Added: 4 years ago
From: Famousgrl2
Views: 94,872
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (243)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • its suck!

    First of all he is mix in the lyrics...0 plus a bar!

  • its suck!

  • it lacks BITE, of all things.

  • He is a good singer and does a good job with MTK...BUT....it's NOT.....a love serenade type song. TB was right. Bobby Darin did this song as a gangster type melody. But ok all the same from Blake

  • This version is nothing compared to Clay's version!.

  • AWESOME!

  • awesome voice for jazz

  • Blake did a very good cover at Mack The Knife, but nobody can do it better than good old Bobby!

  • Is it bad that I loved this?

  • Agreed. This isn't a song you sing- this is almost a song you should growl. The way this is song, it totally loses its meaning. =p

  • I agree. It's sung too soft. There is no shark's bites in this song.

  • he's got a really nice voice. this was one of his performances I really remember.

  • I like how Simon's standards are much higher than those of the other jury members ^^ Sometimes it's like he's the only one daring to criticize people.

  • TONY: (sigh) This song is pre-rap.

    BLAKE: (say what?) Sure, sure!

  • a gay mack the knife?

  • It's not that he's a gay mack the knife that makes this hilarious, it's that he's so feminine--he almost sings it like a young girl would. I don't think anyone be worried about Mack after hearing Blake singing this song. Blake's a good singer, but he's funny as hell when he sings this song. Thanks for the laugh.

  • Pedestrian.

    Great Beatboxer, though.

  • Blake ur The blake .. he's preforming this song just like Bobby darin

  • sorry you got that so wrong...he aint NOTHING like bobby darin!!!

  • he doesn't smile when he performs

  • clay > blake in this song....

  • He maybe a lot of things but he is not "Mack" worthy,

  • EnFadada

  • Is he ever gonna have a second cd???

  • unfortunately , he was dropped from his label :[

    so it's not looking good for him. which sucks. because he's ridiculously talented.

  • OMG!!!! MY LIFE IS COMING TO A TRAGIC END!!! Blake I love you!!!!!@!!

  • but hes got resigned to tommy boy records, and hes not even half done yet^^ he also producing a collaboration record himself with KJ Sawka (his drummer), so his future doesnt look too bad eh? ^_^

  • AHHH REALLY?! i hadn't heard that! i'm so pumped now :]

  • i'm on the fence with this performance.

  • i absolutely love Blake!! he's funny and just so talented!! Not to mention, cute. :-)

  • Blake is smexy. :)

  • hes so cute :))

  • blake made the song a contemporary one that kids our age would like... hahahaha

  • I usually don't care for him, but this was great here.

  • all right clay may have the voice but blake have that certain something and thats is irrepaceable both are great but I prefere blakes version

  • WOW fancy footwork at 1.29 - 1.33

    This is why I love him, he could pull off any style.

    Also [personally] I think he's the next Justin Timberlake!

  • Clay is the better singer

    But Blake is a great performer

    and they both have good voices!

    =]

  • So, I just watched Clay Aiken's version of this. And then I thought I would give Blake a chance and watch his version...oh my gosh. This is really bad. For those who this this is VOCALLY well done, go watch Clay's version. Seriously.

  • I disagree. Blakes is way better. I think it's just who you like better all around. Other wise, you would also say that Blake's is better

  • No...I actually dont like Blake's because he is a bad singer. He has no range and cant hold a note to save his life. If it wasnt for that stupid beatboxing, there is NO way he would have made it that far.

  • the only thing Aiken does better than this guy is be extremely gay. he's good at that.

  • Wow. You are ignorant. Congratulations.

  • Didn't care for either version. Tony Bennett had it right. Blake didn't "get" the song. Clay was better, but still not great. Westlife does a decent version. But you can't beat the versions by Sinatra, Darrin, and Louis Armstrong.

  • I love both versions.

    What you people don't get

    is that Blake and Clay have two toally different styles

    Clay is pop

    and Blake is Hip-Hop, Electronica.

    They both sound great

    ps I am HUGE fans of both Clay and Blake

  • blake rocks

  • He killed it.

    Bobby Darrin, Louis Armstrong, Ella Fitzgerald, Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra.. only people that should sing this song.

  • amen!

  • psh it sounded so much better faster. blake knows what hes doing, and i dont think anyone should have to critique him. bon jovi wasnt even sure if he should of done what he did. but it always turns out good.

