Besides the actually really funny parts, this is a really meaningful, and sad song. "He'll never ever think her perfect as I thought her" made me tear up.
From the tip of his wand burst a silver doe: She landed in the office floor, bounded once across the office, and soared out the window. Dumbledore watched her fly away, as her silvery glow faded he turned back to snape, his eyes were full of tears.
This song gets me every time, no matter how Umbridge I try to become. "You're not gonna cry, you're not gonna cry, you're *James comes on* cuh-RYING!!!!"
honestly in some ways they did the prince's tale better than the movie. they really captured how much of an ass james is and why snape's situation is so devastating
This always makes me feel really bad for Snape. It captures the feelings that you get from this scene (or the scene this is based off) in the books completely. But then I'm conflicted, because Brosenthal is pretty hot as James.
@vegatabletarian But if there was no Harry, Snape would never have died. Would you rather have a bratty teenage boy thinking he can rule the world, or have the bravest man alive?
I've seen this so many times, but this time, I just burst into tears. I think I'm still a little emotionally screwed up from watching deathly hallows 2 last night. I have never cried so much because of a movie in my life. RIP Snape and Remus and Tonks and Fred and half of the characters in Harry Potter. :'(
i have seen the last harry potter movie about a houndred times and if i hear this song now after the amazing memory scene of snape i could cry so hard :/ think that snapes part in the whole harry potter story is the most moving part of harry potter this is a really moving song also and now i am sad somehow because its over now ... somehow so even if i'm in sad motion now beautyful son from starkid :)
Lucius is funny at 3:40 but actually, whenever i hear this part without the laughters, it just breaks my heart. This part of the song "Who'll quench the flame like it's a game with drops of water" is amazingly beautiful, and i couldn't even tell why... The image really moves me, and the rythm is particularly good. Starkids never fails to amaze me =)
Why did they not reuse the Ginny wig for Lily? How hard would that have been? Seriously. That is the only thing that could have made this better and it's so simple.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is great! My dad and I recently stumbled across it leaked online. We found the film at watch harry potter. us (no spaces)
The 8th Harry Potter Movie ended up being fantastic! My cousin and I just now watched it leaked online. We discovered it on watch harry potter. us (w/out the spaces)
I know AVPM and AVPS are supposed to be humorous and everything, but this particular scene really gets to me. I love how they have serious moments like this, as well as the humor. I love you, Snape.
Actully if Snape got Lily then I wouldn't like him so much...I'm all for the people who lose their love....(Rune - COTW, Ashfur - Warriors, Snape - Harry Potter)
Definitely a favorite song of mine from the Sequel. But kudos really go to the band on this take (in my own opinion), at 3:32, the vocals missed the entrance but the instrumentalists managed to keep it together and add an extra couple of notes!
It just shows the genius of Starkid that they make something that I bypassed in the films (and, to be honest, in the books to a certain extent) so brilliant- upsetting and funny all at once. They are amazing!
@PaladinKenny1 Technically, it's not a prequel though. It should be one, but they opened the show with Lucius and the deatheaters after Voldemort died. So because it's a show about them coming into the past, it is a sequel.
@biblegirl Did you see Walker's comment on a message on his FB wall that said: "You wore too much clothes in Starship :[" he replied "just wait til the NEXT one!" :D
@meh3335 Well, then...thumbs up too! ;) In my own case it was just like you said: I already wanted Sev & Lily together before hearing this song, but after hearing it my love for this couple grew only stronger! ♥
Surely a lot of people here are nerdfighters, right? Well, I prompt you to check out "Kony 2012." It will greatly decrease world suck.
Madidog123 6 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
Don't kill Harry!!! You'll destroy the last trace of Lilly Evans :(
MrsGinnyPotterx 1 week ago
:'(
AwkwardNinja98 1 week ago
Awww:(
This just made me cry.
EscapingFromReality 2 weeks ago
There will ALWAYS be guys like Potter ;)
Kickitup15 2 weeks ago 3
Snape yelling, "I'M SORRY!" seriously broke my heart. Crying. </3
1mad9026 3 weeks ago 9
I love how James smacks his butt as he and Lily walk away
Nicoleisawesmazing 3 weeks ago
this and those voices are the best songs in this musical ! <3
me2drescue 3 weeks ago
Besides the actually really funny parts, this is a really meaningful, and sad song. "He'll never ever think her perfect as I thought her" made me tear up.
rgirls16 1 month ago 3
on a side note, Arabella is my 2nd favorite name. Alsaka is the first.
GlitterIsLikeHerpes 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"For HIM?" shouted snape. "Expecto Patronum!"
