NIN: Discipline live at rehearsals, July 2008 [HD]

[lazyjain]

sexy

[csjman1]

That's no the final version ..

[nerimanna]

i like severus snape coz he looks like trent

[PoisonousPot]

whats that thing at the start on the left, the mixer type thing with all the leads plugged in?

[VesterDude]

@PoisonousPot It's a modular synth.

[FrankySpindle23]

trent reznor is god, i mean he composed all this. but live with his crew it sounds more real!,FUCK YEAH!!

[CarolusFilms]

I'm amazed, this is such a perfect live recording. Blows my mind.

[link6161]

the sound of the guitar is so fine

[satan163]

I masturbated to this once. true story

[musiko97]

the perfect song to go back to bad habits, after been a long time without tasting or feeling. only to hear his voice ... it's hard not to have that feeling

[blackgoetia]

hell yea to both the top comment i was just about to say that fuzz is just outta control!!!!! I'm freakin out about that riff and I need more of it

[bergamasque2112]

Fuck!! I like both, this and studio versions

[cbnx30]

Fuck if I like it!

[05hipkinja]

12 dislikes!!!!! I will personally hunt you down! :)

[VesterDude]

That Les Paul is GORGEOUS!

[bravo075]

Yeah that looks just like my rehearsal room, except less roomy, less equipment, regular musicians... the rest is pretty much the same.

[NayveeMan]

i love the groove in this track

[exersois]

Kick Ass!

[wiliuzl]

who da **** and why clicked dislike?

[PrisyazhnyukMike]

Sick performance! Really cool)

[blastedburrito110]

I'll play this at the massive party oll play in with my band this friday... it just strikes me as the perfect thing to play.

[pettka5105]

0:52 - first chorus! (just my tool to get there fast)

[IceBarragex]

rif is addicting.

[regnofficial]

FECAL MATTERS is the name of my first album, listen to some songs at my channel, hope you like it! I need You guys, thanks.

[abby1819931]

sickk songXD

[TeddyStarcraft]

I liked it before everybody else did

[ferovader419]

@TeddyStarcraft haha hipster xD =3

[TeddyStarcraft]

@ferovader419 n_n

[JWhitehurstAcoustic]

I'm in love with this. 

[kmwerewolf]

I just love how some little pricks have to make rude comments about other people's comments. It's nice to know there are so many 5 year olds on YouTube these days.

[Marc7665]

Why cant there be more music like this in the world today?

[ryonafan]

@Marc7665 there is you just have to find it/get lucky :)

[InnuendoXP]

@Marc7665

because Trent Reznor can only produce so much :P

Be glad it's not ALL like this... or THIS would be commercialized crap... and what a shit world that'd be

[ShaiHulud1982]

check out my wifes vocal cover of this song. it's on my channel. :)

[DreamAtTempo119]

@kmwerewolf Hahaha. This made me laugh so hard, sorry. :D

[SlowRiotNewKanada]

@kmwerewolf You're some kind of faggot, that's for sure.

[kmwerewolf]

@SlowRiotNewKanada  takes one to know one pal.

[thehornypuppy]

@kmwerewolf ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffre­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaak...

[kmwerewolf]

@thehornypuppy  jackass.

[thehornypuppy]

@kmwerewolf that doesn't make you any less of a FReeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeak xD

[blacklightburns100]

NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNNN­NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN !!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

[AJ27rider]

does anyone else get turned on to the guitar rhythm?

[bunnyb0n]

@AJ27rider totally!!!!! but then again, get turned on by many.. erm songs.. uhm NIN effect.. (:

[MrDavittow]

Give me that place with all that gear and we are ready to launch into space

[Epic13]

LL Cool J - Doin' It.... step aside...

There is a new 'fuck' song...

NIN 4ever!

[summinrandom]

i prefer this to the studio version

[link6161]

@summinrandom with nin i always prefer the live version

[junkie0423]

i have in-bud skull candies at full blast and they're still not loud enough. and i'm not deaf either

[Kuba4MG]

9 people's deaf.

[TheDeafSinger2]

@Kuba4MG I'm actually Deaf and love this song...

:)

[bluelynch]

Awesome

[crashtv]

you fucked the audio dude... Too loud. Ruined.

[thechoochooshoe]

@crashtv loved your version of 1,000,000 if its the same crashtv

[MaartenIB]

@crashtv. Too loud? What are you, 80?

[2good4name]

@crashtv Lmfao wut

[DJPr1ncess]

‎9 people disliked this video because they're jealous trent reznor is my husband.

[MrFieldy]

This live performance kicks so much ass!

[lakelful]

mmmmm....pie!

[musiquefrique]

Cant wait for HTDA or NIN to go our tour! Trent and the crew were AMAZING in PEMBERTON CANADA- can't wait to do it all over again!

[AFTataryn]

Robin Finck is 1 cool motherfucker.

[TinTinDrip]

the best nine inch nails's line up..i think..

josh is supreme,same thing for robin and alessandro..

[Heathenheart1979]

Who's the key player? Twiggy?

