Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (99)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • how very sad....... stunning..... i understand it more now

  • I can't believe how much I enjoy this song, especially THIS version!

  • With little things she makes something beautiful!!!

    This is call talent!!

  • God i want to know the chords!

  • She's really good,i enjoy every second...

  • she f*cken rules...that is all.

  • Can somebody please tell what name of that string instrument is!

  • @maacor it's called an autoharp (if you didnt already find out)

  • She needs to stay away from the fish.

  • Comment removed

  • I listen to her music for so many years, still cant stop now and never will

  • beautiful

  • She's so beautiful...oh my gosh just so beautiful.

  • L o v e -_-) א ה ב ה

  • Whoever tagged this video is a douchebag.

  • can you tell me which kind of instrument she plays?

  • @chiccabellons It's an autoharp

  • Comment removed

  • çok seviyorum seni...

  • I've watched this like 8 times in a row. She is too good.

  • @tbrogan8009 : Agree.

  • @tbrogan8009 YES!

  • I love the way she re-creates her own songs adaptated to her new point of views

  • the woman's a musical genius.

  • @talentpageant : Agreeeeeeeeeeeee !

  • i cry when i hear this song becuase it makes me think of my first love

  • @TommyBoy1397 : Sad but nice, too !

  • beautiful song...beautiful soul...beautiful women

  • She is just purely beautiful.

  • Beautiful

  • im sorry but i love you harvey

  • Amazing.

    

  • That's fantastic. I can't believe it's been almost 15 years ago since I first got that CD.

  • amo esta cancion

    ooh Polly !!!!

  • I think the song is about Her drowning her daughter because her daughter was either raped or willfully had sex. So PJ thought her daughter was impure after her sexual encounter and drowned her...

  • @Koutoni it's based upon a true story : a religious mother read her daughter's secret diary and discovered she wasn't a virgin anymore. So she drowned her daughter...

  • @Koutoni

    the song is based on the true story of an evangelical mother who reads her teenage daughter's diary and finds out the daughter is pregnant (willful sex). So the mother does the christian thing do i guess, which is to drown the daughter.

  • I just heard this song on the radio recently and it grabbed my attencion.

    im on here today just to hear it again...love the video too.

  • @miamorbid1 : That's her most moving interpretation of this song.

  • Absolutely haunting but beautiful.

  • Whats this song about??? Did she drown some one.... did she drown her daughter and then regret it??? Is that what is about

  • @weXtheXbomb I think it's about either miscarriage or regretted abortion. That's just my opinion.

  • genius as usual

  • All the fish are dead now.....

  • I like this version better than the official video. it's so haunting. But who did the version on CSI? 

  • all of her live stuff during white chalk era is so amazing.

  • More charismatic than Sheryl Crow live!

  • ouf !

  • oh my god. Polly is god. never heard this...its like the song is new to me.

    to bring you my love is one of the best albums of all time.

  • @digitalwhiplash7 You're right.!!!

    I'm blown away.. Freakin amazing...!!! WoW

  • where is this from? i would like to download it...

  • I have to say that miss Polly Jean? - you're looking the best I've ever seen. These vids/recordings show just how talented and special you are. We thank you for making you our little star. R.

  • It's an autoharp.

  • OK. A Jubel Töne autoharp.

  • does somebody knows' what is the name of this strings instrument?

  • Could be a Jubel Töne zither...

  • autoharp

  • @ketemon1

    citra

  • @ketemon1

    or zither :)

    i know, what is the name in russian ;:)

  • can she be depressed? very saidly

  • @qalpos

    Congratulations!

    (Seems like you're trying to make the most ridiculous comment on earth..)

  • @YouForgotToAnswer

    i am already ridiculous guy but

    nick cave misogynist

    kurt cobain manic depressif

    things happen, you know

  • @qalpos

    You've outdone yourself;)

  • Great answer qalps!! lve it

  • Comment removed

  • o m freaking god. never expected to love this song more than the album version til i saw this

  • god, she's amazing!!!

  • Fantastic, pure performance. Polly Jean... So special, indeed.

  • auto harp

  • This is a really special performance!

  • Could be a "Jubel Töne" zither...

  • oh I see thanks

  • O help me, Jesus through these dark waters, little fish, big fish swimming in the water, come back here and give me my water. PJ is one of a kind. Like Dylan, like Lennon...

  • The song goes, "come back here man, give me my daughter." :)

  • Shes so gosh darn pretty

  • (((Great)))

  • Wow. Fabulous, thanks

  • Fabulous, indeed.

    You're welcome ! :-)

  • FORMIDABLE

  • She's pretty good. =D Sometimes watching CSI gives you amazing songs to look up. Glad I found it. Amazing.

  • I know.  The first time I ever heard this song was on CSI.

  • I have been wholly addicted to her music lately.

    I, out of a complete whim, found White Chalk on Amazon, previewed it, liked what I heard, bought it. I loved it. Now I'm deciding which album to get next. :P Each one is so entirely different, but they're all incredibly well written.

    Take this song, for instance. This version has been reduced to its most minimal form, yet it's still amazing to listen to. It's because the core of the songwriting is so good, as well as her voice.

  • Thank you for your elaborate post.

    Hard to choose a PJ album.

    * May be, as a beginning : "Rid of me" 1993. 14 titles, 10 masterpieces :

    "Rid of Me", "Missed", "Legs", "Rub 'til It Bleeds", "Yuri-G", "Man-Size", "Dry", "Me-Jane"

    "Snake", "Ecstasy".

    * And the much underrated "Is this desire ?" (1998), her darker album. One of my favourites. Great tunes :

    Angelene, My beautiful Leah, A perfect day, Elise, Catherine, The garden, The river.

    Anyway, just enjoy PJ's numerous talents !

  • In fact, as I was previewing her albums, "Is This Desire?" sounded like the most appealing. I'm sort of a nut-case in that I research an album in its entirety before actually buying it. =P But, in fact, I made up my mind just ordered that very album off of Amazon.

    Thanks for the recommendations. :)

  • The 4 track demos are one of my favorites.

  • Yes, it's rare to have access to an artist's rough work. And this album explains the power put in her music.

  • I agree.

    I like this version.

    Anything she sings with her passion and heart is brilliant.

    This just is one of the many talent this beautiful Woman possess.

  • Oh come on you leave out "Bring you my love". if anything that is the best PJ album out there.

  • Check out motorbike, dry and some of her earlier tracks

  • this version is soooo amazing. she is so talented. gives me chills!!

  • she is soooooo talented...omg...im not sure i like her hair like that...but who cares? amazing artist!

  • i heard this song on csi. had 2 find it... the csi version is better... not sure i like it =s

  • I found her though "Ballad of a Soliders Wife"

    And she is utterly amazing.

  • So you have plenty of her to discover... You're lucky !

  • that's an amazing song! I heared it on TV 2 days ago but i still listening to it

  • jag fårstår dig från början älskling. men jag e beredd på allt med allt dig och inget ändrar mig med dig jag älsjkar dig kram

  • she's gorgeous without the make up too and sounds just as good with her vocals on a more tender scale.

  • Amazing talent

  • it's like she were a different person in each song!

  • True ! :)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more