What a shame the English language is losing its nuances. "Trebles" should properly be restricted to boys. It is the same thing with "students" - where the proper word should be "pupils". Using it demeans the real meaning of "students", when one goes to college or uni after school.... IMO. This is a children's choir of boys and girls.
That is WAY different from our choirs version. It sounds better when you slow it down & have alot of grace notes for the girls. We are performing this at Southern Divion in March.
all u muppets moaning that they are out of tune and that the tempo is wrong, y dnt u get a life, there only kids singing not pros. they sounded good 2 me
A person of reasonable intelligence would recognize that any criticism regarding the tempo is not an attack on the performers, but a commentary on the carelessness of the director. And I concur-- this is so rushed that all the lovely minutes inherent in this piece, that would otherwise speak beauty and joy to the spirit, are lost entirely because of the lightning fast tempo. Pity.
@gimmeachallenge I agree that it is a little fast for the kids, but people also have to realize that Rutter's version is supposed to be much faster than the original. The original has the tempo somewhere around a quarter note= 50, his version is at 112. That's how he wrote it. They should have done the original hymn version to get the slower beauty out of it.
We are doing this song in my choir at the same tempo. But the thing is, we are trained singers not new singers. I think its way too fast for the children here. But this truly is a wonderful song
I think the tempo is an ok tempo...however I believe this tempo maybe too difficult for the children to sing at this tempo. A slow down maybe necessary in order for it to provide a less rushed feeling for the listener. Rutter sometimes has faster tempo songs however, never rushed songs.
You say "sung at about that tempo" That also means it could be slower! and it should be, I agree with the others. Some of the detail is missing or rushed over, and where is the phrasing? This is just pushed through without much feeling at all. For a truly beautiful performance listen to Libera, that's what it should sound like.
Sorry i dont like this version, it should be kept as the original version and nothing else
MmD4L94 8 months ago
My chorus group is singing this(; -3 Best song we have done(:
mallylovesyouuu 9 months ago
My chorus is singing this soon. :)
Madikinz123 10 months ago
What a shame the English language is losing its nuances. "Trebles" should properly be restricted to boys. It is the same thing with "students" - where the proper word should be "pupils". Using it demeans the real meaning of "students", when one goes to college or uni after school.... IMO. This is a children's choir of boys and girls.
organisten 11 months ago
Is it a bit fast? But as whole, they sang quite good^^
abciloveughs 1 year ago
why the hell can't people sing it properly like when it is sung in church
putty1994 1 year ago
Evidently, 8 people burst into flames when in the the presence of all things bright and beautiful.
willace11 1 year ago
Their smiles are convincing enough for the performance-- all things bright and beautiful.
hatemalky 1 year ago
not that they're not good or anything but this isnt a treble choir...there are girls in it.
Gernald10 1 year ago
Pretty good. but i wonder. THe boys doesn't have any power. they sounds just mixed with the soprano. -,-
balezzaku 1 year ago
@balezzaku they are boy sopranos and the idea is that they blend in with the girl sopranos.
musicedworld 1 year ago 6
@musicedworld oh i c. i think i didn't see the SA choir. haha. thanks anyway. but it's pretty good in SATB anyway.
balezzaku 1 year ago
So nice to hear this famous Sunday School hymn in Rutter's arrangement sung by KIDS!!!
gramps2matt 1 year ago
This is exactly the tempo I would choose. Perfect!
robbicu 1 year ago
excellent choir, excellent blending, tempo is way to fast but it didn't manage to ruin it on the whole
Narsil1000 1 year ago
thisis a good song
SuperArdez 1 year ago
haha .. were going to sing this version , this comming monday .. oh my god :)) i really love this song ..
- oDEHssa :X
dagmaguy 1 year ago
Impressive. It may be a little too fast, but also somehow.. sparkling. Reminds me of a small river flowing on rocks.
It's no small choir but the voices sound as one. Not an easy thing to achieve with kids. Compliments to the conductor.
