el pecado de todos nosotros. 7 Angustiado él, y afligido, no abrió su boca; como cordero fue llevado al matadero;(F) y como oveja delante de sus trasquiladores, enmudeció, y no abrió su boca.
my opinion is, that we shouldn't Celebrate The Prophets Birthday, because i have Rasool maxamed scw always in my heart i follow..i remember him every time i do salaah. he is our last Rasuul.we should remember him all the time...birthday Celebrate is shirk...
@mrzakariye10 you say birthday is shirk. that means we celebrate the birthday of Allah? shirk means doing something for anyone else that you do for Allah. Na oedzoe billaahi min dzaalik
@mrzakariye10 you say birthday is haraam because it is practised by kafirs. the ineternet, the computer is not made by muslims. why are you using it? if it goes about Prophet then you say shirk bid'at. you dont look at the other things
@1DON90 what has celebrating birthdays has to do with using the internet. you only born one time. Allah gives you life..you have to say Alhamdullilah..and while you still are in life follow the teaching of the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and obey Allah (swa). Islam is simple. Islam is simple and if you follow it correctly inshAllah Allah will make everything easy for you.
because it is bidah in the duniya not in the deen, Islam is complete isnt it so y make innovations in the deen, leave it, in the duniya make inventions but the deen leave it.
@1DON90 You did not understand the Bid'a in Islam. Every Ibadah ( Worship ) that doesnt have a proof from Quran or Sunnah is a Bid'a and therfor not allowed. But everythink besides Ibadah is Allowed aslong there is a Proof that it is forbidden. Internet, Computer and so on is not Ibadah and therfore its allowed, and Allah knows best.
@kaydolien ok tell me the hadeeth which states that with bid'ah is claimed bid'ah in deen. where is written? is it written, kullu bid'atin fie iebaadatien dalaalah? or just kullu bid'atin dalaalah?
@1DON90 There is a Hadeeth in Muslim where he a.s.s talks about the bida and he say who every makes a bidah in Islam... Fakt is, it is not Haram to use Pc, Cell Phone etc but Allah knows best. But instead of fighting each other, we all made our point, the best thing to do is to pray to Allah for forgiveness and leave it to him inshallah.
@kaydolien why do u use a.s.s? did the Prophet alaihis salaatu wassalaam allow that? to short the terms? imam ibn hajar asqalani did say that mawlid is a good thing. did he say good or wrong? tell me please. didnt he know the deen?
@kaydolien if its not allowed, then why are millions of muslims following it, thousands of ulamaa following it. and just a little group of salafi, wahabi's rejecting it? why? becvause they dont udnerstadn the Islam. thats why the shaytan salafi's say Allah has a body because they dont have the Eemaan and proper understanding of Islaam. think about it. In the biggest islamic school they allow mawlidun Nabi. Jamia al Azhar in Egypt.
@1DON90 Well if everybody celebrating somethink its does not mean its legal. But even doe its Haram or not we leave it to Allah and may Allah forgive us all. But brother dont let us start calling our self Shaytan etc. We are all Muslims, we all have the same goal, so no need to fight each other. Even doe all we muslims never will have the same Opinion in every topic we should love each other because we all love Allah and his messenger. :)
IT's obvious that we should celebrate the birthdays of the Lord Roscoe. But alas these dates are lost to us. All we know is that the Prophets Mishugina and Geraldo got the Lord Roscoe from Two Guys from Harrison.
MashaAllah. Beautiful explanation. Very logical, very educational and most importantly, absolutely truthful. It is so sad that so many brothers leave ignorant comments here after the truth has been clearly explained in this video. All they can do is to label with words like "salafi", "wahabi" etc. This habit is very close to the habit of the mushrikeen when they did the same with the prophet(s) by calling him possessed, majnun...etc... May Allah guide all of us to the straight path. Ameen.
