thats the funny thing of this most brilliant inventio ... it sounds very good at moderate speed but ooooowww it is also awsome in this fast speed, IF you still can manage to produce the right sound of each 'voice' and clearly hear the elements of this piece
I really like the way you play, and love the piece, great job! Most of its pretty easy but those trills are impossible when you first learn it. Don't worry about your posture, just do what's best for playing (my posture sucks too XD)
Isn't it amazing how the better the performance, the more negative comments you receive? There are some serious vultures on youtube. Just looking for some way to feel some sort of self-worth at anyone's expense.
Excellent job by the way. You made it yours without breaking out of the proper style. A+
0:190:300:44 these are basically the three spots where you could be slightly better~
But I have to say I really like the way you play, it's not like you're playing the piece itself, you're speeding up and slowing down as you feel like it, and I think it's really important to make that distinction, instead of just playing on the same beat all the time~
I also think that you are too fast ... but having hear this kind of tempo brings a new musical feeling to this piece. Great ... and I love inventions since one can never be boring playing them over and over. Always something new to feel :)
Why don't you mention that he should be playing a harpsichord aswell. Or he shouldn't be using the full range the piano can produce that a Harpsichord can't.
I know it's not easy. I learnt it almost a year ago, forgot it, re-learnt it and didn't practise until I lost my touch. stupid me....but I was busy with other stuff.
anyway I think it sounds much better with a slightly slower tempo, although I appreciate his clear articulation despite playing so fast.
niiice....did u use pedal? cause i don't know if i should, considering its bach, and it was written for the harpsichord, not the fortepiano. so could you please give me some pointers? thanks!
Try to add more feeling and dynamics to the piece. You play mf basically the whole piece, and even though it sounds not bad, it could sound better, Great job though.
please thunder spare us your failed attempt at criticism - this piece's "feeling" comes from its tempo and clean playing, which this player hit spot on. How "could it sound better" ??? I can tell you how - on a Harpsichord, there is nothing more he could have done on a piano that would have made it "better." Bah I'm usually not this aggressive in a reply but I hate these kind of "MAN YOU NEED TO HAVE MORE FEEL, THE SONG WAS OKAY" posts.
I posted that comment a while ago while I was learning this invention myself. I now disagree with my own comment as Bach should be played very strictly at one sound at one volume and at one tempo. There are no accents, cresendos, decresendos, ritenutos etc. This video shows all of this very well, and even I play thesame invention likewise. I am sorry if I offended you, but like I said, I realise now it's a very good performance.
yeah, man, killer shit. We're studying contrapuntal works right now, and this whole thing is mapped out, so it was fun to follow along while you nailed this invention. Keep up the good work.
VERY NICE...u know i also play da piano ...i have da same piano u do ...im 14 i played that piece last year...i was wondering how old u were....cuz while i was checking those videos i saw 9 yrs old kids playing da same song ...nd i kinda got jealous , to be honest with u , anywayz...im having problems with finding the rythm , nd my teacher also wants me to find the passion i have 4 music...any tips or suggestions ? i take piano lessons @ da conservatory...u ?
the technique was fantastic b/c you played with the tips of your fingers, another thing, i couldnt tell if it was you pedal or if it was an echo but i kept hearing notes after they were played you might wanna check that out, anyway great job.
Very well done! I hope that I will manage this tripole thing someday as well... ;-)
Keksduebel 5 days ago
@Keksduebel tripole=triole
Keksduebel 5 days ago
that was amazing
Marcello3574 2 months ago
The hunchback of Bach...
LiquidBrainPurge 4 months ago 3
thats the funny thing of this most brilliant inventio ... it sounds very good at moderate speed but ooooowww it is also awsome in this fast speed, IF you still can manage to produce the right sound of each 'voice' and clearly hear the elements of this piece
awsome work Gordon !
Darkboy2525 7 months ago in playlist inventio 4
I really like the way you play, and love the piece, great job! Most of its pretty easy but those trills are impossible when you first learn it. Don't worry about your posture, just do what's best for playing (my posture sucks too XD)
TheTalentedMrArashi 8 months ago
Nice job! im learning this song right now... All i can say is you nailed those impossible trills dead on.
JoshdaROCKSTAR9999VS 10 months ago
J'ai ta vidéo dans mes favoris depuis le 23 novembre 2006 et je ne suis pas près de la supprimer !!
TRAZOME 10 months ago
La postura, te vas a hacer mierda!!!!y despeus no vas a poder tocar ni una nota...
urielcamano 11 months ago
sientese mejor
byronardo123 1 year ago
Isn't it amazing how the better the performance, the more negative comments you receive? There are some serious vultures on youtube. Just looking for some way to feel some sort of self-worth at anyone's expense.
