The way they made it move is incredibly cheesy. So is the music. Rorschach's voice actor SUCKS. Listen to Alan Moore reading Rorschach's journal or even the guy who played him in the movie. All these corny effects just really don't mesh with the spirit and message of Watchmen. It's kind of like they're making fun of it.
I like this voice better. I feel like JEH was trying to do a little Christian Bale's Batman in the Watchmen movie and make his voice all gravelly. But in the comic all it says is that Rorschach talks in a monotone.
listen to Alan Moore do Rorschach's voice. he does it in a couple of interviews on youtube. It is very gravely, low, and the tenses are broken up. the way it's done in the movie is actually how it is meant to be. the man WROTE the damn comics for chist's sake.
@joesomenumbers Good point, but it was stated in an interview that JEH would scream his voice out before filming or voice recording so he could have a gravelly voice. That's dedication.
I know Alan Moore would use a voice like this, but there are a lot of things that Moore wanted for his GN that I didn't care for. I liked the movie's interpretation. Haley rocked ^^
The thing is, I imagined Rorschach to have a voice that mirrored his loathing of society and pretty much the whole damned world. This guy sounds like he's narrating a children's bedtime story.
I happen to like this voice better than the one in the movie. It sounds more monotone like it's supposed to, and unlike the one in the film, there happens to be a voice behind the moderate rasp. In the movie it's all raspy almost throat cancer sounding. Rorschach in the movie sounds chronic.
@ gallifrey: Out of curiosity, What did you expect him to sound like and why? This is almost exactly the way I imagined it, maybey a bit higher in pitch but considering that his word bubbles, his manner and personality and the history you learn about him are all so coarse, this is pretty much what I imagined.
yeah I know, it's just that because he's such a small guy I figured it'd be a little bit more like a smaller guy trying to sound deeper ya know? Anyway I'm excited! Going to see the movie in an hour or two!!
@ project: Two heat-reactive layers of liquid latex? Really? I don't remember that at all. I'll have to check my copy when i get home... If that's right though, It's still kinda annoying the way they make his face move so damn much, considering that there's no way the heat of his face or pressure of his features against the mask is causing it to fluxuating that rapidly or randomly. Other than that though, pretty solid animation.
No, you were right. Chapter 6, page 10 "1962. Special Order for dress in new Dr. Manhattan Spin-off fabric. Viscous fluids between two layers latex, heat and pressure sensitive." I still say it shouldn't be moving so damn much though, except maybe around his mouth as it reacts to the heat of his breath as he talks, or maybe the cheecks and forehead if he get's blushed from physical exertion or anger. Good memory though on your part.
This has been flagged as spam show
Watch our animation 'Rorschach's Revenge' on this same journal on youtube channel ||| mypixelstory |||
tag along with indie spirit !
mypixelstory 2 months ago
"Man went sidewalk diving."
I kinda laughed my ass off there :D
TheLastRainShadow 9 months ago
steves ear ring is on the gay side
98Lubo 1 year ago
damn no mercy.
darksore6 1 year ago
5-10 years from now I may read the book, but the Watchmen movie was so horrible it made me want to break my own index finger
gusbaker4u 1 year ago
Optimus Prime?
BallerCityTV 1 year ago
" Please, don´t kill anybody"
and
" i´ve just broken this gentleman´s little finger"...
THE BEST XD
jarakras 2 years ago
comedian sucked anyway!!!
karsun6218 2 years ago
I liked Jackie Earle Haley better. Suited Rorschach's character better, I think, as Rorschach is a small, angry little man.
RodianPrincess 2 years ago 7
The comics stated he was short, but he wore elevator shoes to mask it.
(Im serious, check the novel.).
bbiguy 2 years ago 5
I agree I saw the Movie before I read the Graphic Novel..
Even when I read the Graphic novel JEH's Voice of Rorschach came to mind
DareDevilWithoutFear 1 year ago
what kind of cigarette were they smokin in the vid
ShortyKidGerry 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The way they made it move is incredibly cheesy. So is the music. Rorschach's voice actor SUCKS. Listen to Alan Moore reading Rorschach's journal or even the guy who played him in the movie. All these corny effects just really don't mesh with the spirit and message of Watchmen. It's kind of like they're making fun of it.
