Added: 3 years ago
From: TheBede003
Views: 92,030
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (147)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • liam・・・

  • you know what i used to hate this song but as i've grown older and after seeing it live i can now appreciate it for the absolute classic it is!

  • he still has the most vocal/frontman voice since l/mc... so fk off all u blur ass pumpers

  • is there a bootleg of the whole show available? like, more than the one-hour broadcast?

  • Round about 0:50, I had to pause this. Couldn't take anymore (Noel's face says it all). Clicked immediately to "Oasis Live in Manchester Lyla." Try it. For a fan, it's enough to make you cry. Liam ain't that old. Mere speculation, but I'm seeing all the signs of long term substance abuse. Hope I'm wrong...

  • DOES ANYBODY HAS CONSIDERED THAT IN A TOUR (DIG OUT YOUR SOUL), FROM AUGUST 2008 TO AUGUST 2009, MORE THAN 100 LIVE PRESENTATIONS, ALMOST EVERY OTHER DAY, LIAM'S VOICE COULDN'T BE AFFECTED? I know that we have to listen to Liam's voice live, but the little minutes of Liam's singing in Beady Eye are amazing!!!. I have a feeling that Liam's voice is back.

  • @SoCloseToTheFire I have this feeling too ! YIPA !

  • at the 2nd minutes liam goes out time! :)

  • bf... the voice...

  • I feel sorry for Noel, he put in 100% effort all the time since he realised many moons ago that they had something pretty special going on. If only Liam could have harnessed his attitude, ironically his arrogance was charming but he let it get the better of him. I still rate the Gallagher's as the best songwriters to have come out of the UK since Lennon and McCartney. Maybe the break will sort them out, who knows?

  • If Noel wouldn't sing the refrian it would sound like shit.

  • how quality is chris's drum stick throwing at the outro !! :P

  • so funny....that shit liam..can't sing anymore....that's why noel left the band

  • imagine if Oasis would have broken up after Be Here Now, then got back together and recorded Dont Believe the Truth.... that would have sent them into icon status!

  • i know its a tough call to leave out some of the classics but eventually liams voice just didnt do them justice. DOYS is one of their best albums and they should have made more of it.

  • imo oasis released the wrong singles from DOYS, think its ridiculous that Bag It Up and The Turning were not singles let alone never played live! the only single they got right was Im Outta time", which is a classic imo. had oasis dropped some of the stuff that liam struggled to sing , such as a lot of stuff off of DM and MG and sang more songs and B sides from DOYS (e.g. Bag It Up, The Turning, I Believen All, The Boy With The Blues) liams voice wouldve been put to better justice.

  • @tozza7157 the reason they didnt release Bag It Up is they couldn't make its sound right live

  • @tozza7157 i also dont like how they only put out 3 singles when they had loads more they couldve released

  • why do the microphones make liam sound so bad?

  • @fortunl errr It's not the mics my friend

  • fucking weird how I've just watched loads of the 2005 tour where they played lyla and he sounds great. This only 3 years later and he sounds fucking shit?? wtf!

  • it might not sound great on youtube but anyone whos seen them live will know it dont matter because hes the bollox live

  • What is wrong with his live voice!?!?!?!?! Sounds like a great lennon voice on recordings and live just some old metal rocker voice

  • @HelterSkelterSOR Yeah, dunno whats up with it! Sounds strange. Is this when he had the throat infection?

  • @LGKemp throat infection? ooHH is that the same throat infection that he's had since 2003?

  • la mejor banda del planeta!

  • @Elienn94 yeah i noticed that 2, Liam sings the line 2 fast and it momentarily goes out of time. Cigarettes and alcohol that nite had a minor fuck-up 2, Noel's intro and Chris's drumming was outta time for a sec. Who cares tho eh? Liam & Noel: My idols and inspirations for life. Yeah man! Live Forever.

  • Liam sounds like shit in this layla's version =/

  • 1:55 who's wrong? liam? something doesn't sound right, haha. liam + noel are gods

  • what did they play before this because what is the little sample at the begining

  • Rock'n Roll Star

  • too much drunk

  • I saw them in '08. Liam sounded great. Unfortunately, he sounds pretty bad here.

  • John Lennon lost his voice toward the end of a performance too, especially the older he got. Twist and Shout nearly ruined his voice, they had to quit playing it live. The sacrifice John and Liam made to sound that way is losing the gift.

  • @Eeohippus but it is the star of the gig

    the setlist starts with rock'N'roll star

  • liams clearly up for this gig look at the sort of gestures he makes at 1.47 and 2.14 and his face during the song you can clearly see hes up for it LEGEND! any1 who doubts his voice in this gig watch songbird and im outta time in my opinion its the best live version of both songs saw them at murrayfield liam and noel were on top form shame they have split up hopefully a break will do them good and they will be back better than ever LIVE FOREVER BEST BAND EVER!

