Added: 4 years ago
From: rosanduh
Views: 34,975
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (107)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Seria muito interessante a tradução desse documentário em língua portuguesa.

  • În faţa acestor oameni mă închin ca unor sfinţi, pentru chinurile pe care le-au suferit pentru Adevăr, pentru Hristos. Dacă aşteptăm să-i canonizeze Sinodul...nu îi vom avea niciodată în calendar; aşa au făcut şi cu Voievodul Ştefan cel Mare, din 1504 şi până-n 1992 sunt aproape 500 de ani. Atât le-a trebuit să-şi dea seama că e sfânt ?!...Pentru cei ce i-au simţit, îi au sfinţi de mult în inimă, nu mai au nevoie de hotărârea Sinodului...

  • well, they were beasts but they did it not so wrong with the religious sort... if you think about it the church tortured and massacred many more people, and in response it even made some of its inquisitors "saints"... bah...

  • "...They used all the methods...For example, hospital for mental diseases. They came with psychiatrists, doctors, who are very important, communist doctors, experimented in Russia. They came to give you special drugs, and to say you are crazy because your are not communist..."

    WOW!!!

  • Stalinism was a brutal, long regime. While preceeding and outlasting Nazism the horrors assigned this time goes nearly unnoticed here in the U.S. This documentary clearly shows the injustice and inhumanity of a time more near to the present than the extermination camps of WWII. Much has rightfully been said about the Holocaust, now it is 20th century communisms turn to be exposed and condemned. The political scales here in the West are tipping frightfully to the Left, away from social justice.

  • the song the wemon sing is very beautiful, sure wish I knew what the song was called though.

  • @TheNewport2009 The song is the Romanian hymn!

  • @hanibal212 No, it's an religious song and it seems to be in english!

  • The evil doesn’t exist, because the only thing that exists is what God made. God didn’t make evil. In the bible it says that God created everything, looked over His creation and saw that it was good. He did not create anything evil. What then is evil? It is a distortion of a good that God made. Evil is a lie and if humans live in this lie, they live in something that doesn’t exist. They are fooled. (father Rafail Noica)

  • Mai silviuverdes tu ai o optica ingusta si o logica sucita, e inutil sa-mi mai pierd timpul cu tine.

    Totusi am o rugaminte la tine, nu mai intra cu bocancii plini de noroi oriunde-ti vine. Ai bunul simt si descalta-te uneori, ca sa nu-ti fie rusine dupa aceea sa-i privesti pe "oameni" in ochi!

  • @ComradeFlorian28 nu...se pare ca nimanui nu-i pasa de ei.. si oricum, au fost alte vremuri

  • comradeFlori : Dar ce fel de crestini erau cei care au omorat amerindieni ? Catolici, ortodoxi, protestanti, iahovisti , penticostatli, adventisti, ziua a 7a ? Pana la urma, dintre acestia care sunt crestini, ptr ca adevarul este doar unul ! Adevarul nu are plural ! Crestinismul este doar unul, restul sunt optiuni !

  • @rosanduh 1.Mersi de upload.2.Problema e de fapt ca fiecare se agata de o credinta,o idee,pt. a-si justifica principiile.Domnul cu comentariul pe care l-ai contrazis are dreptate spunand ca se pune reflectorul pe o crima,in conditiile in care exista altele mai mari.Degeaba incerci sa faci apologia crestinismului,sunt cel putin la fel de vinovati in istorie ca si comunistii.Asta nu inseamna ca daca cineva e crestin e gresit,dupa cum si sa fi comunist nu e gresit,e treaba si dreptul fiecaruia....

  • @rosanduh .3.Metodele fiecarui regim politic sunt diferite,insa daca e sa analizam la rece,rezultatul este acelasi,e vorba de exploatarea omului de catre om.Daca comunismul ca si ideologie are un defect,acela e ca neaga natura umana,atat cea luminoasa cat si cea intunecata,e naiv,iar aceasta naivitate sau prostie a creat monstrii,exact ca religia.Pe de alta parte,atata timp cat fiecare isi tine convingerile pentru el,e ok,problema apare cand incearca sa-l convinga pe altul cu forta sau viclenia.

  • @ComradeFlorian28 Niciun crestin ortodox roman nu a ucis pe cineva care nu a vrut sa se converteasca. Restul, nu ne intereseaza. Punct.

  • socialists are responsible for most of the hate and violence in the world, the muslims are next in line.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • In video apare pictura utilitara in slujba propagandei noilor komisari ideologici aparuti dupa restauratia capitalista de la 1989. Picturile lui Octav Bancila cu tarani si muncitori impuscati de burghezo-mosierime nu mai sunt la moda...