  • I'm sorry but he slayed it, no swing in his voice. I'm sure hes a great singer and probably a really nice guy but this dosn't work.

  • embarassing

  • im sorry but your an idiot falcon clay's version kills this

  • agreed.

  • Nobody does it like Bobby Darrin sorry!

  • 1. NO WAY could Clay Aiken EVER smoke Blake Lewis- in any way shape or form!

    2. Blake doesn't need to "have anything" on Bobby Darrin because it's two totally different styles- you can't POSSIBLY compare them.

    3. Blake did an awesome job on this song- if this performance doesn't convince you, you should really download the studio version. While this is good, the studio version is much better!

  • Clay Aiken smokes this guy!

  • definitly

  • This guy's got nothing on Bobby Darrin.

  • This is one of my favorites.

  • You should listen to his studio version. So much much better!

  • he was good,

    but i still prefer clays version.

    clay seems to have more controll over his voice, and can keep his pitch better.

    but blake was good.

  • i agree.

    blake's good.; clay has better control/range.

    BUT clay can't beatbox ;)

  • hes cute and hes good :)

  • I love how he ends the song. That's the best part. Great job on this one too Blake!

  • I liked this performance of Mack the Knife just as much as any I ever heard including Bobby Darin's.

  • Actually this song was first sung in 1928/1929... You guys know nothing... Google "Moritat Von Mackie Messer" It was first sung by Bertolt Brecht... It's a german song... Lol.. Bobby Darrin just translated it to English and sings it best in English.. You guys know nothing..

  • who is the elderly guy in the beginning?

  • that is THE tony bennett

  • wow really?

  • Sorry.. Bobby Darin was the first to sing this song.. he actually wrote it. For all you "lamer's" on youtube ville.. search "Mack The Knife".

    Bobby Darin wrote this song in 1959. DURRRR!!!

    Sinn

  • ... please go do anything resembling research on the song. Louis Armstrong recorded it years before Darin did, and that was over two decades after it was written.

  • i am british and clay is better

  • my favorite thing about him singing this is that...he sang it on my BIRTHDAY! awesome! plus i like big band & swing type music.

  • Horrible really. Very sad. It's really bad. Awful really. It's just wrong.

  • Whats wrong with it. He sounds great!

  • I really like Blake and all, he was my favorite this season.

    But he didn't sing it well, Clay's performance of this song was a lot better.

  • I also think this is his best vocally. Plus he's yummy!

  • lewiser girls are mean to me. I know he has more than 10 fans so there. I not born 9 days ago so there lewiser girl.

  • performance*

  • i think this was VOCALLY his best performances

  • you guys JUST IGNORE PEOPLE LIKE THAT..they dont matter and blake doesnt care..so we shouldnt either.

  • yeah now i'm pretty sure that hoya03 is gay... thx for telling me that

  • Im only sayin I heard he was gay

  • Is he gay. The radio said he was gay. Is he gay? He dances gay.

  • Question hoyao3: R u gay or a transgender? If u watch his audition u fuckin' prick u'll see his ex GIRLFRIEND standin' next 2 him in the beginnin' of the video!!! Get over it. We know u think he's gay & we know u r 2! FYI: the radio said I thought u were gay & Blake yelled out he was STRAIGHT!!!

  • Who cares what the radio says! NO he isnt gay! He had a girlfriend but he dumped her because he couldnt trust her! STOP PoSTING THIS CRAP! Its not true! He isnt dancing gay! He expresses his feelings in his dance! Your gay, retard

  • Never heard of Blake Lewis, just found this vid 'cos I did a search on Mack The Knife. But yeah, he's gay - gay dancing and gay voice - gay as a lord - but does it really matter - he sings it well?

  • This song scared my dog and my mom is mad

  • The best way 2 get rid of u is 2 ignore every little thing u say.

  • Everything scared your stupid dog. No one cares about your ga y dog so stop. Lier that is what you are a big one too

  • You say that on every Blake video!

  • Question: hoya03 why do come on every blake video & say he's gay. I mean fuckin' get over it. We get u think he's gay. Maybe u are since u keep mentioning it.

  • This is so gay

  • This isn't gay, you are.

  • I really think American idol should let the artist pick their own songs they want to sing, there's no waay on gods green earth he would have selected this shit if it came down to a personal decision

  • Are you so sure? He did say within the first two seconds of the song that he liked it. I'm fairly sure he'd have picked it.

