Watching teh footing of these stances I saw elements of Italian and English fencing, particularly the usage of frog stance (0:32-0:37), and the employment of the falcon guard (1:27). Is this somethign that's been adapted into one style from the other, or are there other similarities that developed independently between the style demonstrated and those of European origin?
what u call fragstance we call "shülin bu". it´s one of our basic stances.
i´would say most of the similarities had been developed independently.
because of the nature of the weapon. a few time ago, i had some exchange with a rapier-guy and we find out a many similarities. but often the "european" fenching seems more restricted (rules) than the chinese swordfenching...
If you are interested in Chinese Historical Swordsmanship, look into the Traditional Chinese Sword League (TCSL). They host tournaments in the US twice a year with the first European Tournament scheduled for May 2011 in Netherlands (2012 in Germany). Sword used in TCSL Tournaments are solid wood & must weigh a min. of 650 grams. Tournament Champions receive damascus swords as a trophy.
You might also like the video 5 Elements of Chinese Swordsmanship here on youtube...
You can really see all the problems with using light weight, foam, toy like "weapons" in this demonstration. It leads to totally unrealistic technique & silliness like jumping toward your opponent, something you would never try if you were using real weight wood weapons, let alone steel.
in some points I can agree.... the softsticks definitly CAN sometimes mislead techniques.... and of course you can´t really compare to realistic jian fight...
but thats not really the point jamming around with softsticks ;-)
... we´re looking forward to see some fine jian-play with real wood jians from you.
Now make them into lightsabers! GO!
trivium666fan 1 year ago
Watching teh footing of these stances I saw elements of Italian and English fencing, particularly the usage of frog stance (0:32-0:37), and the employment of the falcon guard (1:27). Is this somethign that's been adapted into one style from the other, or are there other similarities that developed independently between the style demonstrated and those of European origin?
Dasychot 1 year ago
@Dasychot
in generell we do chinese swordfenching.
what u call fragstance we call "shülin bu". it´s one of our basic stances.
i´would say most of the similarities had been developed independently.
because of the nature of the weapon. a few time ago, i had some exchange with a rapier-guy and we find out a many similarities. but often the "european" fenching seems more restricted (rules) than the chinese swordfenching...
greetz
wudangjian 1 year ago
I enjoyed this video! Its interesting to contrast the Chinese styles with Historic European Swordsmanship using rapiers or messers.
temmy9 1 year ago
If you are interested in Chinese Historical Swordsmanship, look into the Traditional Chinese Sword League (TCSL). They host tournaments in the US twice a year with the first European Tournament scheduled for May 2011 in Netherlands (2012 in Germany). Sword used in TCSL Tournaments are solid wood & must weigh a min. of 650 grams. Tournament Champions receive damascus swords as a trophy.
You might also like the video 5 Elements of Chinese Swordsmanship here on youtube...
wuming108 1 year ago
@wuming108
thanks for the information, that sounds very interessting!
is there any website for further informations?
wudangjian 1 year ago
You can really see all the problems with using light weight, foam, toy like "weapons" in this demonstration. It leads to totally unrealistic technique & silliness like jumping toward your opponent, something you would never try if you were using real weight wood weapons, let alone steel.
wuming108 1 year ago
@wuming108
in some points I can agree.... the softsticks definitly CAN sometimes mislead techniques.... and of course you can´t really compare to realistic jian fight...
but thats not really the point jamming around with softsticks ;-)
... we´re looking forward to see some fine jian-play with real wood jians from you.
greetz ;-)
wudangjian 1 year ago
Please bring in some asians.
CrazyDragonCross 1 year ago
you are welcome. ;-)
wudangjian 1 year ago