Dear salafi? you says that there is two eid in islam. but holy prophet declared the day of juma (Friday) day arafa also eid for muslim. bani israil ask ther prophet ask your lord if coming any food (maida) from haven we celebrate that day as a EID happiness. (holy quran, sura maeeda) Same on you! which day you get your lovely holy prophet, you couldn't make happy yourself! but you fill allergy in your heart. this is the symbol of munafiq.
you are a great lier. Allah discus in holy Quran about arrival of holy prophet. prophet made fasting Monday for the celibate of his birth. sahabi hassan ebn sabeet (R) Narrated some of poem about it, sahabi hazrath Aameer (R) ibne Abbas (R) arrange program about milad and its granted to safayath by prophet for them. tirmizi and ibn e mazzah collect all of hadith and make a baab. jalal uddin souti, ibn kacir, abdul qadir (R), and all of great soler celebrate it. you are blind and enemy.
@983821 so why don't u fast on Monday's and Thursdays instead of singing happy birthday ? If u truly love the prophet(s) then follow his way and do not try to show off that you are better than him(s) by organizing birthday parties,that he and the sahaba never did, but the christians do... Can't you see that you are simply following the Christians and not the prophet(s)? Come on bro, instead of insulting this brother, stop eating too much stinky fried fish and start using your brains....
@vatandust You miss the point of the mawlid were does it say we are better than him. Does that mean Abu bakr was better than him by gathering the quran in book form, or umar making taraweeh prayer a jamaat or al bukhari by writing his sahi and reading 2 rakkat nafl before writing each hadith in it? Cause this is clear bidda. The sahaba never did is not reason enough not to do something. You have core principles and anything which does not go against them is allowed.
@hanafimuslim Salams brother. gathering quran in book and praying qiaymul layl in jamaa are not a bid'ah because these were done during the first three pious generations which are mentioned by the prophet(s) as the best generations. so goes for imam bukhari(r) who was also from the pious generations. we are talking about, birthday parties, which is clearly inherited from pagan/christian traditions. Come on, my dear brother, be smart, and be from those who as Allah says, "ulul albaab. Salam.
@vatandust wa alaykum salaam. the prophet(peace be upon him and his family) did not commmand them to do it. it does not matter if they are from the pious generations bidda is bidda dude. "anything he(peace be upon him and his family) didnt do or isnt done as hes done it is classed as bidda" ibn hajjar asqalani. Imam al bukhari is not of the salaf he came after them. If the pagans do something and we do it with a good intention that does not make it wrong pagans grew beards so do we etc
@hanafimuslim The pagans had a lot of things we do but it doesnt mean we are wrong for doing them. In fact celebrating a birthday is monotheism since Alla was neither born or shall die. As for following the disbeleivers the jews use to fast on 10th muharram for musa(peace be upon him) saved them on that day the muslims adopted the practise. we have more right to show joy at the birth of our master than any pagan has. the salaf arent exempt even if they innovate no hadith states that they are.
@hanafimuslim wow brother, u went too far.. u r even admitting that it is okay to follow the good things of others, even pagans, yet you (wallahu a-lam) recite at least 32 times a day "ihdinas-siratal-mustaqeem. brother, shaytan makes fool of us by believing that we are doing good for the sake of Allah... Remember what Allah says in suratul-imran. "Say, if u truly love Allah then follow me(i.e. the messenger(s)). Broher I pray that Allah guide u and me into that which pleases him.Ameen.
This Guy is a SALAFI Scholar and they all denied the celebrations, minority sect of ISLAM, LOOK yourself on Youtube how many people in the Ummah of the Prophet SAW is celebrating his coming every year, just search the celebrations and you will see ALL OVER THE WORLD. its happening.
brother i will like ot say on thing a hadith says the phrophet peace be upon him sacrafice a animal and distrubuted the food between the compainions . one of teh companions siad "why have you given us food" the phrophet said "to celbrate my brithday and so it can be a sunnah upon my ummah"
I think all of us are Bida......we are inventions...........we were not present during the time of Prophet (Sallallaho alaihe wasallam)..we are new things.........all that according to the philosophy and logic of the Bida (person in you tube) forbidding the celebrating Mawlid un Nabi (Sallaho alaihe wasallam)
when this bida was introduced to the ummah it was praised by all of the four medhebs including the malikiyys. maybe this brother on youtube was smoking crack or sumthing?????? street crack rock dawa i guess
MashaAllah a very clear explanation, if you love prophet Muhammad stay close to his teachings and avoid what he didn't do, don't bring something new to the religion just because you think "it is good". But still many muslims don't want to accept it, as you see the video has already a dislike.