  • blake sings the song much more accurately to the style of the original... but clay aiken's is just better

  • no hes not, hellz no

  • dont get me wrong, im not one of these crazy clay fans by any means, but the power and control he has over his voice is technically better than blake within this song

    but blake does stick to the style of the song much better his performance is much more smooth and sophisicated

    but overall i think clays performance was better

  • type in somewhere only we know and when the stars go blue and listen to them

  • I've never seen Clay Aiken's version, so I guess I've been living under a rock. After seeing Clay's utube Mack the Knife, I don't think Blake should have chosen it. Clay's performance was killer so Blake was inviting unfavorable comparisons from viewers and a luke warm response from the judges. It's all about song choice.

  • I honestly did not understand Tony Bennett and his comments to Blake. Pre-rap? Sub-gangsta? Er...

    Other than that, it was a good performance by Blake. A little underrated, but oh well. Great video!

  • This was 1 of his forgotten about perforfance. good but not great though

  • If you want to see Blake's girlfriend, type this: "Blake Lewis performs 1 at AriSawkaDoria ASD CD Release Show". She was there. Blake so cute and she kept necking him. I hate her because he is mine! ha! No i'm not obssessed! Well just a little bit! LOL

  • on a more seroius note i heard that someone hacked into blakes email and messed it up and read all his emails i no that ppl love blake and i do too but there is a fine line between fan and scary obsesed and ppl can go to jail for doing this so if u or some one u no id trying to do this stop urself or stop someone else becaus ehe is very upset about this andu could got to jail

  • Where did you hear this? I feel so bad for being obsessed with him now! I would never do that though.

  • yea i love him too but u dont have to feel bad unless u would do something crazy like this and i found it on this ome websight i dont remmember which one it was like a messege bord thing about blake

  • Lol. I think I'm REALLY obsessed. Not as obsessed as that person, though. -sigh- He's 11 years older than me! Anyway...did he really brake up with his girlfriend recently?

  • yea hes alot older then me too it will never happen anyway i thinkso on his profile it said single

  • Yeah. I have a friend who has a friend who knows him. I'm a girl with connections.

  • really do u no him? how well does ur friend now him?

  • No, I don't know him. I have a friend that lives in Seattle, and he has a friend that knows him.

  • that is still really cool i wish i had good connections like that

  • Lol. I know, I know. I'm awesome.

  • He sang it so beautifully.. I can always listen to this when I'm stressed. His voice is amazing

  • I know! I always listen to him when I like just want to relax or something, his voice is so soothing!

  • i liked this song before he sang it.

    but now i Love it.

    he looks really Hot here.

  • I get to meet him @ the bradley center in milwaukee. HE is so hot! He rocks at signing! I'm so excited!

  • DAMN THAT JORDIN WON

  • I LOVE BLAKE. I don't really like that song cuz its old but Blake did a pretty good job.

  • tour is gonna be amazing. if i will i will have to run up on stage and hug him.

  • Ohhh I LOVEEEE IT!!!!

    100% agree with what randy said!!!

  • when i go on tour i'm gonna grab his ass

  • Blake is the reason Im going to A.I. tour!!!!

  • he did the best he could with it. he's jazzy but not big band jazz.

  • I just love this boy. I just love love love love him!!

  • totally agree with you sonicflood. this song is about pizazz, NOT pretty singing. Blake WAS IT, performed it from beginning to end. definitely prefer this to Clay's version.

  • as much as I love blake do a search on youtube for mack the knife by clay aiken. Clay performed this same song season 2 and let's just say in comparison blake's rendition comes off stale and slightly boring.

  • great Ella Fitzgerald. He did her song real good, he should study all Ella Fitgerald songs with her scat sound.

  • Ignoring the fact that it's not an Ella Fitzgerald song, I'd say it looks more like he's going for the Bobby Darin version than anything else, where the primary thing that's important is the way you carry yourself. "Mack the Knife," especially the way Darin did it, is a song where showmanship goes a long way, and Lewis deserves all the credit in the world for doing it well.

  • a lot of people had versions of mack the knife. Ella Fitzgerald earned a GRAMMY AWARD for her version. Louis Armstrong introduced Mack the Knife in 1954 and Bobby Darin had his version in 1958. So yes your right he is goig for the Bobby Darin version because Blake Lewis can't touch Ella Fitzgerald and neither can Bobby Darin. Can you say Grammy Award?

