Why do people have to be so hateful on youtube? I think both versions of this song are amazing...Simon and Garfunkel for obviously writing it and their rendition is amazing and i love what hear'say did with the harmony...They are both brilliant in their own right...:)
@Super1993STAR1993 .....true aye ... i love this song ... no matter who sings it ... i do love this version too ...... love and loyalty ... that is what this world needs ... and lots of it too ..........
Thank you Simon and Garfunkel for one of the all-time classics.
And thank you Hearsay, for being able to encapsulate in 4 minutes the whole essence of what is wrong with the "talent" which is unearthed via the now ubiquitous TV talent show. If ever I find myself thinking that maybe, just maybe, they will unearth some real talent, I simply remind myself of this aberration and quickly come to my senses.
I don't doubt the sincerity of their intent, but as for execution - they should be.
I have seen them perform this on telly, just cant remember where. I think it was on here for a while, anyone know where it's gone. Really enjoyed it and wish I could see it again, love this version.
strange for shite they sound alrite i think they should hav stayed together and grown up with their singing I really thought the dark guy was talented watz he doin now
Mylene Klass was out of place with this group, but she has done well since. She is a classicly trained musician (and drop dead gorgeous, but that by the way!!)
If you don't like their music, why look them up ? They split coz, the boys weren't interested in being famous anymore, they were just happy to have won the comp, all three females are still semi famous, Kim Marsh went solo and was dating the guy who played Jamie Mitchell Suzanne married Darren day and Myleene is very successful and OMG she plays that piano beautifully
No - they weren't shite. The true story I remember as it goes was that they were so successful in having strong number ones that they no longer recognised how to compare they are singing tune wise. There was also conflictions between members. Still best group singers from Pop Idols along people like Kelly Clarkson and such
Hello, Please would someone be kind enough to point me in the direction of the documentary that was about why they broke up etc? . . . I'm going crazy trying to find it and I can't find it. Please reply to my comment and let me know. I would be so great full thanks so much in advanced.
I'll tell you what happened, they were reduced to playing pubs, cuz they were shite, which impacted their ego's and caused friction between the band mates. Each accusing one another of holding them back. Apparently the one on corrie was the only one being held back (not a lot mind you) because the rest are all homeless or so I've heard, or wished.
the arrangement is the same as the simon and garfunkel version so....there. and also, it's not fair to compare voices since everyone's voices are unique, so nobody apart from simon and garfunkel can sound like simon and garfunkel. tut tut to you for being too hasty in your criticism
Got a newsflash for you all about the arrangment -- this song was first done by Simon and Garfunkel waaaayyyy back in the 70's, and this is how the song was arrangd then, so dont knock it LOL.
i remember this version, i loved it when it came out!
StarletDancer01 9 months ago
i had that cd single and this was the 2nd song (there was only 2) awhhhh memories <3
Queenofmynamesucks 9 months ago
defo the best version
lisapalli1981 1 year ago
the guy on the far right looks like shrek
sonnydanman 1 year ago
Does anybody know if Kym Marsh takes it up the chuff-chuff?
MuslimPaedophile1 1 year ago
Why do people have to be so hateful on youtube? I think both versions of this song are amazing...Simon and Garfunkel for obviously writing it and their rendition is amazing and i love what hear'say did with the harmony...They are both brilliant in their own right...:)
Super1993STAR1993 1 year ago 2
@Super1993STAR1993 .....true aye ... i love this song ... no matter who sings it ... i do love this version too ...... love and loyalty ... that is what this world needs ... and lots of it too ..........
13sinclair 1 year ago
Thank you Simon and Garfunkel for one of the all-time classics.
And thank you Hearsay, for being able to encapsulate in 4 minutes the whole essence of what is wrong with the "talent" which is unearthed via the now ubiquitous TV talent show. If ever I find myself thinking that maybe, just maybe, they will unearth some real talent, I simply remind myself of this aberration and quickly come to my senses.
I don't doubt the sincerity of their intent, but as for execution - they should be.
lowdeckrap 1 year ago
I remember really liking this version and I still do. Usually classics cant be improved on but in this case they can be, lol.
EvilQueenofHearts 1 year ago
no way does this simon and garfunkel
stevewhu 1 year ago
I have seen them perform this on telly, just cant remember where. I think it was on here for a while, anyone know where it's gone. Really enjoyed it and wish I could see it again, love this version.
steadysteadyed 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I have seen them perform this on telly, just cant remember where. Really enjoyed it and wish I could see it again, love this version.
steadysteadyed 1 year ago
strange for shite they sound alrite i think they should hav stayed together and grown up with their singing I really thought the dark guy was talented watz he doin now
tracegnet 1 year ago
I have seen them perform this on telly, just cant remember where. Really enjoyed it and wish I could see it again, love this version.
steadysteadyed 1 year ago
much better than Charlotte Church,i love this song.
messyhead4 1 year ago
just enjoy the song , they was good ...
dizzzzzzy 1 year ago
Mylene Klass was out of place with this group, but she has done well since. She is a classicly trained musician (and drop dead gorgeous, but that by the way!!)
M4nC1tif4n 2 years ago
If you don't like their music, why look them up ? They split coz, the boys weren't interested in being famous anymore, they were just happy to have won the comp, all three females are still semi famous, Kim Marsh went solo and was dating the guy who played Jamie Mitchell Suzanne married Darren day and Myleene is very successful and OMG she plays that piano beautifully
gigglebuttuk 2 years ago
No - they weren't shite. The true story I remember as it goes was that they were so successful in having strong number ones that they no longer recognised how to compare they are singing tune wise. There was also conflictions between members. Still best group singers from Pop Idols along people like Kelly Clarkson and such
m00fgs00 2 years ago
Ahhahhah awful
mjharden0223 2 years ago
i love this song!!!! im in chours at skool an were singin this i like the elvis and jackson 5 versions the best includin this 1 <3333333
tweetybab74 2 years ago
apparently they broke up because they began to have differences...
