Added: 4 years ago
From: baseballstar132
Views: 59,025
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (431)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Your List Is Complete Bullshit Man

  • Prince Fielder is the worst fielder I have ever seen in person at second base. Your list sucks.

  • @ztaylor1197 dumbass hes first baseman

  • roby cano should be first and really disagree in everything

  • 2nd base cano is number 1

  • @Koenigsegg250 Roids

  • @baseball4life337 No ofense but a trully baseball fan knows not just about the present, Vizquel is above all of those SS, you are talking about Scutaro that is venezuelan too but where is Vizquel? 11 times Gold Glove winner, *Highest career fielding % by a SS (0.985). 22 years in MLB, 95 games in a row w/o an error, 271 Battng Avrg (really good for a SS that relies on his defense) 1st Ballot Hall of Famer for sure, still at his 44 is best defensive active plyr and one of the greatest in history.

  • People need to remember this was made in 2007

  • cano is up there with the top three for sure... 1-utley 2-cano 3-pedroia

    I think cano would be a better shortstop than jeter... has a better arm and more range. Jeter is just the face of Yankees and everybody know jeter is SS until he retires

  • Mark Teixeira is hands down the best fielder in the league. this video was made in 2007, but, now as of 2010, Teixeira is the best

  • wheres Adrian Gonzolez?

  • Wheres paul konerko at? He's the best defensive first basemen.. and he can hit homeruns.

  • how is pujols behind howard especially when this vi was made better hitter and fielder

  • dan uggla is way better then every 2b man out there

  • aaron hill should be in there

  • miguel cabera beats youk out by a long shot but i just relized this is from 07 haha but hes at least number 2 or 3

  • ever thought about posting them from 5 to 1 and how is ryan howard better than pujols he strikes out 500 times a year come on dude

  • carlos gonzalaz

  • @chicagofan43 plays outfield

  • This is one of the worst lists i have ever seen. EPIC FAIL!

  • where is rolen

  • @bluejaybaseballfan rolen plays 3rd base dude

  • @MrBallashockcolla yea it says best infeilder

  • albert should be #1

  • @italiandude6789 albert is a very good slugger but he is not the best in feilder

  • Albert is definitely better than Ryan Howard

  • mixing all 5 tools, here's my list 1B Albert Pujols (The best player in majors) Mark Teixeira (It's All About Consistence) Ryan Howard (Ruthian Power) Kevin Youkilis (Best Damn Fielder Of AL) Adrian González (Swing and Glove) 2B Dustin Pedroia (If he could only reach 20 homers) Chase Utley (MVP Caliber, isn't?) Ian Kinsler (5 TOOL?) Brandon Phillips (A Consistent Player) Robinson Canó (C´mon He got to show us all his talent)
  • they all suck theyre just good hitters

  • Albert puljos is the best player in the league, how in any way shape or form is ryan howard better, and also miguel cabrerra is better than prince fielder

  • 1B. Pujols, Howard, Fielder, teixera, Adrian Gonzolez

    2B. Utley, Cano, Pedroia, Kinsler, Uggla

    3B. A-rod (unfortunately), Chipper Jones, Zimmerman, Rolen, Wright

    SS. Hanley (even tho hes not a SS), Reyes, Jeter, Tulowitski, ______(your pick)...not rollins

    OF. Vernon Wells, Ryan Braun, Carl Crawford

    C. Brian Mccann, Yadi, Bengi

    (your out of your god-loving mind for putting eckstien in there......are you serioues dude?)

  • @dwenyc417 u know ur baseball... well done

  • @ryno0034 thanks but Id like to make a correction and take Wright out of there...idk what happened to him...actually i do but i dont feel like going into that......and i also wanna take jeter out of there (he's slowing down a lot)

    I also want to take crawford out of there and add in JAY BRUCE...call me crazy

  • @dwenyc417 Dont take out jeter.... sure hes slowing down, hes a sleeping mvp never count him out. Outfielders are hard to figure out though

  • @ryno0034 ehhh i guess so but idk its a tough one...i guess when it comes to jeter its an oppinion thing

  • wen ppl wanna watch this they look for best fielders.

  • 1B #1. Derrek Lee #2. Albert Pujols #3. Prince Fielder #4. Mark Teixeira #5. Kevin Youkilis 2B #1. Dustin Pedroia #2. Chase Utley #3. Derek Jeter #4. Jeff Kent #5. David Eckstein
  • @beatlesdude5 Neither Jeter or Eckstein play 2B. . .

  • @Akadema09, Eckstein does dude, I made an error putting Jeter tho, Robinson Cano should be in the Jeter spot lol

  • remember this is 3 years old...this is when ryan howard hit like 50 home runs with over a .300 avg.

  • albert is the best 1st baseman

  • Chase Utley is the best second baseman right now not all of those people. They suck compared to him. Ryan Howard may not be the best but he's PRETTY DAMN GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!