  • he wants it  faster......

  • Liams voice was dodgy in this gig and a few around this time but in the stadium tour this summer he was amazing, i went to heaton park and it was the best oasis performance i've ever seem, it shat on the city of manchester stadium one a few years earlier!

  • NAHH!! I was at both mate,,,,COMS killed it,,,,!

  • ahh, Liam's a bit flat for this one like the one in Manchester in 05 better

  • To be realistic, you can really hear that Liam is not entirely in control of his voice any more. Either that or he just can't be arsed doing his best on gigs.

    I wonder how far they will get without Noel, I really hope he will soon return and they'll finally be able to get along with each other well.

  • On the morning of this gig, Noel was on Chris Moyles. He asked where was Liam. Noel replied "Put it this way, I left him Thursday night in Cardiff with Rhys Ifans and a load others..."

    So the little twat just can't be arsed to rest his voice!

  • 1:56 wtf? Mistake?

  • Yup. Liam came in too early...

  • whats being said at the start of the song? til 0.10 seconds??

  • Fooooda!

  • how do u get theese???//?!!!!!!

  • pure awsomeness

  • liam is mad for it in this show,iv not seen him lit up like this before,fuckin cool

  • how do u get theeese?? they are amazing

  • u rock

  • 0.45 the guy in the background, Noel calls him a silly wizard. :P

  • really? haha. In Singapore, Noel calls him Decendent of Gandalf from Lord of the rings.

  • everybody loves oasis

    and if u don`t well..u should be stupid or something

  • pulling away from the mic looks cool yeah

    but cuts off your words...

  • i dont think liams voice is awful but ova the years it has changed a lot but hes still good but by his mid 50z i dont think he will be singing but lets hope hell sing forever !

  • I'm a huge Oasis fan, but this is awful.

    Noel and Gem (+ Andy and Chris I suppose) are great, but Liam's really letting them down.

  • Without Liam though, It's not Oasis. Full stop.

  • exactly! Noel cant sing cigarettes and alcohol, rock n roll star etc..like liam can! is singing isnt great here but at heaton park on 4th june he was amazing!

  • thanks for the HQ amazing vids!

  • he smoke all the time

  • why is he getting so out off breath ??????

  • yo was their a slight mix up during this song cus half way through it seems that liam sings a wrong bit or something then the band have to change the tune quick ?

  • Yeah! He starts the second verse a bit too early. Professionals don´t get confused though.. they Rock on...

  • what a drummer!

    a shame he isn't really in the band...

    I must say Liam has a bit trouble with his voice, but it is still good, and no matter what he is the coolest front man ever lived

    but I hope he will still be singing when he is 50, but I doubt it...

  • lol what do you mean he isnt really in the band? just because he hasn't featured on any of their albums yet?

  • well yeah

    they said they are a four piece

    bollocks!

  • that dude on de keyboards it's really peculiar... It's a great fucking show!!

  • the energy chris sharrock brings to the shows is fukin incredible

  • This is the best band they've had with Gem nd Chris, shame it's at the end of their best years.

  • Liam always seems to have a bit of trouble with this one live..even tho its a newer song...oh well...who cares, its a top tune and when ur at the concert u cant even hear the vocal cuz u and evryone around and singing along at the top of their lungs neway!

  • kool song

  • 2:07 - 2:15 =(

  • Falta poco, 3 de Mayo.

  • when you go to an Oasis gig , if your standing there an going oh Liams voice is shit an not goin fuckin mental to their songs then i'm afraid you dont deserve to be at the gig in the first place

  • @mick1983lfc

    man, I love Oasis but I have to be objective...in many live gigs actually Liam sings really horrible...probably he destroyed his vocals with cocaine

  • fuck...liam is enjoying this one

  • who is Lyla? Is it an imaginary charachter?

  • think shes a niece of the older gallagher brother, might be partially wrong there

  • thats disturbing then cuz he says he waited to fuck her

  • Lyla is actually nobody, noel says shes an imaginary groupie lol

  • HAHA, it's an imaginary character you dolt.

  • yeah, noel has joked around saying she is the sister of sally cinnamon mentioned in don't look back in anger.

  • Comment removed

  • He's talking to the soundboard guy!

  • You have your Jagger/Richards, Slash/Rose, Lennon/McCartney, Page/Plant, Tyler/Perry and Mercury/May from the Golden Age. This age will only contain one entity: Noel/Liam.

  • haha fuck me out my mind

  • they call him Gandalf

  • Comment removed

  • What a great Drummer Robbie had... :o)))

  • god exists, he sings on oasis

  • cheers mate.. ;)

  • Liam Gallagher is rumoured to have Vocal Nodules you know, so don't give him a hard time for the dodgy singing and timing in places.

