Critiquing the Critics: "The Nostalgia Critic" review

[drhploveboat]

@csbattlebot i dunno, but i sure hate you know...

[csbattlebot]

he also sucks because he hates pokemon, the flintstones, and... well alot of movies we like. what's wrong with you nostalgia critic?!?!?!

[harry426]

I personally think the Nostalgia Critic is highly overrated.

[Demyxsbabe2]

I do like Nostalgia critc because sometimes he makes valid points about the movies he reviews... do i agree with all of them... no but I understand that he may or may not like a particular movie or game. There are some points were he can be a bit annoying but i think thats just part of the character he plays...

[TWIZTIDFLIKS]

Not to say you're a bad reviewer though.

[tamenga88]

You know.

If you pronounce MartialHorror really fast like you usually do when you introduce yourself in your vids... It kinda sounds like

MARTIANWHORE.

[HParker001]

My only beef with nostalgi critic is that his reviews aren't really reviews, which nostalgia chick has subtly called him out on, they're sort of summarized riffs with a short review at the end. Still funny just for his personality as you said. I used to fault him for making frequent factual errors, but he acknowledges that, he's only human.

[drahen1000]

Nostalgia Critic is Awsome he Reviews movies games and shows that are nothing but crap

[Jockerlee77]

he lost his voce while doing the good son episode that why he did not talk in that review. he had gotten feed back so when he did alone in the dark, he had linkara and Spoony help him with the review. othere then that he more of a entertainer then a critic you enther like him or you don't. i like his review then even i don't alway agree with him. good review throw

[TheOriginalBoman]

why a four star rating system?

[TrenchAce]

man you articulate everything perfectly as i see it! Especially with how crappy district 9 is and how genius doug is... your angryjoe review is awesome too - he's my fav game reviewer

[Soulpunch2000]

I Came on to him late on, But i found it Funny as shit. I still think he's funny, and The Good Son Review, for me is Awesome for how much change in pace, it was from the others.

Didn't see anything new in this, but!

I'm going to check out more of your stuff now ;)

[MrsCamui]

Why don't you have more veiws?! You're a roit! I'm so subbing!

[ThinkTink606432]

Finally a neutral reviewer. Thank god! Nice video!

[StPatrickDayMassacre]

can you plz do a newer review explaining why you don't like him now. i enjoy some of his stuff, and don't see why a lot of people hate him now.

[MartialHorror]

@StPatrickDayMassacre Eventually, but my rereview of AVGN comes first. I still like NC. I just think he's become sort of uneven now.

[animebeerandcake]

4 stars my ass! Shitcase cinema is way better than that Nostalgia garbage.

[MartialHorror]

@animebeerandcake Actually, right now, I kind of agree. NC kind of went downhill after this. I still enjoy him, but not on a 4 star level(and I like SC on a 3.5/4 star level; my ratings dont completely reflect my personal feelings)

[tamenga88]

@MartialHorror

I have to agree with you too.

It's not as fun as back in 2009.

I even stopped watching and lack the incentive to even look.

But Honestly how much rating would you give him now in 2011?

[MartialHorror]

@tamenga88 dunno, 3-3.5/4 stars. I'd need to really think about it.

[giurescu123]

@MartialHorror

pff.. ok there are some hit and miss sometimes (dude, just human)

but watch the movie ¨suburban knights¨ he made as a aaniversary special.

after that there is a couple of months where the movies he reviews are kind of doll.

but after ¨james and the giant peach¨ i thing he got in the race again

[MartialHorror]

@giurescu123 bleh, humor is hit and miss.

[Lostprophetzzz]

@animebeerandcake you must have had a Humorectomy.

[Timic83amv]

does your mouth hurt from sucking off NCs dick so much?

[MartialHorror]

@Timic83amv Well, ask yourself that while considering how much your ass hurts from the constant pounding he gave you. (lol, couldn't resist, but I can see why someone would look down on this review)

Is it true you're the Angry Movie Dork's dup account? You do share his uncanny ability to find posts that name him.

[Timic83amv]

@MartialHorror im not the angry movie dork...

[jweinrub]

Great review and I agree, Nostalgia Critic is funny!

[Arthus850]

I rmemember he did a second review where he didn't use his voice. but he used a computer voice and was accompanied by spoony and linkara which made it just as funny. also I think you should try reviewing confused matthew. hate that guy. takes all of the popular stuff and looks at their negative sides making us look stupid for liking them at all

[xxPopcornJockeyxx]

review the angry movie dork. he ripps of NC, AVGN, and a mess of other critics

[MartialHorror]

@xxPopcornJockeyxx Yeah Im aware. Unfortunately, he doesnt meet my quota for reviewing(needs 10 reviews). I saw three of his vids. One was okay, one was awful and one was.....well, I dont remember it. He did rip off NC blatantly though.

