If the grandson were dead, why would the medical professional (the nurse) feed into the woman's delusion by asking how his throat was doing? It would seem that by aiding in this manner, it would put the elderly woman through more unnecessary treks through unsafe territory. Can an English teacher contact me and give me their opinion?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i have homework for this bullshit story for my english class. i just read it and watched this and part one too. what a waste of time. just some nigger hag on a pointless walk seeking sympathy from others. nigger wants attention. -_-
this proves that just any dumb moron can be considered an author.
Thank you, ShakespeareAndMore....thank you. All three of the related videos were beautiful. Had you not placed them here on YT, I would have never of run across them. These videos warmed my heart...even the interview! Each made me laugh and cry...giving me priceless insight into this brilliant Literary piece. I had no choice but to share the link(s) with my classmates. Thanks again...
Thank you for this video. I still do not understand what they say. cuz i m deaf. but i watch what they do and act. lol.. it would help me little. I have to understand A Worn Path what it talk about because the student and i will discuss about it in my english class.
The thing that doesn't ring true to me about this story (either this movie or the story itself) is it shows white people mostly being civil, in those old days in the *South* no less, to a black person. The only "heck" she got was the hunter, and even he wasn't that mean to her! lol So I wonder how realistic it is.
i liked this video quite a likeness to the story, without the forest trek that is so symbolic. She is like the phoenix bird that crashes to the earth to be born again beautiful and golden. Is this the symbolism? how many others symbolism?
It is quite possible that this senile old lady made up a grandson, out of loneliness. However, I think her grandson has already been dead. We have to pay attention to her name, Phoenix, which made this story even more profound.
Nah, the author said the short story was supposed to be straightforward. She thought she had failed as a writer when she heard people had wrongly misinterpreted the grandson.
Some people say that Phoenix's grandson is dead. Others believe that he is at home alive waiting for his medicine.
In a class discussion about this short story, my professor said that Phoenix's grandson was made up. Old Phoenix does not have a grandson! She even forgot about his existence when she was asked by the nurse how he was doing!
What do you guys think of that? Do you agree or disagree?
english 30-1 woot woot
kavewoman1 3 weeks ago
why does the door say colored? does that mean its a clinic just for black people?
leenzin 3 months ago
@leenzin The story is set in the early-mid 1900's, in Mississippi. Back then, the South was still segregated between blacks and whites.
PookieDude1 1 month ago
If the grandson were dead, why would the medical professional (the nurse) feed into the woman's delusion by asking how his throat was doing? It would seem that by aiding in this manner, it would put the elderly woman through more unnecessary treks through unsafe territory. Can an English teacher contact me and give me their opinion?
MrRJMGREEN 4 months ago
@NverEnoughDeathMetal Ahhh yes, ignorance is bliss. Writing is overated anyways. Thank you for your valuable comments.
TheNeoviva 6 months ago
7TH PERIOD FTW!! :)
KristenMunoz1 6 months ago 3
i wish there were subs :(
xsamdabrax 6 months ago 2
HI MS. BOOTH's 5TH PERIOD ENG. 3 IB CLASS!
joroxoutloud 6 months ago 9
@joroxoutloud 7TH PERIOD TOO (:
MinJi14 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i have homework for this bullshit story for my english class. i just read it and watched this and part one too. what a waste of time. just some nigger hag on a pointless walk seeking sympathy from others. nigger wants attention. -_-
this proves that just any dumb moron can be considered an author.
NverEnoughDeathMetal 7 months ago
@NverEnoughDeathMetal
you stupid prick!
creolelady182 6 months ago
what a sweet grandma..this story is so touching
eunji554 8 months ago
4:45
"My grandson"
Me riffing: "Oh fuck, I KNEW I forgot SOMETHING!"
tehcoolcan 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Holy Hell! That's Berta from Two and a half Men!!!
EvolutionAdaptation 9 months ago
Holy Hell! That's Berta from Two and a half Men!!!
EvolutionAdaptation 9 months ago 2
That crafty old lady sure likes Nickles
blacklabel3980 10 months ago
Thank you, ShakespeareAndMore....thank you. All three of the related videos were beautiful. Had you not placed them here on YT, I would have never of run across them. These videos warmed my heart...even the interview! Each made me laugh and cry...giving me priceless insight into this brilliant Literary piece. I had no choice but to share the link(s) with my classmates. Thanks again...
