Added: 3 years ago
From: magorestes
Views: 97,784
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,638)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Rev should be in this list...

  • John bonham should be #1 then Keith moon #2. Bad list

  • I'm glad you used Achilles Last Stand instead of Moby Dick

    Felt good with something little different

  • Lars Ulrich is bent. The guy from Avenged Sevenfold is probably better (although I don't listen to them, what with them being bad and all).

    I still fail to understand why nobody is mentioning Jimmy Chamberlin. Search for Thru The Eyes of Ruby and watch the link posted by underscoredan and you'll see what I mean.

  • LARS SUCKS ASSSSSSSSSSS! And where the fuck is the rev. Good list though. Niel FTW

  • WHERE IS ALEX VAN HALEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • is gavin harrison george harrisons son?

  • in my opinion, the greatest drummers of all time are Neil Peart, John Bonham, Alex Van Halen and Dave Lombardo 

  • In my opinion, and once again, MY OPINION, Neil Peart is to "Show-Offy". It's like yes amazing, he's easily a great drum solo dude. But I prefer Bonham from LZ. He simply knows when to "stop". Once again, my opinion.

  • Lars needs to be atleast in top 10 along with Derek Robby

  • @cgcAWESOME84 lars doesn't deserve to be on the list, get real bitch

  • Where's Martin axenrot.

  • @oilfan1979 in my top 100

  • Dude it should be 1. Neil pert 2. John bonham 3. Keith moon 4. Lars ulrich

  • Chris adler should be top 10

  • This list is gay.

  • ...WHERE THE FUCK IS DAVE GROHL???

  • joey jordison :D

  • Yeah JOEY JORDISON

  • @123metalmania okbut where is IAN PAICE(DEEP PURPLE),COZY POWELL,ALEX VAN HALEN,etc

  • 98% Brits & American?????

  • @Robje300 RACISTS 100% fuck those anglo american bastards there are so many many great drummers around the world

  • En serio esta Barker antes que Mangini? xDD

  • roger taylor! :) #45!

  • what have u done lombardo and bohnham are better than jordison and why is neil part 1. and u forgot eric carr and randy castillo

  • everyone underestimates roger taylor

  • disagree

  • REV!!!

  • Wheres george kollias, frost, inferno, hellhammer, krimh, derek roddy, etc? All are better than neil!!

  • @deathbymetal2011 i agree but derek roddy is in there

  • Where is the rev?!?!

  • lar ulrich no 47??

  • ok seriously the rev is NOT the fucking best drummer. He was a good drummer but not the best.

  • @ZeroSystem100 I agree, noone is the best.

  • Honestly, even though death metal isn't my favorite style, I'm glad this guy chose a few of those because it makes this list more diverse. No matter what you do to a list there will always be someone complaining though.

  • ftw?! lars at 42?!?!!?

  • dont now the name but i think the drummer from disturbed should be here

  • IMO This list is weird...

    There are some drummers that needs to be kicked out like Ulrich and Jordison.

    I am also more of a fan of Zappa then Rush but i am happy to see Mahavishnu Orchestra, ELP, Yes and Rush.

  • xD haha i was waiting thinking where the fuck is neil pert?

  • why does people hate joey jordison he´s a very good drummer and he doesnt think hes the best like that guy travis barker

  • Where are Phil Collins and Simon Phillips?!! There are not in this Top 50....That's a bloody shame!!

  • Bonham and Moon should be in top 10...

    Joey Jordison should not be...

    But I'm glad you put Cobham!

  • thank god finally a vid where fucking travis barker isn't top 10

  • Colega... Aqui te sobran bateristas y te faltan otros...

    Donde te has dejado a The Rev? Madre mia...

  • @Calle16rtg the rev exta en el top 100 que subiré la próxima semana, ya estoy por terminarlo

    y efectivamente, en mi top 100 ya no estan algunos de esta lista, he cambiado de parecer con algunos en los ultimos 3 años

  • @Calle16rtg ya puedes ver el top 100, ahi se encuentra the rev

  • Mangini should be top 15 at least, and probably top 10

  • where the rev dude?

  • Lars Better than The rev! wtf?!?!?

  • Metal Drummers....and where is the Rev?

  • i consider carter beauford to be the best

  • what about Hellhamer ? Frost ? Marthus?

  • @zelior666 Agreed, plus Trym.

  • Ginger Baker is better... He invented the drum solo

  • i cant belive you left out avenged sevenfolds the rev COME ON!!!!!!!

  • Chris Adler 37? aw man

  • My top 5 based on a mix of influence and skill in my opinion is 1. Danny Carey 2.Carter Beauford 3.Neil Peart 4.Mike Portnoy 5.Marco Minnemann great list of course a few here and there that i'd do different but good job.