[fourtwentty420]

@Heathenheart1979 I don't think it's Twiggy. Pretty sure it's Alessandro Cortini.

Check "The Slip (Album)" on wikipedia, and at the bottom where it says "Live Personel" you'll see his name.

[eddy66t6]

@fourtwentty420 @Heathenheart1979 yeah its Alessandro here, Trent obviously, Josh Freese Drumming, Robin Fincks rockin the 6 string and then it's Justin Meldel Johnson on bass and doing some synth parts...

[GoTHICTHUG88]

@Heathenheart1979 nope. Alessandro Cortini

[IanSeine]

You cant beat that great straight head simplistic lead that creates an atmosphere of mis-controlled cahos! The beats are frigging amazing with Bass and Drums just kicking layer after layer / orchestration to the Max. Then that "clean" vocal strap ... Damn.

Can you spell P r O d U C t I o N!

Awesome

[blacklightburns100]

Love it , love NIN

[blacklightburns100]

Trent Reznor <3

[chellycheekzz]

fucking amazing. that is all.

[MechantNoupi]

Listening to a song like this one reminds us that music is an art. And this song is a fucking masterpiece :)

[mtmjr77]

KIller!



[drewkroeker]

Is this version available for download anywhere?

[LPxxxGoW]

@drewkroeker Its everywhere! Ha... Trent sold this album for free on his website, nin.com

[drewkroeker]

@LPxxxGoW thanks but what I meant was: is the rehearsal version of "Discipline" available for download? I just checked nin.com and found the download link for the slip but nothing for their rehearsal performances.

I received The Slip for Christmas two years ago. Best Christmas present ever!

[LPxxxGoW]

@drewkroeker Haha-- but seriously, does it sound any different? Thats the magic of this whole recorded rehearsal, they mastered the song so well I can't even tell the difference between that an the original studio version. O.o

[KeithNet]

I thought the drummer for NIN was left handed

[SQUIDGYBROWNLOG]

@KeithNet thats Ilan Rubin your thinkin of, he plays for NIN nowadays but this is the drummer before the left handed one

[bluewolf401]

:)

[circusfreak0987]

I am Trent's mic.....I am Trent's mic...

[15000volts]

how in the hell does he get that tone?!!! that's one sweet intro. and the tone on the bass is just drooling!

[ReznorRedux]

@15000volts he uses the legend of fuzz pedal for the guitar

[WarriorDudePerson]

@15000volts I'm pretty sure all good effect pedals pray to Trent Reznor before they go to sleep every night

[albundie3]

@WarriorDudePerson trent and adam jones

[MrZerlhock]

Amazing!

[sequekhan]

Once 9 people saw the thumb down button they couldn't help themselves

[jakkfrosttt]

0:31 creeper in the background lol

[JFLD02186]

just fuckin pissa !

[thehornypuppy]

Someone help i can't stop ;__;

I just love this recording...all the instruments sound amazing.

[Subliminallll]

Poetry in fucking motion.

[MissSalmonella82]

I have so shitty day but this song makes me feel much better.

Thank you Trent !

[Jestem wyjątkowo niezdyscyplinowana...]

[Furrypudding]

Holy Shit! the video quality is amazing, this album grew on me, I wasn't to crazy about it at first, but now i can't imagine my NIN arsenal without it

[Blazewhitefox]

@Furrypudding i had the same thing happen to me. the album just grows on you...

[thehornypuppy]

i...can't...help myself... ;__;

[DainityDaim]

I just... I JUST LOVE HIM! <3 :')

[thehornypuppy]

I wish studio versiones sounded this fucking good...i've been listening to this song alone for...3 hours...and it just now...in the morning i listened to this from 10 am to 3 p.m

And then i had to get away from the pc because i went to my room and listened to Only over and over again until i came down and and and...fuck this one is amazing.

[thehornypuppy]

I just realized that is josh at the drums...o.o

[brpeters01]

I'm w/ sbsrocks. as far as i'm concerned, this tune is all about the drums. looks like it would be fun for the drummer.

[sbsrocks]

bass drum sound is amazin

[KurtCobainof21]

Trent sounds so awesome in this. Hes my favourite singer.

[selfdestructstarfuck]

dear trent. without your presence in music i am very sad. Please come up with a follow up to this ASAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

[Selcath]

@selfdestructstarfuck How to Destory Angels 6 track EP

[crazylara101]

Some goddam how I hadn't heard about this album until today! Seriously I've had every other one except this, can't believe I've been missing out on this for so long :O it's fucking brilliant

[NineInchNailsZero]

2:17 the light and god

[fourtwentty420]

How can 9 people dislike this song??

[bravo075]

Trent just doesn't age!!!

[midairman]

@bravo075 Trent 1 time 0 :D

[MissSalmonella82]

@bravo075 That's true, he doesn't age. Year by year he's better.

And this voice... Tomorrow "Discipline" will be my number 1 track in playlist and it's gonna be a beautiful day !

[bravo075]

@MissSalmonella82 True Discipline is addictive

[thehornypuppy]

@bravo075 no shit...