Bartkun 2 years ago 10
@Bartkun Yea, The Blending is impeccable
jerrywongcc 1 year ago
these kids are amazing! most highschoolers at my school can't sing like this!
sakuraoneechan 2 years ago
there are two versions of this song, and they are both sooooooo beautiful!!
Kitty95Cat 2 years ago
now I see you posted here to lol, this is the version I dont know the tune of, but want to :/ any idea ?
ancientsolar 2 years ago
lol my choir is singing this version
girl121carolyn 2 years ago
Omg its way faster that what i had to sing at my choir concert!
punky396 2 years ago
That is WAY different from our choirs version. It sounds better when you slow it down & have alot of grace notes for the girls. We are performing this at Southern Divion in March.
KATYBUGG96 2 years ago
its too fast i sang it in my Church Chior much slower!
AXELkh2ismine 2 years ago
me too
gingin573 2 years ago
what is up with this version? I certainly have never heard it before :S
moshpotpaul 2 years ago
all u muppets moaning that they are out of tune and that the tempo is wrong, y dnt u get a life, there only kids singing not pros. they sounded good 2 me
triggerpepsi 2 years ago
A person of reasonable intelligence would recognize that any criticism regarding the tempo is not an attack on the performers, but a commentary on the carelessness of the director. And I concur-- this is so rushed that all the lovely minutes inherent in this piece, that would otherwise speak beauty and joy to the spirit, are lost entirely because of the lightning fast tempo. Pity.
gimmeachallenge 2 years ago 6
Agreed, dont blame the kids, it is indeed the conductor's responsibility.
musicedworld 2 years ago
@gimmeachallenge I agree that it is a little fast for the kids, but people also have to realize that Rutter's version is supposed to be much faster than the original. The original has the tempo somewhere around a quarter note= 50, his version is at 112. That's how he wrote it. They should have done the original hymn version to get the slower beauty out of it.
dudleydoglucifer 1 year ago
A wonderful song.I had the great pleasure to sing this song in a church in cologne yesterday and john rutter himself was there.Many thanks.
motherbulbei 2 years ago
Beautiful song ! sang this for years in a choir here in Germany ! Amazing felling to sing John Rutter in a church ! :)
MusicandMore2009 2 years ago
sang this two years in a row. Love this song.
zeMusicluver 2 years ago
i luv this wonderful song..i will sing it at my church choir,, but the tempo is too fast!! still good though
cutiefairy123 3 years ago
my select singing group at school is singing this and she said this is how its suppose to be and she said to use this video to practice with
Faraway52 3 years ago
We are doing this song in my choir at the same tempo. But the thing is, we are trained singers not new singers. I think its way too fast for the children here. But this truly is a wonderful song
Sportschic1012 3 years ago
kinda faster than the version we sing at my choir....
popstarmania 3 years ago 2
I think the tempo is an ok tempo...however I believe this tempo maybe too difficult for the children to sing at this tempo. A slow down maybe necessary in order for it to provide a less rushed feeling for the listener. Rutter sometimes has faster tempo songs however, never rushed songs.
razakahn 3 years ago
i dont think its too fast at all, i like the song and i think its sang well
triggerpepsi 3 years ago
What's the hurry?
mtoshamtosha 3 years ago
There is no hurry, the original score does state that it should be sung at about that tempo.
doenen 3 years ago
You say "sung at about that tempo" That also means it could be slower! and it should be, I agree with the others. Some of the detail is missing or rushed over, and where is the phrasing? This is just pushed through without much feeling at all. For a truly beautiful performance listen to Libera, that's what it should sound like.
chandros 3 years ago
Too Fast.....
But good harmony............
choirlover22 3 years ago 2
bit fast for my liking but its ok :)
we did this in our choir but a little bit slower and in two parts awell as you :)
samloveshorses 3 years ago
me 2 I did the split in our choir and it was slower 2.. I'm in soprano. but I like the alto and the bass's slit..
popstarmania 3 years ago
wonderfull song!
grumal12 3 years ago