MaddiieBabes 2 years ago
apparently they broke up because they were shite.
johntuohy 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
LickleTeaser 2 years ago
ok- were shite & had differences.. :]
MaddiieBabes 2 years ago
the only differences they had were that they couldn't collectively agree how shite they were :)
johntuohy 2 years ago
woo; ok, good sum up. :]
MaddiieBabes 2 years ago
Hello, Please would someone be kind enough to point me in the direction of the documentary that was about why they broke up etc? . . . I'm going crazy trying to find it and I can't find it. Please reply to my comment and let me know. I would be so great full thanks so much in advanced.
LewisDre4m 2 years ago
I'll tell you what happened, they were reduced to playing pubs, cuz they were shite, which impacted their ego's and caused friction between the band mates. Each accusing one another of holding them back. Apparently the one on corrie was the only one being held back (not a lot mind you) because the rest are all homeless or so I've heard, or wished.
johntuohy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You can tell there are soooo many effects being used over Noels voice......cos homie can't sing for shit!
TheBlain08 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OMG!... this is the worst version i have actually heard of this song!
JKSKID123 2 years ago
WHERE CAN I DOWNLOAD THIS SONG????
if anybody knows, PLEASE tell me
Jiddso 2 years ago
LimeWire, iTunes or mp3 sites on the net, there are free ones :)
Theaterfreak 2 years ago
best version by a mile
kraksly 3 years ago 3
@kraksly
Ermm...I think you know you're wrong dont you
frapestyle 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol, what a way to ruin an amazing song
CamillaRhodes 3 years ago
this is the BEST version of this song anywhere !
OffroadingBoyo 3 years ago 11
Rubbish you can never beat simon and garfunkel this shit compared.
Samwhitesdreamtales1 3 years ago
the arrangement is the same as the simon and garfunkel version so....there. and also, it's not fair to compare voices since everyone's voices are unique, so nobody apart from simon and garfunkel can sound like simon and garfunkel. tut tut to you for being too hasty in your criticism
lichenxu123 2 years ago 5
@OffroadingBoyo I have my doubts
BobCassidy 1 year ago
@OffroadingBoyo
Yeah....erm....I think you know you're wrong, dont' you.
frapestyle 1 year ago
@frapestyle
I like the fact that I am entitled to an opinion, and in my opinion this is the Best version I have heard to date...
OffroadingBoyo 1 year ago
Where can I download this song?
Jiddso 3 years ago
dio maiale.. O_O bella voce!!! 5++++
alexcanadair 3 years ago 2
wat was the last song they did wiv kym?
luc025 3 years ago
i think it was everybody
it was on that album i know that
anoif19 3 years ago
oo okii thnxs very muchly :D:D:D
luc025 3 years ago
Got a newsflash for you all about the arrangment -- this song was first done by Simon and Garfunkel waaaayyyy back in the 70's, and this is how the song was arrangd then, so dont knock it LOL.
Jonbwriter 3 years ago
i love this song want it in my weddin
staceyandlorren 3 years ago 2
i like hearsay but this is just a bad arrangement of this song, they could have arranged it so so so much better
kate452 3 years ago
i absoluteley loved hear'say...
and i dont see the point in people leaving bad comments, insulting comments! if you don't like them so much, then navigate away from them!
DUHH!
bedheadbread 3 years ago 3
I forgot just how good that Danny was
gingerkisses 3 years ago 4
Saw Danny today in Hemel HJepstead town centre dfoing charity work for Great Ormond street hospital
neilomartin1 3 years ago 5
You saw who?????!!!!!!
kkpb7731 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shrek features.
kevster1314 3 years ago
hear'say harmonies are second to none
slade1971 3 years ago 5
@slade1971
.....Righteous Brothers, Everly Brothers, Simon and Garfunkel, Hall and Oats...you want me to go on?
frapestyle 1 year ago
I know this is nothing compared to the original but I love the harmonies in it
ToonNic 3 years ago 5
Suzzane is in itv's "Dancing on Ice" now!
xlozellisx 4 years ago 2
We all Know that!! IDIOT! hahahaha! :D
kisserqueen 3 years ago
what happened to noel
xLaynieBabieex 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he moved to fijji with steven gately
kevster1314 3 years ago
Omg i rellli miss hearsay :(
god it makes me cry jst listening 2 them agen!! XOX-LORZ-XOX
emmalouisebricee 4 years ago
Myleene did "im a celeb" I love her...and kym!.. Come bck Noel!!:)
xXxLaur2K7xXx 4 years ago
i know noels doin sumet 2 do wit sum play sumtime at the end of this yr! nd it sed sumet bout him goin solo sumtime aswell lol xxxx
Lealuvzharryjudd4eva 4 years ago
I know what happened to marlene any one know what happened to the rest of them?
AnglOsAxOn2 4 years ago
kims currently acting in itv's coronation street but dunno about any of the others, i was well upset wen they split up i was a massive fan luvd em
spliffy64 4 years ago
best version that comes close to the original... especially kyms parts
kezzy78 4 years ago
not bad but not half as good as the origonal
mairawi 4 years ago
May have done a half decent job, but this version does NOT do this classic song any justice at all.
octomonkey1980 4 years ago
i dnt agree, i thought they did a really gd job!
HayleyG2007 4 years ago
oui
1goodbookworm 4 years ago
they slaughtered a really gud song!!!
loveablelaura19 4 years ago