Earth's motion around the Sun, not as simple as I thought

[rEsonansDx]

So maybe the sun is also rotating and revolves around a bigger object?

[RandomUtuber]

@rEsonansDx It certainly does! It's call a galaxy, and it completes its very own rotations threw space! Everything we can observe in space is moving, there really is no suck thing as "Stationary"

Whether you believe the big bang where it all started from one point moving outward, or the Biblical "God stretched out the heavens" I think its pretty much accepted by most that everything in space is in constant motion.

Now, does our galaxy revolve around something much bigger? Wouldn't that be cool!?

[rEsonansDx]

@RandomUtuber of course it does.. the only problem is,, would you be there to witness it? i think our great great grandsons would be very old. and still the galaxy will not yet complete its revolution. :D

[Reynajaimes]

in this video the sun looks like it will flicker out at any second

[Reynajaimes]

a little too complicated

[iorixs]

earth doesnt rotate or anything Tycho Brahe's model is more likely correct

[BURRiah]

this is incredible!

[SunWindSolar]

From 2:55 you illustrate the Earth as changing its tilt dramatically through the year - which of course confuses the truth. Consistency in presenting spinning axial tilt is preferable. Around 5:06 there's a similar jump. At 6:23 using a yellow circle to demonstrate eccentricity of orbit confuses a bit because that yellow circle image is what you use for Sun. At 8:30 quick tilt change...? Anyway, just comments...pretty good job, all in all...!

[lmtzn]

in addition to all of this, you also need to consider that the sun is moving (I'm sure with the same complexity of earth's movement)

[lmtzn]

Considering that the sun is moving, how can a rocket go to the moon or any other planet? since the minute it leaves the gravitational pull of the earth it would stay way behind, unless it's also being pulled by the sun with the same strength as it pulls the earth (wich would mean that gravity has nothing to do with mass right?)

[obits3]

@lmtzn I think the answer has to do with inertia.

[lmtzn]

@obits3 Inertia would send the rocket in a straight line (right?) which would send it even farther since the earth moves in spirals...

[obits3]

@lmtzn LOL, good question. The answer is found is seeing that the rocked was in motion with the earth even before it launches. It is kind of hard to show with text. Imagine standing in a train that is moving and throwing a ball one foot in the air (no wind resistance). The ball does not just go up and down. An observer no on the train would see the ball go in an ark because it has the inertia from the force of your toss + the original movement of the train. Does that clear it up?

[obits3]

@lmtzn In short, when the rocket is launched, it moves "with" the earth because the earth (and therefore the rocket) were already in motion before the launch.

[lmtzn]

@obits3 thanks, but imagine someone jumps out of a train in the middle of a curve, the train will keep turning but the one that left it will move in a straight line, not in a curve right?

[obits3]

@lmtzn If you take out air resistance and gravity (like it is in space), then the person person jumping perpendicular to the train will continue to move in two dimensions: #1 - The direction that he jumped and #2 - the direction of the train. The initial speed of these two directions will determine his trajectory.

[lmtzn]

@obits3 Cheers, but still don't get it... the final trajectory won't be the same as the earth's trajectory, it will be a tangent to the curve which will leave the rocket far away from the earth, no?

[obits3]

@lmtzn I suppose it would leave the rocket pretty far if it just sling shot out of orbit, lol. Most of our stuff these days takes place in low orbit space, so the earth's gravity keeps those things near the earth. To get to the moon you would have to adjust for all the factors of a moving target (I do suppose it would be easier if you aimed for the angle when the moon is were the earth's orbit is heading too). I hope this is a little more clear.

[Kasdorji]

Nice explanation! What?

[tooncrazy1]

Earth, the drunk planet.

[adzereastonfan]

All those that think the world will end in 2012 can suck it lol next polar shift in 11000 years

[Kaniela1986]

I love this stuff. Thanks for the video but that went way over my head. Best part is 9:08. Might have to use it some time haha

[GazGuitarz]

Nicely put together and explained.

[TrueHamal]

Eminently didactic. A very good job. Thank you.