  • @masterworkz ¿cuáles serían tus criterios? ¿por qué no subes un top tú?

  • hold the fuck up where the FUCK IS BILL WARD AND COZY POWELL?

  • @FOOT2DETHROAT Your butt hahaha. just couldn't resist but you do have a point

  • Lars Ulrich, John Dolmayan, Chris Adler, Nick Barker, Josh Freese, Joey Jordison definately not a top 50...:S

  • Dude...Chris Adler, Derek Roddy, Lars Ulrich...WHY NOT TOP 10 ?

  • cual fue tu criterio pa hacer el ranking

    consideras que keith moon de the who es mejor que john bonham de led zeppelin?

  • @kminsi en ese entonces, hace mas de 3 años, me basé mucho en la técnica, además de otros puntos como trayectoria, importancia, innovación y actitud entre otras cosas. Sí pienso que Keith Moon tenía mejor técnica que Bonham, por por muy poquito, por eso están tan juntos. Aún así en mi nuevo ranking que estoy por subir, sí está más arriba Bonham porque tiene una mayor importancia para la historia del instrumento.

  • you had all really good drummers I personally would have taken out all the death metal drummers except for Roddy and Hoglan. Either then that and the fact that Bonham needs to be a bit higher up you have a great list. I like the fact that you have a diverse sense of taste in music. You dont often see travis barker and Gene Hoglan in the same list

  • Where´s The Rev?

  • Where the fuck is George Kollias man?

  • 1 other thing I agree with maggotMuncher96 mike portnoy and dream theater suck but mike Mangini is now the new drummer but they still suck dick

  • Also Joey has played with korn but he was never a member

  • Joey jordison is the best maggot for life

  • oh and

    10th MIKE PORTNOY HAS NO FUCKING SKILL AND SUCKS ASS

  • @MaggotMuncher96 and 11th just because portnoy is not fast and dream theater doesn't have a vocalist that screams about murdering infants and molesting women doesn't mean he sucks open up your musical horizon a bit more. Oh yeah and Job for a gay cowboy sucks as does divine heresy and the black dahlia murder

  • @thesneakygamer4343 so your honestly going to sit there and say that Tim Yeung the man with the worlds fastest hand and foot technique and Shanon Lucas have no skill? YOU ARE CLEARLY NOT A DRUMMER you dumb son of a bitch and idgaf is a band has a vocalist that screams/growls/squeals, its just a coincidance that all the good bands do

  • @MaggotMuncher96 I am clearly a drummer been playing for 15 years i just have a good taste in music unlike you, speed has nothing to do with anything. Which is what those drummers are all about. Its just so boring, same thing over and over again. I would rather listen to Mike Portnoy, Terry Bozzio, stewart Copeland, Mike Mangini, virgil donati, buddy rich, niel peart, steve gadd, and dave Weckl. These drummers are creative and dont just do blast beats. All good bands scream okay...sure

  • @MaggotMuncher96 All horrible bands scream it requires no talent and everyone in the band are people who cant play real music so they play death metal and fagcore. I am a metalhead trust me but I like good old Metal such as Iron Maiden, Metallica, Megadeth, Slayer, Anthrax, Judas Priest, Diamond Head, etc. But death metal sucks guitars are so obnoxious and rip-off riffs from other bands drums are easy and dull, bass is non-existant and the singer just screams, okay you fucking scene kid

  • @thesneakygamer4343 Dude, laying down a solid scream and not having your voice crack or fade takes a lot of dexterity and practice, especially if you're doing it through an entire song. Not to mention it really takes its toll on your vocal chords, these guys are making a great risk to their health.

    No talent? I beg to differ, playing with that much speed and force takes very nimble hands and very fast fingers. Granted, good guitar doesn't mean fast guitar, but they're still really talented.

  • @Moonchipz yeah i dont think its talentless i was just putting down maggotmuncher for being a troll but I can see where you are coming from I mean sure couldnt do what those singers do but yet i dont find it enjoyable. The guitars are okay but I think we can admit that a lot of those bands do rip off earlier bands' riffs. The drumming while talented it really sounds robotic after a while and there is just no emotion in it. I still think Portnoy and peart are more talented due to their feel

  • 1st Burn The Preist and Lamb Of God are the same band

    2nd Vinnie Paule is also in Hell yeah

    3rd WHERE THE FUCK IS TIM YEUNG

    4th Terri Bozio has no skill

    5th where the hell is Trey Williams

    6th why isnt joey Jordison #1

    7th and Where is Shanon Lucas?