Excellent job by the way. You made it yours without breaking out of the proper style. A+
TyronePaulWarren 1 year ago
Terrible posture, dont hunch your back, you will regret it later on...
Vesivian 1 year ago 3
0:19 0:30 0:44 these are basically the three spots where you could be slightly better~
But I have to say I really like the way you play, it's not like you're playing the piece itself, you're speeding up and slowing down as you feel like it, and I think it's really important to make that distinction, instead of just playing on the same beat all the time~
Dan1loBr 1 year ago
a more musically aware version...good job...
dainismichel 1 year ago
Although she plays very good, I think that 'He or She' can play slower.
iprachael 1 year ago
You are a little too fast, but I think your playing is great.
Mathlete1000 1 year ago
I also think that you are too fast ... but having hear this kind of tempo brings a new musical feeling to this piece. Great ... and I love inventions since one can never be boring playing them over and over. Always something new to feel :)
pinkellittle 1 year ago
Comment removed
aiarochp 1 year ago
the reverb is awful but your playing is really wonderful.
vertaile 2 years ago
leave the pedal its dirty use legato playing
crackapolo 2 years ago
*jaw drops
yeaitsjusme 2 years ago
I know the song is powerful that wants you to go faster but don't just keep cool and don't over do it.
pepejhk 2 years ago
Why don't you mention that he should be playing a harpsichord aswell. Or he shouldn't be using the full range the piano can produce that a Harpsichord can't.
ChrisWatch 2 years ago
I think you are bit too fast
dumyhary 2 years ago 9
@dumyhary Maybe so, but it is still a reasonable temp for Bach music. Btw, this song is really hard when you first learn it!
EvanWang999 1 year ago
@EvanWang999
I know it's not easy. I learnt it almost a year ago, forgot it, re-learnt it and didn't practise until I lost my touch. stupid me....but I was busy with other stuff.
anyway I think it sounds much better with a slightly slower tempo, although I appreciate his clear articulation despite playing so fast.
PersianPianist12 1 year ago
@dumyhary the inventions don't have a tempo marker
vivasoberania 7 months ago
@vivasoberania True bit still it can be an opinion each one have as individuel :) ..
Darkboy2525 7 months ago in playlist inventio 4
It's wonderful!!
destinybone 2 years ago
i loved it :)
spareaccountlive 2 years ago
I don't know why that guy says it was messy , in my opinion every note is crystal clear.
Davemaster84 2 years ago
that was really messy at times, but still good
Un1234l 2 years ago
HOLY CRAP UR AWESOME
so this is how its supposed to sound like
whoops
boredcow 2 years ago 2
fantastic! :)
Pianodrum95 2 years ago
awesome tempo.
Jelzebelze 2 years ago 17
Great! Bravo!
NapoleonLee 2 years ago 3
that was really good
tinkerbellandpolly 2 years ago
wouw your speed of dis song is WONDERFULL just EXACLY i like him !! thank you very much !! very very VERY nice did my respect !
Darkboy2525 2 years ago
thats well good =D
agnelovesya 2 years ago
Wonderful job ^^, well played indeed!
RozenMaidenFan 2 years ago
Wow, it sounds so beautiful!
kttruong88 2 years ago
great job!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!It's fast beuatifull
GilvanMerolaGouvea 2 years ago
you are my hero
codarkstarxx13 2 years ago
this is tits
dirtierharrier 2 years ago
That was ponage! I'm playing this for my senior exibiton.
iitzniicole 3 years ago
niiice....did u use pedal? cause i don't know if i should, considering its bach, and it was written for the harpsichord, not the fortepiano. so could you please give me some pointers? thanks!
neoplamixpoop 3 years ago
very rarely would one find pedal in a Bach piece or any baroque piece. Unless its notated i would say don't use it.
mfrancisco7 3 years ago
yeah you shouldn't really ever use pedal for any baroque piece. only for akward transitions to sew up gaps, but that's all.
HyperAX5 3 years ago
that's Beautifull!!!
musicantae 3 years ago
You did this very well... unlike a lot of people. Great job.
MinorKeys88 3 years ago
Beautifull!!! Tks to share it... good energy.
Haciaelsilencio 3 years ago
Great job! I'm learning this now, but I just can't seem to get the trills quite right. :-/
DarknessHowls 3 years ago
I hope you can post some new videos, cause you're really great !!
5 stars
koubache 3 years ago
Very well played!!
koubache 3 years ago
Perfect! You looked effortless keep up the good work!
kittyk4evr 3 years ago
thats pretty perfect
charlyrazz 3 years ago
Keep up the good playing!
