Wow, you can really feel the pain, confusion and emotion. "How can I live on such a field" sounds like she's talking about the Earth's surface with problems and feeling so out of place.
Hearing this song, I could feel all the emotions, and reading the translations, it's really something.
I see nothing wrong in here. She just performs singing in her own way and giving the audiences *unforgettable* experiences. Actually this is the one of the most favorites tracks of my collections.
You are right in that her singing is not conventional, not of singers who had traditional voice training. But it's her words and phrasing, squeezed from her soul that matter to me. It would probably sound wrong even, if they were delivered by musically polished voice...Her performance is more like sound poem than manufactured "music" that you can dance with.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
1:34 to 1:45 is just absolute crap. It's just shouting all the way. She has to listen to herself because I don't find this performance very professional. It's very airy which is bad because professional singers must have good control of their breathing. And I don't see this in the performance.
She sings that parts that you mentioned very well. 1:34 the air must be there its part of the song and 1:45 is also good its shouting but its not just shouting he puts emotions in it.
k i dont like the shouting too but anyway she sings very beautiful
I don't believe that she has gone off-pitch in this video. Also, as a fact, we are not deaf, because if we were, we would probably not being watching this music video in the first place. -_-
I believe, what you call "off-pitch" is merely her singing style when she performs live. It gives off a powerful, lively atmosphere.
I love this song so much
romio2703 1 week ago
sings with his nose ..feigned
MeRzHiTa 2 weeks ago
strong voice
jaahhee 2 weeks ago
She is amazing but troubled soul.I pray she find her peace & keep singing.Welcome back & fight.Don't give up
faheemomj 3 months ago
n_n... amo sta cancion
aozoraga 4 months ago
her voice is weird, but I like it. she gives it a special feeling.
Natsukinon 5 months ago
I am god's child placed on this desolate world
how can i live on such a field
i wasn't born for this kind of purpose.
Kind of messed up translation but hey, i haven't lived in japan since i was 17 :)
yellowhelloable 7 months ago
I respect her cos she stands up for herself
yellowhelloable 7 months ago
i hate the way she stands and her posture..but yet shes an amazing singer..i adore her voice its so strong
ja9failure 8 months ago
I love all of her songs.She is really amazing.
85darkqueen 8 months ago
Sorry guys, but I'm basically here because of Taemin.. <3 But her voice is amazing. I never thought Taemin will like this kind of songs..
chrischaleone 8 months ago 4
Just to listen to the intro... <3
There is nobody like her.
youtubister 10 months ago
no , her not like who , she is onit , just only!
lonelyran 11 months ago
Impressive voice and emotion. I love her musical works.
CirclingFalcon 1 year ago
@youtubister
that doesn't matter :o
Hiwatari94 1 year ago
I get Goosebumps when I hear this!
She's awesome...
LaxRemede 1 year ago
how beautiful ...
Thank you for sharing.
erinkoeringi 1 year ago
Wow! I <3 this song!
Thanks for sharing!
wakyan8 1 year ago
waaaay good
jensen85 1 year ago
Great voice. Really beautiful and deep. It feels like she touches my soul with her words.
Shinibo 2 years ago 4
Gracias, me gusta mas su voz en vivo qu en el cd.... que bonita cancion, la letra es bella
T_T
moshi7kimi 2 years ago
Amazing.
endGodot 2 years ago 2
The best
NiniaVibar 2 years ago
The best
NiniaVibar 2 years ago
清唱部分我聽到哭了
太感動!!
applelft 2 years ago
すごい。
ちーちゃん最高。
ichi1974 2 years ago
她唱歌的時候很投入在歌曲的意境裡面, 因此歌聲充滿了情感, 時而細膩時而激昂, 情感的表達非常強烈, 容易讓人產生共鳴, 個人很欣賞她 :)
YuskaWu 2 years ago
ほんとに すごい!!!!
wonderful voice!
hueLyaHR 2 years ago 2
Wow, you can really feel the pain, confusion and emotion. "How can I live on such a field" sounds like she's talking about the Earth's surface with problems and feeling so out of place.
Hearing this song, I could feel all the emotions, and reading the translations, it's really something.
