Added: 2 years ago
From: LizMcClarnonVEVO
Views: 476,967
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (211)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she so pretty i like you liz!!!!!! your the one for me!!!!

  • wow... amazing song i love it keep it up liz.... god bless us

  • SO SEXXY

  • Comment removed

  • nice ♥

  • fegs

  • That a very beautiful remake.

    

  • love the cover story, but I don't understand why he got killed by the other guys. In the video, at that time, she was showing the ring on the finger and got robbed, but the ring was still on her hand after the fact. I guess the director forget about it, or the robbers got scared and got away w/o getting the ring off of her finger. Anyway, I still love this cover and listen to it many times.

  • this is an outstanding cover

  • Actually I think she has her own style to sing this song.With no disrespect to Barbra but I think Liz 's sound give me a modern feeling.

  • she's very beutifull, but she can't sing like barbra, sorry

  • you can tell shes British by looking at her teeth

  • @dillmon1 Well it's lucky she isn't American or she would be fat and ugly too.

  • shit song

  • @dillmon1 Shit you

  • Gosh, she's so Emma Bunton.

  • She's beautiful. 

  • wow~!! lovee thiissssssss

  • nice video

  • i definitely prefer the barbra streisand version...good however

  • she can sit on my face

  • I love <3

  • damn shes really really hot <3<3<3<3<3 but musically its a lot worse than barbra streisand's version and the original by mirelle mathieu

  • Nice version!

  • beautiful!!!

  • I really loved the video you uploaded

  • Does she play off of sophie and sian

  • awful version.

  • Nice version. I always sing the original version of this during gatherings

  • me encantaaaa!!!

    

  • barbara has an amazing voice, but her version is too slow. I prefer this one

  • This song is older than the singer. A nice cover though.

  • I heard this song wele version ..... In Italian, Polish, French. sung by Dana International, Irene Jarocka and many others. But it is a failure. Great, great match

  • @TVTUGA134 :/

  • did he die? :S

  • wish you guys would stop arguing, so annoying,

  • @closingRemarks...you sound an awful lot like my ex husband, Andy is that you????? If not you must have gone to the same school he did, he was argumentative like you. and @Roelani...stop replying to this sad little person, go free and enjoy your life or you will end up like him/her.

  • @tia571 

  • @tia571 Argumentative, say, like sticking your nose in on someone else's conversation and insulting them? I find the characterization "argumentative" interesting. How is standing up for someone who does not deserve the venom Roelani has been spewing at her "argumentative," but posting a "critique" of that person's work using words like "s***" and "vile" perfectly reasonable?

  • @tia571 lol,,, i love this!!! Andy is that you??? i love it.

  • The original is better than this remake. The beat is overbearing, interrupting the floating quality of the melody. She has a nice voice, but the arrangement is absolute crap.

  • me quedo con la versión original, gracias

  • i love this song... i am a woman in love

  • I was looking for the original Barbra Streisand, and saw this. Decided, regrettably to give it a listen. Appalling version, and I don't think the amazing Barbra needs to worry. What horrifies me more is that a Gibb would let her do this.

  • love this song

  • her voice is god, the music behind is not

  • I want to be in love as that

  • nice but the Arabic version is much better , type Sofia Marikh - Tahwak

  • she has ruined this song!! no doubt it has been changed, if she did this live it would be shit! If i was Barbra striesand or Barry Gibb I would try and get it band, its that shit!

  • @roelani223 Even a rabid fan of the original can admit, if they have the least bit of honesty in them, that she does a tremendous job with this song and that she has a beautiful voice. Your remarks suggest that you do not possess that honesty or that you are tone-deaf.

    Either way, good luck with getting that ban. Streisand has no say in the matter as the rights belong to Gibbs, and Gibbs asked Liz to do the song and produced it for her.

  • @ClosingRemarks I am not tone-deaf and you may think she does a tremendous job, but in MY HONEST OPINION (which we are all entitled to!) she ruins it... and wow, i cant believe he asked her to do that! Bet he regretted that when it was finished!!

  • @roelani223 An honest, valid, and unchallengeable opinion is that you like Streisand's version better. Using quantifiable terms like "ruined" and "s***" takes it out of the realm of opinion into something measureable. It is clearly not "s***" since it made it to #5 on the charts. By that same token, it did nothing to ruin the song. Streisand's version is unaffected, and it brought a great song new fans.

    Everyone has a right to an opinion. That does not make every opinion right.