  • With all due respect to Ella Fitzgerald, who is of course one of the most significant and talented singers in music history, a Grammy Award doesn't make her version instantly better than any other. Success and talent don't always go hand in and.

  • Sorry.. Bobby Darin was the first to sing this song.. he actually wrote it. For all you "lamer's" on youtube ville.. search "Mack The Knife".

    Bobby Darin wrote this song in 1959. DURRRR!!!

    Sinn

  • You got to kidding what make you think he wrote the song he recorded the song not wrote the song. Bobby Darin only recorded mack the knife and it was a success but the song it self was already a success he just had his version just like all the others before him way before him in the us was Louis Armstrong.

  • get your facts straight

    Sinn

  • and I guess you also knew how far back Mack the Knife goes? Louis Armstrong introduced it to the U.S.

  • Sorry.. Bobby Darin was the first to sing this song.. he actually wrote it. For all you "lamer's" on youtube ville.. search "Mack The Knife".

    Bobby Darin wrote this song in 1959. DURRRR!!!

    Sinn

  • Prior to which it was a number in Bertolt Brecht's "Threepenny Opera," yes.

  • Blake i was always there for ya buddy ...u should of won!!!

  • HOT.

  • "It's very swing" Wow... wrong use of the word swing, what is he talking and singing about!

  • I don't get it!!! Short,skinny, kinda geeky. How do you girls see such a hot guy here? My friend in HS looked a lot like Blake and no girl would ever talk to him. I'm sure Blake is a nice guy, but I judt don't see what the big deal is. PLus, Jordin is a much better singer!!!

  • half of the black population can sing better than blake, but you need more than just a great voice to sell albums. if you don't see how blake lewis is a great entertainer, then you're deaf, dumb and blind (yes, dumb too)...

  • lllllllooooooooooooooooooooove­eeeeeeeeeeee him, on my cell bkrnd!!!! dont leave me! i want u 2 teach me 2 blakebox!!!

  • he is soo smooth

  • What's with the freaky hair? Looks like a dunce. And he sometimes sings off key. Get the hook!

  • BLAKEE IS THE BESTT...

  • i can play this on vionline!

  • he is so hot!!!!

  • melinda & blake are my bet for idol 07

  • Agreed

  • this is my favorite performance of blake along with all mixed up

  • blake win hes alsome weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

  • I can play this song on my trumpet!

  • good performance but clay aikens performance of this song was unbelievable so its kind of hard to compare this song to anything other than clays version.

  • Blake did okay but Clay's version of this song wins hands down. Check out Clay's "Mack the Knife" and check out the judges' reactions to Clay's performance!

  • i like melinda and jordin.. but blake's good as well...

  • hes the best him and jodan are my favorites :):) i hope they both go far

  • Amazing! I love this guy. He seriously has so much talent. I pray someone signs him. He's a star :)

  • people need to upload more clips like this. I prefer funnier stuff myself, check out dolphinhump. lostfrog . com , I laughed so hard I got kicked out of class! haha.

  • ???

  • i liked it. but dunt u think he looked into the camera waaay too much during this song? lol

  • not his best performance. Good, but not his best. Gina was way better thatn him that week. sucks she got eliminated though.

  • Blake and Jordin are my favorites.I really really hope they are the top two. Blakes so original, not to mention adorable and jordin is just amazing and abosolutely gorgeous=]

  • OMG me too, my favs are jordin and Blake! I like the sox too!

  • I know most people will disagree but Blake's version worked so much better for me than Clay's. There's no arguing that Clay has the stronger voice, but I think he oversang it unlike Blake who kept it more subtle yet with more attitude. The song is about killing someone for christ sake. Blake's is closer to Bobby Darin's version.

  • Actually, I think Blake did a better version of this song. And while yes he is good, I think Melinda will win. She is AMAZING.

  • In people Magazine it said Blake is gonna win

  • hah yep i got that with them all on the cover=]

  • Clay's version was 10x better, but Blake is gonna win this year.

  • omg i luv blake i tink he iz soo cute and yea... lolii i luv hiz persona and everythin.... i saw him cry! it waz so cute..if ya wanna c it type in blake tearsnd da first one dat cumz up is it

  • wat r u saying clay sang it better??? clay just stood there and shouted all the words.. never liked him! BLAKE is gonnwa win this season - MY OPINION..

  • Blake is the best. Cant understand people who say he cant sing. They even say he's monotone. WTF? Do you all even have ears?

  • Someone give me a knife. This AI season