Thank you for putting this up. :)
alohakakahiaka 3 years ago 22
I think, she's like a japanese Celine Dion :)
Hiwatari94 3 years ago 13
@Hiwatari94 really? I thought she more of the alanis morisette-ish singer of Japan :3
mgswhore 1 year ago
@mgswhore
maybe she's both? :3
Hiwatari94 1 year ago
@Hiwatari94
You must be joking. They are separated by millennia.
youtubister 1 year ago
@Hiwatari94 Thats what I thought at the first time I listened to her :)
LaLLoronaBJ 2 months ago
我喜欢她!!
ainia3000 4 years ago
4:27のこんな想いじゃ
の時の表情が好きです
うれしいです、うれしいです
ありがとう
utamaru1975 4 years ago 2
I see nothing wrong in here. She just performs singing in her own way and giving the audiences *unforgettable* experiences. Actually this is the one of the most favorites tracks of my collections.
jaeh7020 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
compare to this live, kotoko is a goddes of goddes...
Maiku87 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's not that I don't find her singing nice. It's just that she's not singing very professionally there. It's a bit piercing to the ears
wizardo 4 years ago
You are right in that her singing is not conventional, not of singers who had traditional voice training. But it's her words and phrasing, squeezed from her soul that matter to me. It would probably sound wrong even, if they were delivered by musically polished voice...Her performance is more like sound poem than manufactured "music" that you can dance with.
Kryptomass 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
1:34 to 1:45 is just absolute crap. It's just shouting all the way. She has to listen to herself because I don't find this performance very professional. It's very airy which is bad because professional singers must have good control of their breathing. And I don't see this in the performance.
wizardo 4 years ago
She sings that parts that you mentioned very well. 1:34 the air must be there its part of the song and 1:45 is also good its shouting but its not just shouting he puts emotions in it.
k i dont like the shouting too but anyway she sings very beautiful
Mighty1337 4 years ago 4
Her voice or the way she sings reminds me a bit of Alanis morissette. Good or bad? Who knows...
tuckcp 3 years ago
I love her lives and Gekkou is favorite along with Infection, two beautiful songs
Babo7458 4 years ago
wow shes pretty...first time to see her
imaddictedtoanime101 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
awfull or what..Yui's concert performance is more awful...its like her voice is off pitch too
imaddictedtoanime101 4 years ago
Its still about the feeling/singing the song, all the way...
dller 4 years ago 2
she went off-ptich so badly and SO MUCH!
are you all deaf?
i really like the song but this is AWFUL!
i know it's not fair to expect her to sing exactly like how she did in the CD,
but this is of unacceptable standard for a singer...
but great song all d same :)
yootewbsarks 4 years ago
I don't believe that she has gone off-pitch in this video. Also, as a fact, we are not deaf, because if we were, we would probably not being watching this music video in the first place. -_-
I believe, what you call "off-pitch" is merely her singing style when she performs live. It gives off a powerful, lively atmosphere.
*This is entirely my opinion. xP
Litewingz 4 years ago 2
she's a very good singer and this performance is excellent compared to others i've seen.
theillest321 4 years ago
this song from TRICK 1 ^_^! heheheh..btw nice movie ^^
softice 4 years ago
Wow! Such a beautiful song! Thnx for uploading because I just stumbled upon this song and it looked interesting. I wouldn't have ever heard it. :)
ChellzNCheez 4 years ago
oh my god, she's the japanise singing's goddes... never listened to anything better
Nochewish 5 years ago
this should be named: gekkou on steroids or super gekkou, except she takes too much liberty with her english.
granodemostasa 5 years ago
does anybody know why she stop singing??
Ilariachan 5 years ago
all I know is that she got surgery on her throat:S
AyselZaria 5 years ago
I think this is the best live performance for her of singing Gekkou
emmettlins 5 years ago
miss her so much
Mu8384 5 years ago
absolutely love her... shame about the English! "how do I live on such a field"???
rikkinihon 5 years ago
how is that improper? It sounds like a poetic license to me.
zdthn 5 years ago
Do I live on such a field
GodTube 5 years ago
beautiful...i love watching her sing^_^ so much emotion
vaag3 5 years ago
She's awesome
love her voice and her songs
^^
Yumikko 5 years ago