Added: 3 years ago
From: trentnjones
Views: 77,112
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (956)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I loved 2:10 and 6:30 song...what's the name..please! (and what about Ima Sumac? :D)

  • Mariah did not like Giogia high whistle.but she have sounds charming, attractive.

    ํYou can listen to Mini??

  • Christina Aguilera all the way.

  • mariah is the best not only because she can do whistle register but she really sing with awesomeness. Music, she can give that. Others do it for the sake that they can show that they can do whistle register. Georgina, Can she really sing? I mean, This is not to put down other singers. I hope you won't get me wrong.

  • also mariahs not only the best singer and whistler, but also by FAR THE HOTTEST...DAMN

  • ok im a mariah lamb for LIFE but chante is absolutely amazing. i still vote 99% mariah though, and honestly for me to be giving mariah only 99% says a lot about how good chante is

  • Of course Mariah is the best

  • They all sound good but i go for mariah! Love her

  • Good 2nd album for Shanice..."21 ways to grow" ... underrated

  • Georgia Brown is rejected because is brazilian...

    GO GEORGIA!!

  • @augustethomas We love you!

  • I Have To Go For Mariah Carey, The Way She Uses It & Controls It is Amazing For Real

  • Mimi 4 ever!! Number one!! Winner!! Diva!!!!

  • The whistle sound sounds good for Mariah and Denise Richards because their voices are so lovely and almost bird like. The other women just sound like the vocal chords are going to burst..I was holding my throat for mercy watching this.

  • There is no singer in the world .. who has this quality voice control as Rachelle..Georgia has widest range in the world in womens... In males it's Nicola Sedda/not Adam Lopez/:)

  • no need to clarify Mariah is the best!

  • Deb Morgan has a great range, shame she doesnt rec anymore...

  • MARIAH FOREVER.

  • MARIAH IS THE BEST!

  • Mariah the QUEEN of whistles! nobody is that agile and good sounding!!

    Minnie is also so good, but Mariah is the so much better singer overall!

  • Mariah is fantastic. Rachelle is fierce and Chante is angelic!

  • I heard Minnie helped Deniece with that part of her range. Teaching her

  • Damn Mariah is the best!!! And you should had use "yours" by Mariah where she whistles amazing and also never too far away live

  • Wow, I accidentally watched this vid and wondered whether Mariah was at the top of the list. That is an undeniable truth =)))

  • MARIAH CAREY IS NUMBER ONE!!!!!!! Can't get enough of her!!!! She controls every single aspect of her range from Whistle notes to her lowest register possible!!! Chante Moore has amazing vibrato in her whistle note as well! Love it!!!

  • Betty é insuperável live in No pai, No gain. Debelah é genial, Rachelle é esplendorosa em tudo que faz.Minnie é Rainha com sua elegância na voz.

  • Comment removed

  • I realize there is something called "whistle register" -- the highest part of a soprano's range supposedly akin to whistling. However, from my point of view, I have to say sorry folks, but this is singing not whistling. Some of it's awful (akin to screaming and grating on the nerves) and some terrific, operatic, and inspirational.

  • Talk about being musically retarded: Rachelle.

  • If you speak about overal vocal, Mariah definitely win. But about whitsle, Minnie slays them all

  • @iloveabba91 Minnie def does not slay them all. Mariah has the best control of her whistle notes and can speak words while singing in the whistle range! Not many singers can achieve that! That's a fact!

  • @iloveabba91 Minnie can do it too. And she can sound instrumentally in whistle which Mariah definitely can't do.

  • I hate it when fans do nothing but fight other people!!! well i think when you have no job or when you are a real dim wit you ewnd up looking for a fight. The word HOE is prejudicial for me as a Black woman and mother. How Dare you Zanoasses. Let us just pray for these great artists. In the end, the world has enough space for real artists. Mariah jsut need to work on her old skills back. Learn that but never call someone retarded and hoe coz that becomes oyu you white hating scum!!!

  • @reginabellestar Hah, it has been a long time since i last saw a good Mariah fan like you.

  • Mariah slays all singers, nobody is just near effortless like her! To all her haterz, Minnie is o.k but was near as talented vocalist, NONE OF ALL SINGERS! fact

  • Mariah is anway best, best tone, better runs and more agile, she is the only who can also vocalize on that notes. minnie is also talented, but mariah is the BEST of alltimes,so keep hatin shes voted as best voice of alltime by worldwidevotes

  • Minnie is a beast, plus mariah can't do that shit no more. I bet if Minnie was alive she would whistle notes all around Mariah.

  • I find Georgia Brown insufferable.

    Who are Agnes Jackson, Debelah Morgan, Rachelle Ferrell and Deniece Williams?