  • One other thing: Suggesting someone in authority -- in this case, the brothers Gibb -- agree with you does not validate your opinion, especially when there is not one iota of evidence to support it.

    I won't speak for either Gibb brother, but Robin co-produced the song for her after she toured with him in 2005, so he already knew her work. He could have stopped it from being released, but it made it to #5, and it made him a lot of money, That strongly suggests he did not regret it.

  • @ClosingRemarks Wow seems like you have alot of time on your hands.....well hun, it ruined the song for me cause everytime I hear it now, all im gonna think is oh remember when that celeb who couldnt sing did a version of barbra striesands amazing song! And then i'll remember you who must have taken a long time going through that thesauraus writing your previous paragraphs.

  • @roelani223 So you are so shallow, your music tastes are so narrow, and you find Streisand's version so empty that you can no longer enjoy "Woman in Love" because you heard this version? I would feel sorry for you, but that is so pathetic as to be laughable.

    As to the thesaurus comment, I do not need a thesaurus to use common words. If you do, you might try a few online classes rather than wasting your time commenting on a video you are not even interested in.

  • @ClosingRemarks My music taste's are so narrow and i am shallow? and what evidence do you have to support that again? Oh sorry you don't have any....What is laughable is how angry you are getting over this!

  • @roelani223 You said “all im gonna think” [sic] about now is how much you don’t like this version. If any version of a song “ruins” your enjoyment of another version of that song, then, yes, you are shallow. Your intolerance of this version says your tastes are narrow. You could have simply posted that you prefer Streisand’s version. Instead, you posted unwarranted, profanity-laced vitriol. I would say that shallow and narrow are quite generous.

  • @ClosingRemarks Ok lets just leave it at that now, that you find it the best song made and you will go to all lengths to protect it and i find it vile. Lets just agree to disagree.

  • @roelani223 I never said it was "the best song made." I didn't even say it was better than Streisand's. I am simply responding to the obvious and expected gross exaggeration on your part. As @gillfaery predicted below, your reaction is not to the quality of the performance but, rather, out of some misguided need to attack a remake of a Streisand song.

    So, rather, let's agree to disagree on this. You think the song is vile, and I think your comments are dishonest and unwarranted.

  • @ClosingRemarks Oh so your one of those people who try and get the last word in, your obviously loving this debate cause otherwise you wouldnt have wrote all that....Can I just say though if someone like Lea Michelle from Glee had done it, or even if this Liz would have done a better job i probably would have liked it, but i just think that her voice is awful for this song! And if you dont think its better than Streisands version then why are you spending so much time defending it?

  • @roelani223 Regarding Lea Michelle, point taken, but whether you would allow someone you already have a vested interest in to do the song is not really a valid test. Case in point, why would defending this version hinge in any way on whether or not Streisand's version may be better? It doesn't, and that is the point. Please consider that the very question strongly suggests that your analysis is, indeed, being colored by the fact you consider this Streisand's song.

  • @roelani223 Saying she could have done a better job or that you don't think that her voice is a good match for the song is vastly different than saying it is "s***," "vile," or that she "can't sing." The former is honest opinion that I don't agree with but can respect. The latter is vitriol she does not deserve using absolutes disputable by objective facts, and I will respond every time.

    Want the last word? Express honest opinion like this without the snarky comments.

  • @ClosingRemarks Right Im going to pretend I understand what your first reply meant, but, as for the second paragraph I use those terms because I for one hate this version, second thats how i speak and thirdly to be honest, i dont think she cares what people think about her.

  • @roelani223 Yeah, I am sure that she sits up at night worried that you are not among her millions of fans across the world.

    Do you have to work at being this self-important, or does it just come naturally?

  • @ClosingRemarks Maybe thousands, not millions...... and i enjoy being full of self-importance, as i get to trample on you little people......

  • @roelani223 That's the problem with "self" importance. I know that you are the center of your tiny universe, but I don't lose any sleep over your opinion of me, either.

    And, no, I don't care what your opinion is. I reply to you solely to prove just how far people like you will go to disparage a remake of a song you like. You could have ended this by just replying that you don't like the song without the snarky comments, but you keep proving me right with this childish vendetta.

  • @roelani223 @roelani223 Regarding fans: With AK, she has two albums that went to #1 (2x platinum) and one that made it to #5 (platinum), three #1 singles, and 11 more in the top 10. "Whole Again" alone sold over 1.7 million copies. This song made it to #5. In addition to doing shows and charity work, she won “Celebrity Master Chef” and has been a presenter (host) on other TV shows and specials.