Josephdorf03 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love the comic voice... the movie voice sounded like a batman rip-off and didn't fit Rorschach.
AlexDiscoBall 2 years ago
I like this voice better. I feel like JEH was trying to do a little Christian Bale's Batman in the Watchmen movie and make his voice all gravelly. But in the comic all it says is that Rorschach talks in a monotone.
joesomenumbers 2 years ago 10
listen to Alan Moore do Rorschach's voice. he does it in a couple of interviews on youtube. It is very gravely, low, and the tenses are broken up. the way it's done in the movie is actually how it is meant to be. the man WROTE the damn comics for chist's sake.
Josephdorf03 2 years ago 18
But Moore's interpretation is calmer and monotone, while Haley's is more agressive and angrier. This is closer to Moore's vision.
62SG 2 years ago
@Josephdorf03 It's not Alan Moore.
JZPotter 1 year ago
@joesomenumbers Good point, but it was stated in an interview that JEH would scream his voice out before filming or voice recording so he could have a gravelly voice. That's dedication.
stebo11 2 years ago
i actually prefer his voice like this than in the movie.
theBeorn 2 years ago 9
I can Just feel those fingers breaking 'Crack'
Dru0417 2 years ago
what is this? The interactive comic book turned dvd?
RedNymph234 2 years ago
I think its better when JEH is doing it but again anyone can do a good impersonation of Rorschach(besides me)
mwong666 2 years ago
I have to say, RORSCHACH'S A LEFTY! :D
SupaGreenBean 2 years ago
"I have business elsewhere, with a better class of person..."
Haha. Adrian?
mptyyegdlc 2 years ago 3
I know Alan Moore would use a voice like this, but there are a lot of things that Moore wanted for his GN that I didn't care for. I liked the movie's interpretation. Haley rocked ^^
TheLoneOokami 2 years ago 14
his voice is definitely not dark enough. Jackie Earle Haley should have voiced it
DancingInTheRain73 2 years ago 5
I agree 100%. Rorschach NEEDS a dark voice. It' just him. ^^
OOTrishOO 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dr manhattan -One eye Lucifer and Zionst!
Ozymandiaz - Bloody Freemason Ramesses!
Comedian - Happy propaganda (puppet joker)
Rorschach - Honest skull and bone get killed by
Nite owl - American symbol of secret (NASA)
Silk Spectre - A Desperate Sex Symbol.
shamsham1983 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I knew Rorschach was black!
DenitheGreat 2 years ago
Rorschach's awesome. My personal second best.
ZeppelinMan04 2 years ago
The motion comic is good, the editing in particular. Would've been great if they had used the actual actors to voice it.
I'll just stick to reading.
Thoric485 2 years ago 6
I wonder if they used David Hayter's voice for rorschach..that would be cool
ChromeGhost0219 2 years ago
That would be resonable, but then Rorschach will say "Hurmh" in alot of his lines and action. LOL
But seriously, it might be that guy. His Solid Snake voice is somewhat similar to Rorschach
dollargig 2 years ago
yeah
ChromeGhost0219 2 years ago
Ironically, the screen-writer for Watchmen was David Hayter, the voice of Solid Snake =P
noneofyourbiznes 2 years ago
are you serios
sadnaruto523 2 years ago
Yup, he is.
noneofyourbiznes 2 years ago
Hahah yeah. But in the movie "Watchmen" He gots an very different voice, much more dark
HrWimson 2 years ago 2
The thing is, I imagined Rorschach to have a voice that mirrored his loathing of society and pretty much the whole damned world. This guy sounds like he's narrating a children's bedtime story.
valiantvyse 2 years ago 7
It's actually closer to Moore himself's interpretation than JEH's. JEH was great but yeah.
Mrster 2 years ago 2
I happen to like this voice better than the one in the movie. It sounds more monotone like it's supposed to, and unlike the one in the film, there happens to be a voice behind the moderate rasp. In the movie it's all raspy almost throat cancer sounding. Rorschach in the movie sounds chronic.