    Shanice is a wannabe Mariah.

    Chante annoyed the shit outta me when she kept doing it over and over. Less is more, baby.

    Calm the hell down, Betty.

    Minnie: The Queen of the high note.

    Mariah picked up where Minnie left off.

  • @GrimandBright you're right but i think Chante sounds beautiful too, although she kept doing the same thing but her whistle connected to the music, also her tone is beautiful. Mariah wins anyway.

  • @truongphan90 don't get me wrong. I loves me some Chante, but that particular moment from chante, i didn't like too much.

  • @GrimandBright so sorry but mariah could not do all her high notes now LIVE!!! Rachelle and Chante as well as Debelah and Shanice are way way better. Mariah can sing in the level of Justine Beber nowawadays. She lost it

  • reginabellestar maybe in your dreams, mariah is the whistle queen and

    the music business knows that, she is the only artist who can use it and

    be relevant, nobody for forsake cares for chante, debelah and shanice

    who are just fuckin flops... mariah proved in one decades, that every lol

    other whistles singer are just 24/7 flops compared to her you retarded hoe!

    LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOL

  • @zanoases oh my God poor thing you are poor you. You dont need to wagwe a war at me. I said i am a Mariah fan too but she is not the only great artist in the workld. to you if she is the only great artist then i am happy for you. For to me, as a fan and a person who appreciates everybody else i am open to the greatness of other artist. i am not pushing Chante or Debelah or shanice on you i am saying Mariah cannot hit her high notes LIVE all the time. you dont need to call me Hoe, you are the one

  • @GrimandBright Debelah Morgan is an amazing underrated singer with great technique. Deniece Williams is a singer whose carrer spans 40 years. She has a Grammy and has had several hit songs. Funny that you say Shanice is a Mariah wannabe when she was whistling before Mariah. If anything, she'd be a Minnie wannabe.

    Mariah did not create the whistle register.

  • who is mariah?

  • 1-Mariah

    2- Minnie

    3- Debelah.

    The rest!!

  • we all know minnie is the best but rachelle ferells phrasing and musicianship is astouding enough said

  • HEY!!! u forgot RACHEAL ANN GO!!!

  • MARIAH CAREY IS THE BEST HERE !!!

  • Comment removed

  • MARIAH CAREY !!!

  • that first girl got talent to sing that way too bad the music sux with it

  • wtf

  • y is there only one of rachelle ferrell??!!! she has an amaazzziinngg whistle register. i wish it couldve been showed more.

  • @sactownboss I was thinking the same thing.

  • m a r i a h

  • have a view on jaclyn victor's awesome performances 1 & 2..plus gemilang in the finale of malaysian idol too..hehehehe..shes great...

  • although so many artist can sing like that, it was only Minnie & Mariah can sing some real classic hit songs from that. which ppl would love listen to or try sing along for decades

  • Mariah could never ever ever beat Minnie riperton Minnie can go way higher than that and more effortless I find Mariahs to be really screechy but I love chante moore she behind minnie riperton!

  • Minnie is the Best.! <3

  • the best whistlhe are shanice and betty but mariah is the queen ever.

  • Mariah Carey is still the highest!!

  • @evanMiler76Ti mariah was singing The One from the Charmbraclet ablum.

    mariah and minnie are the best whistle vocalists and the fucking world i love u mariah <3

  • @evanMiler76Ti mariah was singing The Onr from the Charmbraclet ablum.

    mariah and minnie are the best whistle vocalists and the fucking world i love u mariah <3

  • @kakayl088 thnx so much! x) <3

  • she's singing "the one" (shinng through the rain)

  • Does anyone know what song is mariah is singing at 9:08???

  • I can whistle voice too v.v but they're better than me

  • @angelemoisme That's why they are famous but you are not!

  • all the hip hop generation votes for Mariah..don't that figure. I would have voted her next to last with my musically trained ear.

  • @brownmajic48 my musically trained ear placed her at number 1

  • Una cosa es cantar FALSETE y otra sacar la voz verdadera.

  • Mariah's sound the most sonically pleasing. The rest sound too much like screaming, imo.

  • omg at georgia brown... my god STFU!!!! the fact u can do it doesnt mean u shld!

  • @andytanhw lol!

  • the woman at 0:35 looks scared lol

  • Mariah

  • Shanice!

    

  • Comment removed

  • everyone sucks except for queen shanice

  • mariah!!!!! <3 :D

  • minnie is look like mariah LOL :D

  • Georgia Brown's whistle notes are wonderful to listen to when you're angry !! THis helps expressing the emotion without disturbing anyone !! Thumbs up if you agree ^^

  • love the wilderness bird chirping at the beginning of the video :P

  • mariah carey brong it in style and famous of doing it to and her voies its amazing

  • mariah won from the beginimg

  • @fatfat123ism OF COURSE!!!!!!!!!!