    8th YOU FORGOT JON RICE

    9th YOUR FUCKING RETARDED FOR PUTTING RICHARD CHRISTY AT #50

  • @MaggotMuncher96 Mike portnoy is better then all those drummers you just listed. You think that just because he is not a death metal drummer that he is bad. First of all the drummers you listed are not on the list because they are just regular death metal drummers. ALL OF THEIR SONGS SOUND THE SAME. Mike Portnoy deserves to be number 2 he has excellent sense of timing and fuses many styles into his music making some very difficult songs. Oh yeah and Terry Bozzio is an amazing musician

  • @MaggotMuncher96 lol why joey jordison isnt number 1? he can only drum fast like more drummers but neil peart and mike portnoy are way better

  • @flyza25 HAHAHAHA that made me lol so hard, Mike Portnoy sucks cock so hard

  • @flyza25

    fast doesn't mean best

  • @dustsmallhong thats what i was saying lol

  • @flyza25 Portnoy is only good for showing off...he has little talent...

  • @theLL777 en el cielo

  • @magorestes jajaja bueno en realidad :P

  • Wheres Mike Mangini and Phil Collins!?

  • @glennandgem mike mangini 49, phil collins 250

  • I saw who was number 50 and just turned it off cause 48 and 47 were above him

  • oye , 2 preguntas , porque no pusiste al baterista de machine head , y cuando estara listo tu top 100 ?

  • @CarlangasDrummer ya lo estoy haciendo, es que no he tenido mucho tiempo, justo tambien vendrá el de machine head, espero terminarlo este mes

  • Dude lars should not be 47 thats just makes the dude who did this retarted

  • Again with the RUSH, sorry sucks!!!!!

  • good drummer choices, bad drummer order

  • muy buena lista , aunque solo unas preguntas , porque no estan the rev ( ax7 ) , mikkey dee ( motörhead ) , y jürgen reil ( kreator ) ?

  • @CarlangasDrummer gracias, rev es un baterista muy básico en cuanto a metal, en este momento pienso que sí puede ser mejor que lars y bozzio, el de motorhead igual es muy básico, y el de kreator está incluido en mi top 100

  • 1- Joey jordison

    2- Lars ulrich

    3- Dave lombardo

    4-wilson silva

    and then:

    5- Me :D

  • @GoodMusicLover95 hahahaha not even close

  • dave lombardo=#1(my opinion) and where the F is nicko mcbrain?

  • Where's Don Brewer in this mix?

  • q pasa con tigo por q excluiste  a jimmy ''the rev''...???

  • @ximenateamotanto porque hay mejores, tómate el tiempo de escuchar todos y cada uno de los 50 que puse

  • fuck you! the rev isnt even on it? fag. neil peart sucks balls.. bitch

  • @A7XfoREVer521 lol typical comment from a7x fan-fag.

  • what about matt greiner or grant macfarland or blake richardson

  • Lars on 47. ??!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?

    omg!

  • Y Ginger Baker? No olvides los clasicos!!!

    John Bonham 17? ????? 17????? Es de los mejores. Deberia ir de los 5 primeros.

    Has puesto baterias buenos, pero no alcanzan a otros...

    Esta todo mal... Se que es dificil hacer la lista, pero no deberias haberla hecho con la poca idea que has mostrado. Un saludo.

  • @juannrocks hay muchos bateristas mejores que bonham, y es verdad, esta lista necesita correcciones, ya tengo mi top 100 con mucha mas idea, hay 2 años de diferencia entre un top y otro

  • This list is gaRBAge, some of the guys are worthy but someone obviously thinks speed and cymbal chokes are what makes a great drummer. Total garbage.

  • jajaja donde esta McBrain y RHINO Y FREDERIK ANDERSSON DE AMON AMARTH TIO ESTAS MAL COMOALEX GONZALES Y MEJOR QUE LARS NO SABES NADA

    AHHH Y AQUILES PRIESTER 

  • @scottcolumbus de los que mencionas solo olvidé a aquiles priester, pronto lo pondré en una nueva lista, a los demás no, incluso lars ulrich sale de una lista de 100

  • @magorestes mejor digamos no de los q te mencione no los has oido carmine y vinny apice tambien faltan mejor deja de ridiculizart y por cierto alex gonzales es mierda comparado con -los q mencione en q t basas para tu lista mejor estudia bien y luego publicas mamadas

  • @scottcolumbus que bueno que te tomaste tu tiempo de escuchar a cada uno de los que puse, ridiculizarme yo? jaja si tú eres el que quiere que ponga más arriba a lars y que ponga a mcbrain, ambos carecen de buena técnica, tocan por tocar

