I'm gonna tell you like this, the Trout Mask album is just like watching a long, complicated movie; you're not going to get everything at first listen. When you do, you will know that this is THE best album ever recorded in the history of time. My Human Gets Me Blues is like cramming 200 different compositions into six instruments, having only three minutes to perform it
I don't understand: I've heard so many people say this song involves two competing guitars that, by the end of the song, seem to work together instead of against each other. But I never really heard them click together.
@Ericthekfukhedmidget Like all timeless albums, its a grower. I felt the same way you did until one day i listened to it while depressed, It stuck ever since then...
@Ericthekfukhedmidget i like your comment on this video, because you are the reason why "my human gets me blues" right now.. btw how do people like you actually end on this kind of music?
@Ericthekfukhedmidget It takes time to get into Beefheart. I hated it at first, now I love it, as is the way with most good music. But if you're on here just to troll then you can fuck off.
@LaxATivvz I understand what you are saying. I have older friends who liked the Beatles when they played the cavern basement and hate it when everybody caught on. I have another friend who put me onto Duran Duran before they hit it big. They are people who go against the grain of what the Media says is "good". 90% of what's out here sucks and Radio is pretty much dead. To me....and I'm saying just to me......I heard no brilliance in the playing or singing. Blame the Beatles, Stones, Prince etc..
There are people who can't play worth a lick, but they think they sound good to themselves. If someboby gets it, I say good for them. 2 hours of jungle drumming may work for somebody. I say good for ya. But when guitars are out of tune, out of rhythm and vocals sound drunk, I'm off the wagon. Stern and Letterman made a big deal about Beefheart so I wanted to see what the fuss was about. And nothing clicked. There are people out there who get Sarah Palin. I don't, but to each there own.
@Sysminsays There's no denying that Don Van Vilet (Captain Beefheart) and his Magic Band could play like some mean mofos! If you need something a bit more "grounded" from the Captain may I suggest his first album with the Magic Band in 1967, "Safe As Milk." Don Van Vilet was an eccentric in every sense of the word and he purposely wanted the band to play like this for the recording of the album.
@MattHatter : People may say the same thing about Prince's music and McCartney early's Wings stuff and I like that music a lot. Some don't. Free form Jazz is horrid to me, but I'm sure there are enough people who like it enough to fill a coffee house. Good for em. It was a total miss for me. But to each there own.....
@Sysminsays O.K. fair enough. Don't get me wrong, I don't go out of my way to listen to free form jazz. Like I said, check out "Safe As Milk" his first album, you might like that one. It's more of a psychedelic delta blues album, none of the stuff you hear on THIS one. Speaking of Wings, for me they've always been hit or miss. When Paul got too sappy, it'd turn me off. But the EARLY stuff from "McCartney" to "Wild Life" is my favorite 'cause it's Paul just doing his own thing.
had to listen to this after hearing of his death. he was truly one of the greatest artists of the last century, the only and best of his kind. RIP love your music 4ver
@devinmillermedia : Ok maybe I'm out put line for wanting to hear musical instruments in tune, singing in key drum beats in time......my bad. The Bowies, Waters, lennons, strummers and Browns of the world ruined it for me I guess.
@Sysminsays You really know little about rock'n'roll history ... Lennon loved the Captain ... Same with Sonic Youth, White Stripes Red Hot Chili Peppers, etc. etc. etc. Open your mind and your ass will follow.
@devinmillermedia Speaking of asses, You like this crap. Good for you. You don't know me to know what I know about music. I know I've listened and played it for over 40 years and I've never read anywhere that Lennon he liked this puke. Even if he did. He didn't let it rub off. While the peppers are ok, mentioning Sonic Youth explains where you are for me.
@Sysminsays "You don't know me to know what I know about music." I know that you know little about knowing how to write a solid sentence, ya know? lol Why are you here again spouting vitriolic opinions that I doubt anyone who likes Beefheart is going to appreciate? Oh yeah, to be a crank troll. Doesn't the world already have enough of those already?
@devinmillermedia ...lol... a crank troll ......I guess that's what this music turns anyone with an appreciation for good music into. 16,000 views and only 48 likes kinda says all I need to Mr. Shit for taste. I'm done with you and this horrid ear nightmare of a so called song. So long and enjoy.
@Sysminsays If you don't like the song why bother even checking it out? Also, if you say only weirdos get this, that just tells me you have no adventurous spirits. Enjoy being a douchebag.