with Rasul s.a.w in their presence, that's the 'Mawlid moment' for the Sahabas. Allah Himself praised Him s.a.w in the Qur'an with no specification of time. YAl
The left speaker works. His basic reply was; the sahaba did not celeberate the Prophets(saw) birthday; so we shouldn't do it. Its a good lecture. If it was important, the sahaba would have certainly celeberated it.
This has been flagged as spam show
Let me tell you that this man is not telling everyone the whole truth,why ?Becouse he does not know enough hadith.All scholars agree unanimously that there are 7 authentic compilations of hadith.Bukhari,Muslim,muwatta,abu dawud,ibn maja,nisa'i and attirmidhi.This young man only takes hadith from Bukhari and muslim and some select hadith from the others and not all of them.He is giving everyone limited knowledge and twisting it with extremists interpretation.Is that what you want ?
shellshock939 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Then on another night I went again in his company and the people were praying behind their reciter. On that, 'Umar remarked, 'what an excellent Bid'a (i.e. innovation in religion) this is; but the prayer which they do not perform, but sleep at its time is better than the one they are offering.' He meant the prayer in the last part of the night(Tahajjut).
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 3, Book 32, Number 22
shellshock939 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ibn Taymmiyya on sufis
In the volume entitled cIlm as-Suluk, ("The Science of Travelling the Way to God"), which consists of the entire 775 pages of volume 10 of Majmaca al-Fatawa, he says (p. 516): "The great Sufi shaikhs are well known and accepted, such as: Bayazid al-Bistami, Shaikh Abdul Qadir Jilani, Junaid ibn Muhammad, Hasan al-Basri, al Fudayl ibn al-Ayyad, Ibrahim bin al-Adham, Abi Sulayman ad-Daarani, Ma'ruf al-Karkhi, Siri as-Saqati, Shaikh Hammad, Shaikh Abul Bayan.
shellshock939 1 week ago
i will continue to celebrate the Birthday of RasoolAllah salalaho alyhi wasalma till the day ov judgement inshaAllah! Nothing wrong with expressing LOVE for the Bleoved of Allah salalaho alyhi waslam... it doesnt say anywhere that you cant celebrate mawlid un nabi salalaho alyhi wasalam so i will continue 2 do so inshaAllah! <3
4urinfo786 4 weeks ago 2
@4urinfo786 anywhere it says dont pray with an finger in you eye, anywhere it says dont dance 1 hour after each prayer! Does that mean i can do it? certenly no! Every Ibadah must have a proof, without a proof its bid'a. There are some ppl celebrating the Birthday of the Prophet and mixed that with shirk! If you do a bid'a either its haram or not haram you open a door for the shaytan and this is dangerous. Look at the sekts in Islam, most of them started with something small.....
kaydolien 2 weeks ago
@kaydolien jummah is the celebration if adma laihe salaams birthday,it states in hadeeth that jumma was created as a celebration as it is the birhtday of adam.
MrNaz1968 1 week ago
prophet(pbuh) also left this world on 12 rabiulawal.why not get sad??instead of doing ibadah,us people are always after entertaiment.. putting flags up reading shirkia naats..
rizwan64104 1 month ago
this guy is talking about something which is related to our relegion and prophet... stop talking about internet and videos you muppets...
rizwan64104 1 month ago
because look at this ummah, people are corrupted, salah is better than sleep makes us realise that excessive sleep is the act of shaytaan and there are hadith which support this
x3DNukez 5 months ago
In the time of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وآله, the `athan for salaatus subh didn't include the phrase "الصلاة خيراً من النوم ". Why isn't that bid`ah rejected?
theWanderingScribe 6 months ago
fie upon u..... did not our Holy Prophet salal alyhy wasalm keep fast on monday because of his birthday. Do not u feel happy when your son born. why do you built masjid so beautiful while the sahaba did not do because you love masjid more then them... unbelievable how u miss guard the people..u should be in ......
