Added: 3 years ago
From: Sarkesian46
Views: 1,194,769
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,175)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I just love the girl at the end who screams "go Miley"

  • Mariah, Beyonce, and Mary J Blige are the best..but Mariah is the QUEEN of all music, I'm sorry but she should be in the center

  • Stand up for Ms. Blige!

  • Beyoncé in the middle. They know what it is!

  • best part of mariah xD

    

  • the first time i heard this, in the begining i swear i heard someone say "she looks so outta place ...shes not moving at all... mariah!"

  • Mariah is the only true legend on that stage, I'm sorry.

  • @yellowtents I agree But Mary is pretty far up there also, she is amazing but MAriah is the TRUE legend.

  • @yellowtents You're right! ;D

  • beyonce to miley was like "what the hell guurrrl???"

  • Dont'get my dislike wrong.Video resolution and whole video really sux

  • y is miley there? 

  • @dfbvfgb Y is it wrong that she is ther to suport it??

  • Lmao @ the song description. Yeah, Duffy, Solange and the PussycatDolls are definitely NOT in this song. Nicole is in the live version to replace Melissa Ethridge who's on the actual recorded version. Then you have Rihanna, Beyonce, Ashanti, Keyshia Cole, Natasha Beddingfield, Leona Lewis, Miley Cyrus, Mary, Mariah, Fergie, Ciara, and Carrie Underwood.

  • MILEY ♥

  • DIVA FERGIE eu te AMOOOOOOOOOO

  • carrie all the way~

  • Beyonce and Mary J were great, but Mariah was amazing...as always

  • Beyonce diva!!

  • im laughing at mileys voice

  • Mariah Carey's voice heard at any surprises. She is amazing, sing like no other.

  • It's not about who has the worst or best voice, it's about the message behind the song.. Think about that instead.

  • Mary J. Blige has a new single called 25/8 it has an old school soul feel to it, check it out!!!

  • In my support to breast cancer this morning, I'm going to a festival all weekend, I'm going to draw a ribbon on my hand & wear my breast cancer t-shirt going around asking people to donate to breast cancer people. & Then I'm going up to my local hospital & donating all the money there. JSU<3

  • Mariah!!! & idk i actually like Miley's part. She added a cool twist to it. But that's my opinion. MARIAH!!!!!!! lol

  • whatever rhianna said to beyonce at the end looked rude

  • They are missing the one and only Christina Aguilera

  • @Obeelady i agree

  • mariah is the best ..

    

  • BEYONCE >>>>

  • Mary J. Blige was the best!!!

  • Beyonce had the most distinct voice. They were all great, except for a few whom other people have already named before this comment :)

  • 'Through Whatever" Mariah carey part is the best part song :) awesome song :) amazing vocals :) congrats GIRLS :)

  • as if you askd who carrie underwood was lol

  • miley was 15 here! now she sings great! shut the hell up

  • I like Mary J Blige<33 And they shouldn't have put Miley Cyrus there!! The song's better off without her..she sounds LIKE A FROG, dammit!! I twitch whenever I hear her line <//3 She sounded a LITTLE better in the studio version though.. OH THE WONDERS OF TECHNOLOGY!!! :) Ughh, Miley Cyrus' voice sounds so bad.. so so bad.

  • Amazing song. Amazing voices. Of course Beyonce was phenomenal ... Natasha and Leona did really great to... I can;t hear Mariah's whistles...if she even did them.... Everyone was really good. I just personally think Rihanna and Miley's parts should have been switched. Rihanna's voice is just more pleasing than Miley's but that's a personal preference. Very good song with a lot of talent on the stage. LOVED IT

  • what about natasha bedingfield ? she's amazing

  • 32 pple dont know how to resist there hippos just move with the pain not fight against it

  • beyonce is the business in this song she has the strongest voice over all of them she is awesome nd ciara didnt do anything in this song miley should really stop trying to sing she sucks nd fergie can't sing at all why does she try? Beyonce, Mariah Carey, and Mary J. Blige rocked this song. especially beyonce

  • beyonce sounds the best(:

  • Miley sounds awful lol

  • BEYONCÉ !! <3

  • Mariah Carey <3

  • @hottysexfemale, it sounds like you're struggling with a huge loss in your life. I can certainly understand being upset and hurt and angry at having suffered such a tremendous loss. However, many of the people who have died of cancer did so with hope in their hearts. I'm certainly going to pray for you.