LegitCritic 3 years ago
Nice playing.
PhilippeLernould 3 years ago
Try to add more feeling and dynamics to the piece. You play mf basically the whole piece, and even though it sounds not bad, it could sound better, Great job though.
thunder1909 4 years ago
please thunder spare us your failed attempt at criticism - this piece's "feeling" comes from its tempo and clean playing, which this player hit spot on. How "could it sound better" ??? I can tell you how - on a Harpsichord, there is nothing more he could have done on a piano that would have made it "better." Bah I'm usually not this aggressive in a reply but I hate these kind of "MAN YOU NEED TO HAVE MORE FEEL, THE SONG WAS OKAY" posts.
LegitCritic 3 years ago
I posted that comment a while ago while I was learning this invention myself. I now disagree with my own comment as Bach should be played very strictly at one sound at one volume and at one tempo. There are no accents, cresendos, decresendos, ritenutos etc. This video shows all of this very well, and even I play thesame invention likewise. I am sorry if I offended you, but like I said, I realise now it's a very good performance.
thunder1909 3 years ago
nice fingers :P
damnn
789celien78 4 years ago
very well, great job !
musicantae 4 years ago
Fantastic. I grew up on the inventions and they are dear to my heart. Thanks!!
DukeRightious 4 years ago
Eh...scratch my last post
I listened to other inventions, and so far, you're the best, except for the 46 second one..-points in scroll box-
neogirl12365 4 years ago
1. Sit straight
2. Try to play faster
Otherwise than that, amazing skill, well done.
neogirl12365 4 years ago
...
exanovaa 4 years ago
Actually, I like it at the tempo you're playing it. Sitting straight would look more esthetic, though.
calvinator84 4 years ago 2
10/10 straight! AMAZING SKILL! Keep it up!
planemadmatt 4 years ago
Magnífico!
enjendro8 4 years ago
yeah, man, killer shit. We're studying contrapuntal works right now, and this whole thing is mapped out, so it was fun to follow along while you nailed this invention. Keep up the good work.
nrlang86 4 years ago
VERY NICE...u know i also play da piano ...i have da same piano u do ...im 14 i played that piece last year...i was wondering how old u were....cuz while i was checking those videos i saw 9 yrs old kids playing da same song ...nd i kinda got jealous , to be honest with u , anywayz...im having problems with finding the rythm , nd my teacher also wants me to find the passion i have 4 music...any tips or suggestions ? i take piano lessons @ da conservatory...u ?
kittycat14r 4 years ago
fuckin amazing. good job sir good job
tanattak3 4 years ago
frankly i find it very good, light, spatial...
aronron2727 4 years ago
amazing. 5 stars
daniel0212 4 years ago
NOT FAST ENOUGH LOL ;P
pipeorganDUDE 4 years ago
frizzle 100: Glenn Gould sat the same way, so stfu
eunomios 4 years ago
amazing... but sit straight XD
frizzle100 4 years ago
playing that song right now, but i am learning the other half ^_____________^ great job!
hmstrsr0ck 4 years ago
That was excellent! You accented all the bottom bass notes well, very nice with the tremles! Try bringing the melody out more though.
dantheman28 4 years ago
Bravo!
pianogirl98 4 years ago
lol hunchback
cassandra5322 4 years ago
wow! i wish i could play like this
Stillillgal 4 years ago
the technique was fantastic b/c you played with the tips of your fingers, another thing, i couldnt tell if it was you pedal or if it was an echo but i kept hearing notes after they were played you might wanna check that out, anyway great job.
Styxfan427 4 years ago
WOW 5/5!!!
xXShmotzXx 5 years ago
I working on that right now and I take your video as exemple ^_^ good job
WinterFrank 5 years ago
very impressive
poeticlarinet 5 years ago
That was beauuuuuuuuuuutiful...
karpond 5 years ago
Very very good
tubamirabilis 5 years ago
congratulation.. very nice!!!
ferfergt 5 years ago
just quite perfect
MAGICA8788 5 years ago
exelente... María del Valle COStantini
tinycostan 5 years ago
cool :)
ryu1ro 5 years ago
you are awesome
1man1piano 5 years ago
thanks for the compliments!
btw, i did not use any pedal. the echo you're hearing is the product of the electric piano itself.
gordonf238 5 years ago 2
come on dude!! no pedal!!! :/
pfbinh 5 years ago
Bravo.
skarmient0 5 years ago
Very nice! :)
-Celia
ailecec 5 years ago
Awesome. Fast and very clean.
christian6657 5 years ago
great. you used the pedal, right?...
lightdark182 5 years ago
Oh wow. Very impressive.
pbnzelly 5 years ago