fakhan26 8 months ago
when did the sahaabah make a video in their house putting their back at the books and make a video and put on youtube? they did not but you are doing
1DON90 8 months ago
@1DON90 yes you r right. these people should be with mental people..
fakhan26 8 months ago
you say that birthday celebration of Prophet is not good? tell me, always i see people putting the Holy Quran on the ground next to their feet. that is real bid'ah and disrespect. you should stop that first
1DON90 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ISAIAS 53 5 Mas él herido fue por nuestras rebeliones, molido por nuestros pecados; el castigo de nuestra paz fue sobre él, y por su llaga fuimos nosotros curados.(D) 6 Todos nosotros nos descarriamos como ovejas,(E) cada cual se apartó por su camino; mas Jehová cargó en él el pecado de todos nosotros. 7 Angustiado él, y afligido, no abrió su boca; como cordero fue llevado al matadero;(F) y como oveja delante de sus trasquiladores, enmudeció, y no abrió su boca.
RC7828 11 months ago
are you a mufti or a scholar? *person in video*
sohail786 11 months ago
my opinion is, that we shouldn't Celebrate The Prophets Birthday, because i have Rasool maxamed scw always in my heart i follow..i remember him every time i do salaah. he is our last Rasuul.we should remember him all the time...birthday Celebrate is shirk...
mrzakariye10 1 year ago
@mrzakariye10 do u know what shirk means? you are out of your mind. you say birthday is shirk, where did you get that?
1DON90 8 months ago
@1DON90 i appreciated u
fakhan26 8 months ago
@mrzakariye10 you say birthday is shirk. that means we celebrate the birthday of Allah? shirk means doing something for anyone else that you do for Allah. Na oedzoe billaahi min dzaalik
1DON90 8 months ago
@1DON90 birthday is XARAAM...
mrzakariye10 8 months ago
@mrzakariye10 you say birthday is haraam because it is practised by kafirs. the ineternet, the computer is not made by muslims. why are you using it? if it goes about Prophet then you say shirk bid'at. you dont look at the other things
1DON90 8 months ago
@1DON90 what has celebrating birthdays has to do with using the internet. you only born one time. Allah gives you life..you have to say Alhamdullilah..and while you still are in life follow the teaching of the prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and obey Allah (swa). Islam is simple. Islam is simple and if you follow it correctly inshAllah Allah will make everything easy for you.
mrzakariye10 8 months ago
very true
x3DNukez 5 months ago
because it is bidah in the duniya not in the deen, Islam is complete isnt it so y make innovations in the deen, leave it, in the duniya make inventions but the deen leave it.
x3DNukez 5 months ago
@1DON90 You did not understand the Bid'a in Islam. Every Ibadah ( Worship ) that doesnt have a proof from Quran or Sunnah is a Bid'a and therfor not allowed. But everythink besides Ibadah is Allowed aslong there is a Proof that it is forbidden. Internet, Computer and so on is not Ibadah and therfore its allowed, and Allah knows best.
kaydolien 2 weeks ago
@kaydolien ok tell me the hadeeth which states that with bid'ah is claimed bid'ah in deen. where is written? is it written, kullu bid'atin fie iebaadatien dalaalah? or just kullu bid'atin dalaalah?
1DON90 2 weeks ago
@1DON90 There is a Hadeeth in Muslim where he a.s.s talks about the bida and he say who every makes a bidah in Islam... Fakt is, it is not Haram to use Pc, Cell Phone etc but Allah knows best. But instead of fighting each other, we all made our point, the best thing to do is to pray to Allah for forgiveness and leave it to him inshallah.
kaydolien 2 weeks ago
@kaydolien why do u use a.s.s? did the Prophet alaihis salaatu wassalaam allow that? to short the terms? imam ibn hajar asqalani did say that mawlid is a good thing. did he say good or wrong? tell me please. didnt he know the deen?