  • albert is way better than howard

  • where is Chase Utley? he deserves to be on the list more than all the second base players bcuz he is the best second baseman in baseball now.

  • @kcamowje robinson cano is way wayyyyyyyyyyy better

  • I don't know. Orlando Hudson is a great defender at second. It's not the best hitter, right? Ryan Howard does not belong in that group. Pujols and Tex do. Agreed on Biggio over Pedroia. Two Red Sox and two Yankees...hmmmm.

  • Ryan Howard? Kevin Youkilis? Where's Derek Jeter? Or Jose Reyes..?

  • Where the heck is Hanley Ramariez

  • @VFW25 not on here he plays shortstop not first or second

  • @sandman542 not on here bcuz they are shortstops not first base abd second base players

  • first of all pujols is way better at first than howard.

  • ryan howard suck big cock at firstbase

  • melvin mora plays third

  • wtf akbert pojuls is so much better than howard

  • You got Pedroia ahead of Biggio? Dont get me wrong Pedroia is a hell of a ball player, but i deffiitely think BIGGIO has him beat..

  • this is about fielding, not batting. just because ryan howarn has power doesnt mean he is the best first baseman

  • Where is Chase Utley????????

  • dude you're an idiot howard over pujols???

  • he made this 2 years ago

  • so he was stil better than him then

  • seriously, Aaron Hill, dude is a god, and noone seems to notice him cause he plays for Toronto

  • calm down it was made in 2007

  • you need to update this plz

  • moras not even a 2nd baseman -.-

  • 1. Albert Pujols

    2. Ryan Howard

    3. Prince Fielder

    4. justin mourneou

    5. Mark texiera

    1.Dustin Pedroia

    2.Ian Kinsler

    3.Chase Utley

    4. Craig Biggio

    1,000,000. Me!

  • PUJOLS #1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • There is no way Placido Polanco is better that Dustin Pedroia

  • chase utley should at least be in the top 3 for second base

  • Pujols= #1

  • berkman

  • even though this video was made in 07 it is still pretty shitty

  • BIG-G-IO

  • pujols should be #1

    Cano doesnt belong on top 5

  • this video was made the year after howard won MVP. if this was an up to date video then pujols should be number one i agree

  • MELVIN MORA 2nd base? lol

  • cano is deff not #5 on that list stupid ass

  • Melvin Mora doesn't even play second base... Dumbass

  • thats all wrong. Youk should be higher up with Texeria

  • did youkilis die or something

    1)Puljos

    2)Youkilis

    3)Teixera

    4)Howard

    5)monreau

  • Dan uggla and chase utley peka bo i can't see you.

  • wheres dan uggla??

  • DAN UGGLA

  • um yanksfgan chase ultley plays second base and this is all wrong

  • chase utley should be #2 for shortstop and pedroia should be #1

  • 1. Mark Texeria

    2. Ryan Howard

    3. Fernando Tatis

    4. Jason Giambi

    5. Justin Morneau

  • Nope.

    1. Albert Pujols

    2. Justin Morneau

    3. Adrian Gonzalez

    4. Miguel Cabrera

    5. Mark Teixeira

  • r u kidding

    1.puljos

    2.howard

    3.fielder

    4.youk

    5.morneau

  • wheres chase utley at second base man you need to watch some baseball

  • 1B #1 Justin Morneau #2 Ryan Howard #3 Albert Pujols #4Kevin Youkilis #5 Prince Fielder 2B #1 Chase Utley #2 Ian Kinsler #3 Dustin Pedroia #4 Robinson Cano #5 Chris Getz
  • what about short and 3rd retard

  • he has other videos douchbag

  • wow wheres pacido palonco, or monta ellis?

  • 1B #1 Albert Pujols #2 Ryan Howard #3 Mark Teixeira #4 Prince Fielder #5 Derek Lee 2B #1 Chase Utley #2 Dustin Pedroia #3 Ian Kinsler #4 Robinson Cano #5 Chris Getz
  • idk how good pujols is in the field but Mark Teixeira belongs as #1 in my opinion, if anything i would take fielder's 600lbs ass outa there.

  • @baseballaddict69 dude, polanco was one of the best, fool!

  • @baseballaddict69 thats how i would put it Pujols would be first he is the best

  • @baseballaddict69 obviously no love for the west coast

  • @baseballaddict69 chris getz?

  • yall are retarted............not good defense players at all...........way better fielders than them at infield.

  • #1 Pojols

    #2 Howard

    #3 Morneau

    #4 Cabrera

    #5 Teixeira

  • Where's Jack Wilson, David Wright, or Derek Jeter.