  • BEYONCE ♥

  • miley sucks !!! i can think of sooo many other great female artist to take her place ... alicia keys,celine dion, but i guess they need somone younger in there to generate awareness to kids that age tho :) ... ugh wtf is the world coming too, if kids now grow up thinking ppl like miley cyrus is a singer ... smh

  • i love beyonce!!!!

  • miley looks a hot mess LOL

  • miley sing what?

  • Mariah <3

  • Cyrus :)

  • Go Leona!!!

  • Miley should choose a new career.

  • natasha sound good~~she always good in live~

  • once again.. miley cyrus ruins another great song.. SMFH

  • celine dion they don't have but miley cyrus they do.... are you fucking kidding 

  • I LOVE THIS SONG IT'S NOT ONLY FOR CANCER PATIENTS, BUT ALSO FOR THOSE PEOPLE WHO ARE STRUGGLING IN LIFE. VERY INSPIRATIONAL. KEEPS ME PUMP UP WHEN LISTENIN TO THIS. THX FOR THE UPLOAD

  • part 2 .......and theyre never coming back. and you get to see your stupid parents grandparents or friends dying of cancer and its hilarious. because theyre worthless. and now theyre dead! how funny was it to see them peeing in a bag and half comatose the last few months of their lives? theyre dead. and never coming back. youll never talk to them again. they cant see you. they cant hear you. its like they never existed.

  • this is for anyone who ever had someone close to them who died of cancer. im sure we can all remember these people. how much we loved them. their smiles. what they gave us. and how much pain they endured as cancer ate their body. slowly killing them off and bit by bit tearing them to pieces until their souls had nothing left to cling on to. the black tumors just spreading through them and now they're dead.

  • Take Nicole and Miley would have made it better, Brandy should have been here.

  • 2:22 " through watheveeeeeeeeer " Love MC !

  • Beyonce is the queen !

  • Rihanna and Miley sound horrible!!

  • @Celeyahh Nahh Rihanna sound good,miley on the other hand sound like a suffocated duck.(;

  • go carrie!!!

  • Mariah n Mary J. parts R the best ...... rihannas n mileys part would have been better if sombody other the miley was with rihanna

  • MARIAH!!!

  • Mariah !!!!

  • im not a hater of MILEY. But her voice IN THIS PERFORMANCE sux. :>

  • @junjoubrian she sounds like a goat ...cute goat -_-

  • Répondre à cette vidéo... 4:18 just millions of dollars walkin' away 

  • i think mariahs and marys part is the best and the worst is mileys and rihannas !!!

  • @Sj2690 Exactly!!! Mary was powerful!!!! as with Mimi..Carrie was Awesome as well..

  • @Sj2690 nah rihanna was actually good for once

  • @Sj2690 really? what did Rihanna or Miley did to you? This is a song to stand up to cancer so shut up and enjoy the song, and stop hating

  • Solange, Duffy, and the Pussycat Dolls were not present for this performance just to let you know.

  • this makes me wonder will miley would hav ever made it as a singer without all the editing and deleting cause live it really sounds oringinal in a bad way SUGGEST THAT SHE DO NOMORE LIVE VIDEOS AND STICK TO THE EDITING AND STUDIO

  • Sorry but Miley fucked up... she sounds really bad

  • MARIAH your amazing! but Miley? Why are you in this song when you hardley have any breasts? HAHA.

  • god miley cyrus sucks ass but everyone else is good and i love this song, i think they should have got Demi Lovato to sing with them not Miley Cryus :(

  • beyonce and carrie underwood sound super good cant believe this is live they were the best ones

  • Miley cyrus is fucking awful!!!!!!! she sounds like a duck!!!!!!!

  • @MultiWalford Nah a duck sounds better XD

  • i wish mariah had done her whistle here like in the original recording!! but she had a lot of harmonizing and background singing tho!