  • Mariah's early whistle was awesome. Her training was superb. As she's gotten older she has let a lot of her early vocal training slide and her whistle has a slight rough edge to it now. That is the case with almost all of the singers in this montage. If you listen closely you will hear that the edge of notes seem ragged. This is because of improper training and trying to force the notes.

  • I didn't know Chante had it like that! Wow!

    Enjoyed all of them!

  • Shanice is amazing!

  • mariah carey sounds and always the best...

    but only georgia can sustain it to the highest

    she sutain E7 for 10 sec. ang sustained a Eb8 for 4 sec. and also hit G#8 and they said G10 but i didnt know if thats true or possible for human vocals

  • mhmm she looks pretty damn Demonic xD

  • I love all the ladies but Mariah's whistles sound effortless.

  • Mariah's Last Song Was AMAZING !

  • Georgia looks like a redhaired psycho, her "singing" really hurt my ears

  • Georgia and Shanice are the living proofs thar reaching high notes doesn't make u a good singer. georgia is just screaming and hitting supper high and horrible notes without melody.... Ewww

  • Well!, I think that the Maria carey´s whistles are so beautiful! :B & i liket more than others! X)

  • great vid! i'm glad to see that you saved the best for last!

    but i think you should've included lisa fischer and christina aguilera. it's not like i'm absolutely crazy about their whistle registers but since you included georgia, shanice, rachelle, and betty...

  • Georgia Brown Has a powerful whistle register but Her voice is ugly I had hear her in live and she hasn't a beautiful voice at all and that note in the video was a E7!!

    But if you considered Mariah Carey F#7 in live in the song All in your mind or Lin Bao Self sastified C8 I didn't hear Georgia sing in live a note over the F7!!

  • if you want to listen what Whistle really sounds, you should listen to Mariah

  • Rachelle is the truth.....no lip synching there!!

  • Where's christina aguilera?

  • @TheCarmensosa Actually, Christina is not using the right way to whistle, so I think that's y she is not in the video, but she has the most powerful voice ever, I'm a fan of her :)

  • @s02229 If Christina has the most powerful voice ever, then there have been no powerful voices in history...

  • what the heck 6:36 rachelle is she lip singing???

  • @doctormelonhead Yes she can...how about you stop being so harsh and judgemental and actually listen to her music.

    I don't understand where all this Mariah hate comes from...

  • Chante moore the gospel song where is that

  • @ablackguy1234567 Yeah one thing i've always said with any part of her range Mariah makes it musical while some of the others are just trynna see how high they can go, Georigia has AMAZING whistle range, but her face scares me, and her pitch control like Minnies' is harsh, i'll always appreciate Minnie for inspiring MC though

  • what a nonsense, this isn't like beautiful or something, it's just annoying. fuck this.

  • its georgia and betty and minnie but not in dat order

  • I see you saved the QUEEN for last lol,

    Ithink the reason why she became so well known and more popular for it for one is because of her perfect pitch in that register, never live nor recorded has she fallen out of pitch while that high plus her technique to use it musically and not just seeing howhigh she can go. And to sound informal That Georgia Brown lady just scares me!!! Plain and simple

  • @ablackguy1234567 The problem I have with Minnie and alot of the other users is they dont have alotta control PITCH WISE, they fall out of key so easily and it becomes harsh to the ears when u have something that high in frequency going up against they original key of the music

  • singers who can do whistles like these are really gifted because only a few can do whistle register

  • that first broad breaths through her ass or something?

  • Mariah and Minnie.

  • Save the best for last :) LOL Jk they were all great.

  • Georgia Ftw has the Guiness Record for the highest voice!

  • Georgia is the highest plus the goes on and on where as the others dont. time it for yourself, she has more control.

  • Kandi from Xscape, Lisa Fischer and Christina Aguilera all have that register as well. I honestly feel as though Mariah and Debelah are the best because they can actually sing and incorporate it in their music without it coming off as doing just because they can. Shanice is really good live with hers as well. Minnie is probably the most notable, but I've never regarded her as one of the better vocalists. That register is probably the only thing that kept her relevant, imo.

  • The first woman ms. brown was off the hook and she could control it, she's like minnie, but i still love shanice which is strong as well, but ms. brown is off the chain!!!

  • OMG that one Geargia Brown did was REALLY GOOD!!! But i think Mariah wins

  • Was this in order? If so, I think it may have been a little off.

  • im sorry but the bird beat them all lol they were amazing but the bird beat them

  • georgia brown looks so evil...

  • @ablackguy1234567 No one compares.