  • @silviuverdes Nu ma mira! La cat de multi tovarasi sunt activi inca, trebuia sa apara si unul care sa arate aroganta incat sa sfideze si cel mai elementar bun simt. TOVARASE, din pacate pentru tine perioada experimentului "Pitesti" a trecut. N-am nici o indoiala ca i-ai fi luat locul cu placere lui Turcanu. Si bine-nteles ai fi sfarsit ca si el.

    Ceea ce se spune in filmele astea e istorie pura!

    Jalnica, reactia ta!

  • @genesisdominus ...ca l-au impushcat pe legionarul Turcanu nu esti multumit...Daca il facea secretar PCR si il decora iarasi ai fi fost nemultumit...fatzarnicie si obedienta ta pt vrajelile de propaganda ca iti place sa crezi in ele.Sau ai poate ai si interese sa crezi....

  • Comment removed

  • @silviuverdes Ce e asa greu de inteles de imi rastalmacesti vorbele? Turcanu e aici simbolul omului care si-a vandut sufletul pentru un blid de linte. Nu ma intereseaza sa-i judec faptele, doar ca urmarile sunt intotdeuna aceleasi intr-un astfel de sistem diabolic; dupa ce nu mai e nevoie de tine, esti aruncat ca un gunoi, caci lipsa de scrupule e prima regula.

    Ceea ce numesti tu "obedienta" e de fapt un elementar respect fata de suferinta inimaginabila a unor suflete.

  • @genesisdominus...aiurea...tu vrei sa faci o conexiune intre Turcanu si ordinele comunistilor de la "centru". N-au fost. Turcanu a fost un dement ca atatia altii in puscarii. Iar conceptul "filozofic" de "Exp Pitesti" a fost fabricat de specialistii CIA ,sleahta de evrei (90%) de la radio Europa Libera. 

  • @silviuverdes Ce aberatie! Ca si cum un amarat puscarias ar putea sa faca legea in inchisori fara complicitatea conducerii!

    In alta ordine, ce sanse ar avea sa fie adevarate povestile tale (cunosc zeci de povestitori ca tine si sute de povesti despre teorii ale conspiratiei), iar nu niste marturii vii, cu dovezi palpabile si care explica multe din mizeriile pe care le traim astazi.

  • @genesisdominus ...acele abuzuri s-au facut cu complicitatea conducerii pucariei. Administratia puscariei a fost condamnata. Esti multumit ? Daca ii decora nu era bine - daca i-a condamnat iar nu e bine.

  • @silviuverdes Sunt de acord cu tine cand demasti mediocritatea guvernarii din zilele noastre, dar nu inteleg cum de nu poti observa legatura intre ce se intampla astazi si "reeducarea" comunista.

    Fara o spalare a creierelor (care nu s-a facut peste tot prin tortura, fiindca nu era nevoie, dar ale carei efecte au fost peste tot aceleasi - depersonalizarea omului) nu s-ar fi reusit inlocuirea valorilor morale, singurele care ar putea vreodata sa responsabilizeze.

  • @silviuverdes Iar diferenta majora intre noi si tarile zis "civilizate" e tocmai faptul ca la "ei" inca nu s-a produs spalarea creierelor si mai au inca o umbra de teama pentru felul in care sunt vazuti, mai tin inca la "demnitatea" lor!

  • @genesisdominus ...ba daaa...sunt spalati bine la creier...si aia din tarile zis civilizate...propaganda, presa,tv, etc ii spala mai mult decat vrei tu sa-ti inchipui....

  • @genesisdominus ...unde vezi tu multi "tovarasi" activi ca nici partid PCR n-au fost in stare sa infiintzeze in 20 ani...cel mult lumea pana la urma sa se revolte de mizeria capitalista si atunci sa se organizeze si sa starpeasca oranduirea asta netrebnica....

  • Comment removed

  • 5 stele camarade

    am dat la toti...

    l-am pus si pe facebook.Doamne ajuta!!!

  • superb !

    5 *****

    Orthodox or death !

  • In the begining of this video you can see the paintings of CIA-radio Free Europe in the duty of of the capitalist propaganda...The paintings show the enemies of the people after 1947...

  • 2 will be outnumbered i know that we.. with the help of the trinity and virgin Mary will win in the end "You are Peter and on this rock I will build my Church and the powers of evil will not prevail against"

  • brainwashed are posting comments and still accuse orthodox church 4 what happend 4 killings but they do not read the history and they dont care 4 what really happend or they are so copy pasted and soul less that they don t care who is 2 blame 4 millions of deaths

    orthodox is not 2 blame ,they do not buy heaven like others ,they die and become saints ,killers belive they win but in fact they

  • Marxism is Tamuldic Judaism for the gentiles. Historical dialectics of Thesis-anti thesis and Synthesis is straight out from the Talmud. The same is also true for Freemasonry (Jewish mysticism of Kabbalah).