  • @magorestes mmmmmm si ellos solo tocan por tocar?????? deberias de estudiarlos careces de bases para tu video pero bueno

  • @scottcolumbus estudiar qué? su falta de velocidad, fuerza y técnica? jajaja muéstrame un video en vivo donde ulrich toque como debe ser en vivo dyers eve y luego me dices que tiene buena técnica jaja, ni siquiera puede tocar sus mismas rolas. de mcbrain qué te digo, es peor que ulrich jaja simplemente no debió tocar nunca la batería, es infame, eso no se puede explicar, tienes que verlo y analizarlo

  • @magorestes mejor mostrame un video donde toques vos y utilizes tanta tecnica aprendida de mediocres como el malparido de mana Mcbrain te humillaria con los brazos atados en la espalda

  • @scottcolumbus no estamos hablando de mi, estamos hablando de los bateristas de mi top, mis influencias son peart, portnoy y harrison, no alex de maná ni mucho menos ese ridículo infame de mcbrain

  • jajaja donde esta McBrain y RHINO Y FREDERIK ANDERSSON DE AMON AMARTH TIO ESTAS MAL COMOALEX GONZALES Y MEJOR QUE LARS NO SABES NADA

  • i also miss the rev..... il ike him way better than the all hyped joey jordison

  • Joey Jordison is the best

  • @someguywithanAk47 holy god yeah man.. couldn't be more true.

    the rev deserves more on the lists then he does.

    i srsly thought i could find him somewhere on a top 50 but NOO

  • WHAT? Richard Christy 50th and Chris Adler 37th? That is fuckin blasphemy, for this list, they deserve to be at least in top 5. Jordison, Barker and Ulrich don't deserve to be even in top 100 of drummers. And to all a7x fans, just because your drummer died, doesn't mean he's good. He doesn't deserve to be the first, and for fuck's sake, stop thinking a7x got the best musicians, and listen to some more bands

  • YOU HAVE FUCKING BAD TASTE!!!! WHERE THE FUCK IS JAMES>!>!>!?!??!

  • Aqui ay q resaltar algo como diablos va hacer mejor el baterista de slipknot q dave lombardo si dave tiene mucha mas tecnica q este tio el drumer de slipknot solo tiene movimiento en los bombos ya casi nada arriba en los tambores y platillos es mas hasta chris adler de lamb of god se me hace mejor q este chavo de slipknot pro bueno pro no cabe la menor duda q dave lombardo pasan los años y sigue desempeñando buena calidad en la bateria o no!!!

  • @valtenius cuestion de enfoques no? para mi ambos son casi igual de buenos, pero jordison me parece que tiene mejor estilo, a lo mejor no tiene tanta energia pero definitivamente es más veloz

  • @magorestes si son casi iguales pro ve el otro lado de la moneda q estilo de musica tocan ambos dave toca thras metal y jordison ñu metal ademas dave tiene mas años en este negocio y sigue tocando de la misma manera ademasya le reconocieron a dave xq ya tiene su clinica de bateria x eso digo q lombaro sea mejor q jordison pro esperemos q llegue a la edad q tiene ahora dave y sabremos quien es mejor aunq dudo q llegue q llegue a la edad esa x las adicciones q tiene slipknot pro es rapido joey

  • Q PINCHE PEDO NO PUSISTE A NICKO MACBRIAN, GEORGE KOLLIAZ FALTARON ESOS DOS BROTHER

  • @yoslam40 a goerge kollias si lo olvide, lo pondré en mi proximo top 100

    a nicko mcbrain no lo olvidé, él no entra ni en el top 100

  • you know, all this time i thought he was saving the best for last. then at #1 the rev isnt there, pisses me off man, why on every list of the best bands or songs or drummers in this case A7x is not acknowledged. they deserve some LOVE!!!!!

  • Everyone is entitled to their opinion & after looking through this list i have to say the thrash metal drummers may be fast but there is no indiviuality. All the same rapid beat + no mention of Cozy Powell one of the hardest hitters aswell as having the skill!

  • @eeby7 YES, missed Cozy.

  • Chris alder should be NUMBER GOD DAMN 1 !!!!!!

  • @AlleyBottomPictures No, no way forever, haha.

  • @aerosmithisawesome11

    hell yeah where the fuck is the rev.

    crappy list

  • Lars is fuck bad. i dont know how he find place on this list. where is chris adler?? inferno from behemoth?? vitek from decapitated??? they're much better than ulrich

  • Adler should have been higher. Ulrich too, even tho he is not the best drummer, he is better that that.