Conker7 2 years ago
It's a shame this scene in particular didn't make it into the film. It's one of my favourites from the book.
"I'm fine, Happy Harry. Yourself?"
IAmRodyle 2 years ago 2
The movie voice was better
GerardoNT91 2 years ago
I hate dr.manhattan He killed Rorschach fucking blue guy
saify1996 2 years ago 8
I so fucking agree with you!
catbaril444 2 years ago
nightowl is like batman right?
cerasi209 2 years ago 2
nite owl is not as confident as batman
illidanwashere772 2 years ago 5
well...thats how his character was designed.
spikytom 2 years ago
Very good job with the editting. I'm impressed
13Hubris 2 years ago
dats right.....
break his fingers
haha
Beatlesfan71 2 years ago
Is that private production??
It´s the greatest I´ve ever seen.
Great Job!
montbard 2 years ago
I think it's from the Motion Comics. It should be out on dvd soon.
paladin102 2 years ago
his voice has too be more raspy
Beatlesfan71 2 years ago
i hate this voice for him. it doesn't sound like rorschach at all. :-\
gallifrey1212 2 years ago
@ gallifrey: Out of curiosity, What did you expect him to sound like and why? This is almost exactly the way I imagined it, maybey a bit higher in pitch but considering that his word bubbles, his manner and personality and the history you learn about him are all so coarse, this is pretty much what I imagined.
JohnnySoprano87 2 years ago
his voice has to be low and raspy
Beatlesfan71 2 years ago
yeah I know, it's just that because he's such a small guy I figured it'd be a little bit more like a smaller guy trying to sound deeper ya know? Anyway I'm excited! Going to see the movie in an hour or two!!
JohnnySoprano87 2 years ago
oh yea i understand
cool
im going to watch it too
probably during the week
my dad is going to get it for me
Beatlesfan71 2 years ago
Rorschacs voice is better in the film :D
daxn55 2 years ago 4
yes it is :D
WaterIceDragon 2 years ago
Animation is good, Rorshach's voice is just plain wrong tho :/
boothjack 2 years ago
While the voice acting leaves much to be desired, the animation (as limited as it is) is actually quite impressive.
Sotnas 2 years ago
how does his mask do that
Blakefe 2 years ago
SPOILERS FOR THOSE WHO HAVEN'T READ THE BOOK!
It's made out of a dress which is two layers of liquid latex which reacts to heat and pressure.He makes it into a mask.
project5121 2 years ago
@ project: Two heat-reactive layers of liquid latex? Really? I don't remember that at all. I'll have to check my copy when i get home... If that's right though, It's still kinda annoying the way they make his face move so damn much, considering that there's no way the heat of his face or pressure of his features against the mask is causing it to fluxuating that rapidly or randomly. Other than that though, pretty solid animation.
JohnnySoprano87 2 years ago
Thats as best I can remember.I'm a fan of the book,hope I'm not forgetting anything.
project5121 2 years ago
No, you were right. Chapter 6, page 10 "1962. Special Order for dress in new Dr. Manhattan Spin-off fabric. Viscous fluids between two layers latex, heat and pressure sensitive." I still say it shouldn't be moving so damn much though, except maybe around his mouth as it reacts to the heat of his breath as he talks, or maybe the cheecks and forehead if he get's blushed from physical exertion or anger. Good memory though on your part.
JohnnySoprano87 2 years ago
This is REALLY good!!
Ghost6Pig 2 years ago
LoL! Rorschach you nut job!
beerasaurus 2 years ago
wow very cool how they make it look and move
ChappaMan17 3 years ago
SkrullKing321 you are a fucking dumb ass
negrote4 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
haha i think Rorshach's the Comedian: the comedian's death waza fake and this is his joke on the word
SkrullKing321 3 years ago
I don't like the voice for Rorschach, to be honest. The concept of this is superb though.
moofloops 3 years ago
i think this is only a sample there is more u just gatta buy m wich sucks
keybladeninja320 3 years ago
awesome!
amiko16 3 years ago
great, great work!
ryusakura128 3 years ago
Amazing.
kestorz 3 years ago
wow...
180proof 3 years ago 2