    Jews are responsible. Please come to this reality and accept it.

  • @1962SatanTookOver2

    boris grünberg, pitesti

  • Boys and girls, please don't forget that Karl Marx came from a long line of Rabbis. Frederick Engels was also a Jew. The Boshevik Revolution was led, financed, and carried out by Jews. Most killing units were Jews. Let's identify correctly who did these things to the Holy Faith of Romania and the rest of Eastern Orthodoxy. The Jews.

  • My partner's Grandfather was in one of these prisons. He was a stronger man for surviving.

  • @gFantasmos he is a hero, and a true orthodox, for that God shall rest him

  • pikycraiova, you are waisting your time and ours. just beat it! the Comunists were all beasts and they should be treated as such! until justice to all the saints that died in the comunist prisons will be done, you and likes like you should not raise their heads from mud and dirt!

  • History is on our side. We shall finish the job; and people like yourself will be finished too.

  • Bullshit!

  • pikycraiova!

    Esti un dobitoc, biserica nu a comis nici o crima, crimele au fost comise de Lening si Stalin. Comunismul a omorat peste 200 mil oameni.

  • Communists > You

  • ceaucescu ran the country dry when iran went revolutionary. the oil money dried up and romania went broke

  • what man can do when we succumb to our fears.,. gitmo and romania both house political prisoners of usa.

    sadly

  • Communism has nothing to do with atheism.

  • Communism = Atheism + Guns. Reds are the nemesis to mankind.

  • Wow can you prove that?

  • Name one communist mass murderer who wasn't an atheist.

  • Hitler, Rwandan Genocide under Hutu ideology, Srebrenica Genocide under General Ratko Mladic, Bela Kun's 'ethnic cleansing', Mao, Pol Pots, and the list goes on. It also includes the crusades in which many died for not believing in the 'right god' Now show me one religion that doesn't have a violent history.

  • Bela Kun was an atheistic Jew. Mao and Pol Pot were both atheists. The others aren't communists - all commie killers = atheistic.

  • You have no proof they were atheistic. The other believed in communism, hence communists. Hitler was catholic and even if you say he wasn't, his followers who followed hitlers orders and did the actual killing were catholic too.

  • Mao, not to mention Pol Pot and a host of others, all committed atrocities in the name of a Communist ideology that was explicitly atheistic!

  • You send me 24 comments apparently expecting me to read them all. I don't have the time to read all this, especially when there is something wrong with the first comment you posted. They did not commit atrocities in the name of atheism nor were the atrocities atheistic. Plus communism is not atheist in any way as you have to bow down to someone like a god. That is why many atheist don't agree with communism. It is dogmatic in every sense of the word, only you're worshipping a human.

  • Second atheism does not have ideology. The only thing we have in common for sure with everyone else who is atheistic is that we don't believe in a god(s). Second, I couldn't help but notice your second comment about hitler. That book is so hilariously wrong I won't go into it, but I will state that your views on christianity are wrong too. Anyone who has taken the time to read the bible, knows that there is no such thing as equality in it, and that hitler got his ideals from it

  • If you're going to associate sane Christianity with that practiced by crazy people, then others will associate your atheism with crazy atheists.  =\

  • You could try, but it wouldn't work. Atheists only have one thing in common, they don't believe in a god. From there they are their own man. As for christianity, the bible accepts slavery, rape, incest, murder, and hypocrisy, to name a few. So I really don't know what you mean by sane Christianity. I will admit there are people who just believe god is real and don't really read the bible, but all christian denominations follow the same bible.

  • - Hence "god's chosen people" from hitler's own public speeches, on the uniforms, and instilled in the children and nazi soldiers themselves.

  • And yes, people have told me pol pot and mao were atheists, my bad for listing them, but they did not fight or kill in the name of atheism. they did it in for their own greediness.

  • ? Have you read the Communist Manifesto? Das Kapital? Look, I realize you are speaking in earnest, but please learn of communism. It was conceived specifically as an antidote for religion, which communists see as an "opiate for the masses". The elimination of religion is one of the main aims of communism, which is atheistic.

    Now communism is awful and atheistic, but not all atheists are awful, and neither is all expression of atheism awful. Try to see the same for christians and Christianity.