Also, if I recall, he took down his vids.

[xxPopcornJockeyxx]

@MartialHorror wow...AMD read my comment and he's blocking me. he really hates when people critique his own work. i mean you probably have people who talk shit to now and then, but this kid is acting like a little brat when it comes to negative comments

[MartialHorror]

@xxPopcornJockeyxx Er, so wait, in the day that you wrote your post, he happened to come to this video and see your comment on him? Odd coincidence. lol.

[xxPopcornJockeyxx]

@MartialHorror eh, must be, haha

[MartialHorror]

@xxPopcornJockeyxx Maybe he searched his name on google or something and it came up. Although that's pretty quick, so maybe there is a youtube search engine that searches comments instead of tags or something.

[xxPopcornJockeyxx]

@MartialHorror huh, maybe. that sounds like something youtube might have. or maybe he gets a type of notification when his name comes up in the comments section.

[KinkyCreamPuffJ]

@xxPopcornJockeyxx He still makes videos under the name Timic83amv he watches EVERY video of NC and tells people how bad it is. He claims he actually liked NC in the beginning and has nothing against Doug Walker himself, but the fact that he does this for every video that the NC releases, shows extreme evidence contrary to those statements. He's not really a critic, he's basically just a little bitch. Therefore, he's not really worth your time as a Reviewer of Reviewers.

[TheGIantR]

I liked this. I also like how you pay tribute to the other reviewers.

[AnonymousElektron]

Hey, I enjoyed your videos, keep up the good work buddy.

[thefrickenfilmcritic]

I LOOOOOOOOVE NOSTALGIA CRITIC! He cracks me up every episode

[mmmmmheyyyy]

"Critiquing the critics... by a not so popular critic.. me, martialhorror."

The Nostalgia Critic is a fucking beast :D Thanks for giving him four stars! (:

[13lade619]

the living legend?.. hell yeah!!

[anthony62490]

Crap. I thought I was the first one to come up with this idea. I see you've already done CinemaSnob and AVGN, but please don't forget TheSpoonyOne and Angry Joe.

[MartialHorror]

@anthony62490 I do the list randomly, and unfortunately, neither of them are planned for the rest of this season(although some TGWTG regulars will be done, like Little Miss Gamer, Guru Larry, Benzaie and I think one more.

[MCJay2daSun]

@MartialHorror u know that diary joke could've been corney but u made it work. good job! LOL

[Jetblast01]

I admit, it's his personality that got me hooked. The guy sounds really knowledgeable. Unlike a certain popular Youtube game reviewer that almost has none in personality and knowledge of actual material. I first started out seeing what he and other people do on Youtube before deciding to like or dislike like Spoony, or AVGN. Critic was really fun to watch and I still remember seeing his Tom and Jerry being my first review I saw. Critic does put effort into his vids along with his team.

[shadowhexogram]

I've had this idea for awhile. Seems like you took it. You can have it I don't like the camera on me. Just send me the check once a month and we'll be square.

[ReallyGoodJoe]

You should review the Nostalgia Critic's joke stealing wannabe The Filmbuff.

[MartialHorror]

@ReallyGoodJoe lol, k, he's been added to the list.

[MastaChief7577]

It's hard to believe you have less than1000 views one your vids, your pretty humorous, and very fair/evenhanded in your reviews usually giving extra credit towards your critic at your own expense. Although I have to disagree with the Nostalgia Critic getting 4 stars. The one flaw I see with him is that sometimes he will overdue a joke, gag or over-exaggerate a minor flaw/detail with what he is reviewing. Other than that he is a great reviewer. I would give him 3 1/2 stars.

[MartialHorror]

I agree that he does do that at times(example, I hated when he's doing that Tim Curry accent in the Congo review), but I try to avoid taking off points when it's only at times. Thanks for commenting. It's always cool to see others honest opinions in regard to the people I review.

[finalredlaser]

The Critic Had Laryngitis when he did the review of The Good Son that is why he didn't talk

[MartialHorror]

Ah, good to know.

[DocNintendo]

why cant the best rating be 5 stars!!!!

[Gutmunchers]

Great video sir. I subbed to your channel.

[tiggerpete]

love this, keep this up, I had a similar idea to this once (but I am a slacker, and am really unmotivated) Hope you get really big and popular, 'cause this is really good, especially the weird jump edits for comedic effect, I think they worked really well.

[Mcrlover2death]

Nostalgia Critic Rules!

[yoshi8869]

@Mcrlover2death AMEN!!!

[ELASTICAMAN]

iim now gonna watch all ur reviews

cant wait til u review irate

[SpazzMaster8705]

Wow...no hate mail yet.

Awesome job, sir!