  • Also, I'm am getting tired of seeing these comments saying Lars Ulrich should not be on the list. If he is so bad, how come he has been playing in the legendary Metallica since year '81 and counting? :P

  • Personally, I think this list had its people chosen based on speed, and drumming skill is NOT solely based speed. Proof: most of the people from 50-41 are the gods of drumming and are behind 30 drummers from bands I have never even heard of.

  • I Hate this list

  • Lars is best of all time!!!

  • @moremudd1 No, no way FOREVER.

  • you forgott that gene hoglan was in death

  • wheres THE REV and Joey Kramer

  • lars????really ????he's not a drummer but a pounder my dog plays better than him

  • why does any one  want to even put Lars into this list?? He is a good business man.... that's it a horrible drummer Joey is overrated!!!!

  • How come Lars Ulrich even have a place in this list?

  • I agree with Neil Peart.. where is Simone Kirke? I agree with Steve Smith.. but some of these no names suck..

  • rev ? he deservs #1

  • What about Jon Hiseman? Chester Thompson? Curt Cress? Buddy Rich? Jeff Campitelli? Pete York? Carter Beauford? Steve Gadd? This list sucks and is an example of deepest ignorance. Mazeltov.....

  • i hate rush

    

  • no. 48? hahahaha...

  • the rev is the best what the fuck i sat through 10 minutes of shit to see my favorite drummer be ignored FUCK YOU

  • DANNY CAREY YAAAAAAAAAA!!! i know Neil peart is better but Danny's shit is just SOOO GOOD!

  • Dolmayan the best

  • Ian Paice not in the top 100 rock drummers??!!

  • WHERE THE FUCK IS NICKO MCBRAIN!?!?!?!?!?!

  • te falto THE REV ese baterista es muy bueno ¿ donde chucha esta D: ?

  • Good on you mate. I was waiting for Neil Peart, happy to see he is ranked #1. The best drummer in the world.

  • no se que os ha picado con Lars Ulrich, es un bateria de lo mas normal

  • Travis Barker is higher than Mike Mangini?! What is wrong with you!?!? ;_;

  • Bonham as #17? You've got it all wrong... The Top Three should be 3) Keith Moon, 2) Neil Peart, 1) John Bonham; Bonzo was phenomenal, you didn't even put him in the top 15!

  • Umm no Buddy Rich?..

  • mmm nose si urlich..pero sin los trples de jhon bonham de partida el metal no seria nada sin eso...ese toque es simplemente infaltable en la musica mas potente...eso pienso..buen listado de todas formas =)

  • WTF Where the hell is the rev??

  • Daniel Erlandsson should definately be in the top 10!

  • yo a bonham le pondria cerquita de mike y neil; era un tio enorme de verdad. podiblemente uno de los abterias mas influyentes de la historia.

    por lo demas me parece muy buena la lista en general y estoy contigo en poner antes al de mana que el de metalica.

    por cierto, al que hablaba de the rev.... ese tio parece que solo se a hecho buen bateria despues de morir, porque antes nadie hablaba de el. por cierto, a mi tampoco me aprecia gran cosa.

  • @euskalduna666 gracias, estoy de acuerdo contigo todo excepto lo de bonham, si es muy influyente pero le faltó mucho en técnica para ponerlo más arriba, mi principal aspecto para hacer la lista es la buena técnica, más que la influencia

  • ok buen video pero te falto poner

    a the rev sullivan

    yyyy lars deberia estar entre los primero 20 y no se trata de ke tan rapido token sino kon el estilo y la vdd mike portnoy es mejor baterista ke neal peart ok

    sobres de rato

  • @sobresx gracias por tu comentario

    no se trata de velocidad, se trata de buena técnica, y lars no la tiene, por lo menos en vivo no la tiene, búscame un video donde toque bien la de dyers eve, cuando lo encuentres lo pongo en los primeros 20

  • TE FALTO JAMES OWEN SOLIVAN

  • WHERE IS THE REV??!!??!!

  • where`s IAN PAICE?

  • worst top 50 drummer all of time !!!!!

  • whhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaatttttttttttttttttttttttttt?­

  • Mike is better that neil,

    Neil is like the creator and Mike is like the master

  • Joey Jordison isn't in Korn, he's played live with them and Lars Ulrich shouldn't be 47. At least top 25.

  • why the hell is lars so lw???????????/

  • Last three are perfect have no idea how Joey Jordison got up there but whatever. Still very good list.

  • Oh yeah, and no Jimmy Chamberlin as well. Jesus...

  • No Hellhammer.

    No Trym.

    No Tony Laureano.

    Gene Hoglan lower than Joey Jordison.

    Lars Ulrich simply included.

    What a terrible list.