From the tip of his wand burst a silver doe: She landed in the office floor, bounded once across the office, and soared out the window. Dumbledore watched her fly away, as her silvery glow faded he turned back to snape, his eyes were full of tears.
"All this time severus?
Always." Said Snape.
thelllb 1 month ago
This song makes me cry! Dx
CuPpYcAkEs898 1 month ago 3
He'll never ever think her PERFECT as I thought her! TEARS!!!!!!
alanrickmanobsessor 1 month ago 3
Comment removed
alanrickmanobsessor 1 month ago
Comment removed
alanrickmanobsessor 1 month ago
Comment removed
jdepp102 1 month ago
1 dislike!, thanks hermionie.
TheIrishDesire 1 month ago
Personally, I think the musical handled Snape and Lilly better then the movies...
ajuoy 1 month ago 5
Story of my life
TheWafertastic 1 month ago
Honestly this is one of my favorite parts in the series. Who knew a parady could do so much more than the origanal.
snickers5191 1 month ago 3
someday Draco will be singing "there will always be guys like Weasly"
lilipad90 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 11
2:18 - 2:23: That's how all my relationships go.
2sly4Anyone 2 months ago
This made me feel more for Snape than the movies ever did...
Zawren 2 months ago 9
I can't help but think of Joe Walker actually wearing that Team Jacob shirt in public...that just ruined the mood.
TheSparklybubble 2 months ago
whoever disliked this is a doochebag and a but trumpet because they have a trumpeting butt bwoo bwwoo *butt noises* see who looks stupid now you do
wandspider 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos 4
0.0 Im watching this wih YouTubes snowflake thingy on and its even more sad!
stmb1 2 months ago 2
I swear this song brings me to tears somethings man I was singing it all day and put it in my perspective and almost cried :'(
RosettaSings 3 months ago
...and not enough guys like Sev :'(
Isabellustration 3 months ago
what means thi duchbag or something?thx!
seeWhitelight 3 months ago
cannot get over snape's actual voice..
pirategirl717 3 months ago 5
This song gets me every time, no matter how Umbridge I try to become. "You're not gonna cry, you're not gonna cry, you're *James comes on* cuh-RYING!!!!"
Blubarry123 3 months ago 4
This song makes me cry :'(
RosieVampMoonChild 3 months ago
its funny how this does a better job than Order of the Phoenix movie
mpianozak96 4 months ago 15
Ahhh I so love the people who play Lily and James I want a pre Harry potter musical xD
SiriusSurvives 4 months ago
There will always be guys like Potter.......
GLEENCIS 4 months ago 3
love how you can hear his real voice at 2:33 it's so hot
123coolname 4 months ago 6
Comment removed
MoonAndWisdom 4 months ago
This captures Snape's suffering better than the actual movie
CarpeDiem262 4 months ago 48
Joe's voice changed so much from now to LeakyCon 2011
JRNspoof 4 months ago 2
so many assholes in this place...so many assholes in my face
twist3dlogic89 5 months ago in playlist twist3dlogic89's Favorited Videos 8
this is so sad and yet so funny at the same time! <3
me2drescue 5 months ago 3
lily as wearing a hufflepuff sweater....*cough*
Winniebear892 5 months ago
@Winniebear892 Colour blind much?
manert 5 months ago 4
Butt trumpet XD
hellokid3199 5 months ago
Watch the above video for my unofficial biography.
incinerator327 5 months ago 3
@incinerator327 , we know how ya feel :(
ilovemusic1112l 4 months ago
Did you notice that when Snape said Potter his mouth puffed.
VanillaTwilight80 5 months ago 6
honestly in some ways they did the prince's tale better than the movie. they really captured how much of an ass james is and why snape's situation is so devastating
lambertfan94 5 months ago 10
Who else always notices Joe's cheeks puff out whenever he says "Potter"? I think it's adorable.
kitchenbitchez81 5 months ago 8
i only have one problem with this scene, it makes Lily look shallow.
edvaira 5 months ago 4
It makes me cry everytime I watch it ♥
Hanka243 5 months ago 2
This always makes me feel really bad for Snape. It captures the feelings that you get from this scene (or the scene this is based off) in the books completely. But then I'm conflicted, because Brosenthal is pretty hot as James.
CGwonder 5 months ago 6
They made me cry the first time I watched this.