[squelchdown]

Now I have a headache =(... lol.

[BrainChild666]

The sun is going around the galaxy at near 700 million miles an hour. We have never gone around the sun.

[smallz2k]

huh? ^^

[ArchytypeNet]

Have you looked in to the Binary Research Institute's Theory on what causes the precession of the equinoxes?

[JDrosa1982]

This is simple. He explains it for you.

[skullthroat]

the cycles of earth around sun last min of clip makes the "circle of life" pattern sort of. Maybe every bit of motion is the universe is toroidial.

[mattmacdonald18]

fantastic! cheers!

[BinAlladin]

This is to much information. I can´t handle it. NOOOO I can´t. Please give me medications ,much painkiller and Valium and (perhaps little weed to )

[sosososo11113]

@BinAlladin Just go commit suicide acronym to..... Sadomasochist Underwriter's Indignation of Cacodoxic Inetlligence of Democidical Etymologist's, Oh! I guess that's what you just did.

[BinAlladin]

@sosososo11113 If Jesus Lord say so I will do whatever he the son of God want,may Muhammed bless boy

[copperload]

"Now as an undergraduate at the University of Rochester in Rochester, New York, I'd taken enough relativity theory to know that neither heliocentrism nor geocentricity could be proven or disproven"...Dr.G.D. Bouw

I can't understand after reading the above, why we are still all told to believe we live in a "solar" system.

[16nowhereman]

I'm getting dizzy.

[nicelyt0asted]

Last week I hit a girl with a pineapple



[Nolen87]

O to perfect! Was looking for something like that. Thanks much for the upload! :)

[IAmNinjaMan2000]

@4u250ut even more reason to believe that any living thing cant make it.

[Kinsky2309]

Thank you.. :) great information vid.. :) i liked it..

[TheSuperSPyking]

Does the Sun move? The Qu'ran seems to think so:

Quran 21: 33 It is He who created The Night and Day, And the Sun and Moon; each of them Swim (float) along in its own course.

[Kinsky2309]

@TheSuperSPyking are you serious!!!

[TheSuperSPyking]

@Kinsky2309 yeah truth hurts..if your not use too....

[TheSuperSPyking]

@Kinsky2309 like the serious stars..serious A and serious B..they are orbiting each other while following an orbit..star is an also a sun.

[sosososo11113]

@TheSuperSPyking Uh, isn't that like saying the gyroscope is not manipulated by mass and gravity. mass and gravity are the emulating forces of the entire universe. our solar system is pushing and pulling on the sun and the entire solar system including the sun is in rotation around the center of the galaxy called a black hole.

[MrRonnoc32]

how the hell did any of you get global warming from this?

[silvercoin1111]

great informative video, thanks

[DemonicSymphonic]

great effin video

[iluigui]

i have 18 sideral years!!! hahaha

[neonegypt3]

what about the sun's motion through space?

[germanjulian]

@neonegypt3 it rotates (aka our solar system) with our galaxy the milky way (not the choclate bar)

[Vlum88]

Yeah , so does this explain global warming??? I so want to understand this video fully. Perhaps I am just too stupid lol

[91Holdem]

i got completely following this, mad world innit?

[macpduff]

Thanks so much for sharing these explainations

many of us notice changes, and this helps explain.

Awesome video.

[papatooth1]

we are like balloons being dragged behind a car!!!! if anything this video make me want to learn more. i would like to know who's hiding the time machine?

[ray1mad1]

Very cool! Is it just coincidence that the troipical year is within an hour or so of the siberian year? e.g. couldn't it just as easily been the case that during the tropical year the earth's tilt cycle could have occurred multiple times instead of just once?

[Awesomecraft99]

I don't understand why people think they need to put an echo in their voice when talking about science, or more specifically, astronomy. All it does is make you 1) more difficult to understand 2) sleepy 3) *snore*

[zalmos12]

‎:)...nice, close but ...incomplete, though: even the sun is spiraling around(towards) Alcione...and Alcione around the center of our Milky Way galaxy and ...and our galaxy around another greater galaxy and that one around the center of this local universe and this local universe is also spiraling together wit some other three universes towards a WAAAAAY BIGER AND GREATER CENTRAL UNIVERSE...Now, what about that view...if you can grasp it?!...