  • Chris Shaddock's a fuckin' sick drummer, around 4.08 when he throws the stick and is still playing, awssummme!!

  • haha yeah i went and watched that over n over lol, very cool, its sharrock btw

  • yea i miss and perfer zac but chris is not bad at all!

  • i'd have to say its same for me zack got a coolness to him i've never seen in any other drummer

  • alan was the best drummer Oasis had

  • You are unbelievable wrong

    Starkey > White

    Chris Sharrock is really good but Zak is the best.

  • i don't know why some magazines said, that "Lyla" is their poorest tracks from "Don'T believe the truth" or one of the poorest ever written.

  • 1:52-2:00. THAT was pretty bad. c'mon Liam. Get your timing right.

  • sometimes his voice struggles to hold up with newer & more blitzier tunes... but he still sounds genius. Can't blame the guy, he's been singin for almost probably 20 years +. I think he's still got it. He's a fuckin rock'n roll singer for god sake, get of his back.

  • Yeeeeeeeeeeah!!! I like this song !!! THX Noel, Riam !!!

  • HEYYYY LYLAAAAAAA!!!

    amazing!!!

    i hate the posers that don`t know oasis i mean who the fuck are u to say one thing bad of them huh!!

    fuck off all the oasis pousers cause those people don`t know what are they talking about!!!if u don`t like oasis don`t say anything about them,cause the oasis`fans don`t keer what you type or say about them and liam`s voice maaybe is not the same but it still sounds fuckin`amazing!!

  • Ur Right m8

  • mad fer it!! you're fucking right!! Oasis are the best band in the world!! cheers!!

  • FUCKING LOVE THE DRUMS AT 1:06

    that transition gets me everytime...saw them live, screamed "FUCK", heard the drums, and was like "YES...THIS IS FUCKING OASIS. IT'S GONNA BE A GOOD NIGHT."

  • I actually think he sounds pretty damn good here.

  • who gives a fuck how liam sounds, the mans a fucking legend so are oasis. mad for it.

  • Liam's voice is good on the rest of the set, he just doesn't sing Lyla well live at all.

  • liam's voice is tired, not in the tone of the song

  • you should listen a little more carefully red hot chilli peppers live... is almost always OFF DUDE, i love the chilli peppers but the Anthony is one of worst singner live...

  • Liam is off tempo 1:56

  • actually it sounds like the guitar missed it's beat

  • well, i do, my favorite band are the Red Hot Chili Peppers, and i promise you that i listen many Chili's Peppers live concerts, and Anthony's voice is more taken care than Liam's voice, its only my opinion, but in this prisice song (Lyla is one of my favorite songs) Liam made his voice sound tired, something sad, but i went to see Oasis show in Mexico City and there Lyla sound better in Liam's voice than here, its onky my opinion :)

    take care!

  • his voice is different not bad

  • Well, I think his voice is amazing. Sounds great to me.

  • Liam was clearly "madferit" this night!!

  • poor liam :(

  • LIAM'S VOICE IS STIIL GREAT..ANYWAY

  • the problem with him is he doesnt have support for his voice, never did...if u rely on ur throat all the time, it will give out and hurt ur vocals....this is the case

  • yeah he cant sing these songs anymore... mainly because he dosent try to he just shouts instead. he should turn up his mike abit and sing along to them

  • he cannot sing this song anymore

  • HIS VOICE IS PISSING EVERYONE OFF ..EVEN HIMSELF LOL ...I THINK HE IS REALLY UPSET TOO BE HONEST AT TIMES . WHEN HE REALISES ITS A BAD VOICE DAY .. these guys 5555500000000000000000000 gigs ect an worked hard an liam always sang his heart out an give it his all ... he trys to do it now an it works because of the passion .. not the sound ... it sounds pretty nasty an he looks like an sounds like he is in alot of pain singing an angry .. only another 50000000 gigs till the end of the tour mate ..

  • he came in way to early on the second verse

  • What is up with Liam's voice?! Is he sick or something?

  • yeah to much gigs he suppose to take a rest more than week maybe before another gig

  • Haha! Read this in the morning, friend. Cheers to ya!

  • Well, first time I saw this video I said : hmmm, something weird around that voice, but the second time : THIS IS PURE ROCK'N ROLL !!!

  • @ 1:05

  • I'm ammused that Liam replaces the word ''blow'' with the word ''fuck'' at the end of the first verse in this performance and the BBC have been playing the whole gig as a loop all day and night since Monday on freeview! Great gig!

  • Hehehe. I noticed that too.

  • Man, Liam is upset with somebody on here.

  • I beg to differ.

  • esta buena lyla

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more