  • @kirkfortune mariah is rude, she turned her bac to the other singers as if she is too good for them. go lipsync some more noob mariah

  • @shellbsd23 ohhh yah ok top hatin on mariah...go hate sum were else

  • @shellbsd23 Bc mariah is simply better. She is a legand. <3333

  • @shellbsd23 Bc mariah is simply better. She is a legand. <3333 you go MIMI!!!!!!! :D

  • @shellbsd23 hello!!!! they r not at the same level as mariah!!! they should have given her own stage!! lol

  • Great song! One of the best songs ever made.

  • wow...thanks for the video...i like beyonce and mariah's voice...i wish they got a chance to sing more...anyway for all those saying things abotu miley, you guys have to understand that she's not really a vocalist...and back then she was underage, so just leave her alone and let her have some fun with these divas.

  • Miley Cyrus sounds off tone! :'(

  • miley kinda sounded bratty.

  • whos that boy next to miley?

  • @ReGandolf haha lol thats rihanna

  • @ReGandolf  That's RIHANNA!

  • miley is aboslutely atrocious. She should be taken to Iraq and stoned

  • Mariah <3

  • Thee chick in the white pants needs to pull down her shirt ....

  • I think Miley Was Quite Fine..

  • i really hate mariah she's too humble. she lacks black peoples nature to overwhelm . She really got outshined despite the fact that she's the best of them all. whatver !humble really kills my ego and pride lol. :S demmmmm if i were Mariah i would've SHUT THE FUCK UP EVERYONE BY DOING MY WHISTLE REGISTER THROUGHOUT THE SONG AND GET EVERYONE ORGASMED. TOO BAD THAT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN. DEM FANTASY

  • @MsBrowse lol i dont hate her but i do hate the fact she didnt bust out a whistle note lol

  • Mary J looks older than Mariah Carey but then it's otherwise. And yea. Mariah Carey debut first before anyone else in the group. Might be the prime factor she been chosen for the climax part of the song.

  • my fault. not dubbed. xD

  • this version DUBBED. :)

  • bitch in the white pants..

  • beyonce is irreplaceable!!!

  • LEONA <3

  • Miley has a god voice, but her voice hasnt matured enough to sing with them

  • @MartinezFreddie What the fuck is your problem? Mariah Carey didn't lip-synch this one. This august rendition was live in its entirety! The reason why you think she lip-synched was perhaps because of her whistle register portion, but let me remind you that a vocalist is entitled to doing one thing at once only; Mariah can't belt and whistle simulataneously. That's an unachievable feat - completely impossible. She was belting, for fuck's sake! Listen before you make hasty, silly extrapolations.

  • MARIAH CAREY!

  • Gawd, I hate it when people blindly rant about things they dislike about something, ignoring the main point of the thing. In this case, people blabbing about Miley and Rihanna, ignoring that they did this song for a great purpose.

    If we all just stand up? To what? I think you stupid (yes, stupid) people took this song's meaning wrongly. It's stand up to cancer, not Miley or Rihanna.

    Shame.

    Today, we need a song about standing up to hate.

  • @KHQMaster so people can't have an open opinion

  • Comment removed

  • i like the whole song with all those mileys and rihannas. for me they sound all right. and i think rihanna is not bad at all, her voice is great

  • BEYONCE ROCKS ALL THEM!!! LUV YAAA QUEEN BEYONCE!!!<3<3<3

  • fergie is so good but miley RUINS the whole song she sound so werid

  • miley cyrus could have been replaced by alicia keys and ciara could have been replaced by jennifer hudson

  • @cantcompareme I agree!!

  • @cantcompareme Could have also had some legends e.g - Chaka or Patti??

  • Beyonce is just on another level than every single one of them.

  • @thedisneygirl1234 you are right EXEPT FOR mariah carey and maybe also Mary J. Blige...

  • @thedisneygirl1234 beyonce is good i love her but she cant touch mariah no one can

  • @christinaaguilerafa1 She is good, but over rated. The reason people thing she is so amazing is cause she can hit high notes. But the truth is that there are actually alot of celebrities who can hit notes like she does. They just don't because it's not their style.

  • @thedisneygirl1234 tell me another artist in this generation that can hit the whistle register, and do it well she is not over rated she worked hard to be where she's at.People can hit high notes, buts its so rare the whistle register

  • BEYONCE LOVE YOU

  • STOP FUCKING MOVING THE CAMERA!!!!

