Her cries of "Huon, Huon" are extremely moving, followed by that incredibly noble yet vulnerable color intoned by a woman in love, which she does so perfectly. At least she finished this in one take and didn't "phone in" her top notes. At least she has a clean attack with no scooping (Leontyne, are you there?) By the way, Domingo was known to "dub" his B flats after recording Forza in another studio. (This I have on good faith from a former colleague of his.)
@sillyboydeux You point out some very valid things.. and.. remember during this phase of recording technology, dubbing in notes was much much harder . as they had not developed the technology to do it cleanly, without the public noticing. Normally, if an artist did not like the high notes in an aria, they just needed to re record the whole thing.. This makes recordings in that era.. more honest than they are today.!
@kgarmaker123 You are so right. Lady Gaga has, by contrast, a "pixellated" voice, completely produced by electronic horseshit effects. She's the biggest asshole in music, in my humble, Catholic schoolboy opinion.
This woman is a living prism, 33 years after her death. By that I mean, upon relistening, this time I hear the two top notes as perfectly on pitch, but "high on the string" like Itzak Perlman and Josef Szigeti used to do. The tempo she creates at the end, sounding more like "allegro con fuoco", is unprecedented in vocal recording I think. This is a masterpiece of vocal art, regardless of the high-note controversy.
@sillyboydeux Yes indeed.. and what was wrong with Callas voice in 1962 could have been fixed, quite easily, had she gone to a proper teacher, or even back to De Hildago.. and had it fixed. MOst of what was wrong, is that she had quit singing.. and adopted a fairly flamboyant, public lifestyle, repleat with lots of alchohol( horrible for the voice) smoking, and late nights. Not to mention a dysfunctional relationship.
@kgarmaker123 Amen. Well, that period adds to the myth and shortchanges her legacy somewhat; traditionally an artist at that age is at the "top of their prime" about age 38, 39. She had to stop a few times in the Paris Normas because she ran out of breath. It caused a riot in the galleries, but she finished. And when the "Guerra" top C came up, she stopped the conductor and repeated it, which is sort of tacky. Onassis over opera? Oh well, there are the Juilliard tapes—an ample compensation.
@sillyboydeux That breath thing was the result of being dehyrdrated.. In the rash of the new Callas books, it is clear she was abusing diruetics and laxatives in an attempt to stay thin for Onassis.. Probably also led to her cardiac collapse and death in 1977. in 1965 she was so thin.. that she looked sick. Has a horrible effect on the vocal cords too. in 1964( much heavier) She sang quite a bit better, and.. if accounts are correct her Paris Normas in that year were solid.
@kgarmaker123 I'm glad I read your comment - I was wondering why her her vibrato at the high note (7:48 mark) was so wide when she'd sung much tighter D-flats later in career.
Save for a rather precarious top B flat and C at the end, Callas sounds huge, full, and in complete control of her admittedly difficult-to-control voice. The darkness of her tone is haunting, and her lowest notes have the thrust of steel. In fact, the entire voice here has a driven thrust. I find it very exciting.
@vocalpianist haha. She was very funny about her use of "English". When asked upon her return in 1954 to the U.S. for her Chicago Opera début in Lucia, "Which is your favorite language to speak, Madame Callas?" "Well," she replied, in that whiny mezzo-soprano speaking voice with a hint of New York in it, "I count in English!"
La voce non è quella dei primi anni ma io adoro questa incisione
TheIpazia1 6 months ago
No idea she sang it! xD AMAZING!
RamirRMA 1 year ago
Thank you for letting me hear the Diva sing in English
nestersg 1 year ago
Her cries of "Huon, Huon" are extremely moving, followed by that incredibly noble yet vulnerable color intoned by a woman in love, which she does so perfectly. At least she finished this in one take and didn't "phone in" her top notes. At least she has a clean attack with no scooping (Leontyne, are you there?) By the way, Domingo was known to "dub" his B flats after recording Forza in another studio. (This I have on good faith from a former colleague of his.)
sillyboydeux 2 years ago
@sillyboydeux You point out some very valid things.. and.. remember during this phase of recording technology, dubbing in notes was much much harder . as they had not developed the technology to do it cleanly, without the public noticing. Normally, if an artist did not like the high notes in an aria, they just needed to re record the whole thing.. This makes recordings in that era.. more honest than they are today.!
kgarmaker123 1 year ago
@kgarmaker123 You are so right. Lady Gaga has, by contrast, a "pixellated" voice, completely produced by electronic horseshit effects. She's the biggest asshole in music, in my humble, Catholic schoolboy opinion.
sillyboydeux 1 year ago
Comment removed
gustopheles 1 year ago
This woman is a living prism, 33 years after her death. By that I mean, upon relistening, this time I hear the two top notes as perfectly on pitch, but "high on the string" like Itzak Perlman and Josef Szigeti used to do. The tempo she creates at the end, sounding more like "allegro con fuoco", is unprecedented in vocal recording I think. This is a masterpiece of vocal art, regardless of the high-note controversy.
sillyboydeux 1 year ago
@sillyboydeux Yes indeed.. and what was wrong with Callas voice in 1962 could have been fixed, quite easily, had she gone to a proper teacher, or even back to De Hildago.. and had it fixed. MOst of what was wrong, is that she had quit singing.. and adopted a fairly flamboyant, public lifestyle, repleat with lots of alchohol( horrible for the voice) smoking, and late nights. Not to mention a dysfunctional relationship.
kgarmaker123 1 year ago
@kgarmaker123 Amen. Well, that period adds to the myth and shortchanges her legacy somewhat; traditionally an artist at that age is at the "top of their prime" about age 38, 39. She had to stop a few times in the Paris Normas because she ran out of breath. It caused a riot in the galleries, but she finished. And when the "Guerra" top C came up, she stopped the conductor and repeated it, which is sort of tacky. Onassis over opera? Oh well, there are the Juilliard tapes—an ample compensation.
sillyboydeux 1 year ago
@sillyboydeux That breath thing was the result of being dehyrdrated.. In the rash of the new Callas books, it is clear she was abusing diruetics and laxatives in an attempt to stay thin for Onassis.. Probably also led to her cardiac collapse and death in 1977. in 1965 she was so thin.. that she looked sick. Has a horrible effect on the vocal cords too. in 1964( much heavier) She sang quite a bit better, and.. if accounts are correct her Paris Normas in that year were solid.
kgarmaker123 1 year ago
@kgarmaker123
This is poor unsteady, hooty singiing pure and simple.
65attila 1 year ago
@kgarmaker123 I'm glad I read your comment - I was wondering why her her vibrato at the high note (7:48 mark) was so wide when she'd sung much tighter D-flats later in career.
gustopheles 1 year ago
Save for a rather precarious top B flat and C at the end, Callas sounds huge, full, and in complete control of her admittedly difficult-to-control voice. The darkness of her tone is haunting, and her lowest notes have the thrust of steel. In fact, the entire voice here has a driven thrust. I find it very exciting.
Zva26 2 years ago
wow, I've never heard her sing in english
vocalpianist 2 years ago
@vocalpianist haha. She was very funny about her use of "English". When asked upon her return in 1954 to the U.S. for her Chicago Opera début in Lucia, "Which is your favorite language to speak, Madame Callas?" "Well," she replied, in that whiny mezzo-soprano speaking voice with a hint of New York in it, "I count in English!"
sillyboydeux 1 year ago