MsSunflower93 11 months ago
THANK YOU FOR POSTING THIS STORY IT MADE IT A LOT EASY TO UNDERSTAND MY CLASS IT IS VERY SAD I HAD TEARS...
celanerose 1 year ago 2
on a scale of 100 how close is this move to the book?
monkeyboiz1 1 year ago
@monkeyboiz1 eh they cut some lines but it's pretty damn close really close to how i imagined it as reading it
It's only a 6 page story not to hard to read if you can focus
I have class in 4 and a half hours so i'm trying to understand it more
Rh3ttD4v1s 1 year ago
@monkeyboiz1 I would say really close near 100 it did not add anything new. just brought the story to life.
Barbiequeen89 10 months ago
to think this old lady was a child fully of enegy before wow why do we get old ? ..this video help me for my journal for literature class
86ambition 1 year ago 2
ii
muskanstha 1 year ago
she is veryyy old woman
muskanstha 1 year ago
Thanks for uploading it. It helped me a lot for my literature.
rockm4u 1 year ago
so my English professor was the director of this movie.
I missed class when he played it for us. So thanks for posting it up on youtube!
RisseGurl 1 year ago
love eudora welty!
henrygrove100 1 year ago
I never want to get that old and crazy. I would rather die in a flaming sword battle than be so weak like that.
SurferShan 1 year ago
thank you so much for this!!! i just followed along with the story and am ready to ace my quiz tomorrow
m5pat 1 year ago
Why do they all call her grandma?
Nique414 1 year ago
@Nique414 like back den u kno how they recognize black men as "boy" so im figuring maybe thats way.. dont quote me on it
diddy23223 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Nique414 like back den u kno how they recognize black men as "boy" so im figuring maybe thats way.. dont quote me on it
diddy23223 1 year ago
such a fucked up story
bhabooshka 1 year ago
Lovely video. Catches the spirit of Ms. Welty's wonderful story. Thanks.
(I'm amazed at the immaturity of many of the comments here.)
lkpeapod 1 year ago 2
I am student of American Literature, I found this video for my class and I have to add that I love the 2 parts. Thanks for making this effort for us.
Grace Casal
graciecu 1 year ago
thanks... dman... the written story was too long
keysle 2 years ago
Thank you for this video. I still do not understand what they say. cuz i m deaf. but i watch what they do and act. lol.. it would help me little. I have to understand A Worn Path what it talk about because the student and i will discuss about it in my english class.
Kimmiekimstar 2 years ago
The thing that doesn't ring true to me about this story (either this movie or the story itself) is it shows white people mostly being civil, in those old days in the *South* no less, to a black person. The only "heck" she got was the hunter, and even he wasn't that mean to her! lol So I wonder how realistic it is.
tall32guy 2 years ago
i liked this video quite a likeness to the story, without the forest trek that is so symbolic. She is like the phoenix bird that crashes to the earth to be born again beautiful and golden. Is this the symbolism? how many others symbolism?
sandra204 2 years ago
It is quite possible that this senile old lady made up a grandson, out of loneliness. However, I think her grandson has already been dead. We have to pay attention to her name, Phoenix, which made this story even more profound.
engfilms2008 2 years ago
Yeah that's possible. It makes you wonder why she gets the medicine then. Maybe I'm slow... lol
tall32guy 2 years ago
Nah, the author said the short story was supposed to be straightforward. She thought she had failed as a writer when she heard people had wrongly misinterpreted the grandson.
Reflectinglight18 2 years ago
It would have been better if it had zombies and space ships in it.
tyler6859 2 years ago
Comment removed
tyler6859 2 years ago
This is such a powerful short story!
Some people say that Phoenix's grandson is dead. Others believe that he is at home alive waiting for his medicine.
In a class discussion about this short story, my professor said that Phoenix's grandson was made up. Old Phoenix does not have a grandson! She even forgot about his existence when she was asked by the nurse how he was doing!
What do you guys think of that? Do you agree or disagree?
Thanks!
ewertonduarteolson 2 years ago 2
not even gonna lie, Phoenix looks a bit like E.T.
Cagae 3 years ago 15
Thank you for posting it, it really helped me get this story!
=]
lizbabys05 3 years ago 7
My class just got finished reading this story. This video will help tremendously. Thanks!
joettaj08 3 years ago
Thank you for posting this classic. I love your videos.
PippinPogle 3 years ago