The key to understanding this album: it's painting. It's abstract painting. You have to have that ability to see music in your mind as paints. Then it'll click for ya.
It brought a wry smile to my face thinking of how this album was created, how my family would react to this "noise," and the avant-garde nature of this music.
It's a perfect reflection of the human condition: we're all crazy to some degree or another.
@curlytoes79 Not needed! All you need to do is understand that this is NOT a bunch of guys playing ANYTHING that comes into their heads on the spot, it's a bunch of guys that LIVED together in a house (basically LOCKED in the house BY the Captain) for 8 solid months until they actually learned to play these songs as they are here, note for bloody note!!! QUITE an impressive accomplishment!!! I was wondering the other day if the `80's era version of King Crimson could've played this stuff as is.
@curlytoes79 Yeah that's true in a way. Because most people, when they first listen to it, complain that every song sounds the same. Once you've memorised every note, you can appreciate how varied and intricate it is. But then the next stage is...you have to FEEL the music. Listen to this album in a depressed mood. You will TOTALLY understand it, it won't seem weird any more.
@curlytoes79 i don't agree.. unpredictability of notes and memorizing part is the best thing about this music... it's like you can listen to his songs million times and every time it's like a first time... :D
@brickstr: LOL LOL I wanted to see what the fuss was about. Howard Stern always talked about Capt. Beefheart so I seek out his music then i hear this clap of bile and i think maybe LSD pulls this earache opera together.
Its almost unbelievable that Trout Mask Replica songs are on the same website as Justin Bieber, Nickelback, Miley Cyrus, etc., let alone the same dimension.
@FraterSoddi -Right right...let us not forget the Magic Band -the Captain's sequestered outfit at Woodland Hills, locked and under the whip to learn and rehearse the music that would set minds and guts on fire. Also, I must add, the Mascara Snake, occasional clarinettist and witness to this marvelous legend...
I want to hear Homer Simpson sing this song.
VikiMarot 2 days ago
I'm gonna tell you like this, the Trout Mask album is just like watching a long, complicated movie; you're not going to get everything at first listen. When you do, you will know that this is THE best album ever recorded in the history of time. My Human Gets Me Blues is like cramming 200 different compositions into six instruments, having only three minutes to perform it
SIatanica 4 days ago
I just found out about this song, this is poetry!
Chdgrant 1 month ago
Being that you don't like beefheart, I guess you probably don't like zappa either.
musiclover01ization 1 month ago
I can't stop listening to this. It sounds different every time.
SuparMonkey 1 month ago
grounded
handymandan100 2 months ago
this album is a really rock masterpiece.
the guy who said that it isn't art:
"if this isn't art, what is?, the stupid 3 minute silly pop of the beatles or
this 2 minutes incredible original fusion of blues and avantgarde.
progreadicto 6 months ago 2
This song is literally insane and accept it and love it for that.
LiamCrowley1990 6 months ago 2
I don't understand: I've heard so many people say this song involves two competing guitars that, by the end of the song, seem to work together instead of against each other. But I never really heard them click together.
Wartler 7 months ago
beefheart encompasses two extremes of the spectrum: the primitive voice and the avant-garde arrangement and lyrics. that's why he's a fuckin genius
doorman292 9 months ago 4
Next time I'm depressed, I'm listening to this with headphones on. I expect to leave my mind on the floor.
7j8i9m 10 months ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stop thinking that this is art, this entire album fucking sucks
Ericthekfukhedmidget 10 months ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget Like all timeless albums, its a grower. I felt the same way you did until one day i listened to it while depressed, It stuck ever since then...
ChaosTitties 10 months ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget
Who do you think you are, telling people what to think? Simmer down, man.
raydrt 10 months ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget You fucking suck. What have you ever done? Your entire life will be an exclamation of mediocrity. Well done.
Lpoolboy 7 months ago
@Lpoolboy LOL
Mr11MUSICMAN 1 month ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget Obvious troll is obvious...
Joalda1 7 months ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget i like your comment on this video, because you are the reason why "my human gets me blues" right now.. btw how do people like you actually end on this kind of music?
pedalla 4 months ago
@Ericthekfukhedmidget It takes time to get into Beefheart. I hated it at first, now I love it, as is the way with most good music. But if you're on here just to troll then you can fuck off.
Tooindieforyou 4 months ago
Awesome play on words.