  • Once again I say the christian religion is crazed, not all the people who follow it. Communism is remedy to religion and atheistic, but unlike atheism and much like religion, it still demands the worship of someone or some people. This is why many atheist do not agree with communism. atheism is not meant to be cure for religion, just an alternative. To sum it up:

    Atheism- belief in no gods.

    Communism- total obedience and possible godlike reverence to one or more people.

  • On the Nazis, this is from 'What's so great about Christianity.' You should read a book called 'Hitler's Table Talk,' which is a revealing collection of the Fuhrer's private opinions assembled by a close aide during the war years, shows Hitler to be rabidly anti-religious. He called Christianity one of the great ''scourges'' of history, and said of the Germans, ''Let's be the only people who are immunized against this disease.''

  • Hitler promised that ''through the peasantry we shall be able to destroy Christianity.'' In fact, he blamed the Jews for inventing Christianity. Hitler reserved special scorn for the Christian values of equality and compassion which he identified with weakness. Hitler's leading advisers Goebbels, Himmler, Heydrich and Bormann - were atheists who hated Religion and sought to eradicate its influence in Germany.

  • townhall . com / columnists / DineshDSouza / 2007 / 11 / 05 / was_hitler_a_christian

    (remove the spaces).

  • Mao and Pol Pot were both atheists!

  • The Crusades were a belated and necessary Christian enterprise to block Islamic invasion and conquest. Remember that before Islam, virtually the entire Middle East was Christian. Egypt, Syria, Palestine, Jordan—these areas were predominantly Christian. The Muslims conquered the region, and then Muslim armies invaded Europe, conquering parts of Italy and virtually all of Spain, which the Muslims ruled for nearly 700 years.

  • The Muslims over-ran the Balkans and were at the gates of Vienna. Edward Gibbon, no friend of Christianity, says that if the Christians hadnt fought back then, today at Oxford and Cambridge—and by extension Harvard and Duke—wed all be studying the teachings of Muhammad in the Arabic language. Western civilization, then called Christendom, was mortally threatened. The Crusades, for all their excesses, helped to prevent this disastrous outcome.

    -Dinesh D'Souza

  • Essential to Marxist ideology is atheism. Marx said that the first critique is the critique of religion. Only when that is complete can we move on to a critique of economics and politics.

  • If you come up with a counter claim that these regimes were not done in the NAME of athiesm, you only need to go and look at 'The Trouble With atheism Part 6' - 4:15. On Youtube. The Russian Priest (who was formerly an atheist, lived in Russia during this time, before emigrating). He said himself, 'BEING RELIGIOUS WAS A VIOLATION OF STATE LAWS' . He says this himself, in his own words 'THE PARTY DEMANDED ATHEISM, YOU CAN'T BE A PARTY MEMBER OF ANY RELIGION'.

  • Soviet Russia, Maoist China, Pol Pot's Cambodia, Castro's Cuba, etc. etc. etc. etc. for decades, propagandized young people into non-belief! Dostoevski said that once God has been removed, anything is possible. The truth of this dictum is amply demonstrated by the moral outrages of Stalin, Mao, and company. To claim that their dismissal of God had nothing to do with their complete moral relativism strikes me as extremely naive.

  • Communists leaders were motivated by a strong desire to impose an ideological "package" over the whole world. The package included the eradication of Religion, defined by arch-atheist, Karl Marx, as The opium of the people. According to Marx, religion helped keep the masses passive before the abuse of the wealthy and powerful, and the only way to free them from the stupor," God and religion had to be eradicated. Lenin embraced Marx's views and so did Stalin up to the Second World war.

  • The enforcement of Atheism was a critical requirement for Communisms success, and thus it had to be implemented at all costs. This meant oppressive measures, such as brainwashing in state schools, the closing of houses of worship and arresting countless religious leaders. (For an enlightening discussion of Atheistic-Communism's persecution of the Christian church search online for the article, 'Persecution of Christians in the Soviet Union'.)

  • Karl Marxs extremist followers were not in any way impeded in their blood-thirsty global quest by fear of a Higher Power. Atheism took very efficient care of this limiting factor. Since the end justified the means, as Machiavelli had instructed, they could do whatever was necessary to bring about a workers paradise. Because the opposition in some cases proved to be powerful and resilient, drastic means were used.

  • Large numbers were killed for refusing to abandon their religious beliefs. A great many were sent to concentration camps. (For an enlightening, "first-hand" account of suppression of Religion and other "enemies" of Atheistic-Communism in Russia, please read, 'The Gulag Archipelago', by Alexander Solzhenitsyn -- especially Chapter 2.)

  • Communist-atheist leaders, in their own eyes, became supreme, all-knowing, all-wise and all powerful "gods." They had total control over peoples lives and over who lived and who died. Being "gods," they asserted their evil schemes over the masses with brutality and mercilessness.