[jefersonvilaede]

yeah but this doesnt explain that the sun is moving through space TOO. so we are following it.

[hyoobz]

the universe is fckin' perfect 

[kevinlmanon]

This is not How the Solar System Moves it Moves in Waves not a Path...

[Dianakios]

After watching this,I think God exists

[a4ol]

There is global warming but it is solar and not man made. As explained in this nice gentleman's documentary. As Earth's elliptical orbit changes so does it's exposure to the Sun and it's radiation which obviously includes temperature changes. The cycle is every 25,800 years.

[wbequet]

haha if they are going to spin the planet the other way, does that mean time is going to go backwards? Yeah I will younger!

[fatfantastic]

I ave given great conemplation to the matter of the planets, and i can tell oyu, it is IMPOSSIBLE, without intervention.

There is NO way the whole universe can be sreading out, and the solar system stayes the same.... not fo rth elength of time we are PRESUMING it has, for the earth.

think about it - the entire galaxy is spiralling outwards, liek areverse plug hole, and the sun is moving on it outer egde (or MID edge) - so HOW is our solar system UNNAFECTED ?

It is NOT possible !

[d3th6]

@fatfantastic What do you mean the solar system stays the same?

[fatfantastic]

@d3th6

When i say it stays the same, i mean, as far as WE are concerned, it stays the same.

The sun and the moon NEVER move out of apredictable range, and yet they SHOULD !

think about it - the whole galaxy, and universe is spreading out, like marbles, thrown ontoa floor - BUT, our system statys nice and neat, and APPARENTLY has done for BILLIONS of years.

Things should NOT be so neat and tidy !

THINK !

[d3th6]

@fatfantastic Our system doesn't stay nice and neat...The moon is moving away from the earth at around 1cm/yr due to the earth's angular momentum. In a few billion years the sun will become a red giant and a bit after that our galaxy will collide with M31, and things won't be so neat & tidy then...and they weren't neat and tidy when the solar system was formed. It only appears so in our short lifetimes. Why do you think the sun & moon should move out of a predictable range?

[fatfantastic]

@d3th6

Because, even this 1cm per year, you speak of, when combined with millions of other little disrepencies, make it, over all, unpredictable.

Even that comet which passed by recently MUST have some effect, no matter how small, and that effect adds to all of the other effects (ALL of which are changing, all the time).

For instance, why cant you say the Sun will explode in 1.732226589 billion years ?Answer: Its UNPREDICTABLE, at that level - and so is everything else.

[d3th6]

@fatfantastic Most of those effects are negligible, and that's why you get a confidence interval or expected error value for calculations. You're overgeneralizing and I can't tell if you're a troll or just ignorant of statistics.

[fatfantastic]

@d3th6

Ok, watch this vid, then CONTEMPLATE (if you are capable), the BILLIONS of obstacles, all around the universe, which this system comes across.

I say obstacloes, because EVERY single item (even apiece of dust) has SOME effect. Combine that with all the rocks which have (and still do) hit the earth, with their kinetic energy, as well as their mass, and I say that NOTHING can be accurately measured.

++ The solar system's motion through space ++

But hey, YOU are the extpert, eh ?

[d3th6]

@fatfantastic Who said anything about being an expert? The concept of 'measuring' involves comparing something unknown to something known, and errors like you're referring to are taken into account. When we measure things well enough to make predictions which are verified from observation, we can say we were fairly accurate in our measurements. The gravitational effect which a speck of dust 10ly from here has on your motion on earth is negligible, so we can say it's 0 for all practical purposes.

[fatfantastic]

@d3th6:

Yes, and then you make future predictions based on your "zero" calculation, which is NOT actually zero, by your own admission.

Therefore, at soem point in the future, you WILL be wrong, with EVERY calculation you make, because you KNOWINGLY used falsified figures.

Im just saying you're wrong. Its YOU who is claiming that wrong is right, or nearly right is right, not me !