OrisLover 11 months ago
NAVY FAWK!
mikexlong 11 months ago
@LaxATivvz I understand what you are saying. I have older friends who liked the Beatles when they played the cavern basement and hate it when everybody caught on. I have another friend who put me onto Duran Duran before they hit it big. They are people who go against the grain of what the Media says is "good". 90% of what's out here sucks and Radio is pretty much dead. To me....and I'm saying just to me......I heard no brilliance in the playing or singing. Blame the Beatles, Stones, Prince etc..
Sysminsays 1 year ago
There are people who can't play worth a lick, but they think they sound good to themselves. If someboby gets it, I say good for them. 2 hours of jungle drumming may work for somebody. I say good for ya. But when guitars are out of tune, out of rhythm and vocals sound drunk, I'm off the wagon. Stern and Letterman made a big deal about Beefheart so I wanted to see what the fuss was about. And nothing clicked. There are people out there who get Sarah Palin. I don't, but to each there own.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays I was the same way but then I memorized every note in the album =) ;I was also severely depressed...
ChaosTitties 1 year ago
@ChaosTitties: Glad you like it and are over your depression. There are people who like Chitterlings too. Good for em.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays I know, the world is a wonderful place :)
NikpupMusic 1 month ago
@Sysminsays There's no denying that Don Van Vilet (Captain Beefheart) and his Magic Band could play like some mean mofos! If you need something a bit more "grounded" from the Captain may I suggest his first album with the Magic Band in 1967, "Safe As Milk." Don Van Vilet was an eccentric in every sense of the word and he purposely wanted the band to play like this for the recording of the album.
MattHatter 1 year ago
@MattHatter : People may say the same thing about Prince's music and McCartney early's Wings stuff and I like that music a lot. Some don't. Free form Jazz is horrid to me, but I'm sure there are enough people who like it enough to fill a coffee house. Good for em. It was a total miss for me. But to each there own.....
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays O.K. fair enough. Don't get me wrong, I don't go out of my way to listen to free form jazz. Like I said, check out "Safe As Milk" his first album, you might like that one. It's more of a psychedelic delta blues album, none of the stuff you hear on THIS one. Speaking of Wings, for me they've always been hit or miss. When Paul got too sappy, it'd turn me off. But the EARLY stuff from "McCartney" to "Wild Life" is my favorite 'cause it's Paul just doing his own thing.
MattHatter 1 year ago
muy entretenido tocar esto en la guitarra
iOnlyGotOneFace 1 year ago
what.. the...
DarthBond11 1 year ago
RIP Beefheart, Captain
nickknox75 1 year ago
this music makes me happy and gets me going
NicoteenDreamer 1 year ago
He didn't die, he just went back to venus.
TheFridgeslayer 1 year ago 2
@TheFridgeslayer with all those big eyed beans?
freespeech4u2 1 year ago
had to listen to this after hearing of his death. he was truly one of the greatest artists of the last century, the only and best of his kind. RIP love your music 4ver
AlecKronicle 1 year ago
Sorry he's gone but only Zappa, Plasmatic etc etc werdos get this
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays originality isn't for everyone.
devinmillermedia 1 year ago 2
@devinmillermedia : Ok maybe I'm out put line for wanting to hear musical instruments in tune, singing in key drum beats in time......my bad. The Bowies, Waters, lennons, strummers and Browns of the world ruined it for me I guess.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays You really know little about rock'n'roll history ... Lennon loved the Captain ... Same with Sonic Youth, White Stripes Red Hot Chili Peppers, etc. etc. etc. Open your mind and your ass will follow.
devinmillermedia 1 year ago 3
@devinmillermedia Speaking of asses, You like this crap. Good for you. You don't know me to know what I know about music. I know I've listened and played it for over 40 years and I've never read anywhere that Lennon he liked this puke. Even if he did. He didn't let it rub off. While the peppers are ok, mentioning Sonic Youth explains where you are for me.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays "You don't know me to know what I know about music." I know that you know little about knowing how to write a solid sentence, ya know? lol Why are you here again spouting vitriolic opinions that I doubt anyone who likes Beefheart is going to appreciate? Oh yeah, to be a crank troll. Doesn't the world already have enough of those already?
devinmillermedia 1 year ago
@devinmillermedia ...lol... a crank troll ......I guess that's what this music turns anyone with an appreciation for good music into. 16,000 views and only 48 likes kinda says all I need to Mr. Shit for taste. I'm done with you and this horrid ear nightmare of a so called song. So long and enjoy.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
@Sysminsays If you don't like the song why bother even checking it out? Also, if you say only weirdos get this, that just tells me you have no adventurous spirits. Enjoy being a douchebag.
musiclover01ization 1 month ago
A Legend Gone R.I.P.
silvani101 1 year ago
The key to understanding this album: it's painting. It's abstract painting. You have to have that ability to see music in your mind as paints. Then it'll click for ya.
gamesDAMNED 1 year ago
I may love this one best, people went before the Inquisition for expressing these ideas.