  • People like Stalin were interested in propagating an ideology, not a look. Nobody was persecuted in the Soviet Union for not having a mustache like Stalin, or for not wearing a uniform similar to his, or for not liking the same food, music or sports. Large numbers were persecuted and killed for practicing religion, and for being interferences to atheist-communist expansion.

  • Moscow's religious policy at this time can only be understood in the context of Soviet security considerations, especially Moscow's concerns about the disaffection of non-Russian nationalities. The Kremlin saw the church not only, and perhaps not even primarily, as a tool for mobilizing and harnessing Russian nationalism throughout the union, but rather as one of several instruments for countering and disarming non-Russian, and anti-Soviet, nationalism.

  • As most tsars could have told Stalin, the Russian Orthodox Church was an effective agent for the Russification of the ethnically diverse and contentious western regions

  • This move, though "seemingly" noble, did not neutralize or excuse his heinous actions toward countless Christians and Muslims who were killed so as to facilitate the spread of Stalin's atheistic-communistic ideology.

  • Militant atheism, therefore, was a major factor in the murder of countless millions, during the past century. Unfortunately, militant atheism, is still driven by some of the same extremist views reminiscent of atheist-communist regimes of old. They, like their predecessors, do not hesitate to admit that they hate God, religion and that they would like to see both disappear forever.

  • You need to read 'Engles and Marx'. Communism is the natural result of extreme atheism. The idea that man decides what is "good" and "evil" lends itself to this extreme. No one is saying that communsim has a monopoly on death. But the 20th century was a blood soaked century with the main casue being communism. So it's valid to say that atheism had a major hand in the violence of the 20th. Why is it so hard for you admit that?

  • Atheism is a basic belief of any version of communism that is descended from Marx's writings. The basic fact of the matter is that any state that was controlled by communism tried to push atheism, and when that has failed, has tried to control the religious beliefs of its citizens.

    In fact, ironically, one of the few truly communist practices that is maintained by "Communist" China is their attempts to control religion in the state.

  • Look at China and North Korea today! Two majority atheist states. They burn down the Churches, kill men, women and children because they are Christian. The police shock them with batons and torture them! They force them to work in labour camps! etc. etc. etc. etc.

  • Communism is a system of economics which is built upon materialist atheism.

  • Pe parintele Calciu l-am cunoscut bine, dar nu stiam ca este el, eream copil. Militari,Apusului bl 44 ultima scara, avea un copil mai mic ca mine cu 3-4ani prin73-74, de multe ori venea impreuna cu cel mic la scoala.Vesnic 4 tineri intr-o Dacie neagra, parcata in scara cu rotile intrate in asfalt, il pazeau zi si noapte. .Pot spune acum ca am avut privilegiul de a sta in preajma parintelui Calciu, l-am vazut si auzit, copilului i-a fost dat sa vada unul din Sfintii inchisorilor comuniste.

  • This documentary should have a place in all Orthodox Church libraries. We have a copy of this in our parish library in Middlebrook, VA.

  • This documentary has really helped me understant a part of our Christian community I didnt even realise went through so much to keep their faith. I have read a book about Elder Arseny. A friend pointed out that his story is set in one of these camps. Can anyone confirm?

  • Elder Arseny Papacioc? I know he did time in the prisons of Braşov, Aiud and Jilava. Just more places of hell...

  • ++++++

  • nice video...greetings from an Orthodox Greek!

  • Slavă Domnului că mai sunt ostenitori care să redea - nouă şi lumii - adevărul despre istoria noastră!

  • Everybody takes on Romania but nobody knows how much we suffered for the hole Europe to survive! Everybody takes what is best from Romania... thats why we are like we are now.

  • Very compelling and sad, yet very inspirational that these people of God were preserved and saved by Him so that the truth could be told to others.

  • And they were only the ones who could speak up.My father was one of the Russians'prisoner for 1 year and a half after 10 years on the Eastern front.

  • All my life I could listen to him ,and wept for how much he endured, the stories he would tell us , his children.

    For us Romanians the greatest joy and health is to know the truth and this video is one of the ways. Thank you for posting it.

  • asta a insemnat comunismul, crime inimaginabile

  • Multumesc foarte mult, ne-ai incalzit inima cu aceste secvente. Pr. Calciu nu de mult mi-a fost duhovnic. Domnul sa-l odihneasca in pace si sa-l aseze in lumea sfintilor Sai.

  • Multumesc din suflet pt.postare! IMPRESIONANT!

  • Esti un mare roman.

    bafta

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more