  • dumbass wilsons is shortstop, wright is a third baseman, and jeter is a shortstop and this a montage of first and second baseman

  • dumb ass we are only talking about first base and second base

  • wheres Morneau

  • Where the Hell is Chase Utley

  • Pujols is Number 1 no question

  • why is pujol#2 and no#1

  • pedroia sucks balls defesively

    he has NO range

    he does make some good plays but they are on balls that could be handled easily by any medeocre infielder

  • no range my ass! do u even watch sox games? he lays out completly every game and he takes all of 2nd and back of 1st for youlk! hes a dirt dog and u kno it - try tuning in to nesn sumtimes instead of watchin queer eye! and trust me ul see that ur rong u dumbfuck

  • if u payed attention to stats dustin pedroia has few errors he is the best defensive 2nd basemen in the AL

  • dis is shyt hea r ma top 5 1B #1 Albert Pujols #2 Mark Teixeira #3 Kevin Youkilis #4 Prince Fielder #5 Ryan Howard 2B #1 Chase Utley #2 Dustin Pedroia #3 Robinson Cano #4 Craig Biggio #5 Akinori Iwamura
  • stupid video

  • ...stupid video as in rankings?

  • Derrek Lee has 3 gold glove awards and averages 1 error a season and hes not even on here

  • ya dude those #'s wer from like 05'

  • Wheres Chase Utley?

  • ryan howard is horrible albert #1

  • Pujols is putting up inner circle HOF numbers with elite defense and he's number 2?!

  • Alberts first bitches!!!

  • woah woah woah ryan howard is not a good defensive first baseman. not as good as alot of others anyways. worst strikout master ive ever seen but ive got to give it to him. he drops bombs

  • how can you not have chase utley in the top second baseman

  • utley should've been on the second baseman list. he's definitely far better than cano, and mora. and pedroia should've been first.

    and then as far as first basemen, youk definitely deserves a higher place. i won't argue that howard and pujols are better, but youk is definitely better than fifth place.

    and i'll give you a slight break because this was posted last year. but still. you're missing some key people, and you need to rethink your order.

  • Two very important words were missing from this video...Chase Utley!!!!!!

  • What the Heck I agree that howard is First on first But whats your problem with second base Where is Utley The only good second base man you mentioned was dustin Padrioa!

  • I realize this was posted last year...but the 2nd base list...really? biased towards teh american league much?

    1. Utley

    2.Uggla.

    3.Brian Roberts(mora above him and their teamates?)

    4.Pedroia

    5.Aron Hill

    IMHO

  • howard #1 is laughable....his OBP was 30 points lower than Pujols batting average...heres my opinion

    1. Prince Albert(he won a gold glove for the haters out there)

    2.Justin Morneau

    3.Berkman

    4.D.Lee

    5.Toss up between Youk and Tex....Howard struck out 199 times this year and batted .252 give me a break.....and fielder he shouldnt even be thought of before these guys

  • howard also had 48 homeruns and 149 RBIS! so just shut the hell up you have no idea what you talking about!

  • way off,pedroia is b est 2nd baseman in league

  • pedroia is #1

    by far

  • you got the first basemen right. And no, pujols is not number one he might be amazing at the plate but his defense is terrible, same with prince. At second base you really screwed up. Where the hell was chase utley. Did you forget about him? Last, after looking at your other video, it seems that the Philadelphia Phillies, "World Champs", probably have the best infield in all of baseball.

  • you are way wrong, pujols has won a gold glove a couple of years ago, his defense is not terrible, remember game 5 of the World Series in 06 win he laid out and threw a dude out lying down on his back, i doubt howard would have made that play. typical east coast bias get your freakin facts straight before you make dumb comments like that, compare their defensive stats career wise and see who is better defensively, oh yeah who won the 08 MVP, yeah thats what i thought

  • hahahaha

    chill out dude. i never said that howard had good defense.

    hahahaha.

    i bet ur like 40 years old arn't u

  • Pujols has won a Gold Glove and the Feilding Bible awards three years in a row smart guy.

  • justin morneau?

  • he is an Al MVP cadidate...

  • i do not agree

  • this video blows... 1st basemen is a toss up from kevin youklis and pujols then prince. then Pedroia I'm not sure what his name is but texas has a really good 2nd basemen and rays 2nd basemen isnt in there? chase utley ? come on

  • pujols is better than ryan howard youki is better than prince and pedroia is better than placido and louis castellia is better than robison cano

  • chase utley is #one craig melvin robinson polacido all suck balls

  • texira rocks go angels

  • wtf chase utley is like 1st and some theres no way hes not even in the top 5 melvin mora and craig biggio and polacido all suck now

  • Ok, this was terrible. Pujols is EASILY the best 1B (this is coming from a lifelong Cubs fan). How Chase Utley doesn't even get mentioned is ridiculous, and Mora doesn't even play 2B. Brian Roberts plays 2B for Baltimore (another one who should have been mentioned). Top 5 2B: Utley, Pedroia, Roberts, Kinsler, Cano.