  • @typicalteenagewaste woof, you are a teenage waste.

  • weeeee love mariah carey part!!!!!!!!! you can hear her vocal runs and melisma

  • Love This Song Beyonce Was The Best...Should Of Been Rihanna And Ciara Singing That Part Instead Of Miley But Miley Did A Good Job Doe...

  • carrie underwood, <3

  • mariah didnt lip at all.. all the whistle notes where prerecorded and puted as part of the music.. mariah cant whistle and belting at the same time...

  • am not surprised rihanna and miley had the least to sing combined...just saying! :O

  • what was wrong with miley's voice she sounded like she had something in her throat

  • beyonce is gorgeous as allways!!!!!!!!!!

  • DONT GET ME WRONG I HATE THE GUY BUT THEY COULD BETTER HAVE JUSTIN BIEBER SING THE PART OF MILEY!! FFS HER VOICE IS SO FUCKED UP, MAKES ME WANNA MURDERRRR HER

  • @AznJulian i for one agree

  • @AznJulian girl justin beiber wasnt even thought of when they did this. but i do agree they shoudlve repaced miley with somebody else but it was for a good cause, dont listen to her sing listen to the damn words.

  • Um Imma say this

    MARIAH LIPSYNCED THIS SHIT

    Look at the parts where she hits the "high notes" FAKE

    WTF is up with Miley?

    At the end when they are all hugging she's like"I'm too cute for y''all"

    Hello, you are in the same room as Madonna, Beyonce,Leona Lewis,Rihanna,ETC.

  • Leona Is so incredible! I get chilled when I hear her sing <3

  • fergie and miley's voices didnt sound good at all here :(

  • Did anyone notice that beautiful transitional note by Leona-it was amazing.

  • @mc1ate1mad1cow Shame don't get the credit or promotion she deserves!

  • hahahahah @ ciara trying to get Mariah Carey's attention from 3:40 onwards

  • besides,mariah's lines are in much higher key - something which when Carrie attempted to do-sounded way off albeit loud.

  • This is like our solar system except there are two suns here.I'll let you'll figure out who those two are.

    One is the 2nd biggest selling female artist of all time.The other is a melismatic queen just like the former.

  • @mc1ate1mad1cow Mariah and beyonce?

  • mileyy ruined this beautiful songgg gosh

  • Mariah's vocals are louder than everyone else! She's so powerful, in the dubbed version they quietened her down lol!

  • this dude cant fuckin video to save his life man dam

  • OMG my dream is to see mariah live in a stage....but i don't think i will see her.. she wont come to my country and i cant afford to travel to country where she sings...and you my friend is a lucky one you saw most of the artist in one place...lucky you

  • this song is very good and they are all good singers except from MILEY CYRUS

  • MILEY CYRUS IS SO GREAT! she's a good singer..

  • MILEY CYRUS IS SO GREAT! she's a good singer..

  • why would you put MILEY CYRUS on the same stage as these amazing artist. she sounds bad and like she's trying to oversing them. but c'mon MILEY CYRUS?! really?!

  • @lambychop98 thats wat im sayin MILEY CYRUS MEST IT UP

  • Great Video, I am so happy you put it up, it gives me a whole different light on my sickness!!

  • 10 ladies singing at once? :D Wonderful

  • Miley has gotten a lot better... that that anyway. still not amazing by any standards

  • leona lewis is the best female singer ever born, simple as that beyonce ;)

  • miley cyrus sounds like daffy duck taking a dump!!!!!

  • i really love the song, but sorry, i think miley totally RUINS it!

  • @Sandynotblonde bitch 

  • Comment removed

  • I don't really understand why Miley is in this song, she dosnt really compare to the others and dosnt sound very good in this at all

  • miley is better!

  • Lindo, muito lindo

    *_*

  • omg miley sounds like a duck!

  • @tigerbite01 LMAO, true so true, her voice makes me sick ughh

  • @tigerbite01 i bet u sound lik one and look lik one okay so shut the fuck up and also miley sings like 500000000000000000000000000000­00000000000000000 times better so get a life!!

  • ahahaha at the 26 people who dislike, i hope you burn in hell, how do you dislike a video giving inspiring people to help stop cancer? how dare you even call yourself a person..... please be serious