    Sorry if it doesn’t fit your distorted paradigm, but she has millions of fans world-wide.

  • @ClosingRemarks Ok it is apparent that you have OODLES of time on your hands to research her every career move and what number each song got to on the chart..... but to be honest 'Closing Remarks' im not really bothered. oh yeah and please can you stop using words such as vitriol and paradigm, cause it doesnt make you sound clever...just pretentious.

  • @roelani223 You pompously demand that her song be "baned" [sic] because you don't like it, and you call me pretentious. You cannot put together a single post without multiple grammatical errors and you use gross exaggeration with words like "vile," and then you criticize me for using precise and accurate words to express my thoughts. You make outrageous claims which I repeatedly disprove with actual facts, and then you double down on dumb by criticizing me for having the facts. Priceless!

  • @ClosingRemarks OH MY GOD! FUCK OFF!!! Im sorry i dont sit by a thesauraus all day and plan my every word! Now get a life you sad sad little person! You should try and hunt liz down since your so infactuated by her 'amazing voice' By the way, i wont be replying anymore as it obviously satisfies you to see that i do...Goodbye, have a nice life!

    (Twat.)

  • @roelani223 For the record, I ignored your writing style from the start because it was never the issue. However, twice now you have tried to talk down to me for using the perfectly acceptable English. I mentioned your writing merely to point out the hypocrisy of correcting someone else. I was not belittling you or anyone else who either lack writing skills or don't bother to use them.

    In contrast to your summation, I honestly do wish you well.

  • she has the loveliest eyes . . . it's nice to hear a beautiful song sung by a gorgeous woman

  • beautiful song...great voice...darn, I'm still in love with Liz !!!

  • barry gibb wrote this,nice version

  • she is ahotty

  • que el clásico

  • Check my videos see a boxing test between and Darness.I am 50 and he is 42 .Who would win in a fight ?

  • watch?v=-ilTwJekVlE

  • There is an Arabic version, amazing one...just type: Sofia Marikh - Tahwak

  • @2741718 Thanks for the link :)

  • Nice version

  • I am a woman in love....^_^

  • @jusy872 it nice met beauty girl like

    could be friend

    i really like you

    my QQ : 1375958744

    my Skype : abubakry7

  • Only woman can tell the feeling Woman In Love : )

  • she's pretty and this version and video is nice ;)

  • Wait... Some guys just came in front of him and... KILL him? omg

    Love the song and Liz!

  • GREAT I LOVE IT

  • She does have a great voice. Sounds like somebody,i just cant quite put my finger on it. i like the part where she sounds like the girl from grease.

  • HE BOUGHT A WALMART RING

    LOL

  • Check out Tracy Huang's cover of "Woman In Love"

  • good

  • Is she nuts??? Covering a Streisand song. McClarnon has got a nice enough voice but she is covering one of the best female vocalists of all time!!!

  • @gillfaery: Yes I agree - it was a poor choice to go up against Streisand with this song. I like this singer and she's great but you're only asking for trouble when you go up against Streisand in the vocals department..

  • I realy liked the part when that man gets beaten up by those CHAVS

  • Holy shit shes white as a nigger in heat.

  • THANK YOU YOUTUBE FOR HAVING DIS SONG .......

  • Liz so hawt. I'd buy her a mercedes.

  • @nicodemisthenecroman

    I'd buy her a Subaru, cuz she's into turbo awd, not couger cars ;)

  • @nicodemisthenecroman haha she prolly has a few alrdy

  • quá chuẩn<3

    

  • the guy in this video is beautiful!

  • superb.....

  • Nice version of this

  • she's my favorite in Atomic Kitten :)

  • EU ADORO ESCUTAR ESTA MUSICA, ESCUTO QUASE TODOS OS DIAS

  • remind me the name of the actor who acting her boyfriend in this v.clip please

  • It's a nice version but nothing was added to the song and the original was far superior. She's prettier than Barbra.

  • Barbara is a diva who needs to be put out to pasture, once and for all.

  • There is only one version to woman in love!!!!! Barbara rules!!!!

  • Is there a way to buy this version?

  • Awesome video.

  • Nobody could sing this as good as Barbra Streisand This woman has ruined a brilliant Streisand classic

  • @AlexandraBurke4eva This womans name is Liz and she sang the song beautifully. Tastes differ.