LBDumont 1 year ago
R.i.p Captain
DrSabbathTheWizzard 1 year ago 21
Two words to sum this up: Mostly Harmless.
It brought a wry smile to my face thinking of how this album was created, how my family would react to this "noise," and the avant-garde nature of this music.
It's a perfect reflection of the human condition: we're all crazy to some degree or another.
Arabesquian 1 year ago 2
Probably the greatest album ever. And if not the greatest, it definitely matters the most.
Havenscope 1 year ago 2
@Havenscope Huh? Matters the most? To some perhaps, to the public at large, I think not.
erad67 1 year ago
I think the key to loving this album is listening to it until you've memorized every note. Then you'll see.
curlytoes79 1 year ago 38
@curlytoes79 Not needed! All you need to do is understand that this is NOT a bunch of guys playing ANYTHING that comes into their heads on the spot, it's a bunch of guys that LIVED together in a house (basically LOCKED in the house BY the Captain) for 8 solid months until they actually learned to play these songs as they are here, note for bloody note!!! QUITE an impressive accomplishment!!! I was wondering the other day if the `80's era version of King Crimson could've played this stuff as is.
RedVynil 1 year ago
@curlytoes79 Yeah that's true in a way. Because most people, when they first listen to it, complain that every song sounds the same. Once you've memorised every note, you can appreciate how varied and intricate it is. But then the next stage is...you have to FEEL the music. Listen to this album in a depressed mood. You will TOTALLY understand it, it won't seem weird any more.
MoralNihilism 1 year ago 8
@curlytoes79 i don't agree.. unpredictability of notes and memorizing part is the best thing about this music... it's like you can listen to his songs million times and every time it's like a first time... :D
pedalla 4 months ago
Comment removed
curlytoes79 1 year ago
That doesn't even look like a Trout.
rba718 1 year ago
@rba718 because it's a REPLICA
JackBlair2 1 year ago 2
@JackBlair2 No it looks like a Carp, Trouts have differently shaped mouths and their heads are more narrow.
:3
rba718 1 year ago
@rba718
Because we all totally care what fake fish head he's wearing.
mattcgoulding 1 year ago
@mattcgoulding Indeed, it is an important distinction. I'm glad you agree.
rba718 1 year ago
@rba718 that's why it's a replica! You have a well honed "trout eye!"
trod999 1 year ago
This music is pure
Catch22ish 1 year ago 4
@Catch22ish ...pure shit
brickstr 1 year ago
@brickstr Ha Ha......go away troll, Lady Gaga awaits you.
mfish618 1 year ago
@brickstr: LOL LOL I wanted to see what the fuss was about. Howard Stern always talked about Capt. Beefheart so I seek out his music then i hear this clap of bile and i think maybe LSD pulls this earache opera together.
Sysminsays 1 year ago
And I thought The Velvet Underground was hard to listen to.
FetaCheese222 1 year ago
@FetaCheese222 Shame on you XDD!
ZupraVisor 1 year ago
@ZupraVisor I kid, I love the Velvets, but really, their screeching landscapes can be really annoying as hell sometimes.
It's not surprising that Lou Reed went on to make Metal Machine Music, the only album that can possibly compete with Trout Mask Replica.
FetaCheese222 1 year ago
@FetaCheese222 i thought that about bands too, but the more you listen, the more you fall in love.
PAULisDEADMANnumber9 1 year ago
Its almost unbelievable that Trout Mask Replica songs are on the same website as Justin Bieber, Nickelback, Miley Cyrus, etc., let alone the same dimension.
kevin4peace 1 year ago 2
Love ya Don, if only for this...
EMILIOMARENGO 1 year ago
@EMILIOMARENGO
You should probably thank Bill, Mark, Antenna Jimmy and John - they were the Magic Band.
FraterSoddi 1 year ago
@FraterSoddi -Right right...let us not forget the Magic Band -the Captain's sequestered outfit at Woodland Hills, locked and under the whip to learn and rehearse the music that would set minds and guts on fire. Also, I must add, the Mascara Snake, occasional clarinettist and witness to this marvelous legend...
EMILIOMARENGO 1 year ago