1DON90 2 weeks ago
@kaydolien if its not allowed, then why are millions of muslims following it, thousands of ulamaa following it. and just a little group of salafi, wahabi's rejecting it? why? becvause they dont udnerstadn the Islam. thats why the shaytan salafi's say Allah has a body because they dont have the Eemaan and proper understanding of Islaam. think about it. In the biggest islamic school they allow mawlidun Nabi. Jamia al Azhar in Egypt.
1DON90 2 weeks ago
@1DON90 Well if everybody celebrating somethink its does not mean its legal. But even doe its Haram or not we leave it to Allah and may Allah forgive us all. But brother dont let us start calling our self Shaytan etc. We are all Muslims, we all have the same goal, so no need to fight each other. Even doe all we muslims never will have the same Opinion in every topic we should love each other because we all love Allah and his messenger. :)
kaydolien 2 weeks ago
This Guy is TRULY EVIL. May Allah give him guidance. Ameen
bill66y 1 year ago
@bill66y ostakfirlla
holiday1ful 11 months ago
when prophet SAW himself did not celebrate his or others birthday den y we should?????
ZainabTalha95 1 year ago
Comment removed
bafoofkit 1 year ago
IT's obvious that we should celebrate the birthdays of the Lord Roscoe. But alas these dates are lost to us. All we know is that the Prophets Mishugina and Geraldo got the Lord Roscoe from Two Guys from Harrison.
bafoofkit 1 year ago
MashaAllah. Beautiful explanation. Very logical, very educational and most importantly, absolutely truthful. It is so sad that so many brothers leave ignorant comments here after the truth has been clearly explained in this video. All they can do is to label with words like "salafi", "wahabi" etc. This habit is very close to the habit of the mushrikeen when they did the same with the prophet(s) by calling him possessed, majnun...etc... May Allah guide all of us to the straight path. Ameen.
vatandust 1 year ago
Dear salafi? you says that there is two eid in islam. but holy prophet declared the day of juma (Friday) day arafa also eid for muslim. bani israil ask ther prophet ask your lord if coming any food (maida) from haven we celebrate that day as a EID happiness. (holy quran, sura maeeda) Same on you! which day you get your lovely holy prophet, you couldn't make happy yourself! but you fill allergy in your heart. this is the symbol of munafiq.
983821 1 year ago
you are a great lier. Allah discus in holy Quran about arrival of holy prophet. prophet made fasting Monday for the celibate of his birth. sahabi hassan ebn sabeet (R) Narrated some of poem about it, sahabi hazrath Aameer (R) ibne Abbas (R) arrange program about milad and its granted to safayath by prophet for them. tirmizi and ibn e mazzah collect all of hadith and make a baab. jalal uddin souti, ibn kacir, abdul qadir (R), and all of great soler celebrate it. you are blind and enemy.
983821 1 year ago
@983821 so why don't u fast on Monday's and Thursdays instead of singing happy birthday ? If u truly love the prophet(s) then follow his way and do not try to show off that you are better than him(s) by organizing birthday parties,that he and the sahaba never did, but the christians do... Can't you see that you are simply following the Christians and not the prophet(s)? Come on bro, instead of insulting this brother, stop eating too much stinky fried fish and start using your brains....
vatandust 1 year ago
@vatandust You miss the point of the mawlid were does it say we are better than him. Does that mean Abu bakr was better than him by gathering the quran in book form, or umar making taraweeh prayer a jamaat or al bukhari by writing his sahi and reading 2 rakkat nafl before writing each hadith in it? Cause this is clear bidda. The sahaba never did is not reason enough not to do something. You have core principles and anything which does not go against them is allowed.
hanafimuslim 1 year ago
@hanafimuslim Salams brother. gathering quran in book and praying qiaymul layl in jamaa are not a bid'ah because these were done during the first three pious generations which are mentioned by the prophet(s) as the best generations. so goes for imam bukhari(r) who was also from the pious generations. we are talking about, birthday parties, which is clearly inherited from pagan/christian traditions. Come on, my dear brother, be smart, and be from those who as Allah says, "ulul albaab. Salam.