But you are a book follower so no one can expect you to understand anything which isnt written in your book

[bttrflykiss7701]

@aryannav Why is this under "comedy"? Is this a hoax?

[aryannav]

@bttrflykiss7701 oh! thanks for catching that. have no idea why that happened.

[bttrflykiss7701]

@aryannav cute

[bttrflykiss7701]

@aryannav is it fun to purposely decieve people to gain sick pleasure? jUST WONDERING

[aryannav]

@bttrflykiss7701 !!! not sure what you mean! Deceiving people?! by sharing this informative clip?

[anubhav504010]

awesome vedio buy 2 long

]

[Elminster797]

Now I know why I didn't study physics, it's cause I would have never learned anything.

But i did learn that I was right about not learning therefore I did learn something even tho it was nothing, make sense?

Yeah Yeah well it all makes perfect sense to me... :)

[BitterAgonyKillz]

@Elminster797 it does make sense :P

[Dorisequador]

Made me a bit dizzy I wonder if millions of years ago we didn't pull away from the sun? We had a perfect all year round summer then got hit and then the circle became and egg spin around the sun.

[HaneefanMusliman]

I really really enjoyed this VDO - congrats to 'aryannav'

I do not like to 'Crow' about God, but I cannot help pointing out to you an Aayath in the Holy Quran Surah 55 Aayath No 7

Translation from Yusuf Ali: The sun and the moon follow courses (exactly) computed;

Translation from Dr. Mohsin Khan: The sun and the moon run on their fixed courses (exactly) calculated with measured out stages for each (for reckoning).

Translation from Pikthall: The sun and the moon are made punctual.

Amazing!!

[wils991]

@HaneefanMusliman you fucking paki cunt firstly stop blowing us up you asshole and your book of bullshit is wrong. the moon move around us we move around the sun in a motion affected by gravity from other planets so it doesn't follow course (exactly) computed.

[PeterEaves]

That seriously jusy confused the shit out of me!

[rochelimit55555]

@PeterEaves its the Milankovich cycle, precision, peri-aphelion, change of zodiac thingy. Let's say that if u understand this, you'll free from the 2012 end of the world stuffs and u could probably predict the next ice age.

[chidmb]

Great!! searching for a video like this....got a clear perspective about precession,tropical,anomolous years and rotation of earth's orbit...would like to get a similar video abt moon's orbit

[wbequet]

I want my 'green/global warming' taxes back!

[BitterAgonyKillz]

@wbequet i knew it global warming is a scam by the big man bs 

[fatfantastic]

@wbequet:

Ha ha, yes the global warming tax !

Theya retaxing you now, with the ALLEGED goal of "stabilising the temperature of the planet".

Can you think of ANYTHING mor eIMPOSSIBLE than that ?

We have had 7 ice ages, since the dinosaurs, and if you think al gore could have stopped them, if he had enough money, then you're as daft as him !

Next week, they will announce a tax, to change the course of the planet - make it spin the other way !

[msms47]

this make no sencse ! when we study the power that pull the earth and its trace around the sun -.-

[triggyt]

Good video, except the Earth's orbit is not that elliptical as depicted in the opening sequence and near 6:00 and at the end. Also, the conversation of the variance in seasonal changes between the hemispheres finally says at the end, "if all factors were equal" But they are not, there is more water than land mass in the southern hemisphere which has a greater overall affect on the temperature variation than does the distance from the sun at perihelion vs. aphelion. Oh and the ice age comment.

[darkangel213]

Great vid

[mobinmahmoudi]

wow, 

[SimXLive]

One BIG mistake in this video is that Ice Ages align with the 100,000 yr cycle NOT the 40,000...see Milankovich Cycles this is well documented.

[Fantasmo77]

@SimXLive watch it to the end ;-)

[SimXLive]

@Fantasmo77 I did...what am I supposed to look for, or better yet what frame? BTW it's a good video otherwise.

[narendrasonawane]

This is awesome

[Galagoz1]

I enjoyed this

[TheDhgff]

cool

[g00glian0]

Awesome