    Do u or anyone else know what song she's singing at 5:28?

  • Comment removed

  • is that a whistle in 1:45?

  • Minnie is the winner she has the longest. listen the inside my love.

  • Don't forget lisa fischer, how can i ease the pain.

  • That first girl was bad on here, she was bad.

  • What song is Debelah singing at 5:28?

  • i recon mariah wins coz she've got the whole package:P she looks amazing and wow..that whistle note just made my jaw dropped to the ground...

  • It's sad that a lot of folks have the opinion that Mariah's is the best. However these r clips & I would say some of the other women can give Mariah a run for the money because of creative flow & transitions.

  • instantaneous laugh at the first one! it sounded so horrible.

    mariah carey the best in my opinion ! she just uses it in the best way and it sounds much nicer than the rest. minnie second !

  • Only mariah makes it sounds nice...the rest sound like their screaming

  • @lovindacheese neicy never screams

  • Im sorry but that first one was horrible.

  • minnie, mariah, and debelah are the best whistle vocalists period. chante is good but somewhat limited. shanice's notes are impressive but a little sharp to the ears and soulless. deniece is....ok. and any woman whose name wasn't mentioned in this comment, PLEASE STOP TRYING TO MAKE THE WORLD DEAF

  • @taquasia2468 Shanice was great LOL ! I'd never heard of her before but now im hooked !

  • @taquasia2468 BITCH DON'T DISS SHANICE SHE SLAYS EVERYONE IN THIS VIDEO

  • @shaniceslaysurfav lmao where the HELL did you come from??

  • @taquasia2468 i''m just a loyal shanice fan putting ignoramus mc sheep like YOU in their place!

  • This is pretty cool. I couldn't listen to it all of the time, but it is still amazing to hear. Minnie, Mariah, Shanice, Rachelle, Betty and Chante are the only ladies that I like on this list. Although the other ladies are great, I think Minnie, Mariah and Betty have the highest registers. However, Minnie, Mariah and Chante sound very sweet and subtle, which I like.

  • Where can I find the full length feature of Chante Moore's performance with the Fountain of Praise choir?

  • @ncatina search "chante moore make me like the moon". it has really bad sound quality just for the warning

  • Okay-The second lady and Deneice Williams should not be on this list as neither of those clips demonstrated whistle tone but rather the highest end of the soprano register. The other ladies, yes! Best control over their whistle register-Chante, Betty, Rachelle, and Minnie. Thanks for posting this.

  • Mariah is the better whistler because she has the most control over her whistles and her whistles ain't annoying like the other whistlers!! And Mariah overall has the most amzIng voice she's the songbird supreme

  • @toamau12 Minnie

  • mariah is the best cuz she doesnt over use it the whistle register

  • All of these woman are amazing vocalists. But Mariah is simply the best hands down. Because is not just about being able to whistle but also make it pleasant to the ear and Mariah Carey does that easily. Some of these singers may be able to go higher than her like Georgia Brown who holds some Guiness World Records for having the widest vocal range by a female but she is painful to watch and hear. Minnie, Rachelle and Betty Wright are legendary. But MARIAH takes the 1st place.

  • @ale5677 Georgia Brown is hard to take serious.

  • @ale5677 excuse me, but this vid is talking about whistle. LoL!

  • the ladies who can do a good whistle are freaking birds <3

  • eww..the first one sucks hard ass! just because you can do the whistle, doesn't mean you can sing. and the first lady is a great example of that.

  • Georgia Brown did her thing !

  • in betty

    u should put the live whistle whn she is singing "no pain no gain"

  • 5:45.... scary ..... gave me chill and put me to different dimension... o.O

  • if you think Georgia Brown has no control over whistle register just listen to "Loneliness" where she hits a pure and harmonic G#8

  • i always thought Rachelle ferrell and minnie riperton was the best. they had the best CONTROL.

  • they were all great

  • OMG!!! who's that rechelle ferrell??

    SO FUCKOING UGLY!!!!

    OH!!!! SHE'S VERY IRRITATING.

  • @PreciousMariah22 lmfao agreed

  • Mariah is the one! Georgia Brown has the guiness but mariah has the records!

  • @KateConan thanks you're so right now my MIMI interest increased

  • Minnie was great and she was the best at holding her high notes but Mariah's techiques are the best ones. The others' high notes are kinda annoying, especially Georgia Brown's (and she scared me a little !!!). Mariah is the #1 at hitting super high notes. Anyone who's got a proper ear can realize that !

  • Mariah Carey is the no.1 whistle singer in the world.. nobody can sing like her. her whistle note is soothing to our ears.. she is known for that.. mariah is the best whe it comes to this. she have a lot of abilities than any other singer! ahahah!!