  • @AlexandraBurke4eva actually, there is a person who can sing this song as good as Barbra and maybe even better. Her name is Mirelle Mathieu and the song in french is called Une Femme Amoureuse:)

  • @Nathaeila aaah yes ive seen very nice

  • @AlexandraBurke4eva sorry, mistake, * Mireille :) if you like Barbra's version you need to hear this, it's really good:)

  • this is a stupid video. it steals all the depth the song has.

  • foarte frumos !!!!!!!;)

    

  • C'mon fckin on!!!! How can you re-do this song and dont hit/hold the note after the second verse.. cmon man, damn! when you do a cover it should atleast match or better the original! oh the british...

  • Wow, she did Bar's song...I'm on the fence on this one, love Bar's version.. The voices are very different. Something is missing in Liz's version??

  • she should get on her back, spread those legs and hold her lipps open and showthe world what she's got...

  • She sounds just like Olivia Newton-John, 

  • Nice rendition of a beautiful song

  • Aw she's sooooo beautiful ! (I'm a girl) :D

  • me la quiero cojer a Liz@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

  • Liz looks stunning

  • Such a heart-wrenching song. Makes me hurt all over for him. *Sniff Snigg* Beautiful.

  • not bad at all she can sing but never like barbra streisand's

  • she s graet i love her

  • she s graet

  • she so beautyful :X

  • I love her

  • She's Like Kylie Minogue:) So Beautiful Love you Liz^^

  • the guy in this video is absolutely gorgeous!!! :)

  • OMG! She's beautiful n song really great!!! Love it!

  • son unos pajeros @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

  • It's OK, but it's the biggest hit of Barbra Streisand's career! She has balls for trying! No wonder I'd never heard her version until now, because it's good; but 'oceans away' from the original.

  • This is a top notch video and song liz looks and sound great you really feel for in the end when the dude dies.... She can sing and cook what more could a man want?

  • like the whole song except when she says 'i defend'... that really offends the memory of the original song!

  • PLASTIC VOICE, PLASTIC GIRL, PLASTIC GUY, PLASTIC VIDEO, PLASTIC WORLD....music rip...

  • What a bloodless, callow, soulless effort. Babs Streisand, there ain't nothin' to worry about here. This girl ain't touchin' you.

  • muy lindo video y canción. !!!!!!!! gracias!!

  • this song is great in a remix version , i cant find it though :(

  • i love this song it means a lot to me my bf died i was only 20 and he was only 20 he was in the raf this song has meanin its a great song x

  • Barbra Streisand better than this version.

  • Can this video be any more on the nose? Seriously looks like an episode of Days of Our Lives. Good song, good voice....horrible video.

  • @rbatty90210 what do you mean on the nose? :P

  • @sofakifuckoff , are you disagreeing or asking what I mean by "on the nose"? If it's the latter, then I mean that the attempt at telling some kind of story within the video (the guy, the marriage proposal, the getting beat up by ganstas) is so cliche and lame that it detracts from her vocal talents and her expressive face in the rest of the video. It looks like one of those cheesy karaoke videos but probably cost a lot of money. A locked off shot of just her singing would've sufficed.

  • @rbatty90210 no i wasnt disagreeing ... you answered my question !!! i think so too though !!!

  • @sofakifuckoff , oh cool. ;)

  • lal!! i really love her!!! bella .

  • kaloo

    

  • You are the best and i ben love in you....!?

  • Genial es genial esta version

  • who's d guy on the video? he's hottttttt!!!!!

  • oh she really took the song and made it her own:D horrible.

  • who would click dislike to this song, you bellends!! Love u liz xxx

  • Such a great voice.....beautiful love song....thanks Youtube for those good finds like this one I also like "Give you my soul" by Mo'Sean

  • I have been in love with Liz all the way back to "turn me on" when she was in Atomic Kitten.This is my fav. to date.I only wish she was in the states (Ohio) I would LOVE to meet her.What a voice!

  • thank you for not shreiking ... Barbra will always own this song..

  • as a streisand fan.. i didn't mind it.. but remember the original!!!

  • she's got nice teeth for an english girl.

  • It's OK, but with Barbra's gusty and powerful performance it's like why bother? This chick is good, but she should have changed the song up more to make it her own. This just comes off as karaoke.

  • @mikesterSTLMO so true

  • What's a moment in "splace" (@0:26)???

  • @m015094  HAHAHA. you're right. she actually says ''splace'' :p