  • Do not agree. Fail.

  • Kevin Youkolus is the best 1st baseman and Dustin Pedroia is the best 2nd baseman

  • pujols and youkilis are way bette than ryan howard. they both hit over 300 and he hits like 230, and pedroia is way better than placido polanco, so get the facts straight dude.

  • chase utley should be #1 by far craige bigio is like 50 and melvin mora sucks now

  • wat bout chase utley craig biggio is garbage

  • alexii ramirez blows he has proven nothing to be on a top 5 list. all alexii has is a bunch of singles. ryan theriot has a lot more hits and goes oppo which makes his hit more valuable and i dont say he is one of the best short stops

  • Prince Fielder and no Justin Morneau SAd

  • u forgot chase utley, alexii ramirez, troy tulowiski

  • pedroia or utley should be 1

  • agree on most

  • i agree but u shouldve put in chase utley for robinson cano but nice nice!!

  • bahahahhahahahaha are you stupid???? Its should go 1. Albert Pujols 2. Lance Berkman 3. Justin Morneau 4. Kevin Youkilis 5. Derrek Lee 1. Chase Utley 2. Ian Kinsler 3. Dustin Pedrioa 4. Brian Roberts 5. Dan Uggla

  • dan uggla sucks in the all star game he made three errors

  • OMG!!! Did you know Babe Ruth went 0-for-4 once! That guy sucks...

  • The funny thing is that i thought he had Placido first in second basemen

  • hail no

  • i will give you pedroia as 1 if there was any other 2nd basemen besides utly...which is still a stretch. what aboub kinsler though he is crushing the ball. and i am sorry but 1st base should go pujols, derrek lee of the chicago cubs(he has 6 gold gloves a batting title, an mvp, and a world series ring, with all of those you gotta give the man credit), lance berkman, prince fielder, and justin morneau. 2nd should be utley, pedroia, kinsler, deRosa, and roberts

  • Horrible ratings you DO NOT KNOW ANYTHING POSER!

  • just kill ur self chase utley is the best 2nd baseman without a question and prob one of the best players in the mlb

  • Yeah he is.

  • you seriously are a poser baseball fan you know nothing, chase utley is the best second basemen in the game and thats not because im a philly fan, plus i am a philly fan and ryan howard hits homeruns and strikes out, hes not the best first basemen, he cant feild and cant hit for average, rethink thiz before you put it up

  • How the fuk can u have top second baseman without CHASE UTLEY

  • dude your crazy..where is astrubal cabera of the indians.or chase utley of the phillies.or orlando hudson on the diamondbacks?

  • pedroia 1 uggla 2 cano 3 roberts 4 biggio 5 howard 1 pujols 2 youkilis 3 texeira 4 feider 5

  • Have you heard a guy by the name of Chase Utley?

  • first base, i think kevin youk should be atleast 3rd

    he has only made 1 error at first base in like 200 games!!!!

  • i agree AROD FAGOT short stop 1.Derrek jeeter ...fagot 2.John Mcdonald ...AWSOME

  • dude has Melvin Mora in top 5 second basemen and he isn't even a second baseman.. Brandon Phillips had 30 30 club with 91 rbi and the best fielding percentage in the league at 2B

  • Wow, you doing greatest 2nd basemen of today and you dont have brian roberts, chase utley or dan uggla. Melvin Mora plays 3rd base too.

  • you stink you anti phillie i am going to sue you ps you SUCK!!!!!!!!!!1

  • good call with Polanco, most underated player in the majors

  • no...

  • ah.. Melvin Mora plays 3rd.. Brian Roberts is the 2nd baseman for the Orioles.. and a damn good one too

  • THT SUKED!!!

  • dude this is stupid the vid is called best fielders not best hitting first basemen thts stupid you cant base off their hitting

  • the first base 1. Andres Galarraga 2. Albert Pujols 3. Jason Giambi 4. Davis Justice 5. Rafael Palmeiro second base 1. Alfonso Soriano 2. Jeff Kent 3. Marco Scutaro 4. Tomas Perez 5. Omar Infante
  • are you kidding me? galarraga, justice and palmeiro are all retired and if you wanna put retired players in there where's gehrig or greenburg? not to mention that putting galarraga ahead of pujols in anything is a travesty and giambi is more of a dh now...

    2nd base? also bad. soriano was TERRIBLE at second and marco scutaro is pretty much a journeyman. where's kinsler, utley, pedroia or lopez? the only legit name you dropped was kent.

    if you're gonna make a list learn a little first bra...

  • AROD FAGOT

  • where is aaron hill on this list? sorry if pedrois goes on here hill should be as well

  • i can only agre with placido polanco

  • Good picks but where is Chase Utley?