MoonshoesPotter2877 5 months ago 2
thats why no one is gonna report it! right snape? *SERIOUS FACE*
chocolatechipbffs123 6 months ago 3
I'm still torn up about who should have gotten Lilly...Snape is amazing but there would be no Harry minus James....
vegatabletarian 6 months ago in playlist Avon
@vegatabletarian But if there was no Harry, Snape would never have died. Would you rather have a bratty teenage boy thinking he can rule the world, or have the bravest man alive?
MsNinjaPigs 6 months ago
@MsNinjaPigs I know :( without Harry though no one would have brought Hermionie & Ron together...but i'm a lot more on Snapes side now, thanks :)
vegatabletarian 6 months ago
@vegatabletarian :) Anytime
MsNinjaPigs 6 months ago
@vegatabletarian im glad she ended up with james...snape was her friend and all but i think lily and james is a much better pairing!
AmazingWingedGirl 5 months ago
I've seen this so many times, but this time, I just burst into tears. I think I'm still a little emotionally screwed up from watching deathly hallows 2 last night. I have never cried so much because of a movie in my life. RIP Snape and Remus and Tonks and Fred and half of the characters in Harry Potter. :'(
rraacchh2 6 months ago
That's why no is going to report it, right snape.
CrimsonFlower12 6 months ago
For there will always be guys like weasly
lilipad90 6 months ago
And I cried
SafiraN13 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lily looks like emma watson
Xtenshiii 6 months ago
Comment removed
Xtenshiii 6 months ago
my favourite song of the Sequel ... very awesome, I love Joey ♥
Xtenshiii 6 months ago
Someone needs to make a video of this with HP clips from HP7 part 2 *-*
XxXmIcH3lleXxX 6 months ago 2
This song gives me the chills
kayb1456 6 months ago
I felt so bad for Snape at this moment
TrueGoldenArrow 6 months ago 5
"he'll never ever think her perfect as i thought her" that line made me cry!!
dancergamer18 6 months ago 94
This song brought me to tears..........
CosplayIsLove 6 months ago 8
i have seen the last harry potter movie about a houndred times and if i hear this song now after the amazing memory scene of snape i could cry so hard :/ think that snapes part in the whole harry potter story is the most moving part of harry potter this is a really moving song also and now i am sad somehow because its over now ... somehow so even if i'm in sad motion now beautyful son from starkid :)
akahp1 6 months ago 7
the one dislike is an asshole in snapes face
lisaking013 6 months ago 2
does "James" kind of look like Mclovin to anyone else
co2lneedssomezs11 7 months ago 2
1 dislike?
Thanks Herman!
R12A3E 7 months ago 6
1 dislike?
Draco you little shit!
R12A3E 7 months ago 10
;D;
AnaysiaTheTRex 7 months ago
"He'll never think her as perfect as I thought her" D':
THEM0CK1NGB1RD 7 months ago 48
Lucius is such a manipulative bitch...using Snape's thing for Lily against him....
CharacterStudio 7 months ago 9
This song makes me cry!!!!! Love you snape!!! Lily's a bitch
TheJokerett 7 months ago
I would love to play lily in this musical!
And now i want to give snape a BIG hug and never let go!
hpdisneyfan 7 months ago 5
This and when Snape saw Lily in the mirror had me tearing up :'(
And it's a COMEDY MUSICAL!
partygalxxx1 7 months ago 4
I dont care if people in the audience were laughing and if this was supposed to be funny but this song always makes me cry... its so sad :(
ErnAndMadder 7 months ago
Man...i love how in his memory, Snape uses his real voice! and how his voice changes to that slow penetrating sorrowful voice he uses....>.>
LaL3p0p 7 months ago 3
Love this:D
one of my favorite scenes from AVPS.(:
accioXlovee 7 months ago
and elfs, eh Lucius?
NobodyTossesADwarf91 7 months ago
one of those brilliant starkid songs like Granger Danger which is simultaneously hilarious, musically great, and surprisingly moving
phemyda94 7 months ago 3
Lucius is funny at 3:40 but actually, whenever i hear this part without the laughters, it just breaks my heart. This part of the song "Who'll quench the flame like it's a game with drops of water" is amazingly beautiful, and i couldn't even tell why... The image really moves me, and the rythm is particularly good. Starkids never fails to amaze me =)
BINGUBANG 7 months ago 4
This song gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it... :)
MegaRandomness3 7 months ago 2
This is my favorite from AVPS. It's still keeping the humor, but it also breaks my heart. Joe Moses really is a great actor.
lissa28 7 months ago 7
Why am I crying?!?!
#PostPotterDepression of course.
Oh, Severus <3
Always.