vatandust 1 year ago
@vatandust wa alaykum salaam. the prophet(peace be upon him and his family) did not commmand them to do it. it does not matter if they are from the pious generations bidda is bidda dude. "anything he(peace be upon him and his family) didnt do or isnt done as hes done it is classed as bidda" ibn hajjar asqalani. Imam al bukhari is not of the salaf he came after them. If the pagans do something and we do it with a good intention that does not make it wrong pagans grew beards so do we etc
hanafimuslim 1 year ago
@hanafimuslim The pagans had a lot of things we do but it doesnt mean we are wrong for doing them. In fact celebrating a birthday is monotheism since Alla was neither born or shall die. As for following the disbeleivers the jews use to fast on 10th muharram for musa(peace be upon him) saved them on that day the muslims adopted the practise. we have more right to show joy at the birth of our master than any pagan has. the salaf arent exempt even if they innovate no hadith states that they are.
hanafimuslim 1 year ago
@hanafimuslim wow brother, u went too far.. u r even admitting that it is okay to follow the good things of others, even pagans, yet you (wallahu a-lam) recite at least 32 times a day "ihdinas-siratal-mustaqeem. brother, shaytan makes fool of us by believing that we are doing good for the sake of Allah... Remember what Allah says in suratul-imran. "Say, if u truly love Allah then follow me(i.e. the messenger(s)). Broher I pray that Allah guide u and me into that which pleases him.Ameen.
vatandust 1 year ago
@vatandust ameen
hanafimuslim 1 year ago
This Guy is a SALAFI Scholar and they all denied the celebrations, minority sect of ISLAM, LOOK yourself on Youtube how many people in the Ummah of the Prophet SAW is celebrating his coming every year, just search the celebrations and you will see ALL OVER THE WORLD. its happening.
Madinahwalay 1 year ago
brother i will like ot say on thing a hadith says the phrophet peace be upon him sacrafice a animal and distrubuted the food between the compainions . one of teh companions siad "why have you given us food" the phrophet said "to celbrate my brithday and so it can be a sunnah upon my ummah"
1ummahpeace 1 year ago
ignorance :)
fuhrerayman 1 year ago
I think all of us are Bida......we are inventions...........we were not present during the time of Prophet (Sallallaho alaihe wasallam)..we are new things.........all that according to the philosophy and logic of the Bida (person in you tube) forbidding the celebrating Mawlid un Nabi (Sallaho alaihe wasallam)
imzadou 1 year ago
when this bida was introduced to the ummah it was praised by all of the four medhebs including the malikiyys. maybe this brother on youtube was smoking crack or sumthing?????? street crack rock dawa i guess
albulghariyy 1 year ago
Go Read the book of Mawlid Allowing for Imam Suyuti
Husnul Maqsed Fi Amal al Mawled
fuhrerayman 1 year ago
@fuhrerayman you must be a man of bida, you are a big bida man
imrane1425 1 year ago
@imrane1425 you don't know Imam Suyuti ha ?
fuhrerayman 1 year ago
JAZAKALLAH KHAIRAN
abudujana13 1 year ago
MashaAllah a very clear explanation, if you love prophet Muhammad stay close to his teachings and avoid what he didn't do, don't bring something new to the religion just because you think "it is good". But still many muslims don't want to accept it, as you see the video has already a dislike.
aldawah 1 year ago
with Rasul s.a.w in their presence, that's the 'Mawlid moment' for the Sahabas. Allah Himself praised Him s.a.w in the Qur'an with no specification of time. YAl
YZTWR 1 year ago
theres no audio from his talk!
blitzker 2 years ago
Today is the bday...r u celebrating? I know I'm not! I love god most!
haarpphh 2 years ago
I can't listen to whatever he's saying!!
TheMuslimahSouljette 2 years ago
The left speaker works. His basic reply was; the sahaba did not celeberate the Prophets(saw) birthday; so we shouldn't do it. Its a good lecture. If it was important, the sahaba would have certainly celeberated it.
Sncc1 2 years ago
@Sncc1: Jazakamullah khair. Yeah, subhan Allah the left one is only working.
Salamu 'Alaikum.
TheMuslimahSouljette 2 years ago