[mangosnake]

Say Trent, can I rehearse with my band in your rehearsing room ?

It looks killer !

[jdj106]

the first lines seems like what my ENTP self is telling my INFJ girlfriend.

[ulbofi]

does anyone know the tabs for guitar? qould be cool... i love this song... my favorite...NIN for ever

[bravo075]

@ulbofi Um, if I'm not wrong it's the same guitar line, the notes are: G#, slide to F#, then D# and C#, you can figure out the rhythm

[ulbofi]

@bravo075 thank you very much

[Rosstacular]

this song alone caused a million babies to be conceived

[christhefis]

1:14

Josh has got the cutest smile!

[doomedarkness]

Nine Inch Nails For Life.

[30fuVkingdollars]

ouuuuu ... i LOVE this vid/song! everything from the lighting to the setting is PERFEKT! please please pleeeeazzza ..... continue taping rehearsals or anything inside the studio. i'm so happy i stubbled upon ninoffcial!

*** jumps with excitement ***

[fourtwentty420]

I cannot stop watching this.

[lepexi]

@stellaswheel well he said hes bringing nails back. sooner than that. HTDA helped him most past some things.

ive been to 4 nin shows and they all completely destroy any other bands live performance besides tool and puscifer, so far in my opinion.

[fourtwentty420]

who are the 9 dumbasses who disliked this song? srsly.

[bigged61]

i could play this beat by myself for 6 hrs 12 min......NIN.

[ElementalNiobe]

This song makes me wanna have sex soooo baaaaad...

[libbern]

@ElementalNiobe

To bad you live on the other side of the world then

[BigballzDeep]

@ElementalNiobe I agree.

[nintifreak]

@ElementalNiobe Not as much as closer ;)

[bullsfan93]

@ElementalNiobe what NIN song wouldn't do that?

[KedViper]

@ElementalNiobe badly

[sorrowedpoet]

Ive got this weird friend called Alan who's incredibly and unbelievably unfamiliar with NIN. what a douche!

[blueblade455]

It's official, this is the most interesting video I have seen today!

[theundeadx]

wow!!! very good!!!

[mrop4]

As usual - exceptional

[bloodyclerk]

i really nope nin tour in the next few years i really want to see them

[Akraz]

Not sure why this doesnt have more views. This IS real music. Not that other fucking shit you hear.

[Horkhman]

This is Robin Finck, ex-G`n R-member.... Great song!!

[ZzZNorgaZzZ]

0:33

must.. get.. that hair..

[snavekd]

once i start, i cannot stop myself

[skunkbait80]

@snavekd masturbating? Peeing? or pooping?

[snavekd]

@skunkbait80 Drinking vodka

[mysterywhylay]

Well, my five n ones love this tune. VERY "growly" love it :) Andddddddddddddd Trents a god..nearly, if he was Scottish...he'd be a god LMAOOOOOOOOO

[Somborac420]

BEST NIN TRACK EVER! THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE!

[elrolo16]

I need your discipline...

i need your help....♪

[Gaarnek1994]

dunno why but i like Alessandro

[lepexi]

@Gaarnek1994 check his band modwheelmood. talented dude.

[12321jr]

whats the guitarist and the drummer's names?

[ARWorksProductions]

@12321jr The guitarist is Robin Fink,

and the new/old (ish) drummer is Ilan Rubin

[briani4735263]

@12321jr Guitarist - Robin Finck, and this drummer is Josh Freese.

[12321jr]

man this song is so FUCKING badass!

[vampire891208]

robin as cool as always

[gundambob646]

i hate youtube and its crappy flash compression.  i have the physical dvd of this rehearsal and it sounds tons better.

[lepexi]

@gundambob646 whered you get that? i havent checked recently but i didnt know this rehearsal was out on dvd or even a torrent. id kill to throw this in good quality on my tv and system.

[gundambob646]

@lepexi it comes with the slip deluxe release.

[lepexi]

@gundambob646 Thanks

[ForgiveTremor]

Anyone know where I can just find the audio of the entire rehearsals?

[briani4735263]

JMJ plays some of the smoothest bass guitar in the world. This album is just beautiful live.

[ToyRobot13]

I want to see them at a concert.

[OutcastMKD]

best everything ever :)))

[Stoneagestatic]

that´s sick :D

[NadDinky]

they're this good at rehearsals? they must be phenomenal live... :D

[pyrosilverfish]

is the guitarist wearing a poncho? BTW what is his name?

[WalkerKansasRanger]

@pyrosilverfish Robin Finck

[Garsound]

trent reznor=inspiration

[californication1992]

0:34 Perry Farrell in the background? haha

[CarrieNuman]

I would have absolutely no problem giving that boy some discipline.

[decayedmatter]

@CarrieNuman That boy? Trent is older than you.

[Xbox360HdmiLover]

I Listen to this song on midnight club..I always win because of it

[Xbox360HdmiLover]

IDK why I like this song so much..LOL

[hitek86]

Maturation. Evolution.

[Somborac420]

Nothing, Trent says he's just going to lay low for a while but also said NIN WILL return.