ShalayahRoher 7 months ago 12
Snapes hair looks like Jackie Kennedy's ;)
waterfallstarfall 7 months ago
Why did they not reuse the Ginny wig for Lily? How hard would that have been? Seriously. That is the only thing that could have made this better and it's so simple.
nelle54141 8 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is great! My dad and I recently stumbled across it leaked online. We found the film at watch harry potter. us (no spaces)
BlanchSummers007 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The 8th Harry Potter Movie ended up being fantastic! My cousin and I just now watched it leaked online. We discovered it on watch harry potter. us (w/out the spaces)
CindieiArchul 8 months ago
I know AVPM and AVPS are supposed to be humorous and everything, but this particular scene really gets to me. I love how they have serious moments like this, as well as the humor. I love you, Snape.
GravityFair 8 months ago 14
Why am stupid enough to watch this right after seeing the movie!? Ugh. SOBBING.
TheatreLoverGirl 8 months ago 9
@TheatreLoverGirl I don't know. Thats is about as stupid as I was for watching goodbye Harry Potter videos a day after seeing the film.
90sfanforever 7 months ago
Actully if Snape got Lily then I wouldn't like him so much...I'm all for the people who lose their love....(Rune - COTW, Ashfur - Warriors, Snape - Harry Potter)
chopchop8916 8 months ago 2
James dislikes this video.
Luray2 8 months ago 16
I used to love the Lily/James canon pairing. Untill I read the 7th book. And saw heard this song. </3
Lily/Severus FTW.
Beep12gurl 8 months ago in playlist Darren Freakin Criss 8
@Beep12gurl Me too! I've always thought of James and Lily as the perfect couple but now that I've read Deathly Hallows, I really feel for Severus.
gryffindorseeker1190 8 months ago
I love snape, it will be one of the saddest moments in my life when he dies :O(
pingponggong 8 months ago 4
I can't get used to seeing snape without his robe.
rraacchh2 8 months ago 6
Snape.... Please marry me?!?!?!
CanYouSayBubbles 8 months ago 7
3:53 but now your alone left to pout and moan cause you were totally poned
so funny, but so sad. thumbs up if you love snape!!
AAAAbbyyE 8 months ago 15
@AAAAbbyyE lol, its pwned. XD
Beep12gurl 8 months ago in playlist Darren Freakin Criss
Comment removed
AAAAbbyyE 8 months ago
Fuck emo Alan Rickman, this is the Snape I love.
KagurasSacrifice 8 months ago
This scene actually makes me want to cry every time. :(
whimsykins 8 months ago 6
worlds saddest scene
PinkCowgirl925 8 months ago
Am I the only one who finds Joe Mose's real voice incredibly sexy?
TheMasterArbor 9 months ago 51
So Many Ass Holes ..... In My Face:)
mariahandmeganbieber 9 months ago 4
There are so many Duchebags In this Worldddd!
mariahandmeganbieber 9 months ago
wait wait! im sorry!!!!!
goosebumps
calliecookie2349 9 months ago 3
I don't like Snape at all...And yet I felt SO BAD watching this. Hope the scene in the movie will be at least half as good as this ...
Rim1789 9 months ago 8
It is incredibly ridiculous how much I love Joe Moses' real voice :)
MrsJasper1 9 months ago 10
This ALWAYS makes me cry, no matter how many times I watch it.
POOR SNAPE!
jingling96 9 months ago 4
You know; in 15 years Draco will be singing this song about Ron and Hermine...
spedesalchipmonk 9 months ago 107
@spedesalchipmonk Nope, he is with Luna
BakaKoneko 9 months ago
@spedesalchipmonk "guys like weasley..."
IsabelLuvs2Sing 5 months ago 3
@spedesalchipmonk Except it'll be called Guys Like Weasel :D
TeamEdward173 5 months ago 2
@spedesalchipmonk There will always be guys like WEASLEY
12StrawberryxCream 5 months ago
I never knew that a comic parody musical could make me cry. but you did it, starkid. you did it.
xandycoleman 9 months ago 8
So many assholes in this place.. So many assholes in my face! BEST LINE! lol!
jeanee1228 9 months ago 6
I love Joe(Snape) he's one reason why Snape is my favorite charater....and "the princes tale in DH" is the other reason lol
Sydneyismuwah 9 months ago 6
Definitely a favorite song of mine from the Sequel. But kudos really go to the band on this take (in my own opinion), at 3:32, the vocals missed the entrance but the instrumentalists managed to keep it together and add an extra couple of notes!
Good job!
diewellsemperfi 10 months ago 2
omg i love this!
vickyy518 10 months ago
It just shows the genius of Starkid that they make something that I bypassed in the films (and, to be honest, in the books to a certain extent) so brilliant- upsetting and funny all at once. They are amazing!
believeinitshona 10 months ago 5
Everytime I watch this I nearly cry.
sandro7418 10 months ago
TYLER TYLER TYLER TYLER <3
dancewithliz07 10 months ago 6
What is up with that random patch of wierd hair on Lucious' head?
angelxmusic 10 months ago
Thumbs up if you want A Very Potter Prequel. They already have a cast!
biblegirl 10 months ago 252
@biblegirl this practically is the Prequel.
MrMatto91 8 months ago
@MrMatto91 No, I meant do a whole musical about the Maurders, Lily, and Snape!
biblegirl 8 months ago
@biblegirl actually..i just want anything with Joe Walkers Abs....
helloworld10145 8 months ago
@biblegirl that would be awesome! ironically, though, this really is a prequel.
PaladinKenny1 8 months ago
@PaladinKenny1 Technically, it's not a prequel though. It should be one, but they opened the show with Lucius and the deatheaters after Voldemort died. So because it's a show about them coming into the past, it is a sequel.
RFazz15 7 months ago
@biblegirl Oh my gosh I'm confused! Can you explain how making a prequel thing... It doesn't makes sense to me! ghaaa D:
Sunlightexplosion 7 months ago
@Sunlightexplosion Snape, Lily, and James as students
biblegirl 7 months ago
@biblegirl Ahhhh, all right. I get ya now. I was confused with the whole sequel already being like a prequel kind of thing haha.
Sunlightexplosion 7 months ago
@biblegirl Did you see Walker's comment on a message on his FB wall that said: "You wore too much clothes in Starship :[" he replied "just wait til the NEXT one!" :D
GetABridgeToMe 7 months ago 4
@biblegirl there will always be guys like Weasley
SimpleStupidness8B 6 months ago 3
@biblegirl Aparently there will be!:)
HanaAndKels 6 months ago
@biblegirl do you want a threequel? cause here comes one!
RJA10001 6 months ago
@RJA10001 Joey literally just said on his livestream that NOTHING is confirmed.
biblegirl 6 months ago
I love Severus!!! I never really liked James. He was so arrogant and conceited. But I LOVE Severus!!! :) SSLE!!! LS!!! :)
MoonGoddessSunGod 10 months ago
Awe! I never really thought anything of him being in love with Lily until this song! Poor Severus:(
Sydneyismuwah 10 months ago 4
If you wanted Severus and Lily get together after you heard this song, thumbs up!
romychan18 10 months ago 15
@romychan18 What if you already wanted Sev & Lily together BEFORE hearing this song?
meh3335 10 months ago 5
@meh3335 Well, then...thumbs up too! ;) In my own case it was just like you said: I already wanted Sev & Lily together before hearing this song, but after hearing it my love for this couple grew only stronger! ♥
romychan18 10 months ago
@romychan18 I know what you mean lol! *thumbs up your comment*
meh3335 10 months ago
@meh3335 Then ur awesome.
biblegirl 10 months ago
Comment removed
romychan18 10 months ago
Comment removed
romychan18 10 months ago
Looks like Joe is going to cry ;__;
FrederikaBernkastel 10 months ago 8
@FrederikaBernkastel we'll snape probably would. wouldnt you?
hunty54 10 months ago
@hunty54 Of course I wolud, but you know he's not Snape but he can feel Snape's emotion, that's sad, but sweet ;__;
FrederikaBernkastel 10 months ago 2
Joe Moses better sing in Starship.
whizzywantstowrite 10 months ago 10
I actually cried a little just now. :( poor snape
liesjeeeWxX 10 months ago 4
This is amazing! XD
btw, Where do you get all these clips for your videos?
TheHuntressQueen 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did anyone else notice he drops the voice when he said "I dont need help from a filthy little Mudblood like her"? lol :)
dinosaurz109 11 months ago
Did anyone else notice he drops the voice when he said "I dont need help from a filthy little Mudblood like her"? lol :)
dinosaurz109 11 months ago 9
WTF? Who would dislike this???
tornado9898 11 months ago 3
@tornado9898 THAT BASTARD
Bbodysplash 11 months ago
snapes memory actually hurts my heart </3
00Manga0Lover00 11 months ago 8
Snape kicks @ss! He was amazing in this song!
hanshandslover 11 months ago
It's weird to hear Joe use his real voice when talking... I'm so used to the Snape voice.
mokeylovescohen 11 months ago
idk weither or not to laugh or cry at Snape's flashback :(
Sendria 11 months ago